The Truth About Canine Ear Cropping

Ranked #2,150 in Pets & Animals, #56,163 overall

To crop or not to crop?

Many people wonder if ear cropping is safe or even necessary. Several people don't really know what is involved with this surgical procedure. With this lens, I hope to bring ear cropping to the attention of anyone interested in dog welfare, humane treatment of animals and to provide information that many may not be aware of. I also provide quick ways for you and others to help as get this barbaric procedure stopped for good.
I will explain and answer the most common questions to help you understand and make your decision as to "crop or not to crop."

picture courtesy: Dogster.com

The Surgery, Risks & Painful Recovery

Ear cropping (Otoplasty) is usually done between 10 to 12 weeks of age, but it also depends on the veterinarian. Many vets will no longer perform this surgery because not only is it purely cosmetic, but it is very painful to the pup. In fact, certain states are outlawing it altogether. In America and Europe, many top kennel clubs are no longer requiring cropped ears as part of the breed's standard requirements. I have been working in the veterinary field for many years. I've worked in the same clinic for over 11 years and when I first started there, the doctor performed ear cropping on full-breed puppies. Almost every time, the puppy awoke from the anesthesia screaming in pain even when given pain medication. Also, after administering antibiotics, infection can occur and as with any surgery using a general anesthetic, there is always a life risk; especially with a puppy. After this particular surgery, the pup is quite unsettled and uncomfortable due to itchy, sore ears. Inside the bandages, humidity builds up and it is hard to keep them from trying to scratch and remove the tape and bandages during the healing process. I finally convinced the doctor to quit doing the surgeries. It really didn't take much persuasion because I know he didn't like doing them anyway. He is an incredibly talented and caring veterinarian and didn't feel it was a surgery of worth and certainly not necessity.

Ear Cropping Facts You May Not Know

What's REALLY Involved in Ear Cropping

Throughout the years, I've often had clients ask for information about ear cropping. Though we no longer provide the service, I explain what is actually involved. Most clients change their minds and quickly decide against putting their puppy through that. There are many people that are not only shocked and appalled after learning that a large portion of the ears are literally sliced off. I often wondered what those clients thought ear cropping was before I explained it to them. I assumed it would be somewhat obvious but as the saying goes, "never assume." It does make me feel a bit better at least knowing they now have the facts and are more aware of what to expect because some clients whom don't have the facts beforehand later express regret. This is why I always offer the details to anyone who mentions possibly having their dogs' ears cropped; whether solicited or not. Further scrutiny behind ear cropping is it is an on-going process for up to at least two to three weeks due to having the client return multiple times (usually every two to three days) to change bandages. Frequently, clients don't keep those essential follow-up appointments which aids in the potential failure for the anticipated outcome, increases the chance of infection and the level of physical discomfort to the pup. Additionally, there is never a satisfaction guarantee for the final results. Luck actually plays a large part in getting the ears to "stand" perfectly. No matter how great the surgeon, some ears are going to end up looking awkward, which often leads to the tactless questioning from others such as, "who in the world cropped those ears?" Thus, painting an unfair and negative picture regarding the skills and validity of that surgeon.

AVMA Press Release Regarding Ear Cropping

(American Veterinary Medical Association)

The AVMA's position on ear cropping and tail docking, adopted on July 9, 1999, states: "Ear cropping and tail docking in dogs for cosmetic reasons are not medically indicated nor of benefit to the patient. These procedures cause pain and distress, and, as with all surgical procedures, are accompanied by inherent risks of anesthesia, blood loss, and infection. Therefore, veterinarians should counsel dog owners about these matters before agreeing to perform these surgeries."

AVMA Press Release Regarding Ear Cropping
Read the AVMA (American Veterinary Medical Association) press release about the policy on the Association's Web site.
black dog wag

Did You Know?

Ear cropping is a lengthy, painful healing process and results always vary!

Stop littering

People Can Be Stupid & Cruel to Animals

Despite the fact that this unnecessary surgery has become less and less common, there is a plus to some veterinarians continuing to perform them. Unfortunately, there are quite a few sick-minded people in this world that take it upon themselves to do this and other related types of "procedures" on their own. Owners and/or self proclaimed "breeders" execute these so-called surgeries without a license, training, anesthesia, pain medication, or sterile conditions. Very often, such procedures are performed with only a razor, tape, sometimes tampon applicators to roll the remaining ear into and maybe a bottle of rubbing alcohol. These are the same types of people that tightly tie off the tail of a dog with rubber bands to cut off the circulation and wait for the tail to eventually fall off on it's own. Given those distressing facts, it is good that licensed veterinarians remain available to cut down on the amount of those performing procedures on their own. The veterinarians that choose to provide this service are not to be looked down upon, even in my opinion of ear cropping. Most are caring, talented doctors providing proper care and pain management in a appropriate, sterile environment. Keep in mind that this is far from the sole purpose of their practice and they studied many years to take the oath to care and protect animals.


help stop animal cruelty

What You Can Do To Help Stop Ear Cropping!

Copy This!

Write your legislators to enact strict laws. Here's a sample letter. Feel free to copy & paste it. All it will take you is a piece of paper (or an email) and a stamp. Simply add your state name and your signature. Help make a difference in 5 minutes of your time!
Also, visit STOP THE CROPS website to learn much more about this issue.

Dear

In 2004 the State of California defeated a provision in for a ban on canine ear cropping in Senate Bill #1548.

The state of should introduce a bill with the followng provision in the original S.B. 1548:

"SEC II. Section 597.6 is added to the Penal Code, to read:
597.6 (a) Any person who crops the ears of any dog or procures the cropping of a dog's ears, except for treatment of disease or injury if the dog, is guilty of a misdemeanor.
(b) For purposes of this action the following definitions apply:
(1) 'Ear cropping' means surgical alteration of the pinna that is performed for the purpose of manipulating the ears of any dog for cosmetic reasons so that the ears heal pointed.
(2) 'Disease or injury' means a condition of the dog that impairs normal physiological functioning and does not include prevention of ear infections."

According to Bruce Fogle, DVM: "North America remains the only significant region in the world where ear and tail amputations are still routinely performed" (Guide to Living With A Dog, a Dorling Kindersley Book).

PLEASE consider creating a similar bill so that the USA may eventually ban ear cropping on all American dogs! No dog on planet Earth would sign a consent to have his ears cropped!

Sincerely yours,
YOUR NAME HERE

Ear Cropping is Your Decision. Just Know All The Facts!

If you are considering having your pups ears cropped, I suggest asking your veterinarian exactly how this procedure is performed, how much of the ear will be removed, what is entailed regarding the outcome, what are the general risks involved and what the necessary after care will be. Having those facts will grant you a more informed basis in making your final decision. Obviously, I am against this senseless surgery. It is cruel, painful, risky, and basically, I think it looks stupid. If Mother Nature wanted their ears that way, she would have created them as such. Besides, floppy ears are way cute!



photo courtesy: Melissapitmom

Help for K-9 Potty Training

Guaranteed Success in 7 days or less!



Why would anyone accept a dog that pees and/or poops all over the house for you to have to clean up when they do not have to? I don't know!
begging for walk
Just think about this for a minute... I am serious, look ahead one year from now when your dog is full grown you are still coming home everyday to get on your hands and knees with a spray bottle of cleaner. Forget having to explain the huge and nasty stains on your floor. Forget not being able to take your dog to your friends house for the night. Would it not have been easier to house train them in the first place?
Don't let it get that far. Do not be the person your friends talk about behind your back.

There is an immediate, downloadable, easy step by step guide to provide you with the best tool and information for having a Fully House trained Puppy or Adult Dog! It is also 100% GUARANTEED and the best part is that it's under 10 bucks! To Potty Train your dog in 7 days or less,
Click Here to fix the problem now!

Straight From Spitfire's Blog-Real Animal Stories

If You Really Love Your Dog, You Wouldn't Do That To Him

So many people proclaim their love for their dogs but then turn around and have their ears cropped. Why? They usually don't even know why. Many just assume it's supposed to be done because it was so much more common in the past with certain breeds such as Dobermans, Boxers, and Pitbulls. There aren't many vets that will even still perform this barbaric elective surgery. I'm happy about that.

When clients mention they want to have it done, I ask them if they understand what the procedure actually entails. They usually say, "well, no. Not exactly." So, I'm always willing to tell them. I say, "Well, first they put the puppy under a general anesthetic which is already a high risk due to a still developing immune system. Then, the doctor holds the ear straight up and slices it all the way down to the middle of the ear flap to the opening of the ear. Subsequently, once the bleeding is under control, we cauterizes it. Next, the ear is tightly wrapped up with bandaging tape so firmly that it actually forms a strong "cone" over the pups ears. The bandages need to be changed every 2 to 3 days for over a week. It is extremely painful, itchy, and uncomfortable." I also make sure to make mention about how when I first started at my hospital, we still offered that surgery. That lasted only about 6 months because I harassed Doc about how he could perform this horrid surgery. And, I mean, I was relentless. But, it worked and finally one day he said, "Okay! We won't do it anymore." Yay! See, I could take only so many times having to hear the screams of agony and pain from the puppies upon waking from the anesthetic.

So, the next time you hear someone say they want to have such a thing done to their dog, maybe you can tell them this little story and change their mind. Not only will you be saving this poor soul from such excruciating pain and suffering, but trust me, the dog doesn't give a shit if his ears stand straight up or if they are floppy. All they want is to love and be loved. They trust us to protect them from pain and unhappiness, so how could some inflict it and still say they love their dog?

Your Feedback, Questions & Comments

You can also find more great lenses here: SquidRank Lens Directory

Thank you for stopping by. Feel free to leave a comment below.
Please visit my other lenses, too!

  • Shawn May 11, 2012 @ 3:26 pm | delete
    Ok here we go. I have a big issue with the standpoint that ear cropping is cruel and mutilation! Really?? If this is the case then removing a dogs testicles is also mutilation. and the removal of any femal reproductive parts is also mutilation. And o is it possible that these surgerys are painful? And don't they require anesthesia aswell? Any surgery by definition unless to save the animals life is NOT NECESSARY!! So stop judging people for following a century's old breed practice. And to outlaw theses practices will only create the illegal procedure being done by unqualified individuals. So if this is mutilation then I demand my Foreskin Back!! And we must stop the practice of Circumcision altogether. Because people keep them and have no medical problems all the time! The only arguement for it is the laziness of a parent in cleaning practices! Man I hate to be right so often, but the truth hurts too !!!
  • Robyn Feb 7, 2012 @ 1:23 pm | delete
    So not one of you have tattoos or piercings? What about circumcison? plastic surgery-bigger boobs or smaller butt? I had my daughters ears pierced when she was 6 months old, is this going to be illegal too? If I want my dog to look a certain way then it should be my choice, If I'm going to a reputable and experienced vetenarian and I am taking all the steps to help her heal then who is it hurting?
  • Cleo May 10, 2012 @ 8:15 am | delete
    "So not one of you have tattoos or piercings? What about circumcison? plastic surgery-bigger boobs or smaller butt?"
    If you want to have a plastic surgery on your own body, It's fine. it's your body, it's your right, it's your choice. But does your dog ask you to get his/her ear cropped?
    "If I'm going to a reputable and experienced vetenarian and I am taking all the steps to help her heal then who is it hurting?"
    Your dog is. Try to cut your own ear, and see if it hurts or not.
  • Lisa May 11, 2012 @ 1:39 am | delete
    Wow. What a horrible person you are where all you care about are looks. Really?
  • RW Jan 18, 2012 @ 2:05 am | delete
    The controversy will be constant, but I just have to add my 2 cents in.

    In nature, mammals of all species have erect ears. Captivity and domestication has led to the flopping over of ears. You don't have to look very far to find scientific research on other domesticated animals, such as fox, wolves, etc. who, over the generations of captivity, have produced floppy ears. So no, floppy ears is not how nature intended.

    Cutting the tips of the ear off under anesthesia (the animal is asleep and cannot feel it) with 2-4 weeks of healing (scabbing over and eventually new skin coming in, not including the taller crops that require time to stand) is -way- less invasive than spaying and neutering, if you want to talk about "cruelty." People are funny. Actually putting the animal out to go inside of its body and take out organs is okay while snipping unneeded flesh from the ear is not? Yes, it prevents further dogs from being produced while there are millions already alive, but are we talking about "other dogs" or are we talking about animal cruelty? People go to a whole other subject to back up their lame excuses as to why spaying is not as cruel as ear cropping or even tail docking.

    It IS a personal decision. I am a fancier of a breed that, if you don't crop the dogs ears, you are either looked down on or respectfully ignored (and good luck showing your dog and making any kind of win). I personally enjoy the floppy ears for pets or for dogs that are not going to show and I probably would not spend upwards of $500 for a 30-minute surgery for a pet, but that's not to say others shouldn't.

    Overall, it's super annoying to get hounded by a bunch of strangers about MY dog. I wouldn't take my puppy downstairs and cut its ears off with my scissors. Now THAT is cruel. But taking every precaution to keep the puppy in comfort is NOT cruel. The idea may be cruel but the action isn't, if you do it right, under a qualified veterinarian.
  • Bob-0 Sep 25, 2011 @ 12:30 pm | delete
    Who is anyone to tell another person what to do with his property? You people make me sick...go picket an abortion clinic or something, Where is natures example of a mamal with floppy ears? There is none, ears need light and air to prevent bactiria,wax an other build up from accuring. And for those who will retort with.."their in pain though"...my response is..thier in no more pain then having their reproductive organs removed.."Write your legislators to enact strict laws."...Nazi's that's all you are !
  • ravenko Sep 21, 2011 @ 4:13 pm | delete
    I don't believe in cropping the ears, I have two Presa Canario's and never cropped their ears or the puppies that they had in the one and only litter, I believe it to be unnatural and just plain cruel...Angel blessed and featured on Doggy squid angel journey
  • TrainMyPitbull Aug 6, 2011 @ 3:42 pm | delete
    Interesting site and definitely drawing a lot of feedback. What is best for each pet--what is best for the breed. Who decides?
  • Jessica Aug 3, 2011 @ 9:45 pm | delete
    This site is a joke. There are benifits to ear cropping. The dogs are less likely to get ear infections. So to say there is absolutley NO benifit is, well wrong. Also with the docking of the tail.... its all about research. Talk to breeders, vets, owners who have gotten these procedures on thier dogs, Im positive you will hear a different story. Dogs dont asked to be spayed or neutered but it happens. And for what? so they dont reproduce? Then keep them away from other dogs.... again this site is a joke. Do your own research, Thats what I'm doing and I unfortunatley ran across this one sided site.
  • Queen Bitch Sep 3, 2011 @ 10:18 am | delete
    To spay and neuter is a law where I'm from!! The dog/cat doesn't ask for it, you're right. The sad fact is if ignorant people were not breeding & breeding & breeding or bein careless about properly confining the dog/cat while not being spayed/neutered there would not be such a huge amount of dogs/cats that are on the street, getting hit by cars, dying of starvation and being euthanized by the millions around the world in the pounds. There are so many dogs/cats in the pound already. Of people were not so ignorant/careless these procedures may not be in place. I haven't heard of any cases where dog ear/tailss are jumping off & multiplying by the millions! Don't be cruel to your pets which i consider part of my family for what...preference...looks? Who knows your dog/cat may like to alter your looks because they don't like your FACE!
  • PADANEBREEDER Jul 22, 2011 @ 1:38 pm | delete
    Very Skewed Thought process about cropping, I am Great Dane Breeder and I have my pups cropped before they go to their forever homes and I am always in the OR with my pups and I have never seen my vet hold the ears straight up and slice it. He uses a cropping clamp to give the correct ear shape and control the bleeding, no cauterizing is necessary anf cropping shears are used to trim the bell of the ear. a few sutures are put in place to refine the cartlidge so they stand properly my pups never wake up crying or whining just hungry and looking for food. Yes this is an elective procedure so is spaying and neutering, one poster mentions the pups have no choice, did your dog choose to have his testicles removed........... Please people think about this vets would not do a procedure if they felt it was harmful or dangerous to an animal. Animal Rights groups have cause more harm to animals than they have helped. PETA and a many others are a bunch of wackos. We had animal rights group at our local 4-H fair a few years back protesting Cow Chip Bingo because it was demeaning to the cow to have hundreds of people cheering it on to poop in their square........ Im not sure what is crazier people who join these groups or the people who donate money to them so they can participate in these bizarre tactics....... Learn more and educate yourself about the procedure when done properly risks and pain is minimal
  • thesevenfigures May 25, 2011 @ 5:01 pm | delete
    i was just reading about this and watched a youtube video that was against it. It had a comment below that "troubled" me though. The user said someting about a Doberman's tail being broken as if it is a reason to cut the tail.

    Why do they cut them to begin with?
    The video said a story about some king that had all his cocker spaniels with tails cut and if anyone hurt a non-tailed cocker he would be beheaded, so the next day the hwole village cut the tails off their cockers.

    But is there any basis of ear cropping and tail cutting to begin with or are they all myths and stories?
  • darciefrench May 3, 2011 @ 10:52 pm | delete
    Squid angel blessed and lensrolled to No Dock Yorkies - registered kennel clubs and their ear cropping and tail docking for looks are just as inhumane as any other group of psychopaths. Thanks for raising awareness about this ridiculous, unnnecessary and harmful act against animals.
  • ChrisDay Apr 8, 2011 @ 12:07 am | delete
    Animals do not make the choice - that's why it is cruel. The AVMA statement you have quoted says it all. These procedures are not in the interests of the dog and cause pain and distress. Why do the vets still do it? (Oh it's that money thing again.)
  • Jen Jan 19, 2011 @ 11:52 am | delete
    Ok, I see you don't agree with the procedure but taking a militant PETA (I hate that damn crooked organization) like mentality towards it is too much. "I don't like it so I'm not going to let you do it." I wouldn't crop a dog's ears but there's no judgment here to those who do. People get cosmetic work done all the time. Is that inhumane? Should those doctors stop doing their surgery? What about the poor people that wake up moaning in pain and the poor people that go under general anesthesia? Animals are tougher than these "humane" organizations give them credit for. The puppies eventually heal and after a few weeks it's like nothing ever happened. After a couple of hours they forget why they're in pain and once the pain is gone, they forget that they were ever in pain.
  • plasticsurgeoninsydney.com.au Dec 29, 2010 @ 3:16 am | delete
    this should be stop, dog ears are design the way it is for purpose and I think it's hearing capabilities will be affected from this procedures

    plasticsurgeoninsydney.com.au
  • Cyndi Oct 29, 2010 @ 2:23 pm | delete
    I have 4 dobermans. 3 have been cropped and 1 has natural ears. I have been there for all 3 of my cropped dobies surgeries and never once did they scream in pain after waking up from anesthesia. Also, as long as there is proper aftercare, risk of infection is minimal. This includes NOT TAPING AND POSTING until the ears are completely healed. I do see a difference in my cropped dobies and my natural eared dobie. The cropped dobies are more alert and aware of whats going on around them. They also look more intimidating so I dont have to worry about intruders. I also happen to love the cropped look of a doberman and would do it again. Why would someone say "it's your decision" and then sit there and try to not make it my decision by attempting to have it banned? What amazes me is that there are people who will advocate for banning this procedure yet they also advocate for the right to have an abortion.
  • Tori Dec 18, 2011 @ 7:46 pm | delete
    Completely agree.

    Funny how people say this is inhumane as the animal has no choice, but then they run around and say abortions are perfectly fine although the baby has no choice either. (not to mention it's a human)
  • BigGirlBlue Jan 17, 2010 @ 1:16 pm | delete
    When I was a kid I always thought dobermans naturally had pointed ears. Imagine my horror when I learned otherwise. I met my first doberman without cropped years about ten years ago. They are incredibly beautiful with their ears. :D
  • draik May 18, 2009 @ 7:54 am | delete
    Thanks for joining All About Animals Group. Your lens was added to our feature module and it will appear randomly.
  • Rinchen Chodron Mar 18, 2009 @ 5:20 pm | delete
    Very valuable information - way to go 5*s Welcome to the Activists Sound Off Group.

by

Spitfire70

Greetings and salutations! So, ya wanna know a bit about me, huh? Well, it was a dark and stormy night, nah, just kidding. I was appropriately nicknamed... more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!