Brother Louie: Hot Chocolate vs Stories

Ranked #5,245 in Music, #145,535 overall

Brother Louie: A Tale of Forbidden Love?

The song Brother Louie, hit versions of which were recorded by both Hot Chocolate and Stories, tells the tale of an interracial liaison between two young lovers and the response to this affair by each of their parents.

The cover version by the American band, Stories, is distinctly different to that of the one by British band, Hot Chocolate.

I hadn't heard the cover until I came to the States. It was only during several months of late night driving that it first came to my attention. Travelling home, I used to flip on the local Oldies station for company, and more often than not, Brother Louie was one of the songs that was played.

I remember thinking at the time: What the heck have they done to this song? Having grown up in England during the 1970s, and used to the original version by Hot Chocolate, the whole feel of the song had been changed. This wasn't the track I knew and loved!

Album Art: Hot Chocolate: Best of the 70's.

About the Band: Hot Chocolate

Brother Louie Hot ChocolateAlthough the group still exists today in another form, Hot Chocolate enjoyed its greatest successes during the 1970s and 1980s.

At a time when both Motown and Philadelphia International were producing their own brands of American funk and soul, in the UK, Hot Chocolate was beginning its prolific run of pop funk chart hits. Over the decade the band managed to become one of only three acts to achieve at least one hit song in the UK in every year of the 1970s. In all, Hot Chocolate charted 20 singles between 1970 and 1979.

Fronted by Errol Brown, Hot Chocolate are probably best remembered for the songs You Sexy Thing - used in the movie The Full Monty - as well as Every 1's A Winner, both also American hits.

Other big sellers included So You Win Again, the group's only UK Number 1, as well as Emma, A Child's Prayer and the one discussed here, Brother Louie.

UK download: Every 1's a Winner - The Very Best of Hot Chocolate

Image: Hot Chocolate by Stepheye on Flickr

Brother Louie: The Hot Chocolate Version

The Original From April 1973

This is the original version of Brother Louie as recorded by Hot Chocolate. Written by group members Errol Brown and Tony Wilson, the song reached a peak of Number 7 on the British music charts in May, 1973.

Hot Chocolate's rendition has a pop/soul/funk feel to it and includes several passages of spoken words which are missing from the American re-recording.

powered by Youtube

Hot Chocolate: The Greatest Hits

Includes Brother Louie

Their Greatest Hits

Amazon Price: $9.99 (as of 05/30/2012)Buy Now

All of Hot Chocolate's best known songs are included on this greatest hits compilation, including You Sexy Thing, So You Win Again, Every 1's A Winner and Emma.

About the Band: Stories

Brother Louie StoriesThe story of Stories is a fairly short one. Formed in 1972 by Michael Brown and vocalist Ian Lloyd, the band only lasted two years in total.

Over that period, Stories briefly brushed the US charts with songs like I'm Coming Home and Mammy Blue, but it was the cover of Brother Louie that became the band's biggest claim to fame when it reached Number 1 in the US for two weeks during the late Summer of 1973.

However, the group could not repeat the success of this song, and only one of their albums, About Us, managed to place inside the US Top Forty. Not long after this, Stories was history.

Brother Louie: The Stories Version

The Cover From August 1973

Stories one big American hit is the revised version of Brother Louie, which became a US Number One song at the end of August, 1973.

Notice that the arrangement is completely different - more of a rock feel - and that the spoken word element has been removed. This is probably due to the sensitivity of American radio stations, which no doubt, would not have played the disc had they remained.

powered by Youtube

Hit Songs of the 1970s

Includes Brother Louie by Stories

Essential 70's 4 CDs

Amazon Price: $14.49 (as of 05/30/2012)Buy Now

Many of the biggest hit songs of the 1970s are included on this four CD set, including Brother Louie by Stories. Over fifty tracks to enjoy!

The Brother Louie Debate

Which version of Brother Louie do you prefer?

Loading

Hot Chocolate

Stories

 

Brother Louie on iTunes

Both versions of Brother Louie can be directly downloaded from here to your favourite mp3 player!

Track Artist Album  
Brother Louie Hot Chocolate Every 1's a Winner - The Very Best of Hot Chocolate
Brother Louie (Re-Recorded) The Stories Dazed & Confused (Music Inspired By the Film) [Re-Recorded Versions]

More Music From the 1970s

If you enjoy pop and rock music from the 1970s, why not try these pages out for size?

Loading

More 70s Music Memories

The British Music Blog

Loading

For Your Bookmarking Pleasure

If you have enjoyed visiting this Brother Louie page, why not bookmark it and show your friends?

Add this to your lens »

Bookmark and Share

About This Brother Louie Fan

Loading

Did You Enjoy This Page About Brother Louie?

If you would like to rate this page about Brother Louie, then please do so here (Squidoo members only).

This module only appears with actual data when viewed on a live lens. The favorite and lensroll options will appear on a live lens if the viewer is a member of Squidoo and logged in.

Add this to your lens »

Is Brother Louie A Favourite Song of Yours?

Your Comments Are Welcomed!

  • uneasywriter Mar 14, 2012 @ 7:06 am | delete
    Both of these versions are very good, I would have to say "Stories" is my most preferred. Great lens!
  • TheLittleCardShop May 4, 2011 @ 10:02 pm | delete
    I like both versions but Stories adds a more "blues" sound to it. Excellent debate about Brother Louie"Song
  • prosperity66 May 3, 2011 @ 11:44 am | delete
    Woops... I like how both version sound but as someone who likes anything original, I would have like that the Stories sing the exact same song as the Hot Chocolate, which I really loved when I was... oh... sooooooooooooo young - but never forgot! What a fantastic band!

by

Waxing-Lyrical

The song Brother Louie by Hot Chocolate, or Stories, is one of my favourites from the 1970s.

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!

Related Music Pages 

Loading