Play the PIANO, Smartly

Ranked #12,503 in Music, #345,098 overall

My Experience Speaks

My passion in life is music, particularly, the piano. I have a degree in music emphasizing piano pedagogy. I have accomplished eighteen years experience teaching all age groups. My studio has included five year olds through grandparents, and includes one college professor at this writing. It was a heart wrenching experience recently when I had to see one student whom I had taught for ten years leave for college. Another long term student was accepted by the top piano professor on staff at the university where I started my degree plan. He heard her play and personally called me with desire for her as a student. Wow! That is a piano teacher's dream. So.... Yes, I know a thing or two about teaching the piano. Are you ready?

Beware the Salespeople

Keyboards Are a Mistake

First of all, there are alot of sales people out there who desparately want you to buy their keyboards. They are ready with their sales pitches and ready-made displays on what the accessory laden keyboards will produce. This is not the wisest choice. Keyboards are characteristically different from acoustic pianos. Beware of the differences before making a purchase. New students may easily be tempted by all the doodads, the accessories, the buttons and gadgets on the side of the keyboard, than by actually playing the keys.

Playing a keyboard is kin to playing an organ. Now, that's not a bad thing. I love the organ, and I adore the works of J. S. Bach. However, the piano is played in a totally different method. The piano uses one's arms! Using a keyboard keeps one's arms dead still. Playing on a keyboard develops wrong technique from the very beginning. As a teacher, I always give a demonstation of this to my new students and parents if necessary. They see in a snap the total difference in stylistic playing. From thereon, the student is sold on listening to me as teacher and applying my wisdom for acoustic superority.

No one wants to start development of an instrument with bad habits. As stated above, starting on a keyboard when one wants to learn the piano guarantees that one is headed down that lane. Bad habits will be the outcome. It is highly necessary to start with a sound foundation of solid patterns in how to hold the hands and form the fingers. Doing so on a keyboard will not give this solid foundation, but will only set a false foundation. Bad habits will then have to be broken later on down the line, and no student nor parent of a junior student wants to have to work backwards over bad habits. Why not start with the correct habits and methods? An acoustic piano will guarantee that outcome.

A little more

I take lots of time with my students of all ages developing strong technical skills so that they will be musical from the very beginning. A keyboard simply does not lend a musical sound. Even the 'made to be musical with dynamics' keyboard is not the same as the action of an acoustic piano. Digital pianos advertise that they are equal in performance method, but this pianist states differently. It is far better to put the money into an acoustic piano even if second hand.

The student notices instantly the difference on an acoustic piano due to the richness of sonority. This, of course, is an instant reward even in the earliest stages of practicing and learning on the instrument. And that is what you want: instant reward. That reward will further the work of the student in driving forward the day to day demand of regular practicing.

There simply is nothing like an acoustic piano no matter the sales pitch from any modern music store representative. Find a classic music teacher with a piano degree. You will be on your way to a fine and rewarding time with your new instrument even if you select a used acoustic piano. And make sure that the teacher is studied in piano technique, not a violin or flute teacher making money on the side by teaching piano or keyboard. Only the true pianist can teach the circular techniques necessary in early development of wrist rotation for expression of dynamics and phrasing. These techniques will set the student forward with a love affair with music that can last a lifetime. I can guarantee that utilizing these settings will lead to a highly rewarding time with the piano and a very fulfilling musical experience.

Reader Feedback

  • whitemoss Jan 21, 2010 @ 6:39 am | delete
    I agree about keyboards, but I compromised and got a top of the range Clavinova. I'm loving it. Great lens- lensrolled to my "resdiscevring and remembering" lens.
  • stevie10772 Jan 21, 2010 @ 8:27 am | delete
    Thanks for the lensroll.... Take heart in that there are some excellent keyboards out that as long as they are touch sensitive. Be sure to place it in the right place, and not just on a table top. Your forearms must be parallel to the floor so that your wrists are loose.. Good luck!
  • stevie10772 Sep 11, 2009 @ 6:32 pm | delete
    Taft: Thank you for your viewpoints! I happen to know that you are very good on the electronic keyboard, and are highly skilled in many ways that I am not: modulation, improvisation, jazz, and that's not covering it all. However, the item that you are leaving out in the keyboard versus piano that is the main ingredient in superiority is the phrasing ability which is created through the excellence of execution and delivery into the bottom of the keys as well as various rotations in hand movement necessary to do so. This is simply not possible on a keyboard, and I have played numerous well developed touch sensitive keyboards.
    On the other hand, a beginner may develop up to a certain level on a keyboard as you state. But the development stops short right there at about an intermediate level, and without the ability to develop the execution of skills necessary for superiority. For highly developing students, this is best set when early habits are developing at an early age.
  • Taft Metcalf Sep 11, 2009 @ 12:45 pm | in reply to Stevie | delete
    I would agree that a good,. well maintained acoustic piano in a reasonable room cannot be beat by anything electronic. However, a good electronic piano, connected to good sound equipment is much better than most practice and home pianos that I have encountered. A good acoustic piano costs 5 or 10 times more than a good electronic setup. The electronic setup can better handle a bad room and readily facilitates recording and playback of performances. Therefore, I would not dismiss electronic pianos out of hand,
  • lollyj Feb 2, 2009 @ 6:37 am | delete
    Hi Stevie. I hope your roster of piano students continues to grow. Thanks for sharing the info on pianos.

by

stevie10772

Welcome! I'm Stephanie S. Sawyer, a piano teacher, a twice published author, an advocate for those with seizures, and a true Texan by every count. I r... more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!