Apple Computers: Macbooks and iMacs

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic by 6 people | Log in to rate

Ranked #2,389 in Tech & Geek, #62,194 overall

Apple MacBook: Excellent computer or just a style statement?

Apple make some wonderful stylish consumer devices, which also function very well, but do they make good computers and software? The standard macbook looks cute and very well made, but it is quite expensive compared to most of the competition. The operating system is different to the majority of personal computers and not all software is available or may arrive on the market later. Is it worth the money or are you paying for style over functionality?

Macs, by default, use a different operating system, Mac OSX, instead of the usual Microsoft Windows, found on most personal computers, which should not be a problem from a usability point of view for most people, but does mean that some software is available later than for PCs, but the OS runs on a Unix platform (Called Darwin) and various Open Source (i.e. free) software can be used on Apple Macs or Windows can be installed as well as or instead of the Mac OSX (discussed in more detail below)

Viruses and other such malware programs are far less common for Macs, so infection is less likely, but do still exist, so anti-virus software is still recommended.

Here is a review of the Macbook, Mac OSX 10.5 Leopard operating system and other software and alternative laptops to consider. Please also see my review of a suitable backup or additional disk drive for your Apple Mac: LaCie Hard Disk Design by Neil Poulton Hard drive 1 TB

The Basic Macbook 

This Macbook looks great and quite different and is better made than many other machines with similar specifications. In white, which is the standard/cheaper option it looks very different from your average laptop. If you prefer Mac OSX rather than a Windows operating system I would certainly recommend it. I am a fan of unix, which is the underlying operating system for all Macs (i.e. the layer of software below Mac OSX) which is very accessible through a Terminal window, but this is probably irrelevant for most users. If however you prefer Windows (e.g. Vista) it is also possible to run Windows via a program called Bootcamp although of course this would add extra expense unless a copy of Windows is already available, because Apple only supply the one operating system, and this does impact a little on the available disk-space. Personally I think this is an extravagant way of getting a Windows PC , unless you really want that Apple style.

Free Opensource software for Apple Mac 

Some free open-source software is also available, such as Gimp, the Linux photo-editing program (similar to Photoshop), because Linux and Unix are in fact virtually identical, but any software specifically for Apple from any source will generally be as expensive as the PC equivalent and probably available some time later, because there are far fewer users of Apples (unless you run Windows on your macbook)

See the related article below:

Gimp Photo-editing Software 

Used Macs and Mac Stuff 

Loading Fetching new data from eBay now... please stand by
eBay

Performance 

In terms of performance it is a fast machine, with Intel dual-core processors, which can be made ever faster by doubling or quadrupling the RAM (1 GB is standard) although buying extra memory from Apple is expensive so upgrading using non-Apple memory at a later stage could be more cost-effective than buying a higher specification initially. Battery-life is very good at up to 6 hours and the clever magnetic power-cable that detaches if someone trips over it rather than pulling the macbook onto the floor has probably saved me a few quid in repair bills already.

Macbook Pro 

Value For Money / Summary 

It is however perhaps more expensive than some of its rivals and the screen is quite small for jobs such as photo-editing and I use it mainly with an extra, large monitor, as well, but so far I have had no regrets in paying the extra for this wonderful little machine.

After daily use for a year, I have no problems at all, I am still impressed with the styling and the functionality, but if cost were an issue I would buy a linux machine and use just free software. This is only really an option for people who are quite computer-literate. Alternatively a netbook with Linux or an older version of Window is also a very cost-effective alternative if you mostly use a laptop for web-surfing.

Advantages: small, compact, fast, good battery life, stylish, well-made, Mac OSX/Unix

Disadvantages: Mac OSX/Unix?


I have included a review of one of my other computers below - a suitable alternative if you prefer Windows Vista machine instead of Mac OSX

Good Disk Drives To Use With Apple Macs 

LaCie Hard Drive Design by Neil Poulton (1TB)

I have several Lacie external hard-disks attached to my Apple Mac computers and have mostly found them to be reliable, quiet and fast, until a few weeks ago when one of them (a 500GB Porsche designed one which I purchased about 18 months ago) failed. I needed a replacement and after quite a lot of research decided to risk buying a Lacie again.

I did a lot of research and chose a Lacie Disk Drive by Neil Poulton1

Alternatives (If you really must buy a PC instead of a macbook) 

Fujitsu Siemens Amilo Pi 2515

The Fujitsu Siemens Amilo Pi 2515 is a very good-value laptop. It is relatively inexpensive, at about £550, but comes with a good feature set, reasonably fast dual-core Intel processor (1.8 GHz), but the 2GB of RAM means it will actually run surprising fast with some more memory intensive software (e.g. photo-editing software). It also comes with a large disk drive (minimum 120 GB but larger ones are also available) It seems robust and well-made although I have mostly used it at home and have treated it carefully, so I haven't really tested this assumption. The screen opens and closes fairly smoothly and doesn't feel fragile like some cheaper models, although I still treat it carefully because I have had laptops in the past that in later life have started to flex near the hinges.

The Fujisu Siemens Amilo Pi 2515 has Microsoft Vista home premium installed, which has been surprisingly robust, rarely crashing. Vista Home Premium provides a good feature set to cover most of my non-business needs, without needing to pay the extra for the more advance versions of the software. I use Apple Macs as my work computers. Vista is not my preferred operating system as I have been using unix for almost 20 years, so I would prefer either Linux or Apple Mac OS X which are both based on unix instead of Microsoft DOS, but most people however will be very familiar with Vista.

The finish and feel of the casing are good when compared to the cheapest of it's competition, with dual colour, silver and black, casing that makes it seem slimmer, although not as stylish as some more expensive models such as my Apple MacBook nor as indestructible as my old IBM T42. The keyboard also has a reasonable "weight" to the keys, which don't feel flimsy, as can be the case with cheap laptops. I find the touch-pad annoying. It is too sensitive for me and the tap to select function gets triggered all the time when I don't want it to. This can actually be adjusted or turned off, but I haven't found the right settings yet, for me, and I share this computer with someone else who finds these setting almost perfect. Plugging in a mouse, of course, resolves the problem completely.

The screen is very clear, sharp and bright and a good size, 15.4", which makes it big enough to use for photo-editing etc. but without being too big to carry. Battery life is not great, often lasting less than 2 hours, but acceptable, and a spare battery would be a good idea if using it away from a power socket.

Overall the Fujisu Siemens Amilo Pi 2515 laptop it is a very good package that looks and feels a cut above many similarly priced laptops.

Summary: Good inexpensive laptop

Used Laptops 

Loading Fetching new data from eBay now... please stand by
eBay

Fujitsu Siemens Amilo 

FUJITSU - SIEMENS AMILO D7830 AC Adapter (Equivalent)

Amazon Price: $43.95 (as of 07/14/2009) Buy Now

4GB Memory Upgrade RAM For Fujitsu-Siemens Amilo Xi 3650

Amazon Price: $98.95 (as of 07/14/2009) Buy Now

Fujitsu-Siemens Amilo D5500 Laptop Battery

Amazon Price: (as of 07/14/2009) Buy Now

Related Articles: Photoediting 

Please Leave Some Feedback 

Tipi wrote...

in reply to JaguarJulie I agree that Andy is tops as the photo guy. I've never used an Apple or a Mac....but I would love to give them a try. Might not have experienced some of the problems I have with either. - Another great lens, you sure do have a lot of them!!!! Wow!

ReplyPosted July 01, 2009

AndyPo wrote...

Hi Julie, thanks very much for the comments. Yes I do have some Apples: just two at the moment, including my old iMac (maybe I should add a review of that too - they are still very popular on the second-hand market) and the macbook. I have also had various PCs, mostly for work - the silicon-chip design industry doesn't generally use Macs for design work, but I prefer them for my photographic work. I added my review of my Fujitsu Siemens laptop just to give a bit of contrast to the Apple. I have actually worked on the design of computer CPUs, but never had any input on the ergonomics or design of the case etc. I shall add some more detail of my experiences with Macs, especially for photography work. [in reply to JaguarJulie]

ReplyPosted June 08, 2009

JaguarJulie wrote...

So Andy -- you have an Apple? It might be neat to showcase more about personal experiences with your Apple provided you do have one and talk about PCs if you've used them. I still think of you though as THE photo guy! You are the tops in that department.

ReplyPosted June 07, 2009

AndyPo wrote...

in reply to Shelly

Hi Shelly,

Thanks very much. I think the break-away cord has save my macbook a few times.

ReplyPosted April 21, 2009

Lensmaster

Shelly wrote

I got a MacBook in August--my first computer! I was frustrated at first as I had never used a Mac before, I think it's worth getting through the frustration, I do love it. One day Tipi will get a Mac too--it's on her wish list. As ever, another work of excellence you have here. I also have appreciate the break away cord several times!

Reply Posted April 10, 2009

 
1 of 3 pages

Photography Articles 

I use my computers mainly for photoediting. Here are few of my photography articles.

Gadget Lenses 

About Me... 

Lensmaster AndyPo, aka Andrew Porter, has been a member since July 7 2008, has rated 1,561 lenses, favorited 1,448, and has created 104 lenses from scratch. This member's top-ranked page is "Le Mans 24 Hour Race". See all my lenses

Check out these great lenses...

lens image
Make Money From Home
There are many ways to make money from home and there is a lot of money out there on the internet to be had, but there are also a lot of people chasing the money. This article is about my research: The methods I have tried and the results I have achi... view lens
lens image
Technical Analysis (Charting)
Technical analysis is the art/science of using charts to predict the direction of financial markets (i.e. using the past to predict the future). Various different types of chart may be created and patterns within those charts, intersections of lines... view lens
lens image
Great Investment and Money Making Ideas
Have you ever been stuck for investment ideas? What should I invest in at the moment? Which stocks are good value? Which markets or investment vehicles should you invest in?This article attempts to cut through some of the jargon and provide some safe... view lens
lens image
The Best Classic Cars and Future Classics
What is the best classic car? Which ones can really be used and which one can you just look at? How difficult and expensive are they to own and run? Which cars are reliable and economical and how much do the parts cost to replace? How frequent and... view lens
lens image
Safari Vacations
This lens is a selection of articles and reviews of safari holidays and wildlife viewing vacations in various parts of the world: Africa (Namibia and Botswana), Borneo, Canada, USA and Asia... Lots of photographs, travel tips, advice and recommendat... view lens