Polls: Hard Rock Lead Singers: Who's Better, The Originals or The Replacements?

Ranked #5,694 in Music, #157,751 overall

Maybe we can settle these debates once and for all, right here on Squidoo?!?

This lens, a companion lens to The 10 Best Heavy Metal/Hard Rock Singers, brings some fun to answering some of the hard rock and heavy metal lead vocalist debates that have been going on for decades.

Let's get to it - who are the best lead singers, for each of the hard rock / heavy metal groups below - The Original Lead Singers or "The Replacements"?

Black Sabbath

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Ozzy or Dio? Read THIS Before You Decide

Here's a portion of one review found about this book on Amazon...

I found the book excellent in its detail given from all the band member's interviewed, clearing up all the holes and rumors floating around over the years... The book should be in any Sabbath or Ozzy fans collection due to the array of pictures within, some never before seen concert shots as well as promotional pictures and offstage shots. Loaded with interviews from the array of band members that took part in this battle, reading what really went on in their own words... clearing up much of the void and silence on some subjects.

Sabbath Bloody Sabbath: The Battle for Black Sabbath

Amazon Price: $19.91 (as of 05/29/2012)Buy Now

Exclusive interview content with Tony Iommi, Geezer Butler, Cozy Powell, Ronnie James Dio, Ian Gillan, Glenn Hughes, Ray Gillen, Tony Martin, Geoff Nicholls, Rob Halford, Bob Daisley, Lee Kerslake, Carmine Appice, Tommy Aldridge, Neil Murray, Dave Spitz, Eric Singer, David Donato, Jeff Fenholt, Bobby Rondinelli, Rudy Sarzo, Phil Soussan, Randy Castillo, Bernie Torme, Brad Gillis, Jo Burt, Pete Way, Dana Strum, Terry Chimes, Lita Ford, Steve Vai, Don Airey, Lindsey Bridgewater, Terry Nails and many, many more.

AC/DC

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Iron Maiden

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Deep Purple

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Judas Priest

Loading poll. Please Wait...

KISS

How about an intra-band singer controversy?

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Skid Row

This one is probably laughable, but...

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Roth or Hagar? Maybe It's The Van Halen Story That Really Matters...

Everybody Wants Some: The Van Halen Saga

Amazon Price: $5.00 (as of 05/29/2012)Buy Now

How did a pair of little Dutch boys trained in classical music grow up to become the nucleus of the most popular heavy metal band of all time? What's the secret behind Eddie Van Halen's incredible fast and furious guitar solos? What makes David Lee Roth and Sammy Hagar so wacky? And, are all those stories about groupies, booze bashes, and contract riders true? The naked truth is laid bare in Everybody Wants Some--the real-life story of a rock 'n' roll fantasy come true.

Van Halen

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Guestbook - Who Are We Missing, What Should We Add, etc.?

  • CDT Aug 11, 2011 @ 4:49 am | delete
    I did come back and ! voted in the polls that you've added since I was last here! Fun lens about a topic I consider to be massively important (I am a fanatical Metalhead!!) - blessed by this Metal-loving Squid Angel as part of the "Back To School Bus Trip" :)
  • Tolovaj Jul 16, 2011 @ 7:44 am | delete
    Nice lens, some nice memories, thanks!
  • MCat711 Jun 5, 2011 @ 11:17 pm | delete
    Iced Earth has also gone through several vocalists, including Matt Barlow and "Ripper" Owens, right after his stint with Priest.

    Cool lens; it was interesting to see the results!
  • szeman May 22, 2011 @ 11:35 pm | delete
    I thought of one that you missed. That is INXS. Do people prefer INXS with the late Micheal Hutchins or the new guy? Sorry, I can't remember the current lead singer of INXS.
  • annonomous Jan 29, 2012 @ 4:16 pm | delete
    but 1 thing to your response, INXS sucks
  • KimGiancaterino Apr 23, 2011 @ 6:55 pm | delete
    Hard decisions ... fun polls!
  • The_Health_Lady Apr 12, 2011 @ 9:47 am | delete
    Some interesting toss ups. The toughest one i think is the AC/DC one as both totally rock.
  • mcochs Apr 6, 2011 @ 6:18 pm | delete
    Cool lens! Had fun!
  • Gary Mar 2, 2011 @ 3:31 pm | delete
    How about Mark Huff the new singer for Quiet Riot ... He is Amazing !!
  • BadSoulPhotography Feb 18, 2011 @ 8:20 pm | delete
    Great to see your passion
  • Hiyaha Nov 14, 2010 @ 6:16 pm | delete
    I like your lens, you are passionate of your work and music.
  • CDT Sep 20, 2010 @ 12:11 pm | delete
    You forgot Blaze Bayley for Iron Maiden...and Rob Halford v Tim "Ripper" Owens for Judas Priest!
  • Ashly_Rain Sep 20, 2010 @ 2:14 pm | delete
    Thank you!!!! Because the polls are so noew, and only a few people have taken them, I'm going to add them in now. Maybe you'll come back and weigh in?

by

Ashly_Rain

Andy & Wendy are a husband & wife team on Squidoo. Boston's our home (Boston-ish).
Substream Music Press magazine focuses on the best new artists in...
more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!

Featured Lenses 

Loading

Become The Singer 

FastTrack Lead Singer Method - Book 1 (Fast Track (Hal Leonard))

Amazon Price: $4.61 (as of 05/29/2012)Buy Now

Transform your shower singing into some real talent! This cool book/CD pack teaches reading music, scales and different keys, and provides all the essential info on how to train your vocal cords. Plus, you'll learn warm-up techniques, tips on handling a microphone, breathing exercises, and many more helpful hints. The accompanying CD includes more than 80 recorded songs and examples.