Best Cookies for a Cookie Exchange or Swap

Ranked #13,516 in Food & Cooking, #237,726 overall

Best Cookies for a Cookie Exchange Swap or Bake Sale

You've been asked to participate in a Holiday Cookie Exchange Swap or Bake Sale but you don't think your favorite chocolate chip cookie is fancy enough to be a part of the mix. Here's a chance to try some new cookie recipes.

There's even an easy recipe for "Trailer Trash Toffee" if you don't normally bake and trust me when I say there are never any left at the end of a party. Or when you whip up a batch, keep them under a watchful eye lest your family nibble bits here and there and you won't have a lick to take to your party.

Some of the best holiday cookie collections are printed in the newspaper. If you see any great recipes in your local paper, please drop us a link in our guestbook and we'll check it out.For 2011, the Washington Post has published:

25 Holiday Cookie Recipes
Sugar Cookie Recipes for Holiday Baking
No Bake Chocolate Oat Cookies

Photo Source: Kraft Foods "Hosting a Cookie Exchange"

Nanaimo Bars

No Baking Required - Just Melting

Ask anyone from British Columbia about a Nanaimo Bar and they will easily wax nostalgic about this regional indulgence. It's a super sweet, rich chocolate no bake bar composed of three layers: a dense graham cracker coconut base with a vanilla custard icing layer topped off by a thin layer of chocolate.

Best Nanaimo Bar Recipes

Trailer Trash Toffee or Homemade Heath Bars

No Baking Required - Just Melting

I am all about the easy when it comes to baking. This is one of those super addictive, can't just eat one treat that always goes over well. I love to have people take a guess at the ingredients. Rarely can anyone pinpoint that the tasty, krispy crust is actually saltine crackers. Trailer Trash Toffee is probably the slang name for this tasty morsel produced by ordinary ingredients which was introduced to me by my mother-in-law, Betty.

Trailer Trash Toffee Recipe

Sugar Cookies

What's Christmas without traditional sugar cookies? Extremely versatile, they can be decorated, sprinkled, iced or just eaten plain. The thinner they're rolled, the tastier they become, especially when the sugar is crystallized and at close to being burnt, the sugar is caramelized. The secret is not overhandling the dough.

Basic Sugar Cookie Dough
Best Sugar Cookie Recipes

Gingerbread Men

The crisp smell of cinnamon and gingerbread say Christmas in one tantalizing, welcoming scent. Try your hand at making Gingerbread men or plan architect, engineer, decorator and designer by building a gingerbread hosue.

Best Gingerbread Recipes

Shortbread Cookies

A holiday classic especially a favorite for Canadians, Brits and Scots. Scottish Shortbread cookies are easy to make, have only three ingredients, and there are many variations.

Best Shortbread Cookie Recipes

Chocolate Oatmeal Cookie

No Baking Required

Sending cookies to a soldier, marine, sailor or other loved one overseas? These no-bake chocolate oatmeal cookies with peanut butter are a perfect choice. Despite the fact that they're chocolate, they do well even when shipped. The recipe is quick and easy to prepare, great to take to a cookie exchange or give as a gift.

No Bake Chocolate Oatmeal Cookie Recipe

Don't Forget to Bring a Container

Crispy Cookies
Store in metal cookie tins.

Soft Cookies
Store in tupperware or ziploc containers.

Hosting a Cookie Exchange

Nothing brings people together like a big plate full of cookies. Having a cookie exchange is a great way to get a wide assortment of cookies without having to do so much work all by yourself. Here are some tips to throwing a successful cookie exchange or swap.

How to Host a Cookie Exchange or Swap

Reader Feedback

  • gottaloveit Dec 20, 2011 @ 8:38 am | delete
    Great tips for hosting a cookie exchange. I love that you've got links to recipes. Nicely done. Blessed.
  • TransplantedSoul Dec 19, 2011 @ 6:50 pm | delete
    Thanks for the pointer to the shortbread recipes. I have been looking for a good one.
  • janices7 Dec 10, 2009 @ 9:26 am | delete
    The homemade Heath bars look amazing...I'm a sucker for toffee. Love this lens...5* and lensrolled to my How To Host A Cookie Exchange lens.
  • tandemonimom Dec 5, 2008 @ 6:51 pm | delete
    Yum, I've got a cookie exchange coming up soon. I'll have to try some of these out!
  • stargazer00 Dec 4, 2008 @ 7:13 pm | delete
    Great sounding recipes! Thanks for featuring my shortbread cookie recipe!

by

AdrienneJenkins

Eat, Write, Love. I'm currently living "La Dolce Vita" in Rome, Italy with my husband who's a professor of architecture. I'm getting to fulfill the dr... more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!

If You Only Get One Gift Book for Your Favorite Baker 

#1 Cookie Book on Amazon.com

Momofuku Milk Bar

Amazon Price: $15.85 (as of 05/30/2012)Buy Now

Foodies in the know love Momofuku in New York. In the latest book Momofuku Milk Bar pastry chef Christina Tosi shares the secrets of Momofuku's nostalgic, innovative bakery treats. Click here to read more.

Let Martha Lead the Way 

Martha Stewart's Cookies: The Very Best Treats to Bake and to Share (Martha Stewart Living Magazine)

Amazon Price: $12.49 (as of 05/30/2012)Buy Now