Should Drugs be Decriminalized?

Ranked #13,554 in Healthy Living, #214,799 overall | Donates to Squidoo Charity Fund

Should drug users, probably among them people you know and love, automatically be labelled as criminals?

I have known people who have died through substance abuse, and I have known people whose lives have been ruined by substance abuse, either their own or someone else's.
So I am well aware of the harm these things do.

But, on balance, I do not believe decent people should be criminalized because of their addictions, whether they be things you stuff up your nose, in your gob or in your veins.

Quite ordinary people, people who would not normally be thought of as criminals, break the law by refusing to accept that the State should dictate what they may or may not ingest. By getting a criminal record, even if they do not receive a custodial sentence, drug users can suffer life-long consequences - it can ruin a career, result in immigration problems and mark a person for life.

And, most important of all, a prohibition on drugs has not stopped the problem escalating over the last fifty years, so it just DOESN'T WORK! There has to be a better way.

I am not advocating that production and large-scale sale of drugs should be decriminalized, only that drug users should not be decriminalized. Unfortunately it is part of teenage rebellion to be curious about banned substances, and to want to experience the effect of mind-altering drugs. They should be warned of the dangers, helped if and when they need help, and brought back to normality without becoming criminals for what is, in effect, a social problem or disease, not a criminal activity.

This is what Avaaz, the Human Rights Organization said:

Avaaz, 24th May 2011

Avaaz is a world human rights organization who use the power of publicity, via Internet, the Media and face-to-face to influence Governments to do the right thing. In a matter of hours they can get their members and friends to support a world-wide petition of one and a half million signatures. They are recognized by Governments as a power to be reckoned with.

"50 years of prohibition has completely failed to reduce drug use, and instead has fueled violent conflict, and devastated lives around the world. Politicians know this and know alternative approaches work, but won't change policy, afraid they will appear 'soft on drugs'.

"For 50 years current drug policies have failed everyone, everywhere but public debate is stuck in the mud of fear and misinformation. Everyone, even the UN Office on Drugs and Crime which is responsible for enforcing this approach agrees -- deploying militaries and police to burn drug farms, hunting down traffickers, and imprisoning dealers and addicts - is an expensive mistake. And with massive human cost -- from Afghanistan, to Mexico, to the USA the illegal drug trade is destroying countries around the world, while addiction, overdose deaths, and HIV/AIDS infections continue to rise.

"Meanwhile, countries with less-harsh enforcement -- like Switzerland, Portugal, the Netherlands, and Australia -- have not seen the explosion in drug use that proponents of the drug war have darkly predicted. Instead, they have seen significant reductions in drug-related crime, addiction and deaths, and are able to focus squarely on dismantling criminal empires.

"Powerful lobbies still stand in the way, including military, law enforcement, and prison departments whose budgets are at stake. And politicians fear that voters will throw them out of office if they support alternative approaches, as they will appear weak on law and order. But experts all agree that the most sensible policy is to regulate, and many former drugs Ministers and Heads of State have come out in favour of reform since leaving office. Polls show that citizens across the world know the current approach is a catastrophe and momentum is gathering towards new improved policies, particularly in regions that are ravaged by the drug trade.

We have a chance to enter the closing chapter of this brutal 'war' that has destroyed millions of lives. Global public opinion will determine if this catastrophic policy is stopped or if politicians shy away from reform. Let's rally urgently to push our hesitating leaders from doubt and fear, over the edge, and into reason".

Update June 5 2011

We did it! Last week Avaaz Executive Director Ricken Patel hand-delivered our over half a million signatures to the UN Secretary General Ban Ki Moon, world leaders and the global media in New York. At the meeting Ban Ki Moon heard our call to action and agreed to create a new UN task force to develop a comprehensive approach to drugs and organized crime. This is a major step forward towards ending the war on drugs as the approach will include a public health, education and prevention focus. We will continue to push to make sure this senseless and brutal war is ended.

RELATED NEWS: FODDER FOR ARGUING MORE

This is a Google Search for Articles on the Web

I hope the news items Google finds are relevant - their choice, not mine!
Regulate Drug Use, Don't Criminalize It
The benefits of taking the global drug business out of the hands of criminals almost certainly outweigh the risks. First, decriminalize possession of small amounts of any drug for personal use. That will have little impact on overall demand for illicit ...
Poll: Majority of California voters do not support legalizing marijuana
The survey found opinions have not measurably changed since voters defeated the legalization initiative Proposition 19 in 2010 by similar margins. And oddly, given the state's long role as the leader of marijuana decriminalization and cultivation, ...
The Garden State looks to follow Portugal's example
New Jersey legislators look likely to further the Garden State's withdrawl from the War on Drugs after proposing a law that would decriminalize the possession of marijuana. The bill was unanimously passed by committee, and could be voted on in the ...
Effort to relax marijuana penalties could reach KC
But now, because of states' legislation and voter referendums, roughly 30 percent of Americans live where penalties for pot use have been greatly relaxed, either through medical marijuana statutes or decriminalization for possession of small amounts.

It's Your Turn Now to Have Your Say

Do you think drugs should be decriminalized?

It's not only drug users themselves who think that use of mind-altering drugs should be decriminalized. There is an argument for saying that, like alcohol and cigarettes, they should be legalized and taxed.

Note the difference in terminology: If drugs are merely decriminalized, users would no longer be prosecuted but suppliers could still be punished. Whereas, if they are legalized, that means there are no penalties for anyone, users or suppliers. Big difference.

Drugs should be decriminalized

Loading

Yes, you're right! People should be able to make their own choice

0ctavias0fferings says:

When you think of the taxes which the Government is depriving itself (and the public purse) of, it's a no-brainer. By legalising and decriminalising marijuana the government gets to control the strength of the product and instead of money going to criminals the taxes gained can be used to improve public services, such as the NHS, and into the bargain, a whole lot of police time will be freed up to chase and convict REAL criminals.

awakeningwellness says:

Obviously the system we have now isn't working so I think it is time to try something different. It's ironic that a society that shoves legal drugs on people like it's candy, treats people that take illegal drugs like murderers. The government already has way too much control over what people do, laws protecting children from harming them self is one thing but adults should be able to make their own choices and their own mistakes.

linhah says:

Let's stop spending money on cops, courts, & prisons over ineffective laws.

Benmajer says:

I would say that there is a difference between drugs and drugs. Cocaine and Heroine for example shouldn't even exist as they do nothing good for people. While drugs such as Marijuana or hasch (Weed pretty much) shouldn't be illegal at all as first of all, weed doesn't contain anything that can get you addicted, secondly because the effects make you more focused, deep and less miserable in this dark world. Weed is a good medicine as well for both mental issues (Such as depression) and physcial injuries.

No way! People seem to be unable to look after themselves, so there should be State intervention

 

Read this - what an idiot!

South Africa's Intelligence Minister seems to have been a bit short of intelligence about his own wife's criminal activities here

It says much for the legal system in South Africa that a minister's wife was actually brought to justice within the law, so it's not all bad news, because at least it shows that everyone is equal under the law, with no special privileges for those in high positions.
SA minister's wife gets 12-year jail term - 6 May 2011 - BBC News
Sheryl Cwele, the wife of South Africa's intelligence minister, has been sentenced to 12 years in jail for drug trafficking.

"Either the minister knew about his wife's operation to distribute hard drugs and benefited from it, or he did not know about it, casting aspersions on his competency for the role of minister of state security"

American Drug War - the last white hope

Documentary video

A documentary film about why the efforts to stamp out drugs is failing - it will sadden you, and probably surprise quite a few of you

American Drug War: The Last White Hope

Amazon Price: $9.99 (as of 05/31/2012)Buy Now

About conflict of interest at government level, profit, competition and things you should know about. It might shock you, it will certainly sadden you.

About Me Diana Grant

The author of this web page about decriminalising drugs

I love a good argument or discussion and enjoy playing devil's advocate!

Diana's Blog at Glorious Confusion My Blog

I am a retired English solicitor. I no longer give professional advice, but I still help people to write letters, proof-read things they have written, and help to improve and pinpoint the essence of what they want to say.

I would be happy to help you if you contact me - You can go to my Bio

Loading

Here are some of my most recently updated web pages

quite a mixed bunch

I hope you find something you like
Loading

You can buy this t-shirt from my Zazzle Shop

I designed it myself - you can design things too, if you like - take a look:

T-Shirt: Too Much Fun is Bad For You shirt
T-Shirt: Too Much Fun is Bad For You by GloriousConfusion
Browse zazzle for a different t-shirt.zazzle

Have Your Say on My Guest Book

Can You Think of More Points about this debate?



Please say Hallo - it's always good to see who has visited.

  • UKGhostwriter May 9, 2011 @ 6:22 am | delete
    Great lens, fanastic topic for a big debate

Did You Enjoy This Lens?

Please will you spare a minute to rate it



I would very much appreciate it - Thank you

Visit SquiDirectory - A categorized Squidoo directory featuring selected pages by expert Squidoo authors, featuring a variety of interesting subjects. From art to shopping, music, people, sports, religion, how's and more. Take a Look!

retweet

This module only appears with actual data when viewed on a live lens. The favorite and lensroll options will appear on a live lens if the viewer is a member of Squidoo and logged in.

Add this to your lens »

Did You Like This Web Page?

About the Decriminalization of Drugs


Did you like this lens "Drugs should be Decriminalized"?

If so, please spare a minute to rate it -

Here's some things you can do -

- push one of the buttons below

- And pass it on to your friends

Your approval would greatly help me - thank you
      It's really good to get feedback



I'm a Squidoo lensmaster, and I'm inviting you to join me. Find and share recommendations online by building a lens. Click the link below to get started.
JOIN SQUIDOO HERE

Add this to your lens »

Bookmark and Share

by

Gloriousconfusion

Hello everybody.
Drug-taking does not form part of my life, but I still have my opinions.
I retired from my work in London as a family solicitor tw...
more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!

More of my Web Pages 

See if there's something of interest

Loading

Kindle Reading Device 

A Must-Have Gift - or Treat Yourself!

Kindle Keyboard 3G, Free 3G + Wi-Fi, 6" E Ink Display

Amazon Price: $189.00 (as of 05/31/2012)Buy Now


You can travel light with this must-have reading device - instead of packing 6 books when you go on holiday, you can pack this light-weight portable gadget and download up to 3,000 books. Brilliant!

Diana's Blog - Glorious Confusion 

My Personal Blog - comments about the news, my locality, things I am doing on the internet, and lots of photos

Loading