Tips for Choosing a Writing Journal

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic by 8 people | Log in to rate

Ranked #4,110 in Arts , #98,460 overall

Keeping a Journal

Anyone can benefit from writing in a journal or notebook. Writing down your thoughts and emotions can be most beneficial: It helps you clarify your thoughts, organize your ideas, and relieve stress. It's also a good way to help you remember things.

Writers especially benefit from keeping a journal. The best way to improve your writing is to make a commitment to write often.

A fine journal makes a wonderful gift for anyone you know who loves to write. 

You and Your Writing 

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Big or Little Journal? 

"Judge me by my size, do you?" - Yoda, The Empire Strikes Back

The size of your journal is worth considering, and depends a lot on how you plan on using it.

A large journal or notebook is preferable if it's going to stay at home most of the time. If this is the case, or you plan on doing a lot of sketching, choose a medium to large journal.

If you want to take a notebook with you wherever you go, you might want something that fits easily in a purse, bag, or pocket.

A notebook that's too big is going to be awkward to carry about. A journal that's too small could make you feel cramped every time you try to write in it, and you'll have to break your train of thought more often to turn the pages.

The Leather Journal 

The Joys and Pains

A beautiful leather diary can suggest another world. It's not hard to imagine a fine leather book resting on a bedside table in an old Victorian house, or else tucked away in some corner of Bilbo Baggins' comfortable hobbit hole.

A leather journal looks and feels important. It is this quality that inspires some writers and intimidates others.

The intimidated writer may feel that so beautiful a book deserves nothing less than wonderful stories written in perfect calligraphy. And you freeze, because you know your handwriting looks dreadful and that your story ideas are all half-baked.

For some writers, the leather journal is a joy and inspiration. For others, it is almost a physical manifestation of writer's block.

The Humble Notebook 

Your everyday spiral bound notebook is not going to win any beauty contests. It's functional yet plain. There's nothing inspiring about it, save that it is full of empty pages waiting for your pencil strokes. (Unless, of course, its cover is splashed with your favorite actor or character from a movie.)

Although a simple lined notebook isn't glamorous, it's not intimidating either. You don't have to think twice about using it to rant about your bad day or doodle pictures of Dr. Seuss-like critters. An ordinary notebook won't be worse off if you write about the new hairs sprouting from your mole.

Another advantage of simple notebooks is that they are inexpensive and easy to find. You can buy them almost anywhere.

To Doodad or Not to Doodad? 

Lots of journals have "doodads" on them, especially if they're the Dear Diary sort of journals. It's most often in the form of a leather cord or magnetic flap that helps keep the book closed. Diaries often have a little lock and key. And let's not forget the buckles and pen holders.

Personally, I find such things distracting. In a way, they make the journal feel less like a book. Such things are not going to keep nosy people from peeking into your journal; if anything, it could make them even more curious.

Unless you really love the doodads, they are probably not going to do much for your journaling experience.

Quality Matters 

A spiral notebook is one thing; you're only out a few bucks at most if it doesn't work out. It's more upsetting if you spend extra money on a hardbound journal that falls apart.

Consider the Celtic Green with Embossed Black Foil Journal to the right. This is a beautiful blank book that's available at Barnes and Noble. It almost looks like it's made of leather, but it isn't. I almost bought it once, but I noticed that several of them had noticeable marks and scratches on the cover. Just brushing it with a fingernail seemed to be enough to leave a mark. It was cheaper than the real leather journals, but I would have been unhappy with this purchase.

If you want a journal that will stay in good shape, be sure to look it over carefully. Be wary of the overly cutesy or trendy mass-produced journals, as they often seem to be made cheaply.

The Journal Poll 

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Refillable Journals 

A Nice Compromise

If you adore tooled leather journals but are skittish about writing in them, there's another option: Refillable leather journals. Once you fill up all the pages, you just slip the old notebook out and replace it with a new one.

A removable leather cover is also not a bad way to dress up a Moleskine notebook, though they're handsome enough in their functional, simple way.

Leather Journals by Sojourner Leatherwork 

Sojourner Leatherwork creates and sells refillable leather journals, which you can buy from Luke and Christine Thompson's Etsy shop. For an extra $5, you can upgrade to a Moleskine notebook that comes with the leather journal cover. (They normally come with a Markings ruled notebook.)

The leather journals are stamped using a leather tooling method called cincelado, a process that originated in Argentina. Not only is each design beautiful, it has a symbolic meaning.

The leather journal pictures you see on this lens were made by Sojourner Leatherwork.

Novelty Notebooks by Moonlight Bindery 

But maybe you want a notebook that's fun, whimsical, and something that no one else has. That's one of the advantages of handmade journals and notebooks: Each one is unique.

One such example would be the mini notebooks made by Moonlight Binderies on Etsy. She offers a variety, but the most whimsical of the bunch are the spiral bound notebooks made from recycled cereal boxes!

Moleskine Journals 

Of all the journals in the world, the Italian-made Moleskine journals probably have the biggest fan following. Once you use one, it's easy to see why: They are durable, high quality, and worth the price.

They're portable and stay flat when you open them. Even the paper quality is good, though it does not handle all inks without some bleed-through. In particular, it doesn't take ink from most fountain pens without the ink bleeding through to the other side.

On the whole, Moleskine journals are simple, functional, and show excellent workmanship.

Moleskine Notebooks on Amazon 

Moleskine Small Ruled Notebook

Moleskine Small Ruled Notebook

This long-standing tradition was continued by writ more...0 points

Moleskine Large Ruled Notebook

Moleskine Large Ruled Notebook

This long-standing tradition was continued by writ more...0 points

Moleskine Large Squared Notebook

Moleskine Large Squared Notebook

This long-standing tradition was continued by writ more...0 points

Moleskine Journals on eBay 

Loading Fetching new data from eBay now... please stand by
eBay

More Great Lenses about the Art of Journaling 

Leave a Note in the Journal 

Have your own insights on choosing or using a journal?

GypsyOwl wrote...

Very comprehensive and very helpful! 5* favorite.
I use several journals as well.
GypsyOwl

ReplyPosted May 12, 2008

Colleen_Boyd wrote...

I like journals that are slightly floppy and stay open. There's nothing more frustrating when you're trying to write than having the crisply bound book continually shutting on you. The pages should lie flat as you write, too.

ReplyPosted December 19, 2007

Victoria_Neely wrote...

Barkely: But those are good too. I switch between the usual notebooks and nice journals depending on what I'm writing about (or sometimes depending on which one is on hand). :)

ReplyPosted November 30, 2007

Barkely wrote...

I should get a nice journal, I usually by five a subject ring binder. I'm in the writes everything down category.

ReplyPosted November 30, 2007