Edward Cullen is an abusive, controlling boyfriend!
Ranked #869 in Books, Poetry & Writing, #37,777 overall | Donates to Squidoo Charity Fund, March of Dimes
The goal of an abuser is control.
Domestic violence is a very important topic to me.
While reading Twilight, New Moon and now Eclipse, I was disturbed by the amount of "warning signs" or "red flags" in the relationship between Bella and Edward.
My concern is that he is too controlling, and that impressionable Cullen fans might be accepting of such behavior in real life.
Thanks to Twilight Quotes whose compilation Web site makes it much easier to recall key things than re-reading each book again. :)
Featured lenses for your review
Recognizing abuse: Know the signs
excerpts from mayoclinic.com
Abuse often starts subtly and gets worse over time.
For example, abuse may begin with occasional hurtful comments, jealousy or controlling behavior.
As it gets worse, the abuse may become more frequent, severe or violent.
You may be a victim of abuse if you're in a relationship with someone who:
• Controls finances, so you have to ask for money
• Looks at you or acts in ways that scare you
• Acts jealous or possessive, or accuses you of being unfaithful
• Tries to control how you spend your time, who you see or talk to, where you go or what you wear
• Wants you to get permission to make everyday decisions
• Gets angry when drinking alcohol or using drugs
• Scares you by driving recklessly
• Threatens to kill him or herself
You are very likely in an abusive relationship if you have a relationship with someone who does even one of the following:
• Hits, kicks, shoves, slaps, or chokes you or threatens you with violence or a weapon
• Forces you to have sexual intercourse or engage in sexual acts against your will
• Calls you names, insults you or puts you down
• Prevents you from going to work or school
• Stops you from seeing family members and friends
• Hurts, or threatens to hurt you, your children or pets
• Destroys your property
• Controls your access to medicines
• Blames you for his or her violent behavior or tells you that you deserve it
• Says that his or her abusive behavior is no big deal or even denies doing it
• Tries to force you to drop charges
• Tries to prevent you from calling the police or seeking medical care
Twilight saga
It's about power and control
excerpts from mayoclinic.com
In all cases, the abuser aims to exert power and control over his partner.
Although a lot of people think domestic violence is about anger, it really isn't.
It's about trying to instill fear and wanting to have power and control in the relationship.
In an abusive relationship, the abuser may use varying tactics, including:
Emotional abuse.
Uses put-downs, insults, criticism or name-calling to make you feel bad about yourself.
Edward = Guilty.
Sometimes it is joking and playful—other times it is simply unneccessary.
I'm certain that dozens if not hundreds will comment this lens to disagree, or to justify, but it is simply wrong to do.
Bella, it's not my fault if you are exceptionally unobservant.
Bella, you are utterly absurd.
Honestly—I've seen corpses with better color.
Don't be offended, but you seem to be one of those people who just attract accidents like a magnet. So try not to fall into the ocean or get run over or anything, all right?
Only you could get into trouble in a town this small.
I've never tried to keep a specific person alive before, and it's much more troublesome than I would have believed. But that's probably just because it's you. Ordinary people seem to make it through the day without so many catastrophes.
Are you referring to the fact that you can't walk across a flat, stable surface without finding something to trip over?
You are a terrible actress—I'd say that career path is out for you.
Damn it, Bella! You'll be the death of me, I swear you will.
Now relax before I call the nurse back to sedate you.
If we could bottle your luck, we'd have a weapon of mass destruction on our hands.
I wasn't about to send you off alone. With your luck, not even the black box would survive.
You aren't exactly the best judge of what is or isn't dangerous.
Must I always be the responsible one?
Denial and blame.
Denies that the abuse occurs and shifts responsibility for the abusive behavior onto you. This may leave you confused and unsure of yourself.
Intimidation.
Uses certain looks, actions or gestures to instill fear. The abuser may break things, destroy property, abuse pets or display weapons.
Edward = Guilty.
How many times did she attempt to sneak around and do something behind his back because she knew it would anger him?
Coercion and threats.
Threatens to hurt other family members, pets, children or self.
Edward = Guilty.
So is acting in a threatening manner toward friends or family.
These are no laughing matter in a real life relationship.
I infuriate myself. The way I can't seem to keep from putting you in danger. My very existence puts you at risk. Sometimes I truly hate myself.
Edward Cullen, Twilight, Chapter 17
Well, I wasn't going to live without you... I was thinking maybe I would go to Italy and do something to provoke the Volturi... Anyway, you don't irritate the Volturi. Not unless you want to die—or whatever it is we do.
Edward Cullen, New Moon, Chapter 1
I thought I'd explained it clearly before. Bella, I can't live in a world where you don't exist.
Edward Cullen, New Moon
Power.
Makes all major decisions, defines the roles in your relationship, is in charge of the home and social life, and treats you like a servant or possession.
Edward = Guilty.
In what strange parallel dimension would I ever have gone to prom of my own free will? If you weren't a thousand times stronger than me, I would never have let you get away with this.
Bella Swan, Twilight, Epilogue
Isolation.
Limits your contact with family and friends, requires you to get permission to leave the house, doesn't allow you to work or attend school, and controls your activities and social events. The abuser may ask where you've been, track your time and whereabouts, or check the odometer on your car.
Edward = Guilty.
He disabled her truck so she couldn't leave.
He bribed Alice to monitor her—virtually imprison her—in his absence.
He forbid her to see her best friend under any circumstances.
Children as pawns.
Accuses you of bad parenting, threatens to take the children away, uses the children to relay messages, or threatens to report you to children's protective services.
Economic abuse.
Controls finances, refuses to share money, makes you account for money spent and doesn't want you to work outside the home. The abuser may also try to sabotage your work performance by forcing you to miss work or by calling you frequently at work.
Abuse is not limited to physical contact.
excerpts from womensweb.ca
Physical
• Hitting, punching, slapping
• Kicking
• Choking
• Biting
• Burning
• Shoving
• Using objects or weapons
• Locking up or confining
• Interfering with sleeping or eating
• Restricting the mobility or access of a differently abled partner
Sexual
• Forcing sexual acts
• Sexual assault with or without weapons or objects used as weapons
• Assault for refusal to engage in sexual activity
Psychological or emotional
• Repetitive and excessive criticism
• Humiliation and degradation, which can include swearing, name calling and put-downs
• Restricting or controlling access to personal or social resources or friends
• Homophobic, racist, misogynistic attacks (degrading and hostile remarks about your sexual orientation, heritage, or gender)
• Threats or harm to pets
Threats
• Direct intentions to harm you, your family, or your friends
• Threats that affect child custody, legal, immigration, or sponsorship status
• Threats to reveal lesbian identity against your wishes
Economic
• Controlling finances
• Stealing money
• Creating debt
• Interfering with employment or education
Destruction of property
• Destruction of property or personal items
Stalking/harassing behavior
• Following
• Appearing unexpectedly at or waiting outside workplace or home
• Repeated phone calls or mail/email to victim and/or family, friends, or colleagues
Your opinion matters.
Knowing what you now know about abuse, answer the following question, and feel free to comment about your choice.
Is Edward and Bella's an abusive relationship?
Fetching blurbs now... please stand byYes, there are definitely elements of abuse.
JJNW says:
I am not sure, but I think it's a good thing to talk over with teens that read the books. Sometime writer's work out their own issues in their fiction. Have you shown this to the author? She might be enlightened! I've given you a SquidAngel Blessing boost for stirring up some thoughts.
Posted November 01, 2011
hprudavis says:
I LOVE this lens! I love it so much so that I am going to feature it on mine! This is an EXCELLENT example and I love that you provided the explanations! Thank you!
Posted July 20, 2011
SocialpathFree says:
Some of the messages for girls in this series are disturbing. I hated the way Bella went all catatonic when Edward broke up with her. Not good mental health practice at all.
Posted July 17, 2011
JeromeWilkins says:
I am concerned about the safety and well being of my wife,however i would never treat her like Edward treats Bella
Posted May 29, 2011
Verda says:
Okay, to all of you fans who say that Edward is doing it for Bella's own good and because he's trying to protect her, even if those are his intentions, that doesn't make it O.K. In fact, that makes the relationship even worse because Edward doesn't even know that what he's doing is WRONG.
1) It doesn't matter if Edward is trying to protect Bella by not letting her see Jacob. He doesn't have the right to tell her who she can and can't see, even if it's for her own good. If Bella wants to see Jacob, Edward doesn't have the right to stop her, no matter how dangerous it is to her.
2) It doesn't matter if Bella doesn't complain about his actions. She has low self esteem and people with low self esteem rarely find fault with the actions of someone who claims to love them.
3) What fans dismiss as harmless "joking" is far from harmless. Edward is constantly putting Bella down and saying how she can't take care of herself and how he knows better than her. In a deleted scene of the first movie, Bella says to Edward that she knows that he thinks she can't take care of herself, and Edward tells her that he KNOWS she can't take care of herself. This is not joking, it is abuse and it is NOT funny, even if it's only in a book.
4) People who say it is just a book have obviously never looked any deeper than the shallow surface of this "saga". There is always a layer of hidden meaning if you dig a little deeper.
5) Certain people (cough, cough) who say that we should be ashamed of criticizing this "wonderful" series, should be embarrassed that they would be so immature as to act superior to other people just because they have a different opinion. Besides, it's the fact that these books are influencing so many girls that is so worrying. If the future generation of women think that Bella and Edward's relationship is the ideal relationship, then we're all doomed.
6) Finally, this is why men so often think that women like to be dominated. A relationship should be equal, and the boyfriend should acknowledge that his girlfriend DOES have a brain and is capable of using it and that he can advise her not to do something, but he can't take away her rights. Edward and Bella's relationship is not cute, it's not sweet, it's not romantic, and it is not acceptable for these kinds of relationships to be portrayed as the ideal relationship.
Posted February 02, 2011
No, it's true love! He does it because he cares!
srioschavez says:
fictional story here not real life i know abuse and this is a story about vampires and werewolves.
Posted November 22, 2011
Patty_1234 says:
Oh come on... You dont even know what the hell you're talking about. This is a fictional story...You know what that means?? This is not an abusive relashionship. In our world, you're absolutely right, but in Bella's world, Edward is dead right about evrything he does. Of course he's allways wacthing her, they live in a world full of monsters, and a significant part of that monsters wants to kill her, if he can help it, why wouldn't he?? If it means allways beeing whit her, and controling who's in and out of her life then thats what needs to be done. Also, If you had a girlfriend and find out that her best friend is a werewolf and you thought that he was dangerous to her and that could at anytime kill her wouldn you stop her from seeing him??. One thing people dont understand here is that he LOVES her. Truly loves her and would do anything for her. Hes not forcing her into anything.. In eclipse you see that he lets her choose. Not only in Eclipse but in twilight and new moon, he always let her choose. Also, of course hes intimidating to her in twilight and she felt afraid of him multiple times... HES A VEMPIRE!!! for god sake!!... wouldnt you be afraid? Thats not him intimidating her. Thats natures job. The predator always feels intimidating to the prey. So that reaction its pretty normal. So you haters...stop ruining twilight. If you dont like go read something else instead of bothering people with your stupid psychic analisys on abusive behaviour... Love has vanished from the world... Has disappeared. In real life love doesn't exist anymore, the only thing people want is sex... Because somewhere along the way people decided that that is lame and "abusive" yea right, we should be free... date whoever we want do wathever we feel like... That brough us to this damaged world...
So please, please.. If we can't have that in real life... at least let as dream and for minutes of reading be in a world where love is real, and heals you, and gives you a reason to be... Just to let you know I'd rather have an Edward in a real life controling me and bla bla bla, then a person whos with me and doesnt love me and cheats on me and hurts me, you know, things that Edward would NEVER do..
Posted February 07, 2011
RosealieH says:
I don't think so. I mean, I feel for all the girls out there in an abusive relationship and all, but not theirs. Of course, you can see the abusive factors in their relationship, but Bella is perfectly fine with it. She doubts herself, and Edward supports her. Not to mention she is just as sarcastic as he is, so they're equally abusive, if at all. His joking remarks are blown out of proportion and used out of context.
If you read the draft of "Midnight Sun", then you'd see that he never means her any harm, ever. He is as gentle as he could ever be, and seeing her sick even makes him miserable. He does not want Bella to suffer even those two days of pain that turn her immortal. That's caring, if you ask me, not abusive.
And Bella is way too smart to let him do something that she didn't want him to. She can take care of herself well enough. And there's the fact that Edward listens to and obeys all of her wishes and commands.
Also, Edward always gives her a choice. At the prom, she could have walked away at anytime with Edward trailing behind her. Upset, sure, but not forcing her to go back. Don't forget she ended up having fun.
I'm not an Edward fan. He could be better. Simple as that, but abusive and controlling, he is not.
Posted May 26, 2010
teamedward1 says:
okay...
1) This saga is not meant to be a guide or a metaphor for relationships. It is simply a love story with a twist. Edward "lives" and "breathes" for Bella. He knows that he is dangerous to her and he tries to leave and protect her. By doing so, she ends up in more trouble and endangering her life. He selflessly sacrifices his happiness for her safety. Furthermore, I don't think you're giving Bella enough credit. She is intelligent. In the first novel, Twilight, the reader is informed that Bella was previously in advanced classes in Phoenix. She would not allow herself to be subject to abuse.
2) This was written to be a love story. You are reading too far into it and missing the whole point. By picking apart this saga you are defeating the purpose of a fantastical love story
3) You should be ashamed of yourself for picking apart a love story that contains a relationship that young girls across America dream about.
4) Who has this much time on their hands? To read an entire saga and pick out individual excerpts to illustrate a nonexistent abusive relationship
Posted May 24, 2010
carinichole says:
Not at all. I have my copy of Eclipse to back it up. Let's start with your first point of intimidation. Yes, in Eclipse on page 165, Edward does break an object- a piece of the bed, comparing the remains to her. It's for demonstrative purposes to show Bella exactly how strong he is, and what he would end up doing if he lost control while making love. She was clearly not scared, but rather curious as to what he broke. His intentions were not to scare her or harm her. I believe it's all about the intention behind the action, and Edward's intentions are clearly meant only for Bella's protection.
Secondly, I have to comment on your section about Isolation. Again, Edward is only trying to protect Bella. That's the obvious part here. There is a conversation that takes place in Eclipse between Edward and Bella after she goes to La Push, and it goes like this:
?I decided that you were right. My problem before was more about my . . . prejudice against werewolves than anything else. I'm going to try to be more reasonable and trust your judgment. If you say it's safe, then I'll believe you.?
?Wow.?
?And . . . most importantly . . . I'm not willing to let this drive a wedge between us.?
In this conversation, Edward is attempting to see her side, and willing to trust her judgement. This is out of love and respect for her, two things that are missing from an abusive relationship.
The last topic I want to address is Power. If you're familiar with the Twilight books, then you already know that Bella is impulsive and prone to disaster. She needs someone to look after her. She probably wouldn't survive in her situation otherwise. Come on, this is a story about vampires AND werewolves! Anyways, here's the part of Eclipse I want to share to back this up:
?Don't you start,? I snapped. ?You made the treaty ? you stick to it.?
?If he'd hurt you ?? (speaking of Jacob)
?Enough!? I cut him off. ?There's nothing to worry about. Jacob isn't dangerous.?
?Bella.? He rolled his eyes. ?You aren't exactly the best judge of what is or isn't dangerous.?
?I know I don't have to worry about Jake. And neither do you.?
He ground his teeth together. His hands were balled up in fists at his sides. He was still standing against the wall, and I hated the space between us.
He is concerned for her protection, and if that means stopping her from seeing Jacob and going to La Push, then that's what it means. It's for her benefit, not his.
I have to add that Edward repeatedly makes references to her being better off without him as a friend or anything else for that matter. I don't have the quotes handy, but if you've read or watched the first movie then you know what I'm talking about. Remember the cafeteria scene? He says that it would be better if they were not friends. Why did he say this? To protect her. Remember, he wanted to kill her. . If she got too close, that is exactly what would happen.Her blood 'sang' to him It wasn't his way of playing games with her mind or making her feel sorry for him. This was not a selfish act on his part; rather, he was sacrificing his needs for her.
I'm guessing you had to do an argumentative paper on abuse and thought you could get a couple pieces of evidence from the Twilight Books. Did you really read through the books or scan through them and ask your friends to fill in the blanks? You have to understand the situations in the book before taking a stand on the characters' actions. Gather ALL the facts before making a conclusion.
Posted May 03, 2010
Breaking the cycle: Difficult, but possible with help
excerpts from mayoclinic.com
• Your abuser strikes using words or actions.
• Your abuser may beg for forgiveness, offer gifts or promise to change.
• Your abuser becomes tense, angry or depressed.
• Your abuser repeats the abusive behavior.
Typically each time the abuse occurs, it worsens, and the cycle shortens. As it gets worse, you may have a hard time doing anything about the abuse or even acknowledging it.
Over time, an abusive relationship can break you down and unravel your sense of reality and self-esteem. You may begin to doubt your ability to take care of yourself. You may start to feel like the abuse is your fault, or you may even feel you deserve it.
1-800-799-SAFE
National Domestic Violence Hotline
There is help.
excerpts from ndvh.org

Help is available to callers 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. Hotline advocates are available for victims and anyone calling on their behalf to provide crisis intervention, safety planning, information and referrals to agencies in all 50 states, Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands. Assistance is available in English and Spanish with access to more than 170 languages through interpreter services. If you or someone you know is frightened about something in your relationship, please call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-SAFE (7233) or TTY 1-800-787-3224.
by NicoleRoberts
Hello world. This is my bio. I can edit it later!
- 20 featured lenses
- Winner of 7 trophies!
- Top lens » If you have a tattoo, do you regret it now?
- This lens »
Won purple star
