Damn Baby Sling

Ranked #3,267 in Parenting & Kids, #104,327 overall

One Wannabe Babywearer's Frustrations with the Ring Sling

I recently purchased a Mamaway Ring Sling after reading about all the supposed benefits of babywearing.  I watched the DVD that came with it and tried it out.  WHAT A NIGHTMARE!  The baby hates it and I feel like I'm torturing, not nuturing him. 

I spent hours on-line at various sites viewing and reading instructional materials--all to no avail.

Surely I'm not the only one?  If you are in the same boat, perhaps this lens will help you.  If you are thinking of a sling, I hope this will help you make a more-educated decision on what sling to buy or whether to buy an alternative baby-wearing device.

The best advice I have to offer, however, is do not buy a sling without having somebody teach you -- IN PERSON -- how to use it properly.  I will try to list resources that can help put you in touch with such a person.    

Why Wear A Baby?

It sounds kinda grotesque: wearing a baby. Images of Ed Gein, Jeffrey Dahmer, and "Buffalo Bill" from Silence of the Lambs might come to mind. But that's not what proponents of baby wearing hope to convey and their is no need to run in horror if someone tells you that they wear their baby.

Baby wearing is a recently-coined English term that refers to the ancient practice of carrying an infant or young child in slings, wraps, pouches, backpack-like devices or anything else that allows the wearers hands to be free.

Below are the more common reasons folks promote "wearing" your baby.
  1. Carried babies cry less. Unless, of course, it is my baby who screams like I'm torturing him with red-hot brands until I remove him from the sling.

    I've read that it takes time for the baby to adjust, but how long am I supposed to walk around with an upset wailing baby. Makes me want to run to a store and get a strappy soft carrier and toss the sling away.
  2. Babies sleep better. Note, some argue that they not only sleep more, they over sleep. See "arguments against," below. I wouldn't know, my son is unable to fall asleep in a sling. He is too busy screaming for me to take him out.
  3. Frees the wearers hands. With a sling you can carry a needy infant and even breastfeed while using your hands to take care of other kids, read a magazine, wash the dishes, work on the computer, etc. Well, you can if you not using them trying to sooth an infant upset about being confined in a sling.
  4. Babies that are carried more grow faster.
  5. Babies that are worn bond to people better. Baby wearing is promoted by those who believe in attachment parenting.

Arguments FOR Slings

Why wear your baby in a sling?

  1. Supposedly they are simple to use. I must be an idiot. The learning curve seems quite high, especially if you don't have someone experienced with slings to help you out in the beginning. But I keep reading how easy they are.
  2. Makes it easier to breastfeed discreetly in public. Pull down the back "rail" and pull up the front "rail" and voila! Happy suckling baby and no one is the wiser. You can't do that with a baby backpack or stroller.
  3. Slings are cheap! Slings usually cost much less than fancy, strappy, backpack-type carriers.

The World's Best Slings

(slings only please)

I bought a Mamaway sling (www.mamaway.com). Did I make a poor decision? Are all my problems due to purchasing the wrong sling? Do you LOVE your sling? Then vote for it. If is isn't listed here, please add it. It is easy to do. Take this module and post it on you blog, lets find out what the best slings are.

Please do not submit other baby carriers. My problem is with a sling. Maybe I should just buy a Baby Bjorn carrier, but that's another discussion. For this poll, slings only please.

Ultimate Baby Wrap- Black

Ultimate Baby Wrap- Black

One of the most versatile, secure and convenient b more...0 points

New Native Baby Carrier: Black Medium (chest size 34-37)

New Native Baby Carrier: Black Medium (chest size 34-37)

Freedom for your hands. Safely bend over or twist more...0 points

Premaxx Sling Carrier-New Edition Black/Gray

Premaxx Sling Carrier-New Edition Black/Gray

The JJ Cole Premaxx sling carrier is comfortable, more...0 points

Urban Sling Diaper Bag Black

Urban Sling Diaper Bag Black

The Combi Urban Sling is the perfect addition to y more...0 points

New Native Baby Carrier: Khaki Medium (chest size 34-37)

New Native Baby Carrier: Khaki Medium (chest size 34-37)

Freedom for your hands. Safely bend over or twist more...0 points

Lite-on-Shoulder Ring/pouch hybrid Baby Sling(moss)

Lite-on-Shoulder Ring/pouch hybrid Baby Sling(moss)

For centuries babies have been carrier in Slings a more...0 points

The Original NoJo Baby Sling by Dr. Sears - Black

The Original NoJo Baby Sling by Dr. Sears - Black

Soft and comfortable! The original baby sling is m more...0 points

Sweet Fletcher Reversible Baby Sling ,Size: Medium

Sweet Fletcher Reversible Baby Sling ,Size: Medium

Sweet Fletcher Reversible Baby Sling A Sweet Fletcher more...0 points

Munchkin Jelly Bean Reversible Sling S/M

Munchkin Jelly Bean Reversible Sling S/M

Babies love the calming effect they get when snuggled more...0 points

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears - Flower

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears - Flower

Designed to grow as your baby does, our Balboa Bab more...0 points

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears - Blossom Trim

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears - Blossom Trim

Balboa Baby "Dr. Sears" Adjustable Sling more...0 points

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears-Dotted Daisy Brown

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears-Dotted Daisy Brown

Designed to grow as your baby does, our Balboa Bab more...0 points

Lite-on-Shoulder Ring/pouch hybrid Baby Sling(Arabic Night)

Lite-on-Shoulder Ring/pouch hybrid Baby Sling(Arabic Night)

For centuries babies have been carried in Slings a more...0 points

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears-Black Signature

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears-Black Signature

Designed to grow as your baby does, our Balboa Bab more...0 points

Hotslings Adjustable Pouch Baby Carrier, Quinn

Hotslings Adjustable Pouch Baby Carrier, Quinn

Hotslings AP - Quinn Stripe The easy to use Hotsli more...0 points

Sleepy Wrap Classic Wrap Baby Carrier, Gray, 0-18 Months

Sleepy Wrap Classic Wrap Baby Carrier, Gray, 0-18 Months

Sleepy Wrap was born out of the dream of the ideal more...0 points

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears - Flower

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears - Flower

Designed to grow as your baby does, our Balboa Bab more...0 points

Hotslings Designer Pouch Style Baby Carrier, Sweet Pea, Size 2

Hotslings Designer Pouch Style Baby Carrier, Sweet Pea, Size 2

Go vogue in these designer prints available in the more...0 points

Moby Wrap Original 100% Cotton Solid Baby Carrier, Black

Moby Wrap Original 100% Cotton Solid Baby Carrier, Black

Be comfortable. The superior design of the Moby Wr more...0 points

Munchkin Jelly Bean Reversible Sling S/M

Munchkin Jelly Bean Reversible Sling S/M

Babies love the calming effect they get when snuggled more...0 points

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears - Blossom Trim

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears - Blossom Trim

Balboa Baby "Dr. Sears" Adjustable Sling more...0 points

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears-Dotted Daisy Brown

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears-Dotted Daisy Brown

Designed to grow as your baby does, our Balboa Bab more...0 points

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears-Black Signature

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears-Black Signature

Designed to grow as your baby does, our Balboa Bab more...0 points

Lite-on-Shoulder Baby Sling(lime)

Lite-on-Shoulder Baby Sling(lime)

For centuries babies have been carried in Slings a more...0 points

Moby Wrap Baby Carrier - Indigo

Moby Wrap Baby Carrier - Indigo

The design of the Moby Wrap uses your entire back, more...0 points

Hotslings Adjustable Pouch Baby Carrier, Quinn

Hotslings Adjustable Pouch Baby Carrier, Quinn

Hotslings AP - Quinn Stripe The easy to use Hotsli more...0 points

Lite-on-Shoulder Ring/pouch hybrid Baby Sling(Arabic Night)

Lite-on-Shoulder Ring/pouch hybrid Baby Sling(Arabic Night)

For centuries babies have been carried in Slings a more...0 points

Original Maya Wrap Sling (NOT PADDED) BRIGHT STRIPE - Medium

Original Maya Wrap Sling (NOT PADDED) BRIGHT STRIPE - Medium

We Ship with in 1-2 business days. FREE US Priorit more...0 points

Munchkin Jelly Bean Reversible Sling, Champagne - Large

Munchkin Jelly Bean Reversible Sling, Champagne - Large

Munchkin Jelly Bean Reversible Sling - Champagne T more...0 points

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears-Brown Signature

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears-Brown Signature

The Balboa Baby Sling was developed and tested by a more...0 points

Peanut Shell Boho Chic Paisley Baby Sling, Blue/Brown, Large/X-Large

Peanut Shell Boho Chic Paisley Baby Sling, Blue/Brown, Large/X-Large

The Peanut Shell® Baby Sling is a stylish pouch-s more...0 points

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears-Dotted Daisy Orange

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears-Dotted Daisy Orange

The Balboa Baby Sling was developed and tested by a more...0 points

Lite-On-Shoulder Ring/Pouch Hybrid Baby Sling (Vintage Silhouette)

Lite-On-Shoulder Ring/Pouch Hybrid Baby Sling (Vintage Silhouette)

For centuries babies have been carrier in Slings a more...0 points

Munchkin Blueberry Jelly Bean Sling - L

Munchkin Blueberry Jelly Bean Sling - L

Babies love the calming effect they get when snuggled more...0 points

Hotslings Everyday Collection Baby Carrier Tokyo size 3

Hotslings Everyday Collection Baby Carrier Tokyo size 3

Make a statement with this fun graphic print in turquoise more...0 points

Moby Wrap Organic Cotton Baby Carrier, Eggplant

Moby Wrap Organic Cotton Baby Carrier, Eggplant

The design of the MobyTM Wrap uses your entire back, more...0 points

Lite-on-Shoulder Ring/pouch hybrid Baby Sling(Vine Stencil)

Lite-on-Shoulder Ring/pouch hybrid Baby Sling(Vine Stencil)

For centuries babies have been carried in Slings a more...0 points

Lite-on-Shoulder Ring/pouch hybrid Baby Sling(Jacqueline)

Lite-on-Shoulder Ring/pouch hybrid Baby Sling(Jacqueline)

For centuries babies have been carried in Slings a more...0 points

Munchkin Licorice Jelly Bean Sling - L

Munchkin Licorice Jelly Bean Sling - L

Munchkin Jelly Bean Reversible Sling Carry your ba more...0 points

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears - Striped Trim

Balboa Baby Adjustable Sling by Dr. Sears - Striped Trim

A sling that?s as comfortable as your favorite kni more...0 points

Arguments AGAINST Slings

  1. Consumer Reports does not recommend any ring sling or wrap style soft carrier: "There are also sling carriers on the market, as well as carriers that essentially consist of a length of fabric you wrap over your shoulders and waist. Those we've seen aren't secure enough during activity." Consumer Reports, August 2004. Also available on-line (subscription required).
  2. Risk of Overheating. This is especially true in slings holding the baby in a position that covers his legs and head. Avoid over-dressing a baby when using a sling and check on the baby frequently to make sure he isn't hot (he should not sweat or feel warmer than you).

    CITATIONS: What To Expect the First Year, by Eisenburg, Murkoff, and Hathaway (Workman, NY 1996)
  3. Risk of Understimulation. This flies in the face of everything else I've read about baby wearing. I find this hard to agree with. Certainly a sling provides more stimulation than a crib and probably more than mere holding. Older babies that can sit with their head up, especially facing outwards, get to take in much more of the world than even a stroller I would imagine. But some experts argue that soft carriers like slings let the baby see less of the world. I think this has more to do with how you wear the baby in the sling than the sling itself. It is like saying that if you put a rain cover over a stroller, the baby will see less of the world than he needs to and thereby become under-stimulated. Therefore, avoid strollers. Just take it off and open the top when protection from the weather is not needed and, presto, problem solved. I imagine that sling enthusiasts would argue along the same lines in defense of slings.

    CITATIONS: What To Expect the First Year, by Eisenburg, Murkoff, and Hathaway (Workman, NY 1996)
  4. Risk of Oversleeping. Supposedly, babies carried in slings get used to catnaps and sleep too much making the less likely to sleep through the night.

    CITATIONS: What To Expect the First Year, by Eisenburg, Murkoff, and Hathaway (Workman, NY 1996)
  5. Risk of Injury. Bottom line: babies can fall out of slings if they are not properly worn. Therefore some people advise against using them or are uncomfortable with using them.

    A sling should not pose any more danger to a baby than carrying him in your arms, but it is easy to get used to having your hands free and forget you are wearing a vulnerable little person. Take the following precautions when wearing a sling:

    --Don't run or jog with a sling as the jostling can injure a babies neck.

    --Don't bend over to pick something up when wearing a baby in a sling. Bend at the knees and hold the baby with one hand.

    --Don't cook while wearing a baby.

    --Don't drink hot beverages like coffee, tea, or hot chocolate when wearing a baby .

    --Avoid holding or working with knives or other sharp objects when wearing a baby.

    --Be very careful when walking through doorways or narrow hallways. Be mindful of obstacles that pose a threat of bumping into the babies head.

    --Always inspect the sling's cloth, stitching, and rings for signs of wear.

Giving Up on the Sling?

Best alternatives to slings for the determined babywearer.

Evenflo Snugli® Serenade Soft Carrier Olive With Red

Evenflo Snugli® Serenade Soft Carrier Olive With Red

Serenade Snugli Vibra Olive/Red . Padded seat, leg more...0 points

Infantino EuroRider Baby Carrier - Khaki

Infantino EuroRider Baby Carrier - Khaki

Infantino EuroRider Baby Carrier The most luxurious more...0 points

BabyBjorn Baby Active Carrier - Sporty Black

BabyBjorn Baby Active Carrier - Sporty Black

Baby Bjorn Active Carrier Whether it?s hiking in the more...0 points

BabyBjorn Baby Original Carrier - City Black

BabyBjorn Baby Original Carrier - City Black

Baby Bjorn Baby Carrier The Baby Bjorn Baby Carrier more...0 points

BabyBjorn Air Carrier - Grey & White

BabyBjorn Air Carrier - Grey & White

BABYBJÖRN® BABYBJÖRN® offers a wide variety of more...0 points

Can I Find Help on You Tube

These people make it look easy...I hate them.

I rarely do this, but I'm letting You Tube auto select as a continued search for new sling videos without my having to search on You Tube every day.
Baby Sling Demo
by williambix1 | video info

115 ratings | 89,279 views
automatically generated by YouTube

Best Sling Resources in Print or Burned to Disk

Add your favorite books and videos about slings are vote on those already listed.

Babywearing by Mary Blois

Babywearing by Mary Blois

If someone told you they knew a secret to help you more...0 points

Works Cited: Books

Loading

Works Cited: Periodicals

Loading

Reader Feedback

Rant, Rave, Console, Cajole, Inform, or Ridicule

I've got broad shoulders, go ahead and tell me I'm an idiot if that's what you think. I'd much prefer encouragement and tips, but I can take whatever you dish out as long as it doesn't send this lens into "adult" territory.

  • RhondaSplint Feb 10, 2012 @ 9:09 am | delete
    Great article on baby slings. Very informative lens!
    Fertility Calendar
  • c_mcgee Apr 14, 2008 @ 12:55 pm | delete
    Thanks for the post, it was very helpful and informative. http://www.allaboutslipcovers.com
  • ChouDoufu Jul 16, 2007 @ 4:24 am | delete
    Victoria, thanks for your input. Your lens on baby slings has some good tips and I encourage others to check it out. I would also like to suggest that you add or vote on slings you find to be particularly good in my WORLD'S BEST SLINGS list, above.
  • Victoria at baby-bean.com Jul 11, 2007 @ 7:50 am | delete
    The trouble is that babywearing has become such a trend that the market is swamped with poor quality carriers, and the information out there is overwhelming. I'm sure I could help you find a sling that suits you; I've written a great guide on choosing baby carriers - squidoo.com/babybeanbabyslings
  • Jun 28, 2007 @ 12:51 pm | delete
    I love the lens! Much useful info. 5 stars from Baby Games.
  • Load More

by

ChouDoufu

STINKY.
SPICY.
SCRUMPTIOUS.

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!