My Mother's Chocolate Mayonnaise Cake
Ranked #8,058 in Food & Cooking, #146,887 overall | Donates to Squidoo Charity Fund
Cold Sunday Nights in Iowa Redeemed by Piping Hot Chocolate Maynnaise Cake
But then Mom would decide it was time to make a chocolate mayonnaise cake and the whole day was worth it.
This amazing cake was as dark as could be, and so chocolaty, but with a different kind of taste that made it just better than anything else. It was denser than most cake, but not really like brownies, really hard to describe, you must taste it to know.
Later Mom would frost it with her special ice cream frosting, but when it came out of the oven, it was cut while still steaming hot and spread with butter like a piece of bread. I didn't put butter on my bread, so I ate the hot cake plain also, but it was far from plain.
Oh, man oh man!
Thanks for the memories, Mom.
People Forget How Easy a "From Scratch" Cake Can Be! Chocaolate Maynnaise Cake Is Not Much Harder Than a Box and Usually Better!
3 c. flour, unsifted
1 1/2 c. sugar
2/3 c. unsweetened cocoa
2 1/4 tsp. baking powder
1 1/2 tsp. baking soda
1 1/2 c. mayonnaise
1 1/2 c. water
1 1/2 tsp. vanilla
Grease two 9 x 1 1/2 inch layer pans; line bottoms with waxed paper. Sift together dry ingredients into large bowl. Stir in mayonnaise. Gradually stir in water and vanilla until smooth and blended. Pour into prepared pans. Bake in 350 degree oven about 30 minutes or until cake springs back when touched. Cool completely. Remove from pans. Makes 2 layers.
Necessity Is the Mother of Invention: Ice Cream Frosting
One cold night, after the cake had cooled, Mom went to frost the remainders, but found out that she didn't have enough milk or sugar after making the cake.But she did have ice cream!
Basic recipe:
* 1/4 cup soft or melted margarine
* Good dash salt
* 1 teaspoon vanilla
* 2 tablespoons milk
* 2 cups powdered sugar
In a medium sized bowl, combine all of the ingredients. Mix and mix until all is smooth. Spread upon a 9 by 13-inch cake and serve.
What she did, clever lady that she was, was replace the milk and half of the sugar (she had a cup) with a cup and a half of vanilla ice cream. It not only worked, but was so good that that became her signature way of making frosting.
This turned out to not just be a decent substitute, but a discovery for a better tasting frosting.
You can play with the amount of ice cream, add a little and keep adding until you have what you want.
Oh, and you can use any flavor of ice cream. Chocolate, strawberry, coffee, what ever you like!
“Hmmm....no milk, not enough sugar for frosting; ice cream has both, I wonder what would happen...”

Mom Was Very Creative
I Am a Purist Myself But You Might Want to Try Adding Goodies.
You can add chopped nuts, raisins, chopped fruit...let your imagination go. Here is Mom's chocolate mayo cake with ice cream frosting. Frosting or Butter for Your Hot Chocolate Mayonnaise Cake?
I have to admit that as a kid, I preferred the frosting to the butter, but now, as an adult, I wonder if the butter might not be better.
However, his cake is so good, I used to eat it, hot, without either, but which would you choose?
Which Is Best?

Hmm...I hadn't thought about it but, butter on hot chocolate cake sounds really good!
ChineseKitesforKids says:
My mom gives me butter on hot cake out of the oven and its so good but soooo bad if you know what I mean!
Tipi says:
I would love to try it because I love butter and ho chocolate.
charlino says:
I've never had butter on a cake before, but sounds like it would be worth a try.
Jimmie says:
Can't go wrong with butter. But plain cake is okay too.
stargazer00 says:
Never heard of eating butter on cake but I have to try it now. Sounds great!
No way, you have to have frosting on cake!
skiesgreen says:
Prefer frosting, not that I eat much of that these days but I don't eat butter at all.
awakeningwellness says:
Definitely frosting!
vallain says:
Mom made this cake too, and we always had icing on it, so I'll stick with that.
lou16 says:
frosting all the way.....although chocolate cake plain is good as well!
TheGreenerMe says:
Gotta have frosting! Cream cheese frosting if you can...
Mom Also Made a German Chocolate Cake
I Couldn't Find Her Recipe But Nightcats Solved That Problem
BTW, the cake didn't exist until the late 50's, since Mom was already making this in the late 50's she was pretty avante guarde!
Oh, and as I remember, this cake is far from being as easy as a box cake, but worth it!
There Are Lots of Ways to Have Fun With Chocolate
Come Join My Salon
In Arrowsmith Printing, you can learn a lot more about my incredible parents.
Wear Your Love for Chocolate!
Chocolate Cookery
Any Purchase Here Will Contribute to Heifer International: The Pay It Forward Entrepreneurial Charity
Wipe Your Fingers Before Signing in Because Chocolate Isn't Good for Your Key Board
-
-
skiesgreen
Feb 9, 2012 @ 5:11 pm | delete
- This is an amazing recipe and one I had never heard of. Blessed and featured on Blessed by Skiesgreen and also on Squids Cooking Cake Recipes. Hugs
-
-
-
awakeningwellness
Feb 8, 2012 @ 12:14 pm | delete
- My mouth is watering for chocolate now. :)
-
-
-
Tipi
Jan 28, 2012 @ 4:15 pm | delete
- Reporting back to say...this is delicious and leaving a little angel dust to add to the recipe!
-
-
-
Sylvestermouse
Jun 4, 2011 @ 4:56 pm | delete
- Using mayonnaise is a cake does sound like a unique ingredient, but I'm game. I love chocolate cake! Thanks for the new recipe :)
-
-
-
ChineseKitesforKids
May 11, 2011 @ 9:08 am | delete
- Such a wonderful lens! Your mother is very beautiful as well creative. Moms are the best.
-
- Load More
Changing the Guard Blog
A Community for People Caring for Their Parents
Chocolate Beauties!
About Margo Arrowsmith
Table of Contents
- People Forget How Easy a "From Scratch" Cake Can Be! Chocaolate Maynnaise Cake Is Not Much Harder Than a Box and Usually Better!
- Necessity Is the Mother of Invention: Ice Cream Frosting
- Mom Was Very Creative
- I Am a Purist Myself But You Might Want to Try Adding Goodies.
- Frosting or Butter for Your Hot Chocolate Mayonnaise Cake?
- Mom Also Made a German Chocolate Cake
- There Are Lots of Ways to Have Fun With Chocolate
- Come Join My Salon
- People Talking About Chocolate
- Wear Your Love for Chocolate!
- Chocolate Cookery
- Wipe Your Fingers Before Signing in Because Chocolate Isn't Good for Your Key Board
- Get Your Free Report: "How to Hire And Affordable Home Health Team"
- Changing the Guard Blog
- Chocolate Beauties!
- About Margo Arrowsmith
by Margo_Arrowsmith
Margo Arrowsmith received the "Lens of the Day" Twice
Arrowsmith Printing 9/22/08
Macular Degeneration: the Blindness You Can Prevent 4/5/11
"Knowledge...
more »
Explore related pages
- Cake Decorating Made Easy Cake Decorating Made Easy
- 7-up Cake Recipes 7-up Cake Recipes
- The Best Homemade Vanilla Cupcake Recipe Ever The Best Homemade Vanilla Cupcake Recipe Ever
- iCarly's Miranda Cosgroves New Room (Buy Gummy Bear, Ice Cream, Cupcake Decor!) iCarly's Miranda Cosgroves New Room (Buy Gummy Bear, Ice Cream, Cupcake Decor!)
- Small Face Painting Designs For Kids For Fun & Profit! Small Face Painting Designs For Kids For Fun & Profit!
- Clothes For Hippies Clothes For Hippies