THE BATTLE OF THE DAVIDS ON IDOL
David Cook vs. David Archuleta
This year's American Idol finale could be (UPDATE: WAS) a battle of the Davids!
I like what David Cook does with his song choices. He made 'Hello' and other songs sound better than the original to me. He's going to make the best album of any Idol ever!
David Archuleta is okay but he gets more boring to me over time. He doesn't sound bad, but I don't think I'd buy his album. Maybe he's just not my taste.
What do you think? Is David Archuleta or David Cook better?
Your Turn: The Battle of the American Idol Davids
Fetching blurbs now... please stand byDavid Cook is Better!
Vien says:
david cook is the best! he has everything. besides the fact that he has a unique voice,he has also originality that raised him up to fame! haha. i love him. don't like archie that much. SORRY. NO OFFENSE. - vien cook.
Posted June 30, 2009
Kelly says:
It's pretty obvious that david cook is waaaayy better than archuleta. He sings better and not only that. He has the style, the looks, and the attitude. Well, David Archuleta is good too but there's nothing that special about his voice. There are alot of singers who has a similar voice with David Archie. David Cook would always stand out in everyway. He is so hott too!!! His face is just so perfect! AND PLEASE DON'T DENY IT... HE IS BETTER LOOKING THAN ARCHIE! Archie is just younger..
I must say like archie too.. BUT I LIKE COOK THE BEEESSSSTTT!!
Posted June 03, 2009
miggy says:
If American idol was more on talent than a popularity contest,david cook would have won more 60 percent of the votes.Today teenage girls really like david archuleta because he's still young and think of him as an angel,but what if he's like 25 and above?they're not gonna adore him like they used too.Because he's old,he's gonna get mature.David Cook is mature and can sing like every song.
Posted June 02, 2009
john says:
David cook is better. in every aspect, the only people who like david archuleta are girls that probably like the jonas brothers
Posted February 13, 2009
Arin says:
Personally i think there both totally awesom i love both of thheir hit songs. But to be honest david cook's voice can do so many other toones and notes... but i've got to say i love them both!!!!!:D*
Posted December 05, 2008
Claudine Alexxis ( ; says:
okay. so COOK won. and that is a big YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY! he reaaly deserves to win. im so happy for him. ARCHIE is also good but.. DAVID COOK is BETTER! haha! ARCHIE`S voice is not yet fully developed coz` he is still sooooperr young(^.^). haha! DAVID COOK yaaaay you. congratulations with all heart dear!! you simply R O C K !! plus you are simply A M A Z I N G!! OH MY GOSHH.
Posted May 24, 2008
KAYLA says:
Congratulations David Cook! (: Sorry fake Vanessa but DC won! YAY! hahaha. :P
Posted May 24, 2008
LexI Cleghorn says:
David Cook is better. His cover of Elenor Rigby was the best. David A. is good, but I just don't think at his maturity level he is ready for all pressure of the music business.
Posted May 21, 2008
Jamie says:
Oh, and another thing, David Archuleta chooses the same kind of songs OVER AND OVER AGAIN! Light, slow songs...It gets boring.
Cook has a variety of songs he chooses.
Posted May 21, 2008
Jamie says:
Me, personally, I would much rather see David Cook win. He has talent, and he's older...Because think about it, the majority of American Idol viewers are 10-17 year old girls, who adore David Archuleta. If only they knew he was gay...
Obviously he is!! I mean how can people not see????
Posted May 21, 2008
charie says:
i adore david cook. :)
i love him with all my heart.
Posted May 21, 2008
jeffwend says:
I think Cook will win, Archuleta's dad may have ruined it for him.
Posted May 20, 2008
Camille says:
David Cook must win!
Posted May 19, 2008
amber elizabeth says:
David Cook shows more maturity.
He's much more talented, and he doesn't seem nervous.
Archuleta has a nice voice, but he never surprises me, his music would just simply put me to sleep.
David Cook just seems more adult to me, seems like he'd go further.
I adored him since day 1, and always will.
Win or lose he's still my idol.
Posted May 19, 2008
davidcookie4ever says:
David Cook should and must win american idol. he has the potential of becoming a great singer as wella great performer. his sexy looks attracts women like me haha! he is original and talented. win or lose dc is the one, my only american idol.
Posted May 19, 2008
Shahar says:
David cook is most original and he deserves to win. he is not like archuleta who messed up on the lyrics,and he makes every song his own,and thats what ur supposed to do!
Posted May 18, 2008
Vee says:
David Archuleta has the voice.
David Cook has the charisma, originality, range, vocal strength, personality, stage presence, experience, versatility, star potential, confidence, marketability, consistency, & looks.
Sorry, but I'll always be a Cook fan, whether he wins or not!
Posted May 17, 2008
elizabeth! says:
DAVID COOK ROCK...THERE'RE TO MANY POP IDOL ALREADY WE NEED SOMETHING NEW AND AMAZING LIKE COOK...VOTE FOR HIM!
Posted May 16, 2008
Nik says:
david a;s bring
david c rocks !!
Posted May 16, 2008
the boss says:
david cook has the whole package... archuleta is one big teletubby
Posted May 15, 2008
suyee says:
David Cook is the only one.
Because after all the performance.
I agreed to the simon, he is original, take the risk and got all the package to be next american idol.
David Archuleta is just ok, listen first time is great but soon will be bore.
My Vote go for David Cook. You make Roberta Flack proud for the "First Time Ever I Saw Your Face"
Posted May 15, 2008
in-G says:
i'm sorry archie fans but david a. is getting pretty boring and predictable. david c. has the hot half-smile and the same edge that chris daughtry. he hasn't even one and his version of always be my baby is already a most requested song everywhere. even if he doesn't win, he's gonna be way more successful than david archuleta.
Posted May 14, 2008
michael says:
well now guess what! It is the battle of the Davids!! Ya!! Sayesha was just voted off 5 min ago! So my vote is w/ cook cuz he has the overall stuff archuleta just has a voice...kinda weird one too... so go david and his guitar!!!
Posted May 14, 2008
rocker says:
david cook rocks the house!! , you´ve heard it before..
Posted May 14, 2008
Glyth says:
I agree on Archuleta getting boring, too many ballads. Plus I have always been a rock fan and I like David Cook's voice.
Posted May 13, 2008
kayla says:
David Cook is by far the best. He has the best voice and such a great personality! He makes me so happy. He totaly deserves to win.
I LOVE David Cook!!!!
Posted May 12, 2008
franly says:
just wanna tell you guys.. if you listen to all david. a songs, he just made it the same there is no different at all, at first i also his fan but later on i found out that its getting boring, its just the same, BORING!!!
Posted May 11, 2008
Juls says:
David Cook diserves to win!
He has a great voice!
David Archuleta is sooo annoying!
He should go home already!
Posted May 10, 2008
Barkely says:
I'm a David Cook fan. I think he has more talent than David Archuleta. They're both great though... It should be an interesting finale. I think Archuleta has the tween crowd, and Cook has the rockers. Cook wins it on originality.
Posted May 07, 2008
spudnix says:
Once you've heard David Archuleta sing once, you've heard it all. He get's really boring. David cook however, has fantastic arrangements, unpredictable, and brilliant
Posted May 02, 2008
Susan52 says:
I love the maturity in David Cook's performances. He's already ready to be a star (as was Carrie Underwood) while young David Archuleta needs to continue to grow up to be more than just a pop idol whose career may or may not last.
Posted April 28, 2008
fefe says:
I like David Cook's versions of songs better than the originals in most cases. I look forward to his performances each week and watch them more than once. I think he will go on to be a big star.
David Archuleta is okay, but boring to me. I don't look forward to his performances, but I don't fast forward them either. He has a lot of fans and might just win Idol.
Posted April 26, 2008
David Archuleta is Better!
Madaboutthis! says:
I think that they are both very great singers and this website is stupid because they are both very lovely singers and some PEOPLE dont like stupid things like these. SO fefe, this is a stupid vote. GEEEZZZZ
Posted June 10, 2009
davidFTW says:
adam lambert FTW! haa no kidding (please don't attack me lolz) David Archuleta makes better pop music after idol, David Cook hasn't been as good since the show
Posted June 04, 2009
David Archuleta Fan 1 says:
David Archuleta is so talented. His voice is amazing!
and hes so young! Hes miraculous!
Posted April 02, 2009
donatella says:
david archuletta is way too better than david cook. gosh! David cook Cook looks dirty. He's old, i dont like his style yuks!!!!
Posted March 13, 2009
emilie says:
David Archuleta is having best vocal that touches my heart. I love you David
Posted March 13, 2009
simon says:
david archleta is better!!!
david cook suks
Posted March 01, 2009
Mary says:
David is better!!
and he IS the best!
He should have been the grand winner!!
Posted January 16, 2009
Shai says:
DAVID ARCHULETA is LOVE!!
Posted January 16, 2009
Jenna says:
david A is wayy better
Posted January 01, 2009
Kate says:
DAVID ARCHULETA IS INPIRING AND A GIFT TO US ALL :)
Posted January 01, 2009
davidarchuletaisHOT says:
go to votefair.com and look at the AI david A/C results
Posted June 30, 2008
Eleanore says:
DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <333333333333333333 DUH
Posted June 30, 2008
stella hudgens says:
did you watch american idol last night? 5/20/8 :D
i adore simon now.
you rock archuleta!
Posted May 21, 2008
stella hudgens says:
i agree with my sister.
Posted May 21, 2008
Vanessa Hudgens says:
I was just looking around. I wanted to find out if many of my fans agrees that DAVID ARCHULETA SHOULD BE THE NEXT AMERICAN IDOL.
Well, I think David Archuleta should win. I think he's a great singer. He deserves to win than David Cook. But really, both of them has an amazing voice. :)
- V
Posted May 19, 2008
Gia Jazmin says:
david archuleta = honto ni kawaii! great singer...whoop!!! he should win. he has a great voice!!!!! he's also a great dancer... DAVID ARCHULETA SHOULD BE THE NEXT AMERICAN IDOL. :D
Posted May 19, 2008
cherry says:
David Archuleta can sing anything from ballads to pop musics. His the one to be the next american idol !!!!! Its over the boy loves to sing . Singing since he was 10 yrs old. Music is his world. David Archuleta you are the STAR !!!!!!!!
Posted May 19, 2008
Blake says:
everyone on this side is right.
david cook shouldnt win american idol.
vote david archuleta all the way.
Posted May 17, 2008
Brittany says:
I completely agree with Caelyn.
Archuleta deserves this more.
He should win.
Posted May 17, 2008
Caelyn says:
David Archuleta wanted this all along.
He couldn't wait to audition.
David Cook just randomly got picked while his brother was auditioning.
He never wanted this.
Both David's have amazing voices.
I think David Cook wants to win, for the sake of winning.
Archuleta has always wanted the American Idol title.
He deserves it most. With his ever so positive attitude and thoughtfulness, along with his wonderful talent, why shouldn't he win?
Posted May 17, 2008
TAylor says:
David Archuleta is 100 times better than Cook. Cook is too cocky and a wannabe.
Posted May 15, 2008
Samantha says:
David A's sound amazing. He has the voice of an angel and he is so dam cute. David C on the other hand, has been creative in his arrangements but also has plenty of pitch problems.
Posted May 15, 2008
nellely says:
I love david archuleta! he's the best!!! I've never heard noone better than him!! love him!
Posted May 09, 2008
Krista says:
I think that David Archuleta is an amazing singer. I find some of the other idols to be kind of boring at times. His voice is just plain amazing to me and I hope he wins it! =]
Posted April 30, 2008
Austine says:
I like David Archuleta and I like how he does his songs. David Cook makes everything sound 'rock' - not that it's a bad thing, it sounds pretty good actually, it's just not my taste.
Posted April 28, 2008
JustBon-Crochet-Designs says:
I have been following Archuleta since the beginning of this season, and believe he has the purer voice. I can understand David Cook's popularity, as he does put his own twist on well-known songs and does have a contemporary style.
But, for purely his singing skills, my vote goes to David Archuleta.
Posted April 26, 2008
David Cook VS David Archuleta In The News Together
1
Idol Clears the Way for Dueling Davids
Another contestant is eliminated and the Top Two are heading into next week's finale1 point
2
Will 'Idol' Finale Be A Battle Of The Davids? - News Story | Music, Celebrity, Artist News | MTV News
"American Idol" may come down to a battle between David Archuleta and David Cook, many observers say.0 points
3
Death, Taxes and David vs David
0 points
David Cook: Always Be My Baby
David Cook Links
2
American Idol: Help Raise Money for David Cook's Brother
A local American Idol fan has set up a special Web more...1 point
3
David Cook No. 1 on iTunes
David Cook is No. 1 on the iTunes download chart. more...1 point
5
American Idol: David Cook Profile
David Cook's official American Idol Profile0 points
6
Fansite For American Idol David Cook
David Cook fansite and forum including downloads, more...0 points
7
Myspace: David Cook [fansite]
MySpace music profile for David Cook [Fansite] wit more...0 points
8
David Cook - American Idol 7 Fansite
David Cook fansite: www.davidcookidol.com0 points
9
Wikipedia: David Cook
0 points
11
What David Cook Is Really Like
Working as a web producer at FOX 4, I've written d more...0 points
12
David Archuleta Links
1
American Idol: David Archuleta Profile
David Archuleta's Official American Idol profile1 point
2
Judd Rips Dad of 'Idol' Fave Archuleta - AOL Music
(April 21) -- The 'American Idol' judges and fans more...1 point
3
'Idol' Bans David Archuleta's Father From Backstage
"American Idol" producers have reportedl more...1 point
5
MySpace: Vote For David Archuleta
David Archuleta MySpace Fan Page0 points
6
David Archuleta On Squidoo
Is David Archuleta the next American Idol? The 17- more...0 points
7
Who is David Archuleta?
Is David Archuleta the next American Idol? The 17- more...0 points
8
Wikipedia: David Archuleta
0 points
9
Mayor, his mustache ignite 'Idol' intrigue - Salt Lake Tribune
David Archuleta's Mayor's Mustache in the news!0 points
10
Who is your favorite Top 12 American Idol Contestant?
The Davids aren't the only ones on American Idol, so here you can choose your favorite.
Sorry if your favorite went home too soon. I hate it when that happens!
Got comments about American Idol?
html will be stripped from comments
For more great MonkeyBrain lenses, check out the MonkeyBrain group!
Check out my other MonkeyBrain Debate: American Idol vs. Dancing With The Stars.
Got any comments? Who is your favorite American Idol?
Barkely wrote...
I hope you're right, I'd love to see a battle of the Davids on finale night.
Posted May 07, 2008
JustBon-Crochet-Designs wrote...
I think you're right - it will be a battle of the David's at the final. And may the best one win :)
Posted April 26, 2008
