The Best-Ever Creamy Scalloped Potatoes Recipe

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic by 32 people | Log in to rate

Ranked #126 in Food, #1,462 overall

My Deliciously Creamy Scalloped Potatoes Recipe

The Best-Ever Creamy Scalloped Potatoes Recipe is Umm, Umm, Good! These potatoes are exactly what I think of when I think of comfort food and they are soooo delicious. My sister-in-law quite likes them and she, believe it or not, does not like scalloped potatoes! These ones are rich and it must be the presence of these extra special ingredients that makes them tasty and different to her.

I have been making these scalloped potatoes for years...since I discovered the recipe in a Parents Magazine in April of 1993. My family loves it as have all our guests to whom we have served it. My potato-loving son has always loved it. My other son, who does not love potatoes, always opted for the homemade country seed bread instead of the potatoes...until recently when he has discovered he has a taste for this delicious recipe, too.

The Best-Ever Scalloped Potatoes are a perfect accompaniment to your Easter Dinner, New Year's Dinner, Christmas Dinner or any special occasion meal. We always serve them with The Best-Ever Glazed Baked Ham. We do tend to reserve this recipe for special occasions because of its richness but there is no reason you could not prepare this recipe for creamy potatoes on a more regular basis!

Picture by peaceful-daze.

The Best-Ever Creamy Scalloped Potatoes Recipe ~~ Serves 8 to 10 people 

There is some preparation work in peeling and slicing the vegetables, but otherwise this is a pretty simple recipe.

Ingredients:

1 medium onion chopped
13 oz homemade chicken broth or one can if homemade is not available
1 cup of whipping cream
1 bay leaf
1 tsp salt
1/8 tsp pepper
1/4 cup flour
6 large potatoes peeled or unpeeled (about 3 pounds)

Directions:
  • Heat the oven to 325 degrees.
  • Grease a 13 by 9 inch pan.
  • Mix together the onion, broth, cream, bay leaf, flour, salt and pepper in a bowl.
  • Wash the potatoes and make sure they are somewhat dry.
  • Slice potatoes into 1/4 inch slices and arrange them in your pan.
  • Add broth mix to the potatoes.
  • Cover and bake for 45 minutes.
  • Remove cover and baste the potatoes for 45 minutes longer.

Making Scalloped Potatoes Is Much Easier With A Top Quality Vegetable Peeler Like The Oxo Good Grips i-Series Y Peeler 

This Amazon's bestselling vegetable peeler PLUS it has received more five-star reviews than any other vegetable peeler available on Amazon. In my opinion, that makes it a pretty darn good peeler. Featuring extra-hard stainless steel blade which will stay sharp but can even be replaced by an OXO Peeler Bade Replacement Cartridge.

Oxo Good Grips i-Series Y Peeler

Amazon Price: $11.08 (as of 11/12/2009)Buy Now
List Price: $13.50

"You get what you pay for, but ten dollars is a small investment for such a useful kitchen tool. Make the investment - you won't regret it, and will wonder why you waited so long. I'd been using a cheap peeler that came in a set of kitchen tools and found peeling potatoes painful, difficult, and time-consuming. What a world of difference with the Oxo peeler! It makes quick, easy, and effortless work out of peeling potatoes, even sweet potatoes, which are more difficult to peel. The blade is extremely sharp and glides over the vegetable with ease, removing the perfect amount of peel. Try it on a mango - you'll be amazed at how perfectly it peels off the skin without wasting any of the flesh of the fruit. I've also used it to peel carrots, broccoli, zucchini, apples, butternut squash, all with success." ~~ Grace Doll

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

 

My Mother-in-Law always matched the correct type of potatoes the the method that she was preparing them. I have always used whatever I have on hand except, that is, for this recipe. For this recipe, I go out of my way to buy Yukon Gold potatoes. I think they are perfect for this recipe and no others will do!

 

Shortcut:

I do not believe you should make this recipe ahead of time. However, on the day of your meal you could prepare the potatoes and soak them in a bowl of water and you could prepare the rest of the ingredients and store them in the fridge.

This Le Creuset Rectangular Baker With Cover Would Work Nicely For This Potato Recipe 

Available in such fantastic colors!


Le Creuset's Enameled Stoneware Covered Rectangular Baker is actually a bit bigger than the one called for in this recipe. However, I believe it still would work very nicely PLUS it comes with a lid, making covering your scalloped potatoes simple. Click here to buy it from Amazon.

$89.99

If This Recipe Is Not Quite What You Are Looking For, Maybe One Of These Is 

Slow-Cooker Scalloped Potatoes Recipe
Slow-Cooker Scalloped Potatoes Recipe from Family Fun and the kitchen of Heather Ashley, Toms Brook, Virginia.
Rachel Ray's Cheesy Scalloped Potatoes Recipe
Rachel Ray's Cheesy Scalloped Potatoes recipe is featured in the November issue of Every Day with Rachael Ray.
Tyler Florence's Scalloped Potato Gratin Recipe from the Food Network
Food Network invites you to try this Scalloped Potato Gratin recipe from Tyler Florence. From the show How To Boil Water and the episod: Christmas Made Easy.
Yankee Magazine's Scalloped Potatoes Recipe
Mashed potatoes rate high on most "comfort food" lists, and I'm all for them--anytime, anywhere, any season. But the crispy, cheesy love that comes from baking simple sliced spuds really speaks to me. I adore the textures and flavors, and they remind me of holiday meals with the people I love around a big, festive table.
Emeril Lagasse's Scalloped Potatoes Recipe From The Food Network
The Food Network invites you to try this Scalloped Potatoes recipe from Emeril Lagasse.
Gourmet.com Scalloped Potatoes Recipe
There's no question: If meatloaf, then potatoes. These have all the comfort of mashed, but with a nice texture from the potato slices and from being baked in cream. And they can go in the oven along with the meatloaf, so dinner will be ready all at once.
Gourmet Magazine's Old-Fashioned Scalloped Potatoes
Gourmet Magazine's delicious potato recipes, like old-fashioned scalloped potatoes, and others at Epicurious.com.
Bon Appetit Magazine's Scalloped Yukon Gold and Sweet Potato Gratin with Fresh Herbs
Find delicious herb recipes, like scalloped yukon gold and sweet potato gratin with fresh herbs, and other recipes at Epicurious.com
Cooking Light's Cider Scalloped Potatoes
Cooking Light's Cider Scalloped Potatoes can be baked in a casserole or individual gratin dishes.
Taste of Home's Light Scalloped Potatoes
"Even with lighter ingredients like chicken bouillon and Parmesan cheese, this is a comforting potato dish," shares Tamie Foley of Thousand Oaks, California.
Recipezaar's Healthy Scalloped Potatoes Recipe
A low-fat, heart healthy version of this traditional comfort food, courtesy of SparkPeople.com.
Womansday.com Scalloped Potatoes & Spinach
How to make Scalloped Potatoes & Spinach from WomansDay.com.
Canadian Living's French Scalloped Potatoes
Canadian Living's French Scalloped Potatoes contain whip cream and dried porcini mushrooms.
Paula Deen's Scalloped Potatoes
Paula Deen's Scalloped Potatoes recipe is from Cooking with Paula Deen, Christmas 2007.
Karina's Kitchen Vegan Scalloped Potatoes From Recipes From A Gluten-Free Goddess:
On a whim and out of nowhere (and at 2:54 AM, I'll have you know) I began conjuring images of creamy scalloped potatoes. Odd for someone who must avoid cheese and cream and butter and who- most days- is reconciled to her cheese-free life with a shrugging Zen detachment they write books about. Not to mention, it's been (literally) over a decade since I made this retro recipe, cream or no cream. Alas, I simply couldn't get the idea out of my sleepy Ewan McGregor-esque spiky head. The scalloped potato challenge bit me. And refused to let go.

A Selection of 13 by 9 inch Casserole Dishes Available Through eBay 

Perfect for baking your scalloped potatoes!

If you're interested in one of these, act fast. They're at auction and once they're gone, they are gone. Once again, you can click on the blue link, the picture or the 'bid now' to get more information without any obligation to buy the item.

Loading Fetching new data from eBay now... please stand by
eBay

Cheesy Scalloped Potatoes 

Scalloped, Cheesy Potatoes
Picture byJ*A*M*I*E

People Are Talking About Scalloped Potatoes In Their Blogs 

Slow Cooker Scalloped Potatoes and Sausage Recipe: Recipes ...
Slow Cooker Scalloped Potatoes and Sausage Recipe - This quick meal is a cinch to put together and ready and waiting. The creamy sauce with the flavor of ranch is perfect with the potatoes.
Once Upon a Plate: Potatoes Daphinois ~ Scalloped Potatoes
Potatoes Daphinois ~ Scalloped Potatoes. Honestly, do Scalloped Potatoes need any explanation?! I loved when my mother would serve them with dinner ~ they have always been one of my favorite ways of enjoying potatoes. ...
Scalloped Potatoes TTF Farewell for Now « Chaya's Comfy Cook Blog
Nigella is a great choice. She has many recipes that are appealing and easy to handle. Thanks you all. Come play at I Heart Cooking Clubs. potato on a plate. Scallop Scalloped Potatoes Tyler Florence TFF Adapted. 4 to 6 servings ...

Looking For More Great Potato Recipes? Try The Ultimate Potato Book 

Hundreds of Ways to Turn America's Favorite Side Dish into a Meal



Amazon Customer Review:

"I bought this book because I owned others in this series and I'm not disappointed. All the recipes are for main courses with potatoes, so this is a book for real potato lovers. Great soups, really yummy stews, and some cool new things I've never seen before--potato casseroles that are way great. I love all the international dishes, Japanese, Chinese, Irish, French, German, African. It's so cool to make potatoes from around the world."

Click here to buy the
Ultimate Potato Book:
Hundreds of Ways to Turn America's Favorite Side Dish into a Meal
from Amazon.

List Price: $16.95
Amazon Sale Price: $14.41

More Potato Recipes Can Be Found In These 5-Star Potato Cookbooks 

Amazon's customer reviews are a great way to judge the quality of a cookbook. I've included a quote from a customer for each of these books. If the book is out-of-print, it is probably available from Amazon's private sellers at the used price. You can visit any of these items for more information simply by clicking on the link shown in blue, the picture or the 'buy now' button. Doing so will NOT obligate you to purchase the book.

The Williams-Sonoma Collection: Potato

"Every recipe we have made has been wonderful. Many family favorites are contained here. And our favorite part? Pictures for EVERY recipe!" ~~ Jennifer Thompson

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $13.22 (as of 11/11/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $16.95
Used Price: $2.31

Potato Salad: Fifty Great Recipes

"Well actually it probably has your mother's potato salad and a whole lot more. From the traditional to the revolutionary, all the bases are covered in this book. I particularly like Tarragon and Lamb Potato Salad and Jansson's Temptation. If the spud's your thing, you must have this book. ~~ A Customer

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 11/11/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $18.95
Used Price: $5.47

Potatoes: More than Mashed: Over 100 fantastic potato recipes from all over the world from classic potato salad to potato cake, show step-by-step in 300 tempting photographs

"Experienced and casual cooks will find a tremendous selection of main dishes, soups, sides, and baked goods which can add variety and interest to any meal. Recipes include vegetarian, meat, and fish dishes, as well as a wide variety of unique ethnic choices such as Chinese, Tex Mex, Carribean, German, and Russian options." ~~ C. Carlson

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $12.74 (as of 11/11/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $16.99
Used Price: $7.99

The Great Potato Book

"Any spudophile will love this book. A lengthy but fascinating introduction relates the history of the noble potato as well as useful tips for cooking and storing. Numerous types of potatoes are described in detail, each accompanied by illustrations and pertinent recipes." ~~ Spudman

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 11/11/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $15.95
Used Price: $4.88

Potatoes

"Simply outstanding in every respect - Wonderful and unique receipes for potatoes, simple to follow instructions, listed ingredients separate from receipes for ease of preparation, and great photographs. ~~ Baazumi

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 11/11/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $18.60
Used Price: $11.14

People Are Talking About Scalloped Potatoes In The News 

Keep it together when you make scalloped potatoes
Scalloped or au gratin potatoes are so simple. But it can be frustrating when the creamy sauce and cheese separate or look curdled. ...
Not in the Mood for Mashed? Try Scalloped Potatoes
These scalloped potatoes can be prepped up to a day ahead. Prepare them up to the point of adding the cheese, then refrigerate. Continue with the recipe ...
Senior meals
Tuesday ? 1: Pork roast with gravy, scalloped potatoes, green beans, dinner roll, applesauce. 2: Meat taco with cheese, lettuce, tomato, salsa and sour ...

My Food Pages That Go Well With The Best-Ever Creamy Scalloped Potatoes 

Do You Like Scalloped Potatoes? 

Loading poll. Please Wait...

 

Photobucket

Let me know how you've enjoyed your visit. Are you hungry for scalloped potatoes? 

stargazer00 wrote...

These scalloped potatoes look great!

ReplyPosted October 24, 2009

mbgphoto wrote...

My scalloped potatoes always get too runny. I'll have to try this recipe. 5* and blessed.

ReplyPosted October 23, 2009

KarateKatGraphics wrote...

I love the addition of bay...have done a very simple cream pasta sauce with bay that is wonderful. 5*, faved, and rolling this to Main Dish Potato Gratin.

ReplyPosted October 15, 2009

24websurf wrote...

Oh you should have left me a fork
here in the guest book! These look so good!
It has been such a Blessing to get this recipe!

~~ Very Happily Blessed! ~~

ReplyPosted October 14, 2009

tan1212 wrote...

i was looikig for the recipe Creamy Scalloped Potatoes .thanks for sharing this .

http://scalloprecipes-scallop.blogspot.com/

ReplyPosted June 30, 2009

view all 25 comments

My Pages Dedicated To Kitchen Tools 

My Other Food Pages That You Might Enjoy 

My Entertaining Food Pages  

Visit my ham and carrot jokes pages and you might enjoy the carrot photo fight, too!

You can create pages or lenses on Squidoo, too! 

YES YOU CAN! Anyone can create pages or lenses on Squidoo!

Join Squidoo and create your own lenses just like this page. It is free to join and you might earn some money through affiliate marketing. Simply put, lenses are web pages and Squidoo calls them lenses because they focus on topics. You are an expert on something. Whatever interests you probably can be written up to help inform someone else. Ready to join? Click right here.

by Treasures-By-Brenda

These scalloped potatoes are one of our very favorite recipes...just add ham and the vegetables of your choice and you will be set for a comfort food... (more)

Explore related pages

Create a Lens!