Why does it matter if your flowers are organic?
Where are your flowers from?
The average cut flower travels 1,500 miles in its short lifetime.
Colombia is the world's top producer of cut flowers, leaving Holland in the #2 position. Other major exporters of the world's cut flowers are: Ecuador, Guatemala, Costa Rica, Mexico, United States, Israel, Turkey, Belgium / Luxembourg, Germany, United Kingdom, Italy, France, Spain, Zimbabwe, Kenya, Tanzania, Morocco, South Africa, Mauritius, India, Thailand, New Zealand, Malaysia, Singapore and Australia. The best producers of cut flowers will be located close to the equator, with year-round warm temperatures and (ideally) high altitudes, such as Ecuador and Colombia. Due to technology and greenhouses, the United Kingdom, Germany, Belgium / Luxembourg and of course Holland also are able to produce flowers year-round. Most of the more temperate and cold-weather climate countries (aside from Holland) are not high on the list of the world's top flower exporters though.
The origin of your cut flowers is environmentally important for several reasons. Most obvious is the fact that the more miles your product travels, the more airline fuel is used. Every 3 hours, a 35-ton cargo plane laden with cut flowers departs Colombia, destined all over the world(1). Flowers grown in developing nations are not always subject to the same pesticide regulations as we are necessarily accustomed to. One flower farm in the state of Morelos, Mexico, was shown to be using 36 pesticides in its operations, including the chemical DDT. Finally, due to stringent controls now present on agricultural products entering countries such as the USA, cut flowers are doused with chemicals in order to clear customs. One of the many chemicals used to "sanitize" imported flowers is the toxic and ozone-depleting methyl bromide.(1)
Aside from environmental concerns, many foreign-grown flowers carry a human toll as well.The workers, often women and children, are frequently exposed to the above-mentioned pesticides and chemicals. These workers are frequently bare-armed with no facial masks or other forms of protection. Workers are sometimes present when the greenhouses and crops are sprayed with toxic pesticides. Sometimes they are removed during the treatments, but return to work only several hours after pesticide application.(2). Colombia in particular has been criticized for the high rate of miscarriages, congenital deformations and premature births associated with pregnant women working in the flower farms. Often, sweatshop conditions exist for flower farm workers. Trade unions are discouraged if not downright dangerous to take part in. Wages are minimal and overtime is expected, particularly around big holidays such as Valentine's Day.
Flowers grown in "developed" countries are not necessarily 100% ethically correct however. Most flower pickers at farms in the United States, the United Kingdom and even Holland are undocumented workers. Of course, they work for substandard wages and have no access to established labor standards.
The proposition has been made that transporting naturally grown flowers is more environmentally-friendly than powering the heating and lighting needed in greenhouses. The fuel used in the air transportation of cut flowers grown in equatorial countries potentially contributes less pollution than that generated by powering the heat and light required in greenhouse growing conditions.
Isn't growing plants a good thing for the environment?
Many flower-growing practices carry a heavy eco-pricetag.
As mentioned above, flowers grown in colder climates are grown in artificially heated and lighted greenhouses. It has not yet been determined whether this use of energy contributes more or less to pollution than the use of air fuel to jet in flowers from equatorial climates, grown in natural conditions.
Growing high-quality flowers requires a lot of water. In certain areas of the world, flower farming has caused water tables of certain locales to drop. After the flowers and plants have been watered, that water flows somewhere. The water will flow into the ground, rivers, streams and our oceans - having picked up a multitude of chemicals and pesticides from unsustainable flower farming practices.
Weighing environmental costs of cut flowers against jobs in developing nations
Saving nature and people at the same time.
Flowers are thirsty creatures. Really thirsty. In fact, African flowers farms have been drying out that continent's 3rd largest lake, Lake Naivasha in Kenya. Not only is the water of this lake being siphoned off and exported in the form of cut flowers and roses, the remaining water is being polluted through chemicals and pesticides, the workers are often being treated inhumanely and indigenous tribal peoples are being pushed off their lands.An easy solution to this problem is to stop buying cut flowers. However, countries like Kenya are facing an economic crisis. One has to decide what is the greater evil: furthering the economic or the environmental damage for countries experiencing severe crises such as these. The most logical and humane choice may be to continue to support the flower industry through purchase of both organic and fair-trade flowers.
You can read more about efforts to save Lake Naivasha and, consequently, the Kenyan environment through a boycott of cut flowers in the Los Angeles Times 'Emerald City' blog entry, "Roses are red and water-intesive".
What can I do to help?
I don't want to give up the romance of cut flowers!
While this article meant to alert you to socially and environmentally unsound practices in the cut flower industry, it is not meant to dissuade you from purchasing cut flowers! Flower farms in developing and third-world countries can provide employment for thousands. We, as consumers of cut flowers, can demand certified or organic flowers from our florist or local farmers market.
Consulting your local florist is a good bet for finding locally-grown, organic flowers. They can also offer certified flowers. Of course, certified or organic flowers will cost more. You can be assured, however, that your money is going to improve someone's quality of life. On holidays of love such as Valentine's Day or Mother's Day when flowers are de rigeur, it makes sense to also honor this largely female workforce by contributing a premium to the workers through your purchase of certified flowers.
Fortunately for the US, it is coming up to speed with European demand for certified flowers. It is no longer difficult to purchase socially, economically or environmentally conscious cut flowers. Major online florist 1-800-FLOWERS.com offers a selection of "Organic, Natural & Fair Trade" gifts and flowers (Fair Trade Certified). FTD.com offers an "eco-friendly" selection of flowers & gifts that are "certified as sustainably grown", although not certified organic. Organic Bouquet boasts the following certifications: USDA Organic, Biodynamic, Veriflora and Fair Trade Certified.
Where Can I Buy Organic Flowers?
Order Organic Flowers From Organic Bouquet
All products are USDA, Fair Trade or Rainforest Alliance Certified
If your Organic Bouquet product comes in a cotton bag, there is a story behind that. In Kochi, India in 2008, Organic Bouquet agreed to purchase scrap remnants from the cotton mill where Organic Bouquet sheets are manufactured. These scraps are sewn into the bags that contain the sheets or other gift items. This agreement raised enough funds for 300 girls from the area to go to school for the first time.
Back to flowers though.. In Peru's Andean Highlands, Organic Bouquet 100% financed the purchase of flower seeds for local flower farmers. In 2010, Organic Bouquet plans to extend their commitment to organic flower farmers in the highlands of Peru and Colombia as well. They plan to cover 100% of the cost for certification of these farmers, presumably (its me presuming here) for Veriflora certification or another like name.
Organic Bouquet has many partners. These include: USDA; Fairtrade; Rainforest Alliance; Accion International; Conservacion y Dessarollo; Florverde; Flor Ecuador; Veriflora; www.carbonfund.org and the Nicaragua Reforestation Project.
You can even save some money along with saving the Earth when you look for Organic Bouquet Coupon Codes
Flower Certification Authorities
What to look for when buying flowers
- Fair Trade Certified Flowers
- Certified by TransFair USA (the only certifier of fair trade products in the USA), Fair Trade Certified flowers do not necessarily meet "organic" standards, but certify that your flower grower meets social and environmental standards, and that workers receive a premium to invest in community development programs such as daycare centers.
- Veriflora - Certified Sustainably Grown
- A certification program for fresh cut flowers and potted plants conducted by the independent third party, SCS. Standards that must be met fall under both environmental and social & economic responsibility, as well as product integrity.
Nevado Flower Farm in Ecuador - A Step in the Right Direction
PBS - FRONTLINE / World - Deb Tullman & Cortney Hamilton
FRONTLINE/World | ECUADOR: Flower Power | PBS
Fair trade roses for Valentine's Day Reporters Deb Tullmann and Cortney Hamilton investigate the changing landscape of flower farming in Ecuador, where the latest trend is towards environmentally sound practices, safer working conditions, and fair trade certification. One farm, Nevado Roses, is leading the way in this revolution. http://www.pbs.org/frontlineworld/rough/2008/02/ecuador_a_rosie.html
Runtime: 652
5263 views
5 Comments:
curated content from YouTube
B & H Flowers
Veriflora Certified
Economics and the Colombian Flower Farms
A weakened US dollar and rising fuel costs wreak havoc on the Colombian flower market
Further Reading On The Cut Flower Industry and Organic Flower Farming
Bibliography
Sources Cited
- Organic Consumers Association
- "Why Buy Organic Flowers For Valentine's Day & Every Day" - submitted September 5, 2003.
http://www.organicconsumers.org/organic/flowers020204.cfm - Sierra Club Canada
- "Sierra Club of Canada urges Canadians to put love first this Valentine's Day." - February 12, 2004
http://www.sierraclub.ca/national/media/item.shtml?x=570 - International Labour Organization
- "The World Cut Flower Industry: Trends & Prospects" - Last update: September 28, 2000
http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/papers/ctflower/139e1.htm#1.2.2 - Scientific Certification Systems
- http://www.scscertified.com/
- Commondreams.org
- "Valentines Day Sweatshops" - Russell Mokhiber and Robert Weissman, February 12, 2005
http://www.commondreams.org/views05/0212-12.htm - Veriflora
- http://veriflora.com/
- TransFair USA
- http://transfairusa.org/content/flowers/trade_faq.php
- green LA girl
- "A fair trade rose is a Veriflora rose is an organic rose?" - siel, January 29, 2008
http://greenlagirl.com/2008/01/29/a-fair-trade-rose-is-a-veriflora-rose-is-an-organic-rose/ - San Francisco Chronicle
- "In flowers too, green is the new red" - Amy Stewart, February 7, 2007
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2007/02/07/HOG8SNTG4C1.DTL
Your Feedback
Criticisms, Praise, Further Questions...
Do you have any feelings on the cut flower industry or the information presented here? Did this discussion leave you asking more questions? Did we omit any important facts or resources? Please let us know!
-
Reply
- JenOfChicago JenOfChicago Apr 20, 2009 @ 12:29 pm
- Great page. Have you read "Flower Confidential"? Its a great book that discusses many of these issues.
-
Reply
- Graceonline Graceonline Jan 1, 2009 @ 5:19 pm
- P.S. I found an organic flower seller on Amazon at http://tinyurl.com/8fcnnv. I would have loved to have found it in your lens first and clicked through. May I suggest you add a few items from their vast collection? They have several lovely winter bouquets available right now that might be cheerful for folks experiencing a letdown after the holidays. Btw, I don't know any of those folks personally and am not affiliated with them in any way, in case you're wondering.
-
Reply
- Graceonline Graceonline Jan 1, 2009 @ 3:32 pm
- I found this page because I'm about to order organic flowers and hoped to give a Squidooer a clickout boost at the same time. I am grateful for your work on this lens. The story of the flower industry workers in Colombia needs to be told again and again until all of us ask before buying our flowers. How sad that something we use to give and send joy, to celebrate, or to lift spirits should come from such suffering.
-
Reply
- EverythingMouse EverythingMouse Nov 4, 2008 @ 6:37 pm
- I rarely buy flowers but if I do I make sure it is from the farmers market. Thank you for raising awareness of the issue.
-
Reply
- ArtByLinda ArtByLinda Aug 19, 2008 @ 1:06 pm
- Very interesting read, thanks for sharing! Shined up those stars! Linda
- Load More
Publish your own page at Squidoo
Think you can do better?
by LauraSchofield
There are plenty of ways to save money online. You just need to know where to look and what to look for. Unfortunately, this takes time that mo...
(more)













