Bottled Water: Should It Be Banned?
Ranked #2,282 in Healthy Living, #43,354 overall | Donates to Squidoo Charity Fund
Should Bottled Water Be Banned? Here's What I Think
Bottled Water: Should It Be Banned?
I have mixed views on this subject.
As a bleeding heart liberal I don't believe in the banning of anything. I believe that through education you can persuade most people to do the right thing.
However, I also believe that most people don't give a damn about the earth or what type of a legacy we will be leaving for future generations.
So I've got mixed feelings and I want to know how you feel about this major issue.
You should know that our family no longer purchases bottled water (except when there are no other choices or when it makes sense) and have taken other steps to reduce, reuse and recycle when ever possible.
Contents at a Glance
So How Do You Feel About This Issue?
You don't need to be a Squidoo member to take part in this discussion. So fire away!
Should Single Use Plastic Water Bottles Be Banned?

Yes
Goofy says:
its super bad for your health you could get real sick
kudfh says:
It is unhealthy for your health from all that junk in the plastic
it should be banned!
jason says:
all the dirt from the RECYCLED plastic sinks into the water when it sits in a warm area.
matthew says:
because we doesn't know that if germs are there.
WhimsicalWatters says:
The single servig size water bottles should go away. As for large gallon jugs of water, they should stay. I live in a house that has well water, so I have to buy gallon jugs of water for cooking and drinking. I reuse the jugs until they are no longer usable. I think in the past 4 years, I only had to replace 3 of my water jugs.
As for 16, and 20 and 32 oz water bottles.I own my own water bottles. They do not get thrown away, and they are of course reusable. It makes more sense to just buy a 7 dollar water bottle, then to buy multiple disposable water bottles. It means less waste, and more money saved.
Iris jung says:
the container from it could be easily melt when exposed by heat, so it's hard to reduce.it is very uncomfortable.It also gives out harmful gas while burning.
travis says:
I say we ban them but they do come in handy sometimes
claire says:
ban plastic water bottles and other sugary drink bottles all the bottles that arent get recycled are killing are envirement
Rush says:
They kill too many animals when they digest them and litter the countryside
ali says:
Yes, single use plastic water bottles should be banned. 1.) they are a threat to our environment 2.) they (the bpa in the plastic) are a threat to humans 3.) they are just a scam and many people don't understand that the regulations for plastic bottle water companies are practically none, while your tap water has many regulations and can be trusted to be safer. Corporations often use tap water to put in their bottled water, i.e. dasani, aquafina, and nestle brand bottled water - therefor you are just being charged for the label. It's a scam that is highly dangerous to humans and our earth.
KingLobster says:
I never buy bottled water. Not only is it harmful to the environment, but the cost is just ridiculous. Why would I pay for something that I can get for free? The water bottling companies engage in some terrible practices, and I would like to see this faux demand eliminated.
tubad says:
plz dont ban
malaz berry says:
many people think that whater battles are not bad ...but you are killing our earth and people are making a diferents ...one person think that if she or he is going to help that world they think that the world is still going to be that same but you can make a diferents my helping and you can change the world to ...SO PLZZ MAKE A DIFERENTS IN THIS WORLD
Janine says:
they are bad for the environment
mothernatureluvr says:
Laziness and convience!--most of the bottled water is stolen from local water supplies and then we buy i for 1600X the cost!---Oh capitalism you tricky little leprechaun
I says:
I think we should should banned water bottles cause if your water is safe use your but if it is not safe then you can use a water bottle
Me says:
Bottled water should be banned because bottled water may be better to drink but it isn't good for the environment. A lot of plastic has been wasted upon using bottled water for consumption. Also, it's CHEAPER!
josh ksen says:
watch the documentry called "tapped" everyone who reads this please.... if you have any interest in this subject whatsoever. i was blind sided with just how deep this rabbit hole goes. i was left angry-sad. another reason why we as americans ... human beings need to open our eyes and remove the blindfold so delicately placed upon on us.
No
Jaydon Ryu says:
there are many people that cant drink tap water and it is handy when traveling
Jenna says:
Bottled water can be recycled, can't it?
Tiggered says:
Banned? Next thing you'll ban computers, cars and all the plastics. How about giving it some negative pr instead?
banning this is stupid! says:
why should we ban it? it is convenient for road trips or at school when its either that or drink out of a water fountain which is half water half pure germs.
and people who just through it in the garbage are jerks, why not just throw it in a recycling bin so it can be used again. bottled water is light and more convenient than a heavy water bottle. And it is many peoples opinion that bottled water is better more you than tap water. DONT BAN!!!!
bob the builder says:
don't ban!!!
rumbling says:
I don't think they should be banned, there are situations where its hard to find clean water and plastic water will come in very handy then, but as you said we can always reduce using them with providing proper infrastructure and through education
annna says:
i think we shound not banned water bottles becuse not evry one has clean tap water
ShirlW says:
Not sure which side to post on here. We do use them in our home, however I buy a case of water once every several months. We fill these bottles from a five gallon container. I am the official water bottle Nazi in our home, if you are caught getting a new bottle you better have a good reason as to why you need one OR ELSE!
banner says:
DiSaGrEe!
BOBTEHNOOB says:
YAH DUH
anne says:
no! its bad for the earth and studies show tap waters better 4 u!
Tempus says:
Oohh! Tough Call - How about buying one single use plastic water bottle and then refilling it several times from a lager 5L/1gallon bottle. That way you help to save the earth and you also don't have to impose a ban.
Balancebydesign4u says:
Educate and allow people to make informed choices. We live in a free country!
Jae says:
It kills me to have to drink bottled water. I have tried sink filters as well as pitcher filters and even combined the two, only to have allergic reactions each and everytime. I recycle but still feel horribly guilty even though it is out of my hands.
Cassidy says:
Bottled water to consumers should not be banned. Consumers have a right to pay ridiculous prices for bottled water that is usually the same if not a little worse than tap water. However, I strongly believe that City Governments should ban the purchasing of bottled water for employees and city sponsored events. San Francisco CA and Seattle OR both have banned the purchasing of bottled water and have saved between hundreds of thousands of dollars annually that can be spent on more important things. This ban could also encourage the citizens of the city to think about their bottled water consumption and maybe decrease their over consumption of this high priced NOT HEALTHIER alternative.
ajgodinho says:
No, I don't think banning one item is going to help a great deal. Besides, I don't believe they will be able to do so anyway. We would have to ban a lot of things and people are not ready to give it up. I think we should focus on educating people about the harmful effects of not just plastic bottles, but everything like prescription drugs, gas-guzzling vehicles, littering, etc. and allowing them to make the decisions, may be those items that are harmful to the environment and health should be taxed steeply. There are many ways to tackle this issue rather than just banning it. I think being responsible is the way to go!
Furry H8er says:
Mr.Gore is a very esteemed man in socitey and you mock him with your typos and balderdash. Throwing rocks at animals? Really. I should have you arrested you scrub. Using more plastic is not the anwser. Using less is the way.
Selwa says:
I don't think a ban is the answer. But I don't advocate the purchase and consumption of bottled water either. Here's a good article on reasons for and against a bottled water ban: http://www.filtersfast.com/Bottled-Water-Versus-Tap-Water.asp. There are valid reasons for both sides, but I'm not sure a ban would do any good. People tend to value their freedom to choose. There needs to be a creative way to make people more informed (like the above article, for example) so that they will make responsible choices for the environment, on which we are all mutually dependent for survival.
A Few Facts About Plastic Water Bottles
Some of the data is from 2006 and since then, there has been an increase in the use of bottled water - so most of the statistics would now be much higher.But as you will see some are quite shocking.
~ The Pacific Institute estimates that producing the bottles for American consumption in 2006 required the equivalent of more than 17 million barrels of oil.
~ The manufacture of every ton of PET produces around 3 tons of carbon dioxide (CO2). Bottling water thus created more than 2.5 million tons of CO2 in 2006.
~ 250g of CO2 are released for each bottle of FIJI Water imported to the United States. This includes 93g for manufacturing a bottle in China, 4g for transporting an empty bottle to Fiji, and 153g for shipping a full bottle to the United States.
~ It also takes water to make a bottle. You probably never thought of that - I know that I didn't.
Read more about bottled water at Wikipedia and the links right below.
My Favorite Sites For Information About Water Quality and Single Use Bottled Water
Environmental Protection Agency - Local Drinking Water Information
Get information from the EPA on the facts about yo more...0 points
EPA Ground Water & Drinking Water
Drinking water standards and explanations and also more...0 points
Bottled Water - Corporate Water Privatization - Sierra Club
See startling facts and figures of what bottled wa more...0 points
Sierra Club Free PDF Report
Quick and short report with facts about water qual more...0 points
What Does it Mean To Be Going Green?
Going Green Ideas Are All Based On The Principles of Reducing, Reusing and Recycling
Do you know what it means when someone says that they want to "go green" - I mean do you really know?
While many of us think we have an idea we may not truly know.
Here are just a few hints as to what "going green" actually entails.
You may have heard many people say or have seen bumper stickers with the phrase "reduce, reuse and recycle" - but how does this affect what you are currently doing now to go green? By the way - the bumper sticker is actually anti-green so it's not really a good idea. Remember a bumper sticker is not a needed item - so it's wasteful.
1) Reducing
This first part of the go green principle triangle is to rely less on the energy we're using in addition to material objects. This doesn't just mean turning off the light switch when you leave a room, or cut down on your leisurely driving habits (think Sunday afternoon drives with the family) - it also means saving energy by consuming less. Everything we buy took more energy to create than we realize. By reducing everything we use, we're going a long way to protect the environment (and we'll be saving money).
Reducing also means to think more about your purchases even if we don't necessarily cut down. For example, some of the most important going green ideas are based around the food we eat. When buying food from the supermarket, simply choosing a brand that uses less packaging than others will reduce our carbon footprint. When you are purchasing 1 small item from a store do you really need a bag for it or can you just pick it and the receipt up and leave? If you can you'll be saving a bag. Ok, I know - that's just 1 bag - but if each of us saved 1 bag every month you'll quickly see how it adds up.
Do you fabric softener to every wash that you do?
Could you cut out or cut back on its use?
Do you need to have a plugin air freshener plugged in all the time? Maybe just when you are expecting guests.
Sure you could probably do without air fresheners, fabric softeners, perfumes and rug fresheners, but if you feel you can't start by cutting back as every little bit does help.
2) Reusing
The second principle says that we should try to make the most out of everything that we already have before replacing it. Many of us are used to throwing things away without really thinking carefully about whether the item still has any life left in it.
Some going green ideas that come under this heading include repairing holes in clothing, or even re-purposing old jean into a fashionable new skirt or a reusable eco-friendly bag.
What do you do with your old worn out towels that no longer suck up the water they once did? Do you just toss them out?
We use our old towels for dust cloths and cleaning towels. Also if you have any bath sheets, they are great to place down on the floor near your door and when pets and people come into your home with wet and muddy shoes, it will catch the mess.
Old T-shirts & socks also make great dusting cloths.
Do you have your groceries packed in plastic bags?
We do and this is why. We reuse the plastic bags as trash bags.
I know many people who will use reusable shopping bags for their groceries and then purchase heavier gauge plastic bags for their trash..
Shopping bags are usually made from a thinner plastic and many now are biodegradable while the heavier trash bags are not.
So for me, I prefer to use the plastic grocery bags. When the bag is full we tied the handles together so that there is no opening for birds or other creatures to get their head caught in them.
Also did you know that many reusable bags are made from a heavy plastic material? Not very earth friendly is it?
3) Recycling
This principle is also based on reducing the number of items we send to the landfill. Recycling means using old materials to create something new, instead of leaving it to decompose (which believe it or not can take thousands of years for some products).
Many cities and towns have rules and regulations for their garbage pick up and recyclable items must be cleaned and separated.
If your town does not have a mandatory law they still may have a voluntary one and if they do try to take advantage of it.
While we all hear the term "going green" all the time how many of us actually do much about it?
Just start small and make more changes when you feel ready.
Safer and Eath Friendly Water Bottles
Videos To Help Prove The Point That Single Use Water Bottles Should be Banned
I Don't Believe That Plastic Water Bottles Should Be Banned
Here is a link to prove why
Ok, it's time for you to add some links to show why single use plastic water bottles should not be banned.
http://www.bottledwater.org/
Information from the International Bottled Water A more...0 points
Can't Live Without Toting Around Water?
Instead of single use plastic bottled water, why not save the earth and money by using eco-friendly, family-friendly, kid-friendly, reusable water bottles?Sigg Water Bottles
Home filtered water is less, much less expensive than bottled water.
Here is a quick average cost comparison
Tap Water ( unfiltered) .0015 per gallon
Home Filtered Water .13 per gallon
Bottled Water $1.36 per gallon
This cost comparison was made before the price of gas had spiked. Your savings of filtered water over bottled water increases with each gas price hike as the cost to ship the bottled water to the store increases.
News Articles Discussing Single Use Plastic Water Bottles
- In new tack, senator proposes ban on water bottles if not redeemable by 2013
- Cynthia Creem thinks she has a solution to the long-stalled effort on Beacon Hill to expand the state's bottle redemption law to include water: just ban water bottles altogether. Frustrated by the reluctance of House and Senate leadership to entertain ...
- Buy, Grab, Drink, Trash: Environmental Implications of Bottled Water
- This is the life of one bottle of water after a consumer gets their hands on it. Imagine doing that seven days a week, every week for one year. The trash pile that would accrue from this habit would probably fill your entire house.
- Is Your Water Bottle Giving You Cancer?
- BPA is a common chemical used primarily in the production of plastics, such as baby bottles, canned goods (lining the inside of cans), soda bottles, and other common plastic goods that typically hold food or beverages (although it is found in countless ...
- Water bottle ban proposed at London Olympics
- Olympic organizers, fearing the use of ?liquid bombs? at this summer's games in London, are reportedly banning spectators from carrying outside water bottles to events. It's part of an exhaustive list of items attendees will be barred from bringing ...
Harmful Chemicals?
Do single use plastic water bottles actually leach harmful chemicals into our water?The better questions is: Are you willing to take the chance?
by The_Health_Lady
I have mixed emotions about the banning of single use plastic water bottles and I want to see how you feel about this subject.
- 111 featured lenses
- Top lens » Woodstock Music Festival 1969