Skip to navigation | Skip to content

Share your knowledge. Make a difference.

Physical Therapy: The Truth

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic (by 0 people)   Your rating: 1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic

Ranked #5931 in Health

0 people favorited this page (yet!)

Rated G. (Control what you see)

Created by GastonRehab (contact me)

Brian Boyle PT, DPT, CSCS holds a Doctorate of Physical Therapy from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and is the President and Co-own...  (more...)

Start your own Squidoo page

Your fans are waiting!

 

This lens will educate you about physical therapy. My desire for starting this is to dispel the myths that physical therapy is only for grandparents and all that physical therapists do is help people walk, give massages, and use electric stimulation and heat.

Physical Therapy First

The next time you or someone else you know, has pain, hurts a muscle or other structure of the body, why not go and see a physical therapist first? Often times a physical therapist can provide relief just as well as medications and they will look for a root cause and not just try to mask symptoms.

What to Look for in Outpatient Physical Therapy 

  • Find a licensed physical therapist. You can ask family, friends, or other healthcare providers or you can look in the phone book or go online and look at the web.
  • Make sure the physical therapist is trained in working with your condition. Do this by asking questions. A simple "yes" is not enough of an answer. Ask open ended questions such as "how many other people have you seen with this condition and how many have gotten better," "how much experience do you have working with this condition," "what kind of training did you go through," and so on.
  • Don't be satisfied. If you are uncomfortable with the communication style or the services you are being provided by the physical therapist you are working with, then keep looking. It is not against the law to switch therapists.
  • Look for alone time. Most people like to be where the action is, but when you need physical therapy why would you want to be in a group setting or have a lot of people being worked on at the same time by the same therapist. Be greedy and find a facility that offers one-on-one treatments. Don't be afraid to ask for this either.
  • Plan your trip. Make sure the physical therapist explains the treatment plan of care. This will tell you how long they plan on working with you and on what types of activities. If the therapist seems unwilling to discuss this with you they may be hiding something.
  • Remember physical therapy just like any other service is generally not free. Co-insurance or co-payments may be due at the time of service.
  • Ask your physical therapist to tell you what you or your insurance company are being charged for at the end of each visit. Transparency in healthcare is an emerging trend and like other industries in which we know what we are being charged for (think McDonald's you know how much you are getting charged for a hamburger), ask for a copy of what will be billed for each session. Keep this record and match it with the explanation of payments you receive from the insurance company. If they do not match up you could have grounds for accusing fraud.

Physical Therapy: Reality vs. Myth 

Physical therapists are quite simply, experts in function and movement of the human body. These professionals are educated at a bachelor's degree or higher (many new and some older physical therapists (PT's) are educated at the doctorate level) and work closely with all other health care providers as part of the health care team.

A point of clarification is needed before I proceed. A person who has graduated from an accredited physical therapy school with a Doctorate of Physical Therapy degree is considered a doctor, but is in no way considered a physician. A Doctor of Physical Therapy has a different skill set than that of a Medical Doctor and prescribes treatments that are related to musculoskeletal and movement disorders. Whereas a medical doctor or physician would be concerned with the overall health of an individual it may be in their scope of practice, but not in their mastery of knowledge, to provide such treatments that would be provided by a doctor of physical therapy.

Keeping the above in mind, here we go:

Myth 1: A physician has to send someone to a physical therapist.

Did you know that in 48 states, people like you have some form of direct access to physical therapist care. Some states do have provisions which must be met, by the physical therapist and some states only have access to evaluation.

Myth 2: Personal trainers that use the PT initials behind his/her name are also physical therapists.

Licensed physical therapists are the only professionals allowed to use the initials PT after their names. Many personal trainers try to use this designation to shorten how they classify themselves. Personal trainers often have a cursory level of fitness education and many have only passed a weekend certificate course. Physical therapists are trained in evaluation of movement disorders and in treatments that can correct these disorders. Licensed Physical Therapists are truly professionals and are held to a code of ethics as outlined in each State's practice act.

Myth 3: Athletic trainers and chiropractors are the same as physical therapists.

Many people try to confuse the public to say that modalities such as electric stimulation, ultrasound, massage, and the application of hot packs and cold packs are physical therapy modalities and therefore they practice physical therapy. Unfortunately when PT's bill insurance companies they do not have codes that are specific to physical therapy other than their initial examination and re-examination codes. The fact that other healthcare providers can bill certain insurance companies for modality codes does not mean that they are practicing physical therapy. In fact in most states, to claim they are is against the law.

Myth 4: Chiropractors are the only healthcare providers who manipulate/adjust the spine.

Doctors of Osteopathic Medicine and physical therapists are also able to manipulate the spine. In some states physical therapists need a physician's permission to adjust the spine, but that is easily accomplished by a trained physical therapist and often requires nothing more than a phone call and a faxed prescription. Also a great deal of the available research done to date on the appropriateness of spinal manipulation/adjustment has been done by physical therapists.

Also despite many claims that spinal manipulation is safe, there are always risks associated with treating the spine. Technique and the practitioner performing the technique will have a big effect on the outcome. Be sure that the person who performs any treatment to that area knows what they are doing. If something doesn't feel right, trust your gut and run.

Myth 5: Physical therapists only work in hospitals.

Licensed physical therapists work in many different settings including but not limited to the following: hospitals, schools, fitness centers, on-site at businesses (including industrial, commercial transportation, office), home health, rehabilitation centers, nursing homes and assisted living facilities, performing arts (ballet, dance studios, and even musicians), and with sports teams (amateur to professional).

Myth 6: All physical therapy is the same.

Because of the large breadth of knowledge that physical therapists can posess, like any other profession, there will be differences in treatments provided, communication styles, and with outcomes. Many people will go from one accountant to another if they are dissatisfied, but still refuse to go see another physical therapist instead chalking it up to the thought of "physical therapy just doesn't work."

Myth 7: Physical therapy is for everyone.

If this were true, every professional in the healthcare industry would be a physical therapist and we would no longer need any other providers. Physical therapists can help many people with many conditions or needs, however there are many other conditions that are completely out of the scope of practice for anyone other than a medical physician.

Myth 8: The chiropractors that list themselves under Google ads for physical therapy are ethical.

Misleading the public is not ethical. Nor is attempting to perform treatments or services that are out of the scope of your practice for any professional. It is great to be a physical therapist because apparently everyone wants to be one and everyone thinks that they can be one.

Myth 9: All people working as "physical therapists" in physicians offices that provide physical therapy are physical therapists.

The fact is that physicians can bill what is called "incident to" when billing insurance companies for physical therapy services. To that regard, they can hire anyone (and I mean anyone) to perform treatments under their "watchful" eye. Now the physicians worth your money will hire licensed physical therapists in their office, but not every physician does this especially when it is cheaper to hire someone that isn't licensed. Why would anyone want to go to physical therapy where it is not provided by a licensed physical therapist or assistant? Unfortunately if you don't ask, they won't tell.

Myth 10: Referral-for-profit relationships don't hurt anyone.

The reality is that any referral for profit relationship has the potential for overutilization of services and fraud. There is defintely an incentive for a physician to refer to a physical therapy provider in which they own all or a percentage of the business. From a business stand point it doesn't make sense not to send existing clients to a facility in which you stand to gain financially. It is well documented that physicians that own imaging services utilize imaging services more than their counterparts that do not have the imaging services available. Does this mean that these physicians intentionally attempt to overutilize these services? No, however there certainly is no incentive to not send every client for an X-ray. The same with physical therapy services. If a physician stands to gain from a client that will be seen in a physical therapy office, why not add two more weeks to a prescription that could stand to net a few hundred dollars more. Think this doesn't add up? Most small physical therapy practices will see 2000 visits a year. If each client nets an owner $30 after expenses that is $60,000 extra each year. Imagine the large clinics that can see 2000 visits or more a month?

While not illegal in 48 states (Delaware and South Carolina are currently the only two states in which it is illegal for physicians to have ownership in physical therapy practices), it is not good for the general public and the educated consumer should know that there are other options for physical therapy services. Most physicians will offer you a choice (closest to your house, trained in your condition, accept your insurance as in-network, and so on), be weary of those that don't and insist you utilize their therapists. This is often quantified with any of the following: "I can keep up with your condition much better if you go to our therapists," "You trust us for your care, why wouldn't you trust our therapists," "We offer one-stop shopping for all of your healthcare needs," and any other catch phrase designed to make you feely guilty for not using the recommended therapists.

Myth 11: All healthcare providers are Saints and would never attempt to commit fraud.

The potential for fraud is there in any business and is not just limited to physician owned physical therapy services. There are unfortunately physical therapists in all settings that attempt to commit fraud to reap the benefits. This goes back to the concept of transparency. Ask for a copy of the itemized charge sheet after each visit. Compare this to the explanation of payments and make sure they match up. Do not be afraid to speak up if they do not!

Myth 12: Physical therapists are looking to become independent practitioners that have no need for any other healthcare providers.

The American Physical Therapy Association Vision 2020 statement indicates that by the year 2020 physical therapists will be Doctors of Physical Therapy and will be autonomous practitioners. Many are trying to construe this to mean that physical therapists will no longer need to communicate with any other healthcare providers. Instead what it means is that like any other medical specialist the decision making process for the physical therapist will be independently managed by the physical therapist. Information regarding the client will be shared with any other healthcare provider or physician as medically necessary for the treatment of that client. It will mean that the licensed physical therapist will assume greater responsibility for the treatment of the client, within their scope of practice, and will accept greater accountability for their actions as well.

Here's my favorite link:

Healthcare Blog

New Link List 

Gaston Rehab Associates, Inc.
Home website for Gaston Rehab Associates, Inc. Physical Therapy.
American Physical Therapy Association
Home of the American Physical Therapy Association
My Physical Therapy Space
Networking site for physical therapists, physical therapist assistants, and students
Atlas Ergonomics
Atlas Ergonomics is the leader in ergonomic consulting services for businesses. Their unique model includes using a network of providers throughout the nation that are trained in their systems. Based on objective, cost effective strategies the goal is to save companies in both direct and indirect costs while implementing an ergonomics program within their business.
WorkWell Systems
WorkWell Systems applies many of the same quality improvement and Six Sigma techniques pioneered by the most successful companies, to significantly reduce on-the-job injuries and related workers compensation costs.
Gaston Chamber of Commerce
Web site for the Gaston Chamber of Commerce. Quickly becoming one of the most active Chambers of Commerce in the Charlotte Metro Area.
Inc.
Inc. magazine and online source for entrepreneurs and business owners.
Finger Lakes Running Company
Running Store in Ithaca, NY owned by a former Collegiate All-American Cross Country runner and close personal friend.

Great Stuff on Amazon 

Blue Ocean Strategy: How to Create Uncontested Market Space and Make the Competition Irrelevant

Amazon Price: $19.79 (as of 05/17/2008)

Freakonomics [Revised and Expanded]: A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything

Amazon Price: $16.77 (as of 05/17/2008)

Be the Elephant: Build a Bigger, Better Business

Amazon Price: $19.95 (as of 05/17/2008)

Loving What Is: Four Questions That Can Change Your Life

Amazon Price: $10.85 (as of 05/17/2008)

Physical Therapy Related Books 

Therapeutic Exercise: Foundations and Techniques (Therapeutic Exercise: Foundations & Techniques)

Amazon Price: $49.94 (as of 05/17/2008)

ACSM's Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription (ACSM'S Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription)

Amazon Price: $33.26 (as of 05/17/2008)

Treat Your Own Neck 4th Ed

Amazon Price: $10.00 (as of 05/17/2008)

Essentials of Strength Training and Conditioning

Amazon Price: $51.75 (as of 05/17/2008)

Differential Diagnosis for Physical Therapists: Screening for Referral (Differential Diagnosis In Physical Therapy)

Amazon Price: $68.55 (as of 05/17/2008)

Great Stuff on Amazon 

Orthopedic Physical Assessment (Orthopedic Physical Assessment (Magee))

Amazon Price: $75.16 (as of 05/17/2008)

The American Physical Therapy Association Book of Body Maintenance and Repair

Amazon Price: $16.32 (as of 05/17/2008)

Fundamentals of Musculoskeletal Imaging (Contemporary Perspectives in Rehabilitation)

Amazon Price: $61.12 (as of 05/17/2008)

Clinical Orthopaedic Rehabilitation

Amazon Price: $98.56 (as of 05/17/2008)

Treat Your Own Back

Amazon Price: (as of 05/17/2008)

New YouTube vids 

Exercises for Iliotibial Band Syndrome

Gaston Rehab Associates, Inc. Physical Therapy

Runtime: 4:49
4362 views
6 Comments:

powered by YouTube

Evidence Based Medicine Blog 

Loading Fetching RSS feed... please stand by

Debate Forum 

This forum will be for topics related to physical therapy. We can't have a "truth" forum if we hide from the truth (including the good, the bad, the ugly)

Anyone that has utilized physical therapy, tell us what your thoughts are!

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

Wow, the physical therapy was great, couldn't have asked for anything more.

GastonRehab says:

In response to the comment left here from a colleague, I will respectfully disagree with all of the points made. For one there is no reason why you can't ask how long your treatment should take. Yes the "human" variable which is each individual and their compliance to home program and rate of healing accounting for co-morbid or co-existing conditions (diabetes, high blood pressure, and so on) will have an effect on treatment length. However it is not unreasonable to ask for an idea of expected length of time to be coming for physical therapy. Even unscrupulous providers who often tell people they will need to come in for years have the decency to at least provide some expectation.

The second point about having the front desk person handle the money is really up to the individual office and the corporate environment already in place. Healthcare is a business whether we like it or not. We should not have a problem talking about money with people when we are asking that they part ways with their cash in exchange for services provided.

Lastly, the video is something that we put together to highlight exercises that are beneficial for some people that have ITB syndrome. Medicine is not an exact science. The people that follow the video without seeing a health care provider in the first place would be the same that may turn to another on-line source or worse yet ask an untrained friend for anecdotal exercise advice. When done correctly (and as shown) none of those exercises should cause any pain and since we rely on body weight only none of those exercises should be harmful. It would be irresponsible for us to make claims that these exercises would help every person and to show a subject using heavy weights. If a person can't perform functional body weight exercise without extreme pain it is time to see a health care provider anyway.

I appreciate your comments and the ability to clarify my talking points.

jafopt says:

I too am a PT and think that this is a great lense. However, as a business owner, and 12-year PT, I have to disagree with you on a few points.
1. I would remove the part where you say that patients should ask how long they will be treated. That has as much to do with HEP compliance and activity modification as it does the PT's skills.
2. Your last comment under "What to look for..." can be a mixed bag. First I would change it to ask the front office what will be charged. That way you keep your PTs out of the financial picture which can be a nice separation and help stave off time-consuming discussions about how you charge; taking away from treatment time.
3rd and last, I'm sure you will disagree, but I believe any generalized treatment - in a video no less - is irresponsible and can be detrimental. Making it available to PTs as an anectdotal protocol for professionals is one thing I would be glad to see. However to make these exercises available to the general public is likely to cause more harm than good. I could go into more detail, but I'll just say that usually ITB synd. is found in conjuction with other, moderately more involved conditions. Without proper progression you are likely make people worse with this video.

Physical therapy? Not on your life; I can't believe I went!

 
 
1 of 1 page
 

Reader Feedback 

Did you know that physical therapists did this much?

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

I had no idea. I am now much more informed!

I am still not convinced that physical therapists do that much. I will see my family doctor or chiropractor the next time I need help.

 
 
1 of 1 pages
 

New Word of the Day 

latitudinarian: Dictionary.com Word of the Day
latitudinarian: having or expressing broad and tolerant views.

New Weather Widget 

X

Hi, I'm GastonRehab

GastonRehab

Join my fan club

Brian Boyle PT, DPT, CSCS holds a Doctorate of Physical Therapy from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and is the President and Co-owner of Gaston Rehab Associates, Inc.


Dr. Boyle works with individuals and organizations providing strategies which allow his clients to meet their own unique needs whether it is through hands on care, education, or ergonomic consulting.

More pages by me...

See all my pages