Best Thanksgiving Pies

Ranked #23,541 in Food & Cooking, #456,748 overall

Pumpkin Pie is NOT the only Pie

I never grew up with Thanksgiving. When people in North America, and other Thanksgiving enthusiasts were celebrating historic turkey day, I was frolicking in the spring flowers in Hermanus, South Africa. Even in the first couple of years after immigrating to Canada my family mostly begrudgingly ate KFC and watched movies because everything was closed. When I went off to University the pang of a soon to be empty nest inspired a sudden interest in making Thanksgiving a tradition, which was perfect because it was right around the time I started obsessing over pie-making and in fact found what I still believe is the best pie crust recipe. Since none of my family ever really acquired a taste for turkey or pumpkin pie, I decided to be creative and come up with some traditional foods of our own. While I realize this lens will ultimately just make dentists all over the place very rich, I am hoping that these melt in your mouth alternatives or twists to these classic pie recipes will be well worth your future investment in dentures. Find some of the best Thanksgiving pie recipes that are alternatives to pumpkin pie and learn how to make your pumpkin pie different than the others. Make your own pumpkin puree, make your own pie crust, or simply skip the pie and see what neat gourd recipes may serve your Thanksgiving needs.

Making your own Pumpkin Puree

The canned stuff is pretty classic and I get that but I started making my own puree and while it can be quite a bit of work it's something you can do way ahead of time and freeze or refrigerate until you'll use it. Plus, it makes the pie so very tasty.

You Will Need:
1 Sugar Pumpkin (or Butternut Squash, or 6-8 Yams)

-- Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F
-- Cut the pumpkin into 1/8 pieces after cleaning out all the seeds and gunk in the middle.
-- Place on a baking sheet lined with foil. Smear a generous amount of butter on each slice to help them brown and then, my secret method, sprinkle brown sugar (the nice thick dark kind) or some honey on each piece.
-- Bake in the oven until caramelized on top and when you are able to poke your fork through with relative ease.
-- Let it cool. Now take scoop all the pumpkin out of the skin and throw into a food processor and puree. If you don't have a food processor just mix and pound it until its smooth.
-- Now the hard part, using a strainer, strain about a cup at a time of the puree. Pumpkin has all these stringy bits that you don't want so this gets rid of them. You need to press the puree through the strainer with a spoon because it isn't liquidy enough to just strain by itself. This can be a bit painstaking but let the family take shifts or do it while watching a late afternoon murder mystery on T.V

Voila!



Caramal Apple Pie

Oh yum!!! A classic apple pie recipe drenched in caramel and baked to make a sweet crust on top of the warm tart taste of green apples. I found this recipe online and it's now a family favorite.

Some of my ow advice:

-- ALWAYS use granny smith or other hard tart apples. You are adding sugar to the mixture so don't pick a soft sweet apple. It bakes into a soggy overly sweet pie.
-- Most recipes call for the apples to be peeled- NAH! keeping the skin gives it a real homemade taste and look. The pie bakes long enough that the skin gets soft and sticky and the taste is well worth it.
-- To keep your apples from browning, squeeze a small amount of lemon juice on them and toss. No more brown mushy apples before its even in the oven.

JUST click on the picture to get this AMAZING recipe.

Pumpkin Streusel Pie

A twist on a classic recipe. WARNING: After eating this pumpkin pie it's all your family will want. Creamy crunchy deliciousness. My moms favorite and soon it will be yours! Click on the picture to go straight to the recipe.

My Advice:

-- The recipe makes quite a bit of streusel topping and I personally find it a bit too much. I want the pie to stand out and not be too sweet. I am old school that way- so I use only enough to make a nice single layer of the topping on my pie. It's not a waste though- check out my gourds section to see how you can use this streusel topping again!

-- Beware leftovers- they will be short-lived. Bake two of these bad boys!

Sweet Potato Pie

Sweet Potato Recipes
Check out this fellow squids recipes while I work on perfecting my own for next turkey season. Check back soon though- either there will be a picture of something great or of my burnt face. Either one is promising, you must admit.

Stewed Fruit Pie with Devon Custard

This recipe can be found in many varieties and can be used not only in pie but with filo pastry, as a dessert in itself, on top of a pound cake, and as a parfait or sundae. It's definitely a fall/winter dessert and perfect as an alternative to pumpkin pie.

What You Need:
***Try and stay within the season or buy locally but here are some of my favorite fruits to use. How much you use is totally up to you.

2 peaches sliced thickly
1 package strawberries (use whole or halved)
1 package blackberries
2 plums thickly sliced
1 pear cut into chunks
A handful of halved apricots
A vanilla bean (halved)
Whole star anise and/or cinnamon stick
Brown sugar (1-2tbsp)
1/2 cup of water

Pie Crust (see below for recipes)

1 Can Devon custard

To Do:

-- Preheat oven to 425 degrees F
-- Boil water in a medium to large sized pot. Bring heat down to a low-medium and add sugar, stirring until it is fully melted into the water.
-- Scrape the seeds out of the halved vanilla bean into the pot of boiling sugar water and chuck in the bean as well. Add the star anise and/or cinnamon stick as well.
-- Add the cut up fruit starting with the harder fruit and then adding the softer fruits like berries (about 2 minutes later)
-- Simmer (or stew) the fruit on a low temperature until all the fruit is soft and the water has a thicker more syrupy look.
-- Scoop fruit into prepared pie crust avoiding pouring in too much of the liquid and flash bake on 425 degrees F for 15 minutes. Turn down heat to 350F and continue baking for another 15-20 minutes or until outer crust is golden brown.
-- Let is set for at least 10 minutes and serve warm with a dollop of custard.

Try your own stewed fruit variation and post it in the comments!

A Pie Countdown

Become a AllRecipes.com subscriber and get a Pie Countdown Newsletter! It's amazing and full of great pies. It's free too.
Simply follow the link, scroll down, and hit "join now".

How to Make a Lattice Crust

Check out this kid show us how to make lattice crust.
powered by Youtube

Pie Making Equipment

Loading

My Food Processor/Love of my Life

Yes, it's true. My food processor and I have been having a love affair since December 25th 2009 when it was unassumingly sitting underneath a Christmas Tree in my parents house wearing what i can only describe as a festive clothing and a card that said exactly what I needed to hear, "i am here for you".


Black & Decker FP2620S Power Pro Wide-Mouth 10-Cup Food Processor with 5-Cup Blender Jar

Gorging on Gourds

Gourds are beautiful little warty things to keep on your table during fall especially during the Thanksgiving and Halloween times. If you are not a big pie person or simply predict many relatives fattening you up with pies all weekend long and you want something else for your own dinner- TRY SOME OF THESE!

Edible Gourds: Not all gourds are edible and you should be careful of this. Most of the edible ones other than the classic squashes like butternut, acorn and ambercup will have an "edible" sticker on them to indicate if they are for the table or for your belly.

What You Need: (per 2 gourds or four servings)

Each guest should have half a gourd. Buy a bunch of different types and serve each guest a different looking one. This makes for a very pretty and festive table.
1 can of lentils PER 2 gourds (four halves)
1/2 cup of crushed walnuts or pecans (I've even used crushed almonds)
2 teaspoons cinnamon (or 1 nutmeg and 1 cinnamon/ or 2 pumpkin spice mixture)
4 tablespoons thick brown sugar
2 teaspoons flour
OR use the leftover streusel topping from the pumpkin pie above

To Do:

-- Preheat oven to 375 degrees F
-- After halving and cleaning the gourds scoop out half of their insides to form a kind of bowl. Keep the insides one side for now.
-- Rinse the lentils and combine with insides of gourds.
-- Put spoonfuls of mixture into each gourd bowl and keep flattening to make room for more.
-- Put on baking sheet and place on individual squares of foil that will later wrap up your gourds.
-- Topping: Combine butter, sugar, flour and nuts until it forms large crumbs.
-- Use the crumbs to build a crust over each halved gourd and cover it in foil when done.
-- Bake for 20-40 minutes depending on gourd. Halfway through cooking take off foil to brown the crust. TEST: If you can poke your fork through the bowl part easily without much resistance it is ready. The topping will also be browned and caramelized.
-- If it has not caramelized but the filling is cooked, turn up the heat to 425F and bake for 3-5minutes uncovered.

I'll be posting pictures soon!

Which Gourds Are Edible??????

Squash Variaties and Storage
Summer and Winter Squash

Breaking the Rules

Since we are from South Africa we choose to do an African themed fall table. The colors actually really compliment each other and textures and materials like straw mats, dried flowers and plants, and sienna, burnt sienna and browns are common in both.

Where are you from? How do you incorporate your customs or heritage into your Thanksgiving spread? Post it in my "What's Eating You?" section.

What's Eating You?

  • AlecToller Oct 6, 2010 @ 10:20 pm | delete
    I want to eat this every day until I die.
  • remanon Oct 5, 2010 @ 6:19 pm | delete
    I love pumpkin - but not pumpkin pie! Now that Caramel Apple Pie, that looks like a winner to me. Really enjoyed this lens.
  • SandyPeaks Oct 5, 2010 @ 5:25 pm | delete
    Excellent lens! Point me at the Pie!
  • emmalarkins Oct 5, 2010 @ 12:43 pm | delete
    Saw that you're new, and wanted to give you a leg up. This lens has been blessed by a Squidoo Angel!
  • nnaij Oct 5, 2010 @ 11:30 am | delete
    I want an apple pie for Thanksgiving!
  • Load More

by

EdenT

Thanksgiving is a new tradition in my family but one we've adopted with passion and gluttony. Pie is my favorite part of the traditional meal so here... more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!

Amazon Spotlight 

Seasons

Amazon Price: $71.50 (as of 05/30/2012)Buy Now