Easy Chocolate Chip Cookies. (Secret Ingredient Revealed!)

Ranked #16,700 in Food & Cooking, #294,576 overall

Recipe and directions on making yourself a legendary chocolate chip cookie maker...

Hi, my name is Carrie. I have worked for years in a hospital lab. Our break room is a free-for-all. Any time there is any food brought in there, we descend like vultures! By now, we all have our little specialty items that we are known for, but one treat was legendary. Marti's chocolate chip cookies! She teased us all for many years about her secret ingredient. No one ever did figure it out! Finally, though, I think Marti got sick of being the go-to person for chocolate chip cookies. One day out of the blue, she came in with the recipe! Oh The Joy! And now YOU get to benefit. I must warn you, though. These cookies are not for amateur cookie eaters. These are solid, hearty cookies. Also, don't serve these unless you are prepared to be hounded for more. Seriously- it happened to me!

The Recipe...

Remember- proceed with caution. It's not easy being a legend!!!

Before you start baking, do you have an oven thermometer? I don't bake anything without one. No two ovens heat the same, but a thermometer will tell you exactly where you're at!

O.K. ready for the secret ingredient?
INSTANT PUDDING!!!!!!

Doesn't sound like much, but after you try them, you'll be a believer!

Here we go:
(I'm giving you the original recipe, but I usually make a half batch.)


THE RECIPE
4 1/2 cups flour
2 teaspoons baking soda
2 cups butter, soft
1/2 cup white granulated sugar
1 1/2 cup packed brown sugar
2 teaspoons vanilla
2 packages (4 serve each) instant vanilla pudding
4 eggs
2 packages (12 oz each) chocolate chips

Preheat oven to EXACTLY 375*

Mix flour and baking soda. In a large bowl, cream together butter, sugars, vanilla, and dry pudding. Mix with blender until smooth. Beat in eggs. gradually add flour/soda mixture. Add chocolate chips.

Bake for 12-15 minutes, depending on size of cookies. Do not overbake! Cookies will appear slightly raw in the middle. Remove hot cookies from cookie sheet with spatula immediately, cool on a layer of paper towels on counter.

Once you get the basic recipe down, feel free to experiment. Use different flavors of pudding. I've used lemon pudding with white chips. Chocolate pudding with mint chips. Add nuts or crushed candy canes, whatever sounds good to you!

Good luck!

Baker's choice Amazon Deals

Loading

Haven't done enough Baking yet?

If you're still HUNGRY after baking these cookies, maybe you'd like to try out my Spanish Bar Cake recipe! The girls in the lab say it tastes just like the cake they used to get at the local A&P store. Try it out for yourself!

Click here for Spanish Bar Cake Lens

Who wants to talk about chocolate chip cookies?

Eating raw cookie dough risks e. Coli
Resist the urge to sample that raw cookie dough, the Tufts University Health and Nutrition Letter advises. A report that looked at 35 cases of E. coli food poisoning in 2009 concludes that all but two of the victims had consumed uncooked chocolate-chip ...
Ultimate Plain-Old Chocolate Chip Cookies
Everybody has a favorite chocolate chip cookie recipe, but I dare say that this one isn't just our family's favorite. It's a true-blue winner over just about every other chocolate chip cookie recipe alive. The secret is a whippy brown sugar mixture ...
Our local home ec blogger cooks with love
On Wednesday, May 9, 2012, Suburban Life home ec/food blogger Melissa Jerves, of Darien, bakes chocolate chip cookies as her kids, Eamon (from left), 4; Alec, 9; and Eva Bargher, 6, take turns scooping dough onto a cookie sheet.
Celebrate National Chocolate Chip Cookie Day
The cookie was an instant hit and the recipe was printed in a local Boston newspaper. Because of the success of the recipe, Nestle began selling bags of chocolate chips in 1939 for bakers to use at home. Honor Ruth Wakefield's delicious mistake today ...

Please let me know how they were!

  • miaponzo Jul 18, 2011 @ 4:09 am | delete
    Wow! I would never have thought about that!!!! I'm going to try this delish sounding chocolate chip cookie recipe!
  • blanckj Jun 1, 2011 @ 8:47 am | delete
    Instant pudding cookies. Hmmm...never thought of that. Thanks for sharing.
  • Chinajoy Dec 18, 2010 @ 9:09 am | delete
    Pudding is great in cakes, but I never would have thought of trying it in cookies.
  • jgelien Nov 14, 2009 @ 4:49 pm | delete
    Pudding! I would never have thought to put that in. It sounds fabulous. Thank you for sharing the recipe. Can't wait to try it.
  • carrieokier Sep 1, 2009 @ 9:39 pm | delete
    add the dry mix in when you are blending your butter![in reply to littlebaker]
  • Load More

Carrie's must see links

Get your Free Diet Profile Analysis here!

Feeling guilty after eating all those cookies? Get your free diet profile analysis here, and find out what kind of diet help you need!

The Real Reason to Diet

This isn't about getting beautiful, it's about getting healthy! Check out the Cinch diet- a diet for the rest of us!

Cinch Diet Overview

If you think you're ready to learn more about the Cinch inch loss plan, or get started...

Home of the total wellness plan...

Tired of feeling tired? Pain in your joints? Doc can't help you? We have what your body is begging for! Whatever your ailment, why not see if we can help? Unsure what will help? Ask me about the total wellness plan to cover all the bases for complete nutritional support.

Get Clean, Get Green!

How toxic is your home? Don't know? Check out the labels on your household cleaning products! Rid yourself of all the harsh chemicals and carcinogens in your cleaners. Our cleaners are natural, eco-friendly, biodegradable.

Home Business in a box just $299

Been thinking about starting your own home business? We may be just what you're looking for. If you're tired of leaving your kids in daycare, worried about your long term financial future, maybe you just hate wearing shoes! Check out this 10 minute video and see what you think. Turnkey operation, all sorts of training and support- everything you need to get started. No boss, no daycare, no compromise!

Tees for the proud baker...

Loading

Toll House Tried and True recipes...

This book has some amazing recipes from Ruth Wakefield's original Toll House restaurant.

Toll House Tried and True Recipes

Amazon Price: $5.96 (as of 05/31/2012)Buy Now

by

carrieokier

Hi,
My name is Carrie- Squidoo is my new favorite online place to go!
I have 2 great kids- Jake is 20, and Shaelyn is 2 1/2! Jake said "hey, cool mom,...
more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!