Best Casserole Dishes

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic by 2 people | Log in to rate

Ranked #2,409 in Food, #57,545 overall

A Perfect Dish For Your Casserole

This is the time of year that you don't mind using the oven to make a delicious casserole for your family and guests. But when it comes time to actually buying a proper casserole dish for your casserole, it can get a bit confusing, even to the most experienced cook. What kind of casserole dish should you use? Cast iron casserole dish, stainless steel casserole dish, porcelain casserole dish, glass casserole dish, anodized aluminum casserole dish, or stoneware casserole dish? That's why I've decided to make a guide on how to properly choose a casserole dish. Learn about the advantages, the disadvantages, and where to purchase a perfect casserole dish.

Perfect Casserole Dish

Portable Casserole Dishes 

Just bake it and take it! Use one of these portable casserole dishes and travel without worry of spillage. Your casserole is sure to arrive safely by using any of the featured portable casserole dishes.

CorningWare Portables French White 4 Piece Serveware

Amazon Price: $42.49 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

Stainless Steel Casserole Dish 

Casserole Dish - Stainless Steel

Advantages:

Durable; easy to clean; pots with an aluminum or copper core or bottom will conduct heat well and be good for browning.

Disadvantages:

All-Steel pans do not conduct heat well.

Comments on Stainless Steel Casserole Dishes:

Pots for oven use must be of heavy-gauge steel. Make sure handles are oven proof.

Casserole Dish Stainless Steel

Stainless Steel Casserole Dishes on eBay 

Loading Fetching new data from eBay now... please stand by
eBay

Uncoated Cast Iron Casserole Dishes 

Casserole Dish - Uncoated Cast Iron

Advantages:

Inexpensive; very durable; conduct and retain heat exceptionally well; good for stove-top browning; can be a source of dietary iron.

Disadvantages:

Extremely heavy; can affect color and taste of foods; needs special seasoning and clean.

Advice on Uncoated Cast Iron Casserole Dishes:

Look for a one-piece pan with handles formed from the iron itself; with proper care, a cast-iron casserole or Dutch oven can last for generations.

Cast Iron Casserole Dishes 

Old Mountain Cast Iron Preseasoned Casserole with Lid

Amazon Price: $57.05 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

Texsport Cast Iron Fish Fry/Large Casserole Pan

Amazon Price: $59.99 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

Stansport Cast Iron Pre-Seasoned Steamer / Casserole

Amazon Price: $24.99 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

Paula Deen 5 Quart Cast Iron Covered Oval Casserole

Amazon Price: $50.92 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

Cast Iron Casserole Dish

Cast Iron Casserole Dishes on eBay 

Loading Fetching new data from eBay now... please stand by
eBay

Enameled Cast Iron - Casserole Dish 

Casserole Dish - Enameled Cast Iron

Advantages:

Good heat conductors; won't interact with food.

Disadvantages:

Extremely heavy; requires careful handling to avoid chipping of enamel; will rust if it gets chipped; does not brown food well.

Comments on Enameled Cast Iron Casserole Dishes:

Choose a pot with steel handles; if the handles are of another material, it should be oven proof to 425 degrees F.

Enameled Cast Iron Casserole Dishes 

Lodge Enameled Cast-Iron 6-Quart Dutch Oven, Cafe

Amazon Price: $69.32 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

Chefmate® 6.5-qt. Cast Iron Casserole Dish - Red

Amazon Price: $59.99 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

Lodge Enameled Cast-Iron 3-Quart Dutch Oven, Cafe

Amazon Price: $48.41 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

Porcelain Enamel on Steel Casserole Dishes 

Casserole Dish - Porcelain Enamel on Steel

Advantages:

Come in bright colors; won't react with food; easy to clean; heavyweight pans conduct heat well.

Disadvantages:

Not good for browning; lightweight pans do not conduct heat well and are not suitable for oven use.

Comments on Porcelain Enamel on Steel:

These attractive pots are particularly suitable for oven-to-table use.

Porcelain Enamel Casserole Dishes 

Ovenproof Glass Casserole Dishes 

Casserole Dish - Ovenproof Glass

Advantages:

Retains heat very well; won't react with food; can go from freezer to oven to table.

Disadvantages:

Not for stove-top use, so food cannot be browned before baking; relatively fragile.

Comments on Ovenproof Glass Casserole Dishes:

Comes in clear and opaque versions; reduce oven temperature by 25 degrees when baking in glass.

Ovenproof Glass Casserole Dishes on Amazon 

CorningWare Casserole Dish Set 

CorningWare 17-pc. Set - French White

Amazon Price: $77.49 (as of 07/13/2009)Buy Now

This Corning Ware casserole dish set is n excellent starter set or a great replacement set. The nonporous surface does not absorb food odors, flavors or stains. Casserole set includes 3 oval casseroles (15 oz., 23 oz. and 2.5 qt.) with covers and 3 round casseroles (16 oz., 24 oz. and 2.5 qt.) with covers. Also includes 2 each 4-oz. and 7-oz. ramekins and 1 chrome wire rack.

Stoneware and glass lids are dishwasher, microwave and oven safe; plastic lids are dishwasher and microwave safe.

Lenox Casserole Dish 

Lenox Butterfly Meadow Bone Porcelain Round Covered Casserole

Amazon Price: $53.99 (as of 07/13/2009)Buy Now

This Lenox Casserole Dish would make a lovely gift. The Butterfly Meadow collection covered casserole dish; 80-ounce capacity and 7-1/2-inches tall. Crafted of fine bone porcelain. White with delicate red and blue flowers and butterflies. Dishwasher, microwave, and oven-to-table safe. Manufacturer guarantees product for replacement or refund for any reason.

Casserole Dish with Warmer 

2-qt. Porcelain Warmer

Amazon Price: $20.00 (as of 07/13/2009)Buy Now

Now you can serve piping hot food right from the oven, in style. This splendid covered ceramic casserole dish with stand is a must if you like to serve friends and family hot delicacies. This set includes a 1.5 Qt. casserole dish with cover, a chrome plated tarnish resistant warming stand and a tea light candle. The warmer will keep your foods warm for over 2 hours. 2 Qt capacity Bowl - 9 inches diam. x 4 inches high. Total height on stand - 7.5 inches high.

Pottery Casserole Dishes 

Casserole Dish - Pottery (Stoneware, Earthenware)

Advantages:

Attractive for oven-to-table use; retains heat well; if glazed, easy to clean.

Disadvantages:

Not for stove-top use, so food cannot be browned before baking; fragile; unglazed ware is hard to clean.

Comments on Pottery Casserole Dishes:

Buy pottery from a reliable source; cheap tourist wares may have a dangerous lead content.

Pottery Casserole Dish

Pottery Casserole Dishes 

Large Casserole Dish - Light Blue

Amazon Price: $69.95 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

Covered Casserole Light Blue

Amazon Price: $49.95 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

Pottery Casserole Dishes on eBay 

Loading Fetching new data from eBay now... please stand by
eBay

Aluminum Casserole Dishes 

Casserole Dish - Aluminum

Advantages:

Lightweight; heat quickly and evenly.

Disadvantages:

Pit and stain from contact with salt or acidic foods; may discolor some foods (cream sauce may turn gray).

Comments on Aluminum Casserole Dishes:

Only heavy cast aluminum or aluminum alloy is suitable for oven use.

Aluminum Casserole Dishes on eBay 

Loading Fetching new data from eBay now... please stand by
eBay

Anodized Casserole Dishes 

Casserole Dish - Anodized

Advantages:

Resistant to sticking, stains, and dents; unlike regular aluminum, won't discolor foods; lighter than cast iron.

Disadvantages:

Expensive.

Comments on Anodized Aluminum Casserole Dishes:

Good choice for serious cooks--top performance, a professional look (dark gray).

Anodized Casserole Dishes on eBay 

Loading Fetching new data from eBay now... please stand by
eBay

Casserole Cookbooks 

Looking for delicious casserole recipes? Try any one of these Casserole Recipe books. If your looking for casserole recipes online, visit Casserole Recipes

Bake until Bubbly: The Ultimate Casserole Cookbook

Amazon Price: $15.61 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

101 Things to Do with a Casserole

Amazon Price: $9.95 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

Better Homes and Gardens Biggest Book of Casseroles (Better Homes & Gardens)

Amazon Price: $14.96 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

The Big Book of Casseroles: 250 Recipes for Serious Comfort Food

Amazon Price: $13.57 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

Crazy for Casseroles: 275 All-American Hot-Dish Classics

Amazon Price: $12.89 (as of 07/13/2009) Buy Now

What Kind of Casserole Dish Do You Like Best? 

AppalachianCountry wrote...

Great lens. We use cast iron alot. Thank-you so much for all the tips.

ReplyPosted June 05, 2009