Celebrities Should Stay Out of Politics a debate run by rms

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic (by 6 people)   Your rating: 1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic

Here's What I Think About Celebrity's Role in Politics

 

I think celebrities should stay out of politics unless they - themselves - are running for a public office.

I think someone like the richest man or woman in America, and people like professional wrestlers, actors, musicians, descendents of past political leaders, karate champions, brand-name designers, sports figures, famous authors, or even cartoon characters have too much power to sway their fans towards, or away from, an otherwise good candidate who is running for office.

Each and every one of us has the opportunity to cast one vote, including celebrities. I don't think anyone should use their "personality power", however great or small it might be, to try to sway the minds of the public.

I am not against people in the spotlight having the chance to back their own political favorites, I am however against them using thier larger stage to influence others to their way of thinking.

In other words, I think they should be allowed to stand behind their chosen candidates, but not make a spectacle of themselves while doing so. The politician should be the only one in the spotlight when it comes to politics, never the celebrities who are backing them.


What do you think? Sound off here:

Do You Agree? Disagree? 

State Your Opinion Here

Tell us why you think celebrities should stay out of politics, or why you think it's okay for them to get involved.

Celebrities Should Stay Out of Politics

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

Yes, you're right! Celebrities should stay out of politics.

sharkytoon says:

I absolutely agree. Celebs should stay the hell out of polities

Someone says:

Celebs just want more fame!

TalkingBull says:

Let's look at Sean Penn. The man never finished high school. Why would I listen to this idiot? From what I have seen, he has a substance abuse problem and is violent. I care what the intelligent and well informed have to say; not the Jane Fonda wannabees.

SusanVillasLewis says:

I wouldn't object because, as Cinetech says, they are citizens and have a vote and say just like everyone else. But they do have a larger stage from which they tend to spout total nonsense. If they could get involved in an intelligent way, maybe I wouldn't mind. But they just parrot what they're told without a real understanding of the issues. Not much different from Larry at the watercooler, only their watercooler is much bigger and people listen to them. Nobody listens to Larry.

Grasshoppa says:

Unless they're willing to step into the arena like Arnold did and serve in office. Most of them simply don't know enough about politics to successfully do that.

Why do celebs think their status qualifies them as smart enough to advise the rest of the country on political matters? They should stick with what they were trained for -- entertainment -- and leave the politics to people who actually know politics.

Tammy says:

Just because you have the right to do something, doesn't make it the right thing to do. Yes, celebs have freedom of speech. But, that doesn't make what they say matter. I truly could not care less what Oprah Winfrey or Bruce Springsteen or George Clooney think about the president, tax rates, or the farcical Global Warming! Stick to providing me the entertainment I pay for, and I'll get my political advice from people who've devoted their life to that pursuit.

coollikeme says:

Most of them have there own agenda.

catchquests says:

definitely, especially if they're stupid like previously, our local erap estrada, he used to be an action star, ran for president and won! wtfreak! he was charged for plunder and then was pardoned by our current president gloria arroyo- c'mon now? still, ya gotta admire what people in power do. it makes us think that we're all human,no matter how powerful..

blondeheroine says:

I'm on the fence. Right now, I love that Oprah is campaigning for Obama because it's where I stand and I see that as helping more than anything. Of course, if a very influential celebrity were to stand up for someone who was obviously no good for our country, ehm, I'd have major problems with it. So, I guess I will say - Yes, you're right - celebrities should stay out of politics when I don't agree with them. :p

charlino says:

You are right. Celebrities should stay out of politics. A celebrity offering their own humble opinion in answer to a question off stage is one thing. It is quite another when you purchase a ticket to see a celebrity perform on stage, and end up being unwittingly part of an audience forced to endure a star on a soap box who espouses opinions without fact, comments without merit, without any consideration to those in the audience who may disagree with their position. IMO, if celebrities want to be in the political fray, they should not be stumping under the guise of entertainment.

No way, Celebrities have earned their power and should be allowed to use it.

Squidoo-Pat says:

I don't think celebrities should "Stay out of politics". I think that their opinion shouldn't matter anymore than anyone elses.

When someone gains fame that doesn't mean that they are also gaining mental and emotional stability. Witness all these young guys and girls who have been in the spotlight lately. They have all the fame then need and yet they are unstable and often addicted.

They as Americans, have their right to voice their political opinions, but we as fellow Americans can just ignore them.

Recently Susan Sarandon threatened to leave the country if McCain wins the presidency. I don't know anyone who would care if she left or would even think about it. These celebs are spoiled by the pop culture media-they give them too much attention. But, they still have the right to voice their political opinions in public-if you disagree just ignore them.

greg2213 says:

No way. It's a freedom of speech issue. Celebs should be free to make idiots of themselves with their opinions just like anyone else. Besides, most of us would rather listen to (or laugh at) what a Celeb says compared to what Joe Nobody says.

Yes, they do have a stage that we don't. But there's little stopping us from putting in the work to build a blog and get our word out. Silly as it may be.

Speak on!

Grangrad says:

The problem is that certain celebrities enter the political arena to further thier career. On the other hand there are celebrities with a good understanding of social and economical problems, in certain cases better than the career politicians. They are human and should be allowed to have thier say.

RufusQuail says:

I don't know about "power," but I like celebrities being involved in politics. Other than celebrities, almost no one cares about politics. If someone would listen to me, I'd speak out too.

Cinetech says:

They're citizens like anybody else. Do I need to say more?

lynnie600 says:

I don't think that celebrities lose their rights to be citizens. They may have an inordinate amount of exposure due to their notoriety, but we can't stifle them or infringe on their first amendment rights. I must confess that I do get tired of many of them.

famousmortimer says:

If your political views are swayed by a celebrity you should probably be stripped of your voting rights. I almost want to support this argument because when a celebrity embraces a candidate I like it makes me embarrassed for liking them. Come on Oprah, don't make me support Hillary.

But at the end of the day people have the right to do whatever they want. Even as a non celebrity if I really put my mind to it I could probably go out and drum up some sort of crazy spectacal in support of a candidate and get myself on the evening news. Hmmm, that might propel me to some sort of limited fame and then I could go on Celebrity Fit Club and Dancing with the Stars. BRB in 15 minutes!

fefe says:

Celebrities can say what they want because they have freedom of speech. People should be smart enough to take what they say with a grain of salt and think for themselves. I usually disagree with celebrities political views except for Drew Carey.

lika says:

i think that celebrities should get involved in politic. if person have enought education and he can discuss and decide better dy for country he should get involved in this job

grenetta says:

That all celebs should stay out of the politic game . I believe that Ronald Regan is a good example for the argument. He did nothing for this country but spend money the US didnt have. IM not a child born in the 80s I was living it going to school and seeing how hard my parents had it.They said the economy was good back then but for who, it was not the low-middle class, it wasnt them at all. My mother couldnt afford to get a house and able to pay for it until Clinton got into office. CELEBS stay where u are in HOLLYWOOD leave running the country to those like Obama not Geogre Clonney!!!

sterling says:

If that is what they are interested in, they can voice their opinion just like you or me.

kab says:

I'm okay with them saying what they believe; they have the right to say whatever they want. What I have a problem with it stupid people (and the media) putting value in those statements. Just because a celeb uttered it, it doesn't mean it is true, and it doesn't mean it is newsworthy.

webnh says:

One of the great things about living in the United States is that everyone has a opportunity to be heard and to express their views about any subject. Once you decide that one group or another should be quiet or should be quiet in some places and not others you start down a slippery slope of censorship.

If more people would expose themselves to different and distasteful points of views we would have a much stronger society and a much healthier debate as a country.

The_Book_Garden says:

I think that celebs, whether TV Personalities, Rock Stars, Film Stars and athletes have as much right to campaign for our political sport as anyone! After all politics does effect every aspect of our lives.
I've started a similar debate about Sport & Politics!

 
 
1 of 1 page
 

How Do You Feel . . . 

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Celebrities and Politics 

Links to online resources about celebrities and politics.
Feel free to add a link of your own on this topic.

Sport and Politics Do Mix, Boycott the Bejing Olympics

Many people say that politics does not mix with sp more...1 point

MRC Spotlight -- Celebrities on War and Politics -- Media Research ...

Media Research Center (MRC) is a conservative medi more...0 points

Reality blurred by star-spangled politics - smh.com.au

That the prominence of celebrity in politics is to more...0 points

Diana Forum: Celebrity Politics, Political Celebrities ...

From the standpoint of political activists, celebr more...0 points

USATODAY.com - Entertainers blur line between celebrity, politics

When Arnold Schwarzenegger steps before the camera more...0 points

Read More on the Subject 

Of Celebrities in Politics

Click on the product link to learn more, or to purchase these great books on the subject of celebrity's role in politics.

Celebrity Politics (Real Politics in America Series)

Book Description
This book looks at the evolution and impact of celebrity politics in the United States. It discusses how closely intertwined the worlds of politics and Hollywood have become, how celebrityhood pervades the political process-from campaigns and elections to governing, lobbying, and legislating, and the long-term implications of this trend. Chapter topics cover media image-makers, the money machine, the celebrity presidency, activist celebrities, sports politicos, satire: the downside of celebrityhood, and public evaluations of the celebrity regime. For anyone interested in the politics and pop culture of America.

Amazon Price: $29.20 (as of 07/26/2008)

Celebrity-in-Chief: How Show Business Took Over The White House

Book Description
Tells the colorful story of how the two most visible branches of American celebrity--the presidency and Hollywood--came together in a marriage of pop culture and politics.
U.S. presidents and Hollywood have had a mutual admiration society that extends far back into history. In Celebrity-in-Chief, journalist Alan Schroeder contends that each camp has influenced the other--particularly over the past century--creating a president who no longer stands apart upon a remote civic pedestal, isolated from Hollywood and pop culture. Instead, the powerful forces of the American celebrity circus drag him into the tent and ask him to put on a show. The job of president has always been politically demanding, but now there is another requirement: to exude star quality. In the parlance of Hollywood, he must "fill the frame." Drawing upon a wealth of fascinating anecdotes about some of the most celebrated individuals in American history, Schroeder shows how a succession of presidents since Woodrow Wilson has put on a show with mixed results. Whether is was Bill Clinton apologizing to the nation for an adulterous affair or George W. Bush boasting of faithfulness to his wife, Celebrity-in-Chief entertainingly and convincingly shows that the result is a wholesale demystification of the office--and that this marriage of pop culture and the presidency will continue to fascinate and endure.

Amazon Price: $19.76 (as of 07/26/2008)

The Schwarzenegger Syndrome: Politics and Celebrity in the Age of Contempt

Book Description
An irreverent look at the rise and rise of California governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, from the journalist the New York Times calls a "huge satirical talent."
"It's the most difficult decision I've made in my entire life, except the one I made in 1978 when I decided to get a bikini wax."-Arnold Schwarzenegger, announcing his candidacy for governor of California in 2003

From the California recall circus, in which Gary Coleman, Larry Flynt, and Arianna Huffington vied with over one hundred other candidates to replace a supposedly inept governor, Arnold Schwarzenegger emerged triumphant. How did this onetime bodybuilding champion and gay pinup, with no political experience and a string of mediocre action movies to his name, come to take over the world's fifth-largest economy?

In The Schwarzenegger Syndrome, celebrated journalist and novelist Gary Indiana makes the case that this tale is a product of a media-soaked culture in which image matters more than substance. The recall process, a parody of direct democracy, gave Schwarzenegger the chance of a lifetime. With so many candidates in the race, he certainly wasn't the most qualified, the most articulate, or the most credible-but he was the most famous. And for the majority of Californians, that was enough. A witty and biting travelogue through the intersection of celebrity culture with American political life, The Schwarzenegger Syndrome lays bare the dark implications of Schwarzenegger's rise to power in the Golden State.

Amazon Price: $19.95 (as of 07/26/2008)

The Good, the Bad and the Famous - Celebrities Playing Politics (Documenting the Ascension of Celebrities From Court Jesters to Kingmakers in American Politics)

Product Description
Why have celebrated actors, athletes and musicians become publicly involved with politics, and what political roles do they play? To answer these questions, documentary film producer/screenwriter/journalist Sherman traveled around America and talked with Charlton Heston, Ed Asner, John Randolph, Judd Nelson, Sarah Jessica Parker, Robert Downey, Jr. and other performers; political organizer Robert Squier; presidential candidate Bruce Babbitt; TV newsman Sam Donaldson; rock music producer David Krebs; and Congressman Fred ("Gopher") Grandy of Iowa. Among the questions he asked are: How do the media present politics? Are the media liberal or conservative? How do different TV talk shows treat politicians and celebrities? The answers are worth pondering. Among Sherman's conclusions: Ronald Reagan and Jane Fonda are alike in highhandedly insisting that their individual, limited visions encompass the "essence of the grander truth." The book is instructive reading for concerned citizens; required reading for people in politics.

Amazon Price: (as of 07/26/2008)

Digital Debate: An article from: Junior Scholastic 

Should celebrities be involved in politics?

Description
This digital document is an article from Junior Scholastic, published by Thomson Gale on October 1, 2007. The length of the article is 490 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser.

Should celebrities be involved in politics?(Debate): An article from: Junior Scholastic

Amazon Price: $9.95 (as of 07/26/2008)

Additional Thoughts on Celebrities and Politics 

State your additional thoughts about celebrities use of power in politics here.