Addressing Culture in Education

Ranked #7,518 in Culture & Society, #154,394 overall

Education Systems and Culture: The Ultimate Square Peg in a Round Hole?

Amy Chua and her Chinese tiger-mom approach to learning and mothering recently generated lots of heat in the western world, but not much light. Is she wrong? Not at all. What she does fits into one cultural style, but is deeply offensive to others.

If you don't understand culture and context, you are the nightmare of the education consulting business. Mathematics is the same everywhere. How you go about helping people learn mathematics is as wildly varied as the mosaic of world cultures. It seems we love the difference in culture as tourists, but pretend all culture is the same when we plan learning. Little folk in Sri Lanka reading stories of English children in 1930's Yorkshire Schools. Christmas with snow and flying sleighs in the Philippines. Snow loading on roofs as a calculation in Fiji. Hmmmmmmm. Interactive "child centered learning" in Pakistan or Shanghai. Without a strong sense of culture and what each culture expects of schools, we are simply marketing our answers to other peoples' problems and most often, they simply do NOT fit.

How Culture Affects Education

Read this book

This book applauds the traditional ways mothers do to push their children to success. The tiger mothers are far from the indulgent parents most of us have become. The description of the tiger mothers can be really hilarious at times and the way she compares the Chinese and Western ways are interesting. You will find how much culture shapes us and the ways we shape the next generation.

Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother

Amazon Price: $11.40 (as of 05/31/2012)Buy Now

I included this book because this gives us an idea of how culture really affects education and the more we face this and see what we can do, the better it is for our education system.

Developing education systems that fit into a country's culture

More research needs to be done

More research has been done on the relationship between education systems and culture. How do we go about developing systems that fit into each country's culture, values, traditions and social hierarchies as well as a country's particular moment of development? Timing is everything and one size does NOT fit all.

In the past, development banks and donors have funded a whole range of "innovative systems" that mimicked the "best practice" of the home countries of the consultants that were hired. But many of these new designs have not taken off or the take off was so cumbersome and protracted that it was clear the plane was not well designed or fit for purpose. ...or did an A 380 and blew an engine off in take-off. Why? Often, because at that particular point of the country's development, the donors' idea of the required system had no resonance at all with the real issues on the ground. The designs sounded good but when the project is rolled out on the ground, it is the ultimate square peg being pounded into a round hole!

Education Addressing Culture

Culture is complex and changing, too

We may have overlooked the role culture plays as an agent of change. We often look at what is logical but what is logical may not  work. Culture is so complex in its various manifestations in social roles, interactions, relationships, values and aspirations.

But all these are crucial in education. For education to effect change and development in a person or in a culture, it needs to address these components of a person's life or that of society. Most often, education no longer speaks to the ones being educated. And we all complain that kids no longer listen or that education systems are no longer effective.

Culture Educates

Cultural Practices are Effective

Cultural practices many times educate more effectively the young as they are integrated into a national identity, an appreciation of their own heritage.

Why address culture in education?

Education is situated in a context

Education happens in a context and culture is the social context in which individuals find their place in society , their opportunities for mobility and the water in which they must swim. It is based on reality, not on what a researcher or a consultant thinks "should be". Changing the cultural context can happen-changing Taliban attitudes to girls is possible-but not likely in any time frame expressed in less than decades. Changing acceptance of challenging authority or questioning adults is possible in Asia, but painstakingly slow (ask Singapore). Culture sets what can be a achieved and pulling the education system out of the home culture, out of fresh water into salt water, leaves it flapping on the shore like a beached Carp. Making heroes of sharks in a culture that values schools of herring is just a pointless waste of energy. And surely, the shark is NOT worth more, just more heroic to western cowboys!

The Culture of Education

Amazon Price: $12.49 (as of 05/31/2012)Buy Now
List Price: $23.00
Used Price: $2.03

This is what Jerome Bruner argues in his book. That learning is situated in a context, which for human beings involves the shared symbols of a community, its traditions and toolkit, passed on from generation to generation and constituting the larger culture.

To make education more relevant to the culture

Leadership is needed

Cultural Leadership: The Culture of Excellence in Education

Amazon Price: $18.86 (as of 05/31/2012)Buy Now

Education Leads to Appreciation of one's Culture

Participation is the best strategy

Replication and Duplication

Is this all what education can do?

Yet so many  education specialists only replicate the model they know very well, with no adjustment for a local culture.  Even worse, a new school often tries to duplicate the existing school system with iron clad pre-requisites and inflexible academic achievement levels that bear no relationship with the reality of what is to be learned. I still remember the nun who taught us current events from her notes margined in Spanish and yellowed by age. Saluting the flag of Spain or England each morning in the school yard, even though those tired banners were pulled down 50 years ago and even though those two old sinners have abandoned the systems the ex-colonies still ape!

In many schools now, teachers still teach as if the world has not changed at all, using the same methodologies they learned from their own schooling. And in many developing countries, schools are just duplications of either Scotland or Australia or US models. Just duplicates of the walls and restrictions and curtsies of the vintage academic models of history.

Addressing Culture in Education

Recent books

Attempts have been made to go beyond just duplication and replication. You can read some of these in these books.
Loading

What is Culture?

Why should education address culture?

Eventhough this book is for marketing, it emphasizes the significance of the culture code in how people respond and education is effective if it can engage people to respond and develop or grow or change. Marketers know that by addressing culture, they can attract people to their product or service. So, why don't schools do this, too?

Get on with your own education

Have one of these

Do your own research wherever you are and enahnce what you know. Always get connected to sources.
Loading

Mahatma Gandhi

A nation's culture resides in the hearts and in the soul of its people.

Has your own education experience addressed culture

Share with us

I have to say, there are things I am learning now that I wish I had learned earlier in school. Things that not only adults can learn. In fact, children can learn very well during their school age although in developing countries, we usually substitute memorizing for learning.

I still remember studying William Wordsworth's poem, "And then my heart with pleasure fills, And dances with the daffodils." Our teacher was really good but just never thought about what a daffodil meant to South-east Asian students! In our girls school we thought they might be poncy little boys in pink shorts making the usual rude smells! The teacher kept asking us how the author felt. We just invented the answer based on our images and assumed the daffodils were as messy and smelly as most little boys and old William was a bit of an odd lad but we were clueless as to the depth of his experience. I only got a sense of the Wordsworthian joy when I moved to North America and was over powered by the daffodils in Ottawa's magic spring gardens.

Try to understand anything about King Lear when still a 12 year old!

Still, some would say, "but you were not learning about daffodils but about great poetry". But I would have appreciated the greatness of the poem if it was part of my experience. This example is very simple. But other cases are disastrous. The parachuted systems were and in some cases still are meaningless and many students would rather not have school. This does not mean they don't like to learn. They are learning many things: how to play a video game, how to upload movies to Youtube, how to edit their pictures and how to apply a computer, how to fix their bicycle and moto and so much more.

What changes are happening in education

Learn to Change, Change to Learn
by PearsonFdtn | video info

107 ratings | 46,602 views
curated content from YouTube

Initiatives in Addressing Culture in Education

Check out these links

TVET and Culture
In rethinking TVET, there is the constant challenge that very little research has been done on the relationship between skills development and culture. How do we go about developing systems that fit into the country's culture, values, traditions and social interaction as well as its particular level of development?
Dewey's Challenge to Teachers
Given the serious social problems confronting Americans and others world-wide, the authors propose that Dewey's 1932 challenge to teachers is worthy of reconsideration by educators at all levels. In times similar to our own, Dewey challenged teachers to cultivate students' capacities to identify the
Digital publics and participatory education - Digital Culture & Education
2011 Digital Culture & Education. All rights reserved. Volume 1

Be a lifelong learner

Carry this with you

Loading

Sensitivity to Culture

Culture is changing and education has to change, too

Designers and advisors to designers of education systems, as well as teachers in systems where teachers have any influence must be very sensitive to the changing ocean in which the students are swimming. Technical educators would not be teaching the car engines of 1950. Yet, many academic classrooms are halls of history, of what used to be or of what never was except in Latin scholars tired old minds. Academic research on culture and social antropology should not be ignored as design inputs. To education specialists, do your homework on culture BEFORE you develop your grand design.

Culture and its Impact

Education has to take culture as key to development

Loading

Culture and Education

News stories

The Way We Eat: CULTURAL ANTHROPOLOGY AND DIETETIC COUNSELING WEBINAR
The webinar joins a series of free resources for registered dietitians and nutrition educators developed by Dairy Council of California, including a cultural food guide, A Celebration of Culture, and a Nutrition Education and Counseling Skills training ...
Overhaul of State Theaters Opens Turkish Cultural Rift
After the theater, it will be the opera and ballet, and then they will move on to impede education in the arts at the universities. Frankly, I am afraid.? The Culture Ministry, while declining to disclose details of the overhaul project it is drawing ...
Culture minister quizzed on rights museum issue
... whether Minister of Culture Lung Ying-tai would accurately represent dictator Chiang Kai-shek's role in the 228 Massacre at a proposed human rights museum during a meeting of the legislature's Education and Culture Committee in Taipei yesterday.
Time Is Due For A Disability Sports Centre In Ghana
By Theodore MK Viwotor (Multi Sports columnist) Section 39 of the Persons With Disability Act (2006) Act 715, 'Access to sporting events, festivals and cultural activities' states that, ? The Ministry responsible for Education and Sports, the District ...

Current education systems and digital culture

What do you think?

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Education systems and digital culture

Effective dialogue

Today, students are engaged actively in the digital world. Are education systems respponding to these developments more effectively?

Are education systems responding effectively to the developments in the digital world?

Loading

Yes, very effectively

sousababy says:

I believe to an extent they are, however some kids have a hard time communicating socially because they are used to texting or typing (rather than talking). We need some balance.

CruiseReady says:

Yes, and no. Sometimes I worry that they are trying to do so at the expense of a classic education. I ran into a high school graduate the other day who knew all about creating a website, but had never even HEARD of the Ides of March.

No, they just ignore these

 

Look at some of these classrooms

Integrating culture?

120525_8742_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8741_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8738_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8743_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8739_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8755_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8746_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8758_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8751_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8749_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8747_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8767_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8756_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8760_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8761_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8766_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8762_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8759_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8765_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8764_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8744_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8753_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8750_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
120525_8754_5D Kayla Big Show by Dick_Morgan
automatically generated by Flickr

Lenses worth visiting

On educating children

Loading

What others say on education and culture

Interesting opinions

Culture minister quizzed on rights museum issue
... whether Minister of Culture Lung Ying-tai would accurately represent dictator Chiang Kai-shek's role in the 228 Massacre at a proposed human rights museum during a meeting of the legislature's Education and Culture Committee in Taipei yesterday.
Time Is Due For A Disability Sports Centre In Ghana
This section, part of an act passed by the Parliament of Ghana in 2006, stipulates that the Ministry of Youth and Sports, as well as Education and Culture, put in place adequate facilities to ensure access to sports and cultural events by Persons With ...
The Way We Eat: CULTURAL ANTHROPOLOGY AND DIETETIC COUNSELING WEBINAR
The webinar joins a series of free resources for registered dietitians and nutrition educators developed by Dairy Council of California, including a cultural food guide, A Celebration of Culture, and a Nutrition Education and Counseling Skills training ...
Children in care inquiry is planned
Members of the the Scottish Parliament's Education and Culture Committee are to examine the issue. It follows on from an inquiry MSPs carried out into the educational achievements of children in care. Committee convener Stewart Maxwell said: "During ...

Jerome Bruner books

Culture and Education

Jerome Bruner has done substantial thinking on how culture impacts education.
Loading

An angel blessed this lens

And made it special

Here is the angel who blessed this lens

Thank you

More help in your learning

Invest in your education

Loading

Leave us your comments on culture and education

What do you think?

  • blackspanielgallery May 15, 2012 @ 1:47 pm | delete
    Nice lens
  • Interdev Nov 3, 2011 @ 12:52 am | delete
    Very thoughtful. Well done
  • sousababy Oct 8, 2011 @ 8:45 pm | delete
    Oh I had to come back to google + 1 this gem of a lens.
  • sousababy Oct 8, 2011 @ 8:44 pm | delete
    It will take a collaborative effort, I do feel that socializing face-to-face is still a very key skill to learn. In my area of Canada, I am extremely impressed with the sensitivity and respect shown towards other cultures. As long as the 'teachings' are not abusive and promote healthy and equal treatment of both girls and boys, I am all for it. Great lens, good to see it has a purple star, congrats! Sincerely, Rose
  • aesta1 Mar 29, 2012 @ 8:20 am | delete
    Thanks, Rose. Canada is one country that really tries to be more sensitive to culture.
  • Wbisbill Oct 3, 2011 @ 9:53 am | delete
    An interesting and useful lens.
  • cjaz99 Oct 2, 2011 @ 1:46 am | delete
    Culture does play a part in education. In Singapore, getting good results is very pressuring as the standards are set very high. I try to balance this out through using technology, games, videos as well as introduce school concepts and explain them in everyday life so that my son can see value in his leanings.
  • aesta1 Oct 2, 2011 @ 9:24 am | delete
    Social expectations often influence education. Good that you try to make your child find value in what he is learning.
  • poutine Sep 24, 2011 @ 12:12 pm | delete
    The education system is adjusting to this new world.
  • aesta1 Sep 25, 2011 @ 5:53 am | delete
    Many education systems try but often the resources are not there.
  • Load More

Love this Lens?

This module only appears with actual data when viewed on a live lens. The favorite and lensroll options will appear on a live lens if the viewer is a member of Squidoo and logged in.

Add this to your lens »

Share this Lens

Add this to your lens »

Bookmark and Share

by

aesta1

I have worked together with my husband as consultants in developing and improving educations systems in several countries. We have always worked in ed... more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!

More on education 

Impact of cultural norms

Loading

Other lenses to Explore 

More on education gap

Loading

Culture and Education 

Bridging Cultures

Bridging Cultures: Teacher Education Module

Amazon Price: $40.50 (as of 05/31/2012)Buy Now

To understand better how to bring culture into people's awareness, this book is a good help as it gives ideas on how we can build links through culture.