Is morality found in the golden mean, the middle path, as Aristotle claims (as does the Buddha)? Aren't honorable, but extreme,

From the lens Intro To Philosophy - My Final Project!.

The Golden Mean vs. Extreme (sounds like a wrestling match!)

Again, two possible correct answers to the same question. Where is morality found? Back to Wittgenstein - what is the definition of morality? Assuming the most common - doing good, doing nothing to excess (except being good), serving others, choosing the 'right' - I personally believe that morality is to be found in the Golden Mean, yet extreme actions can also be moral. How do I reconcile the two views?

Consider suicide. It is considered immoral by many to commit suicide. Perhaps a soldier throws himself on a grenade and in the process, saves the other soldiers in the foxhole. What of a mother throwing herself in front of a moving vehicle to save her child? Or of a firefighter running into a burning building to save a stranger? These are extreme acts that could undoubtedly result in the ending of one's own life by choice. Yet can one argue that these are immoral acts?

  • boshemia Jan 29, 2009 @ 3:17 pm | delete
    Or consider the fact that in some cultures suicide is considered the honorable solution. When the Titanic sank there was a Japanese survivor. While American survivors returned home to celebrations, he returned home to scorn and ridicule. His life was ruined, his families reputation was ruined... his name became a synonym for the word "coward."

    Why? Because he survived when so many women and children died.

    Or consider sexual taboo, it is wrong to have sex with children. There are millions of children in our country who are molested, their lives are ruined, many never fully recover.

    Yet in some cultures it is tradition for an older aunt or uncle to initiate their family members sexually. This happens as young as 12 in some cultures. Since it is considered a rite of passage into adulthood none of these children are scarred. For them it is an honor.

    As Americans we scream this is WRONG, yet they see us as being just as savage by NOT initiating our children.

by

SadieCope

Hey, ya'll! I am in the process of building my first Squidoo lense as a creative project for a Philosophy class I am taking. Watch as my lense devel... more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!