Ten Things We Should Never Say To Kids | A Rant by Jim Hancock
Ranked #7,077 in Parenting & Kids, #247,604 overall
TEN THINGS IS MOVING
CLICK ON THE LINK BELOW TO GO TO MY NEW HOME
From now on the free downloadable files will be at Ten Things We Should Never Say To Kids at Blogspot.com. The new location will enable us to communicate a bit more easily if you want to tell me what you think
THING ONE : Do You Have Your Jacket-Homework-Gym-Bag-Back-Pack-Ticket-Keys?
Adults say lots of things to kids that don't really help either of them. OK, that's not exactly true-some things help adults get things done right now; but the near-term benefit quickly turns to a long-term liability. Thing One: Do You Have Your Jacket-Homework-Gym-Bag-Back-Pack-Ticket-Keys? is such a thing. THING TWO : What Were You Thinking!
I've looked into this pretty carefully and come to believe a lot of parenting is thinly veiled hazing. You know, hazing-where the strong (or privileged) humiliate the weak (or recently arrived) as part of initiating them into a desirable society. Take your own survey: I bet you'll find most kids never feel much stupider or more tongue-tied than when backed into a corner by an angry adult demanding to know Thing Two: What Were You Thinking! THING THREE : Because I Said So.
Anyone can be broken. If kids nag long enough almost anyone will crack and utter the words they swore they would never say . . . "BECAUSE I SAID SO!" Why, I wonder, after 14 generations of life together as North Americans, has no one stepped up to say, "I have an answer that's better than "Because I said so!" Well . . . the wait is over. THING FOUR : You Are Such a Pretty Little Thing.
All things considered, I think one of the worst things you can tell a little girl is how pretty she is. Let's say for the sake of argument that a child stands before us and the child in question is relatively attractive in whatever subculture she inhabits. So what? Telling her she's pretty is a useful compliment the way Krispy Kreme is a food product. Tasty? Sure, if you think so. Nutritious? An important part of a balanced diet? Are you kidding? THING FIVE : I'm Proud of You!
Thing Five unpacks the (apparently heretical) notion that telling kids we're proud of them is a mistake. Go ahead; roll your eyes. But hear me out. This chapter is also the reason Ten Things We Should Never Say To Kids is free. SHAMELESS PLUG: The Book that Inspired This Book is Updated and Downloadable Now!
Raising Adults
The book that inspired Ten Things We Should Never Say To Kids is newly updated and available for digital download.The premise of Raising Adults is a simple word play: I mean, who can help noticing that parents, schools, churches and communities spend 18+ years raising children - or in any case, people who still feel more like children than adults?
This is not what most of us thought we were doing.
We can do better. Raising Adults isn't about blame, it's about Do-Overs. It's about starting right where we are and doing what it takes to get kids ready for life in the world as it is - not as we wish it were. Raising Adults is just $10 at the YS Underground.
THING SIX : You Can Do Anything You Set Your Mind To.
You can do ANYTHING you set your mind to? Come on, who are we kidding. I hate give away the punchline before you've had a chance to read Thing Six. So I'll only give away half: "If you think you can, you might..." THING SEVEN: Let Me Tell You What Happened Here.
The language of expertise is, "Let me tell you something."The language of exploring is, "Let me ask you something."
I think we fail kids as teachers if we don't respect them as learners.
THING EIGHT: That's Not How You Do It.
Who said the only way to fold towels is the way your mother folded them, which is the way her mother and her mother's mother folded towels for as long as anybody can remember; probably back to the time when there were no towels and people just stepped out of the river and air-dried? When a kid hears the words, "That's not how you do it," she thinks, "No; that's not how YOU do it," and the battle of wills is on. But to what end? THING NINE: Don't Make Me Turn This Car Around.
Adults who try to bluff children into submission really haven't thought through the whole threat thing in general. By the time you resort to threats (especially if everyone knows you're bluffing) you've turned parenting into a zero sum game. And you've already lost. THING TEN: I Give Up.
"I give up" has a permanent ring to it that shocks and terrifies children. Giving up sounds like abandonment, like the end of hope, like the death of the future. If your child believes you've given up on him, there's a scary chance he'll give up too. Ten Things We Should Never Say To Kids: THE LAST WORD
tell me what you think . . .
submit
-
Reply
-
delicada
Nov 23, 2010 @ 12:09 am | delete
- This is good stuff. I know that we are supposed to keep in simple and that was my first mistake on my first lens on here. I think people/parents need a bit more info....
1. It depends on the kid, but I think it's a good idea to give fair warning. For example: Summers over and I can see that there is a lot for you to remember. What do YOU think that YOU can do so that you will remember your keys/backpack/...etc...
2. I completely agree. If you want to your kids self-esteem to sink as quick as a dead guy on a Law and Order episode ask them that question. How about " I can see that you made a very quick decision here. I would like to hear how this happened step by step. Then say nothing. They will already feel bad enough.
3.Because I said so leads to the child/teen/young adult/ to wanting more control and only teaches them how to be a control freak. Instead of saying "Because I said so," How about, I NEED you to take the dog out now. Then don't say another word. When you say this to them make sure you are making eye contact. If the child is small, kneel down so you can look them in the eye.
4.I agree that it sends the wrong message, however you are not a girl. The way it could be done is simple...."My oh my, you have your grandmother's beautiful blue eyes."
5.I agree. Instead of saying "I'm proud of you," you can say "Wow, that was some,great pass that you made at the big game"
6.I agree. I have always hated it when an adult said that to me. Reality is that I could put my mind to something that I want to do, but there is always a bump, a hang-up or even a catch. How about "You should give it everything that you can and remember to learn as much as you possibly can from the mistakes and mishaps on the way.....And thank God for those.
7. I agree. If a teacher doesn't know this, then they are in the wrong line of work. How about "What do you think happened here." After the student is finished, there is nothing wrong with saying "That's one way of looking at it, anyone else have another."
8.I agree. Let your child pour his own glass of milk. If it spills the answer is simple. That's what paper towels are for.
9.I agree. Empty threats do not get you anywhere even close to what it is that you want. Pull the car over, pick up the child, look him straight in the eye and say " You NEED to stay in this car seat." Trust me, he will.
10.I agree and this one is scary. It's a terrible and horrid thing to say to your child of any age. I heard a parent say this to his son at my daughters school after he failed his math test. It's a freaking math test. How about "I can see that you are struggling in math. I understand that this must be very upsetting. Can you think of a way that may make passing math easier? A tutor? Great idea.....Let's go see about one right now.
Last word on number six.....If you think you can you might. If you think you can't you won't. I think that statement depends on the child.
-
-
Reply
-
Homunculus
Jun 23, 2007 @ 3:21 pm | delete
- If anyone who reads what you have written here has any doubts about the validity of some of the apparently counter-intuitive points you have made, then they are the people who probably need to read it the most.
Good post! Good luck! - Brian at Mathmojo.
-
Books by Jim Hancock
MORE FROM JIM HANCOCK
These books, digital videos, scripts + youth group curricula reflect my effort to help thoughtful youth workers create safe + robust learning environments.
- The Tiny Company Called Me
- Resources for youth groups from Jim Hancock
by jimhancock
jimhancock
Kids don't learn what they're supposed to learn.
They learn what they're prepared to learn.
My books, digital videos, scripts + youth group curricula...
more »
- 1 featured lens
- Winner of 3 trophies!
- Top lens » Ten Things We Should Never Say To Kids | A Rant by Jim Hancock
Feeling creative?
Create a Lens!
Explore related pages
- Autumn Coloring Pages Autumn Coloring Pages
- Thailand's Must Visit Markets Thailand's Must Visit Markets
- Things To Do in Bangkok Things To Do in Bangkok
- Avatar Action Figures Avatar Action Figures
- The Fresh Air Fund: Summer Vacations in the Country for Inner City Kids The Fresh Air Fund: Summer Vacations in the Country for Inner City Kids
- Sex Education NOW! Sex Education NOW!