Cookie Cutter Collecting

Ranked #18,816 in Hobbies, Games & Toys, #314,791 overall

My cookie cutter collection spans more than fifty years since I inherited my mother's cutters with just one or two that had belonged to her mother as well.  My favorites are those handmade of metal by family businesses around the country.  The shapes of the cutters amaze and amuse me. My fascination started as a child watching Mama press some very special red plastic cutters into very thick dough.(These were known as "Aunt Chick's" cutters and can still be found on the web and on Ebay.)   Later, I used those same vintage cutters with clay dough to make decorations for our tree and those of other family members. My sister still has hers and I think her children (now adults) remember them, too.

Cookie cutters and cookie recipes also reflect the social history of the United States.  Perhaps no one today would make those big, thick sugar cookies of my childhood.  For a time, certainly most people would not have used butter.  I think butter is essential!  At certain times, certain ingredients have been scarce and some of the recipes in the reprint edition of the old "Betty Crocker Cooky Book" (See the second Amazon module below) gives a quick timeline of some of those recipes.

Cookie cutters aren't limited to Christmas, of course.  They embellish other holidays as well.  Do you have a favorite cutter, or cookie or story?  Please visit my guestbook below. 

Contents of this lens are copyright, 2006-2008 by Marguerite Manor. All rights reserved.  Thank you.

More Cookie Books on Amazon

Loading

Craft Ideas for Cookie Cutters

In addition to baking cookies and clay dough ornaments with cutters, the cutters themselves may be hung from the branches of the Christmas tree with yarn or ribbon and put away to make cookies again the following year.

They make great templates for drawing and other craft projects, especially applique. Trace carefully with a non-toxic crayon and be sure to save your patterns to reuse. I have made cards using fabric designs made with the cutter shapes glued or bonded with a hot iron and transfusible webbing to a variety of paper and card stock. These are fun to make, very original and have been well received.

Cookie cutters make great ornaments for a Jesse tree and also make Twelve Days of Christmas ornaments--fun sets to give as gifts.

My Two Most Favorite Ever Cookie Cutter Makers

These two companies are family businesses and they make wonderful cutters in amazing shapes. A few may be found in the Amazon module below.
Foose Cookie Cutters
A family owned business with a great variety of cutters including a Nativity set.
Little Fox Factory
The first company I became aware of when I was selling cookie cutters in the 1980's. In addition to a Nativity set they have many dog breeds. I cherish my Keeshond cutter because it reminds me of my family's beloved dog.

These folks have a page of recipes that includes a chocolate sugar cookie recipe. Yum! Very good recipe--I've tried it. (Guess I'll have to do another module on cookie recipes soon!)

Great Stuff on Amazon

Loading

Links for Cookie Cutter Crafts

Some of my favorite cookie cutter and cookie dough (non-edible) on the net.
All About Clay Dough
Great clay dough recipes and things to do with it.
Amish Christmas
Part of an amazing collection of lenses, this one has a recipe for "sparkly" clay dough. More salt than any other recipe I have ever seen makes the dough sparkle. I really want to give it a try!
St. Nicholas Center
This links directly to the St. Nicholas Center page that contains the papers for the cookies. They have cutters too.

Decorating Cookies

An Art in Itself

Decorating cookies is truly an art form. The ones in this picture were edible. By changing the materials you use but using the same techniques you can make ornaments that will last for years. My friend, Linda Powers, an accomplished artist and baker taught me much in an intense afternoon of cookie decorating.

Use a toothpick dipped into food color paste to swirl a different color into the icing. Pipe one color around the outside edge of the cookie. That will make a border and also contain the main icing.

We didn't use any chocolate icing that afternoon. That is certainly a possiblility though.

Use your imagination and have fun. As you can see, you needn't be constrained by conventional colors. We made these cookies for Valentine's Day in 2004 and our colors ran wild!

Cookie Baking Books on Amazon

Loading

Cookie Cutters on EBay

Loading

Cookie Ingredients

Some of these ingredients make great decorations too!
  • Chocolate
    Chocolate bits
    Sugar
    Flour
    Nuts
    Butter
    Baking Powder
    Candied Fruit
    Honey
    and more!

Cookie Cutter and Cookie Guestbook

Please share your favorite cookie anecdotes!

  • margueritemanor Oct 12, 2008 @ 12:16 pm | delete
    Hi CKConrad.
    Sorry for taking so long to get back to you. I was going to email you, but in posting your comment, I accidentally deleted your contact info.

    Those "very special cutters" are Aunt Chick's. I googled and found a number of places, including Ebay, so I think that if you search Aunt Chick's cookie cutters, you will find them. These are the ones that are like molds.

    Another style that was also popular are called HRM. These are flatter, although they will leave a design impression if the dough is thick enough. Search on HRM or red plastic cookie cutters and you will find sellers.

    Good luck. It is always so nice to continue family traditions.
  • margueritemanor Oct 12, 2008 @ 12:00 pm | delete
    ckconrad
    Marguerite: Do you know the name of the company that manufactured those "very special red plastic cutters"? It was located in Massachusetts and I ordered some in the late 1970's; now, the next generation is looking for them. Thanks. ckc
    Posted October 08, 2008 03:40 PM
  • margueritemanor Nov 19, 2007 @ 1:27 pm | delete
    See the link I just posted to the St. Nicholas Center above.
  • cmtrzos@att.net Nov 17, 2007 @ 2:51 pm | delete
    Need HELP locating Father Christmas paper for 5 1/2" cutter. The cookie cutter is the stainless steel German Father Christmas. any suggestions would be appreciated...

by

margueritemanor

Marguerite Manor(Peggy Manor to her family and friends)is a writer and graphic artist. She holds a BA in Medieval History with Honors from Stanford University... more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!