How Did Charlotte Mason Suggest Art be Taught?
With most things CM (Charlotte Mason), once you get accustomed to her methods and they become a habit, you realize just how easy they are. Artist study is no exception. Charlotte Mason's way of studying artists is inexpensive, simple, and enjoyable.
The Basics of CM Artist Study

Miss Mason suggested that a different artist be studied consistently for an entire term -- up to 12 weeks. During that time, at least 6 different works of art by that same artist should be studied. That's only one work of art for every two weeks! Very doable!
But of course, you can do one work each week or even one each day. The point is that you focus on one artist and immerse yourselves in his style, his methods, and his images until you know that artist.
This artist study is mainly done through what CM called picture talks. During this lesson, your role as teacher is so easy. You just let the art speak to the child. You don't say much if anything. Just let the art speak to the child. The little that you do say may include some background relevant to the painting, the artist, or the time period. But by no means do you need to give a lecture about the work.
Don't let the term picture talk mislead you. You don't have to do all the talking! The child should be doing most of the talking as he describes what he sees and admires in the painting.
Then leave the art work available to be seen through out the week until another piece of art is studied.
Charlotte Mason's Thought about Artist Study
read her own words online

What did Miss Mason herself write about art study in the homeschool? Actually, there are two main exerpts from Home Education that deal with this subject. It will take you only a few moments to read these pages. You will be enriched by reading her own words about artist study.
For more of Charlotte Mason's works, see the additional links and bibliography below the guestbook.
- Volume 1 p. 307-315
- Scroll down to pages 307-315 to the section titled Pictorial Art for her clear, detailed directions of how to conduct an art study.
- Volume 6 p. 213-218
- This entire section is concerned with the study of art.
An Example of Artist Study
at my home

I'll give you a glimpse into artist study at our home........
Background
For that term we were studying Renoir. We had already studied approximately 30 of his paintings, one each day. Each day my method is the same. I hand the art print to my daughter and let her study it for 1-2 minutes, until she feels confident that she knows it well enough to narrate it back to me. Then I take the picture from her and listen as she describes everything she saw.
Problem
What if during the narration, she describes something incorrectly? For example, she says there are two people in the background but, in fact, there are five people? After she is done with her narration, I would say, "You said there were two people in the background, but take another look at the painting and make sure." Then I would hand her the print and allow her to look more closely and amend her narration.
Don't interrupt the narration if at all possible. Wait until the end to allow your child to make corrections.
If she doesn't mention more subjective things, I may ask her. For example, "What is the mood of this painting? Would you like to be in the scene painted? If you were there, what would you hear, smell, or feel?" I often use the questions listed here; in fact, I keep this laminated page with my weekly homeschool schedule. Asking one or two different questions each day gives our artist study more variety and often opens the door to some great mother-daughter discussions.
The Lesson
Then we came to two portraits of Renoir's son: Portrait of Claude (Coco) Renoir, below on the left, and The Clown, farther down.

I realized that the notes in the art book had some interesting facts that my daughter would be able to relate to and that would help her understand the painting. I only occasionally share the book's notes since I'd rather her do the thinking herself. But these notes about The Clown would help her more knowledgably contrast the two paintings.
I didn't read them, I simply paraphrased it in conversational language: Renoir's regular model had not come to sit for that day's painting. So Renoir's son had to act as a stand-in. The boy complained about the itchy stockings and being forced to stand still. Renoir both threatened and bribed the boy to get him to pose for the painting.
After our regular study of each painting, complete with narration, I had my daughter contrast the two pieces. She mentioned things such as the pose, the background, the child being older in one, the child's mood, the colors and condition of the painting.
The Creating
Then I gave her a blank piece of paper cut to the proportions of Portrait of Claude (Coco) Renoir and asked her to draw and then color a copy of the painting as closely as she could. You can see her result beside the original.
I pointed out all the ways that her rendition matched Renoir's original and praised her. Then I asked her to place her work alongside his and point out what was different or lacking in her version. In this way, I am not criticizing her work but I am teaching her to look critically at art
Then we displayed her artwork in a blank frame hanging on the wall of the homeschool room and moved on to science. Later that piece went into our art notebook.
After studying four or five more paintings by Renoir, we were finished with our book of art prints and moved on to another artist.
Note that we do not duplicate every painting we study. So far, I've chosen to do this with only one of each artist's paintings. In this way, art study is very quick each day, and only occasionally does it take longer.
Taschen Art Portfolios
Picasso (Portfolio (Taschen))
Amazon Price: $11.69 (as of 12/04/2009)![]()
14 high quality prints suitable for framing; each with a brief description
Helps with Artist Study
- Looking at Art
- This is a GREAT list of questions to ask about the art you study. I have laminated this page and keep it handy every day during homeschool.
- How to Pronounce Artists' Names and Artistic Terms
- This is a great reference tool! You certainly want to say those names correctly!
- Pictures Every Child Should Know
- This is the online text of an old book by Dolores Bacon. It is very much in the spirit of Charlotte Mason. For each painting (unfortunately only a black and white print of the original), she gives pronunciation of the artist's name, his artistic school of thought, and some background to help you in your picture talks.
- Animated Art Principles
- This little animated show will introduce you to several art concepts -- pattern, balance, etc. It's an engaging way to open the discussion of these concepts with your child.
- Art Resources
- This page has loads of material! There are printable PDFs, online activities. I started linking to so many of these (such as the next link below) that I decided to give you the main site and let you explore for yourself. Have fun!
- Creating a Question Checklist
- This PDF checklist has questions to ask about a work of art.
Real Help From Real Moms
a Yahoo group and great blog entries about artist study

I started a Yahoo group for homeschoolers wanting to implement Charlotte Mason styled art study. If you'd like to share ideas and join the discussion, I invite you to visit this group.
Articles are great and helpful, but there's something nice about reading a mom's own blog entry about how she does art study. It's more homey and personal. So here are some of my favorite blog entries about artist study by some CM minded homeschoolers. Be sure to poke around their blogs for other art ideas. Each of these posts is representative of many more each mom has written.
- Peakmore Academy Artist Study
- This blog entry recounts a study of Pieter Breugel. There is a free PDF notebooking page and a scanned example of her daughter's work! A great place to start for a newbie!
- Picture Study
- This blogging mother shares how she does art study with her children. She even has pictures from their art notebook! Very practical notes from a CM educator!
- Harmany Art Mom Artist Study
- Here are all of Barb's Artist Study posts. This is a treasure trove of inspiration since she has information about over a dozen artists. If you're just getting started with artist study, be sure to read Art Appreciation: A Starting Point.
- Impressionists Artist Series
- Homeschooling Kiwi Style is a blog about a New Zealand mom and her four lovely daughters! In these posts, she shares her Impressionist studies.
- Charlotte Mason Help Picture Study
- Linda Fay is always a great encouragement! Enjoy her posts about picture study. (These formerly were at Higher Up and Further In blog, but LindaFay has her own website now.)
- Charlotte Mason Mondays - Picture Study
- Dana writes for the Epikardia blog. Here she explores the basics of a Charlotte Mason artist study. She includes a list of artists to study.
- Charlotte Mason Mondays -- Picture Study for Older Students
- This is Dana's follow up to the previous article. Here she shares how artist study can be individualized for older students to match the period of history they are studying. She also offers some very valuable tips for beginning to analyze art.
Art Notebooks

Some parents like to make notebooks of the art they study. They use single page prints of the paintings to create their own art resource.
These prints may be purchased online, bought cheaply in the framed art section of a chain store, taken from calendars and postcards, or printed from the Internet.
By letting your child take ownership of this notebook, decorating it, organizing it, making notes, and even selecting the pieces of art, his motivation to study art will increase.
You may also want to include in the art notebook your child's renderings of the art you study. Whether you use black and white coloring book style pages for the child to color or whether you let her draw her own version, those would make nice additions to the art notebook. If you would like more note taking added to the notebook, Molly at Homeschool with Index Cards offers an attractive, free, printable Artist Biography Form. And Notebooking Pages offers some nice art and artist related freebies as well! Another general artist notebooking form is at Homeschool Helper Online.
Eclectic Education has a wonderful slideshow presentation of her children's Van Gogh scrapbook which can give you an idea of the possibilities of art notebooks.
Here are some fun printables you may be able to incorporate into your artist notebooks:
Below is an example of a self portrait by Van Gogh and my daughter's rendition of it. This is in her art notebook.

Art is All Around You
Be Aware and Be Deliberate
Your artist study is not limited to online pictures and art books. Once you are looking for it, you will find art all around you.
While shopping, you will see framed art reproductions of famous paintings. You can stop and admire them with your children. There are a couple of benefits to this. One, this it totally free. Two, your children see that art really surrounds us in everyday life. And this is not limited to the framed art section of the store. You will find fine art on calendars, stationery, journals, postcards, and notecards. (These are four art calendars bought well into the year for a ridiculously cheap price. These make a great, cheap resource for studying art!)

Of course, you can visit art galleries and museums, but don't forget less obvious places such as libraries, town halls, and government offices. They often have sculpture and paintings decorating the facilities.
College campuses often have exhibitions of student work. Although some of it may not be appropriate, there is a possibility that your children would have a great opportunity to study art and even meet a young artist.
Be on the look out for art. And when you see it, stop and enjoy it for a moment.
Another option for daily art study is a page a day calendar. This calendar is a tad oversized, and the images will be perfect for art notebooks.
Art Gallery Calendar 2010
Amazon Price: $14.39 (as of 12/04/2009)![]()
I bought this calendar and can't wait to use it when 2010 starts. It's just another way to sneak a little art appreciation into our day.
Links about CM Artist Study

- Penny Gardner's Tips for Artist Study
- Penny's tips and pictures of her children's projects.
- Affordable Picture Study
- Great article with links.
- Karen Andreola's Tips for Artist Study
- Great article.
Artist Timeline
When you study each artist, you will want your intermediate level child to know the general time frame of his career and what artistic movement he is part of. I suggest an artist timeline. Keep a record of each artist and arrange it in chronological order. Label each artist's school of thought.
Or if you already keep a timeline for history, simply add in the artists to that timeline. Give your children the perspective of when each artist lived and worked.
This is a basic art timeline with most of the major artists and all of the artistic periods. Look for the link at the top left for a printable version!

Renoir
Potential Artwork for an Art Notebook
You can include your child's artist study related artwork in the art notebook. For a free coloring page of a Renoir, click here.
Artists Worth Studying
a list
These artists were ones that Charlotte Mason specifically suggested.
Millet
Cassatt
Monet
Raphael
Grandma Moses
Da Vinci
Michaelangelo
Renoir
Van Gogh
Rembrandt
Wyeth
On the Ambleside Online artist study pages, you will find even more options for artists who created timeless works of art worthy of study. The current artist study schedule and previous years' studies are available.
If you don't mind using many online resources, you can use Ambleside's schedule and your entire artist study will be free. Links are available for the artist's works. You can just view them from the computer screen. (Many people set the week's art as their computer screen saver so that it is constantly visible.)
Another nice resource for artist study can be found at the 4Real Forums. There is a list of artists, and for each artist a thread including images, biographical links, and ideas.
Oh, and one last thing. Remember to consider your children's natural interests when you choose an artist. Read LindaFay's blog entry about this for more details.
Specific Artist Helps
-
Vermeer Artist Study
-
Vermeer is a rather mysterious artist. We have no portraits to tell us what he looked like. Even the facts of his life are few. We do know that he left only thirty-five paintings, and his creation of a few of them is still disputed. With little back...
-
Cassatt Artist Study
-
Mary Cassatt is an excellent choice for your homeschool artist study. She is one of the few women Impressionists, and commonly portrays domestic scenes of women and children. She was American by birth, but lived for much of her life in France, surro...
-
John James Audubon Artist Study
-
Was John James Audubon a sketching naturalist or a nature loving artist? Actually, his bird drawings were intended to be scientific sketches instead of art. But most people would agree that his careful observation of birds brought a realism and deta...
-
Picasso Artist Study
-
Study the artwork of a modern artist whose very name has come to mean a masterpiece of art-- "a Picasso." If your children have been studying more traditional artists, the works of Picasso may be a most welcome change of style. Dabble into the arti...
-
Egyptian Art
-
I am creating this lens to gather links and images for a study of Ancient Egyptian Art. It will correspond to my fifth grade study of ancient art on Harmony Fine Arts art and music appreciation program. You can learn more about Harmony Fine Arts at m...
Art Books

Personally I don't like to rely on the Internet for our artwork. I much prefer to have a hardback book to sit with and pore over versus staring at a computer screen. And if you are printing pictures from the Web, I really doubt the ink costs are cheaper than just buying a nice, used book with full-sized art prints.
When buying books for artist study, your main concern is how much of the book is just art. You want full page reproductions of the art, not tiny images and a lot of text.
If you have little ones joining in the homeschool experience, you may want to offer them a coloring sheet version of the painting.
You can also supplement your artist study with living books about the author, for example, the fictional story Camille and the Sunflowers linked below. The Diane Stanley biographies of Da Vinci and Michaelangelo are excellent reads as well.
These books all deal with Van Gogh. But you can search for similar books in these series about many other great artists. Amazon has a wealth of art books for children!
Van Gogh (Portfolio (Taschen))
Six loose prints that would work well for artist study.
Purposes and Attitudes for Artist Study
Why are we doing this?
According to CM, there are two reasons to study artists.1. To cultivate a love of beauty.
2. To hone the ability to see.
So those are our purposes: We encourage children to interact with art by giving them opportunities to do so. And we train their seeing by asking them to narrate back the artwork during the picture talks.
Furthermore, we have a particular attitude when we study art. Sidford says in the article Art and Enjoyment that endeavors in the study of art should be
urged when they are a source of pleasure, not otherwise. I do not wish to infer that the whole of a child's course of study must be a 'primrose path,' far from it, but the essence of Art is enjoyment. . .
If art is beauty, then that beauty should be enjoyable. So make modifications to your artist study to make it fit your particular child. Make it fun; make it a joy.
For some children, that will mean adding field trips to experience art. For others, you will need to add hands-on art activities (see book recommendations below). Some children would be excited by exploring an art site on the Internet (see links below). What do your children think is fun?
Discovering Great Artists
Hands-On Art for Children in the Styles of the Great Masters
Discovering Great Artists: Hands-On Art for Children in the Styles of the Great Masters (Bright Ideas for Learning)
Amazon Price: $12.89 (as of 12/04/2009)![]()
Featuring more than 150 activities, this guide teaches the styles, works, and techniques of the great masters-Van Gogh, Michelangelo, Rembrandt, and more.
Online Art Activities
- Inside Art
- This online, interactive story will teach you about art through a jouney INTO a VanGogh painting! Although it is designed for 4th grade and up, a child as young as 1st grade could benefit from it with an adult reading/paraphrasing the screen.
- A. Pintura: Art Detective
- An online mystery story in which you read the clues to identify the artist of the painting. This is a great activity because is shows how an artist's entire body of artwork has a look, a feel, common themes, etc. The artists which are featured are Raphael, Titian, Millet, Van Gogh, Gauguin, and Picasso. Although it is designed for 4th grade and up, a child as young as 1st grade could benefit from it with an adult reading the screen.
- National Gallery of Art for Kids
- The content is always changing at this site! Explore and learn!
Art Reference Sites

For artwork, biographical sketches, and more.
- Art Cyclopedia
- The guide to great art on the web.
- WebMuseum's Artist Index
- A long list of artists which will take you to a biographical sketch and linked thumbnails of many of his/her paintings. You could do your artist study right from this site!
Art Study for the Little Ones
Charlotte Mason said that art study through picture talks should begin at age six. Of course, you can start earlier than that. But if you choose, you could do more general art study rather than just limiting your study to one artist.
These are some great resources for introducing fine art to young chidren (or keeping them involved while you teach older children in your home).
Children's Matisse and Van Gogh Two-Book Set: A Magical Day with Matisse, In the Garden with Van Gogh
These are board books for the very youngest of children! Other artists in the series are Monet, Degas, Seurat, Picasso, and Matisse.
Child Size Masterpieces of Steps 1, 2, 3 - Matching, Pairing, and Sorting - Level 1 Easy
This is the first in a series of 7 books with small, postcard sized reproductions of famous art. Your child can play sorting and memory games with the cards to become familiar with the art. A great way to make art fun at an early age!
Articles
written in the spirit of Charlotte Mason
- Picture Talks
- by Miss K. R. Hammond
This article suggest some particularly excellent paintings for picture study and gives an example of a picture talk. - Art and Enjoyment
- By K. Sidford
This article will motivate you to make artist study a pleasurable part of your homeschool journey and not just another task to tick off the list. - Artistic Feeling
- By Canon Norris
This author claims that most all children have artistic spirit, but the home environment must deliberately draw it out.
Guestbook
please leave a note

Your comments, questions, or suggestions are always welcome.
Additional CM resources are listed below, so keep looking.
-
Reply
- C. Tarling C. Tarling Nov 14, 2009 @ 1:20 am
- Hi there, I won't put it all into words, however this may have spared my son and I reaching a place we couldn't resolve the stress of failed courses that did not suit our needs.Thank-you from the bottom of our hearts.P.S. Looking forward to the grades 9 to 12 programs and exams to come! Sincerely, C. Tarling from Canada
-
Reply
- drossart drossart Oct 14, 2009 @ 10:37 pm
- I can see some value in what you are saying about the study of art, but I also feel it is extremely limiting to the imaginative value of a non prescribed method of seeing art. Let a child interpret as he or she will, let them acquire imagination and inspiration from all the beautiful art in the world. We don't all need to see things the same way, as an individuals interpretation and expression is the variety and spice of life.
-
Reply
- Rachael in NZ Rachael in NZ Sep 10, 2009 @ 5:49 am
- Thanks again Jimmie for a great lens on Picture Study! I was also surprised to see my name up there :-) I am hoping to begin studying medieval/renaissance artists soon to go with our Story of the World Volume 2 (The Middle Ages).
-
Reply
- tandemonimom tandemonimom May 5, 2009 @ 10:08 pm
- Another wonderful resource! Welcome to The Homeschooling Group - you're a featured lens!
-
Reply
- Intuitive Intuitive May 1, 2009 @ 7:51 am
- I love that you point out the difference between criticizing your daughter's work and learning how to see critically. I wish I'd had you as my drawing teacher in college. :) 5*
-
Reply
- Tiddledeewinks Tiddledeewinks Apr 26, 2009 @ 1:21 am
- Great job. I've heard about Charlotte Mason through home school catalogs.
-
Reply
- daria369 daria369 Apr 23, 2009 @ 6:58 pm
- Great lens, good info - although I prefer to enjoy pieces of art to studying them... :)
-
Reply
- nichole nichole Apr 14, 2009 @ 5:11 pm
- hi. does nay one know the best place to get inexpensive reproduction of famous art paintings to display? maye size 5x7 would be good
-
Reply
- LeftHandMan LeftHandMan Apr 13, 2009 @ 9:09 pm
- Very insightful thing you are doing, and I like your approach. So many times when children recognize realism they take it as the gold standard. They abandon their art because they feel they can't measure up. It is good that you are helping her through this by helping to developing the confidence of personal expression. I look forward to seeing what the future holds.
-
Reply
- AndyPo AndyPo Jan 17, 2009 @ 11:20 am
- Excellent lens and very interesting.
- Load More
Charlotte Mason's Original Six Volume Work
Her Philosophy
Charlotte Mason's Works Online Links
online for FREE
- The Original Homeschooling Series
- Miss Mason's original writing.
- Modern English Version
- Miss Mason's works, rewritten for modern readers.
- Summaries of Miss Mason's Six Volumes
- Summaries of each volume for a quick read.
- Twenty Principles
- For an even quicker overview, see this list of twenty principles.

















