Skip to navigation | Skip to content

Share your knowledge. Make a difference.

Bruce Price's EDUCATION REVOLUTION

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic (by 3 people)   Your rating: 1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic

Ranked #2342 in How-To

1 person favorited this page

Rated G. (Control what you see)

Created by brucedeitrickprice (contact me)

Novelist, artist, poet and education activist. That last interest led to creating Improve-Education.org and now this site.

Both sites start from the sa...

  (more...)

Start your own Squidoo page

Your fans are waiting!

 

Thomas Jefferson famously said: "A little revolution now and again is a good thing." Nowhere do we need it more than in education.

----------------------- 

FOR PARENTS, STUDENTS, TEACHERS, AND COMMUNITY LEADERS--THIS SITE WILL HELP YOU FIGHT FOR BETTER SCHOOLS. THERE'S MANY SMALL SECTIONS. PLEASE STOP BY WHENEVER YOU HAVE A FEW MINUTES.

 

LATEST NEWS: Big new piece called "31: Teacher Liberation Front" put on Improve-Education.org. Idea is that teachers must distance themselves from elite educators, who are hopelessly bogged down in tired old theories. Article was inspired by very provocative quote from a new book called "The Great Reading Disaster" where the authors sum up the last 50 years in UK like this: "The real villains were not the victimized teachers who carried out the intellectual child abuse but the training establishments that brainwashed them into doing so." Victimized. Brainwashed. I suspect a lot of American teachers will see themselves in this quote. Please check out "Teacher Liberation Front."------------------

:MORE NEWS: For years I've been working on an article called Toward More Efficient Education. Sort of an engineering or ergonomic approach to the classroom. How do we teach the MOST info in the SHORTEST time with the LEAST effort??? Problem historically is that our educators got so lost in ideological concerns, they forgot what education has been throughout the centuries: giving knowledge to kids. Even now, if you Google ergonomic teaching, you'll find lots of stuff about chairs, lights and computer screens, but not the "intellectual engineering" I'm interested in. FOR REFLECTIONS ON HOW WE CAN MAKE CLASSROOMS MORE FUN AND EFFECTIVE, VISIT "26: HOW TO TEACH HISTORY, ETC." (on Improve-Education.org).
----------------
The Big Pretend
Saturday, October 13, 2007 4:07 PM

The biggest mystery of the 20th century is this: how did American education get lost in its own private wilderness??

Here's the short answer: John Dewey and his "progressive" pals decided that public schools should be primarily interested in a child's "social activities," with a corresponding decrease in emphasis on reading, writing, arithmetic, etc.--and all those finer things that Dewey dismissed as "mere learning." (This tragic shift started about 100 years ago, financed mainly by John D. Rockefeller's guilty millions, which is one of history's big ironies--the world's most successful capitalist paid for the undermining of capitalism.)

Next step: the Third International--with its waves of meddlers, subversives, and front groups--buffeted us with insults on top of injuries, all of THESE people being primarily concerned with doing whatever would weaken Russia's main enemy.

Note that the people behind all of this activity could never tell the truth about their goals. They had to say they were concerned only with better education. (As in, "Give us more money and we'll provide better education.")

The result from 1925 onward is one of the most startling edifices in the intellectual history of the world--a gigantic Rube Goldberg contraption that went through the motions of educating but somehow ended up producing uninformed citizens and 40,000,000 functional illiterates. So many wheels and gears turning. So little product. Hmmm. It's almost as if some of our top educators weren't all that interested in education.

I call this whole charade The Big Pretend.

----------------------

1) One of our smartest pundits, David Gelernter (a professor at Yale), last year proposed shutting down the public schools. He thinks the schools are so bad they can't be saved!

2) Here's a sad and shocking comment recently left on IllinoisLoop.org (link below): "Mom of a 7 year-old. Hi, I was living in France for the last 2 years where my child attended kindergarten and 1st grade. The French have a national curriculum in the schools where it gaurantees every child is getting the same education no matter if you are poor or rich. In 1st grade, the French national curriculum emphasizes addition, subtraction, geometry, memorizing a poem per week, a spelling-b with 10 new words every week, cursive writing every day, reading every day, once a week the following courses: science experiments, music, art, history, gym. Homework in math, poetry, reading, writing are sent home every evening. Now he is attending 2nd grade in Illinois and I can see the big difference. THere are no high expectations in any of the subjects being taught. He finds school easy. Schools here are not challenging our children. Where are the high expectations for all the children of Illinois?"

Now, you can claim she's lying or that French children are smarter than American children. Otherwise, I think you have to agree with me that this is a devastating indictment of our educational establishment. The French schools are evidently trying to smarten up their kids. Our schools settle for mediocrity from the get-go. Why do we put up with this?

3) For several years I've been researching the "reading wars"--Rudolph Flesch, phonics, look-say, whole word, Frank Smith, and all the rest going back to John Dewey. I kept hoping there might be a benign explanation for why our educators promoted look-say so aggressively, even though it appears to be without merit. My conclusion--presented in "A Tribute to Rudolph Flesch" (link below)--is that there is no benign explanation. Basically, it was all about social engineering and preparing students to be well-adjusted members of a collectivist state. The problem is, to get there you have to wage war against the potential of each individual student (you are, after all, deliberately dumbing them down) and against the prosperity and success of the whole country (when you create dumber citizens, you subvert the whole society, don't you?).

American educators will finally, I think, be judged very harshly for pushing such a destructive idea. Once you confront the intellectual bankruptcy of look-say (or whole word), you start to wonder if the people behind this thing would be capable of anything but bad ideas. 
LATE NEWS
HELP: I'm thinking a lot now about THE BIG SILENCE of the media and the academics, while all this is going on. If anyone knows of an academic (especially in the Ivy League) who supported Rudolph Flesch, I'd love to hear about it. If anyone knows of a big city newspaper that criticized Whole Word, I desperately want to hear about it. I asked my local paper (Norfolk, Va.) and the reporter piously says, "We can't take sides." Listen to me, buddy. That silence you hear is you taking sides!  

 ----------------------------------------------------------------

The first three links below are to articles on improve-Education.org. The rest will take you to some of the real heroes of American education:

Samuel Blumenfeld,

John Taylor Gatto,

Charlotte Iserbyt,

and Martin Kozloff.

(Please suggest items that should be here.)  

Ideas for Improving Education 

A Tribute to Rudolph Flesch
Has the subtitle: "A Short Sad History of American Education During the 20th Century." Tries to make clear what look-say is; why it is dangerous; and why it was used in the first place. (by Price)
Let's Get Serious About Education
A good SHORT introduction to why we have so many problems in the schools. Provides some historical background and some good quotes from early educators. (by Price)
Latin Lives On
333 Common Words Letter-For-Letter Identical in Latin and English. Interesting in itself and as well a compelling case for one of my favorite strategems: teachers should always use the most dramatic means available. (by Price)
Have Public Schools Become a Criminal Enterprise?
by Samuel Blumenfeld....Second only to Flesch in fighting for phonics, Blumenfeld is always an excellent source. Many articles on web, and many books (some available below).
The Underground History of American Education
by John Taylor Gatto....This is an important book; and the whole thing is on the site if you click around. Gatto was a very popular teacher in the New York City system. Find the book, read a chapter at random so you know what Gatto has to offer.
The Deliberate Dumbing Down of America
by Charlotte Iserbyt....Another important book. Also on site and downloadable. Quite scholarly and detailed. Download this book and read a chapter so you know what Iserbyt has to say.
A Whole Language Catalogue of the Grotesque
by Martin Kozloff....This rambunctious guy is actually a professor of education and a great warrior in the education battles. Lots of things on the net. Anything by him will enlighten and probably entertain you.
Illinois Loop -- Parents Fight Back
A big site with lots of pages. If I may presume to sum it up, IllinoisLoop is a site created by people who are mad as hell and not going to take it anymore. There needs to be a similar site in each state!
"STUPID IN AMERICA" -- John Stossel's Terrifying Report
MUST-SEE TV...View ABC Special as shown on YouTube. Report makes clear once again that American education is debased and pathetic. In case anyone doesn't know. So what are we going to do about it?
David Gelernter on Public Schools
Here's the gist of David Gelernter's column: "Today's public schools have forfeited their right to exist. Let's get rid of them. Let's do it carefully and humanely, but let's do it. Let's offer every child a choice of private schools instead." Click for whole column.

PHOOEY ON JOHN DEWEY 

the guy who started us downhill...

So long ago. More than 100 years. But John Dewey and friends, back then, were putting in place all the problems we still have! I just finished an essay for Improve-Education.org called Phooey on John Dewey (#25). Here's the first paragraph:
----------------------------------
"First off, let it be stated that John Dewey was a phenomenally brainy and productive guy. During a long life, he wrote more articles and books than you could read in a year. Indeed, he wrote so much on so many topics that he surely said some things that you would agree with, no matter what your opinions are. In some weird way, he made everyone a Deweyite. For example, in his book "The School and Society" he perfectly states my own philosophy on education: "What the best and wisest parent wants for his own child, that must the community want for all of its children." The problem is that the onslaught of Dewey's words has tended to work against that goal. His efforts, in their totality, have tended to create precisely the sort of education that the best and wisest parent wouldn't wish on a tuna."
-----------------
Point is: Dewey and Company downgraded academics to make room for social acitvities. One of those academic areas is reading and literacy. These guys even praised illiteracy! That's why they could drift into promoting a reading pedagogy (whole word) that doesn't work. I believe this pedagogy, which requires memorizing thousands of "sight word," is the reason we now have so many reading disabilities, such as dyslexia. I belive this is the great unreported scandal in American culture: educators make children sick, to put it bluntly.
I just put an article on AmericanChronicle that links John Dewey, dumbing down, and dyslexia. Remember, 100 years ago, this country had reached 98% literacy. Then our educators went to work and fixed that! Now we have 40,000,000 functional illiterates.

Reading Tutor Offers Passionate Critique of Whole Word 

Interested in the Reading Wars?? Read This!

I got a great letter from Kim Latta, who runs reading clinics in Nova Scotia:

"I can't agree with you more on how you categorize Whole Language as child abuse. I teach reading by intensive, systematic phonics only after establishing a strong base of phonemic awareness first. It is a crime to see so many children suffering (needlessly) from reading disabilities. I tell most of my parents that their child is not learning disabled, but curriculum disabled. They are being taught by the wrong methods and often these methods cause a life long reading disability.

To see the flipping of words like 'was' and 'saw' and 'felt' and 'left' is an example of whole word memorization gone wrong. Simple phonemic awareness or being taught the alphabetic principle would tell these kids that 'left' could not say 'felt'. Witnessing the reliance on pictures (which quickly disappear after 3rd grade), or guessing words in controlled text and not being corrected when substituting 'horse' for 'pony' in a passage, because it doesn't affect overall meaning, makes my blood boil. I don't consider saying 'horse' for 'pony' reading. No wonder we have an epidemic of children failing to read."
------------------------
UPDATE SEPT. 07: This note led to an intereview by email. The result is titled: Interview With A Reading Coach, The Truth About Dyslexia. Quite good! You can find it via Google. (For more on reading, see #21 on Improve-Education.org. Also, I made a little video for YouTube.com called "Phonics vs. Whole Word." It's a good way to see all the issues in about 5 minutes. )

If you find this video, you'll also find my other videos: HOW TO TEACH LATIN, ETC; WORLD'S EASIEST TEST; JOHN DEWEY AND THE BURDEN OF IDEOLOGY; and THE TRUTH ABOUT ROBOTS. Cute!

Hurray for Marva Collins 

She's done well by us.

If you have children in school, the very luckiest thing that could happen in your life would be to have Marva Collins as the principal of that school.

Collins is famous for running a school in Chicago which accepted all children who wanted to attend, and making most of them successful academically. She is a real educator. And it's a mystery how all the phonies we have in that field can face themselves once they are aware of her work.

I just spent some time on marvacollins.com. Here's a nice quote I want to share:

"Our children and parents surrender themselves to those who are identified as protectors, but who actually destroy them. Children come to school to get what they lack, and they are told, instead, all the things they cannot do."

I suppose we might disagree on a thousand tiny details but ever since I first heard about Marva Collins I thought: yeah, that's it, that's how you do it. What the hell is wrong with the people in Washington? Why don't they ask Marva how to run the schools? And then get out of her way.

A History of American Education--It's A Wild Ride 

We Had Our Own Quacks.

Writing "A Tribute to Rudolph Flesch" made me realize that our problems in education have complex roots. Consider this:
-----------------------------------------
"By 1930 hundreds of Communist fronts and agents of influence were in place; then came the Depression, which seemed to confirm their doctrines. At that point, all the pronouncements became more shrill and even smug. Indeed, many people suppose, looking back to 1930, that the Communists must have imported all our bad ideas. But what struck me as I looked back toward 1900 is that the ideas were already in place. The blueprint was agreed upon. There would be a war against religion, against individuality and family influence, against ordinary American values. And that war would be carried out by taking control of the colleges that train teachers, and then using indoctrinated teachers to push the ideas upon the public. All the Communists had to do was aid and abet our homegrown quackery, which they did with great energy. Thus, America got hit by a double whammy. We're still reeling."
---------------------------------
Trying to explain how our educators could possibly scorn Rudolph Flesch took me all the way back to 1880. The beginning of two new fields: Education and Psychology. Heck of a story. Right off, these pioneers got lost in the wilderness of their own bad ideas....If you want to see how it all fits together, visit #21 on Improve-Education.org.

Other Heroes of the Education Wars 

In time I'll probably find many other names to add here. But for now let me make sure you know about:

CHARLES SYKES....author of "Dumbing Down Our Kids" and other books.

RITA KRAMER....author of "Ed School Follies" and a biography of Maria Montessori.

DIANE RAVITCH...author of "A Century of Failed School Reforms" and several other books about education.

SEE AMAZON BOOKS BELOW.

Can We Improve Our Schools?? 

Professor David Gelernter says, shut the schools. My own hope is for a steady improvement--sort of John Dewey's program of socialist gradualism in reverse. Basically, progress will occur when enough parents demand it; or when enough educators begin to have a guilty conscience or awake to a new vision...How optimistic are you?

Loading poll. Please Wait...

"The Art of Teaching" by Gilbert Highet--is it used in a single ed school??? 

HURRAY FOR HIGHET!!!

A very nice lady in Texas told me (in no uncertain terms) that I must read "The Art of Teaching" by Gilbert Highet. So I did!

I have to report that this book, from the perspective of modern educators, is woefully quaint and curious.

Poor old Professor Highet actually had the audacity to insist that a teacher "must know what he teaches...It is not enough for a chemistry teacher to know just that amount which is taught in schools and required for the final examinations. He must really understand the subject of chemistry....One cannot understand the rudiments of an important subject without knowing its higher levels--at least, not well enough to teach it....A teacher must believe in the value and interest of his subject as a doctor believes in health."
-----
I want to see Professor Highet (who died in 1978) make a come-back. I want to see The Art of Teaching--both the book and the message--become the latest craze. I'm working on an essay about Highet's book. I'd love to know if any ed school uses it.

I've also been reading Rita Kramer's "Ed School Follies"--to see Highet's thought next to ed school "thought" is terrifying indeed. He's saying, "Teach! Teach! Teach!" They're saying, "No, anything but that."

Two Important Articles 

TAKE YOUR PICK. BOTH ARE GOOD READING.

The Quizz is #20 on Improve-Education.org. It's 100 QUESTIONS that every high school graduate should be able to answer. This piece is fun but makes a serious point--too many schools are located in FACT FREE ZONES. (The Quizz was spin-off from Jay Leno's Jaywalking. Recently, Improve-Education.org named Jay Leno "Educator of the Year for 2008.")
--------------------------------------
On Bullsh-t & Sophistry is #22 on Improve-Education.org. This piece jumps off from "On Bullshit," a somewhat notorious book published by a professor at Princeton. My take is that bullshit is not that big a deal and he should have written about sophistry, which is a deadly epidemic in our society.

Education Revolution on Amazon 

SUPPORT THESE BOOKS

Dumbing Down Our Kids: Why American Children Feel Good About Themselves But Can't Read, Write, or Add

Amazon Price: $11.53 (as of 05/22/2008)
List Price: $16.95
Used Price: $4.16

Usually ships in 24 hours

Ed School Follies: The Miseducation of America's Teachers

Amazon Price: $20.95 (as of 05/22/2008)
List Price: $20.95
Used Price: $5.95

Usually ships in 24 hours

Maria Montessori: A Biography (Radcliffe Biography Series)

The look-say educators seemed to attack everything sensible--one very striking example is Montessori's ideas. Circa 1915 she was becoming very influential. Dewey and friends attacked her. She almost disappeared from American education until the l960's.

Amazon Price: $16.08 (as of 05/22/2008)
List Price: $24.00
Used Price: $11.65

Usually ships in 24 hours

The Graves Of Academe (Common Reader Editions)

Richard Mitchell published "The Underground Grammarian" for many years. You can find the collected archives via Google.

Amazon Price: (as of 05/22/2008)
List Price: $15.95
Used Price: $12.49

Left Back: A Century of Failed School Reforms

Amazon Price: (as of 05/22/2008)
List Price: $30.00
Used Price: $2.06

Martin Kozloff for Secretary of Education 

I wonder if Professor Kozloff would consider a job in government...
When I try to think of ways to improve American education, most of the ideas don't seem likely to change matters very quickly. However, if we could get a really smart and independent person at the top federal post, ah, then we might see some feathers flying.
Martin Kozloff on Ed Schools
If you are not familiar with the remarkable Martin Kozloff, here is a good introduction.

He is himself, by the way, a professor of education.

CREATIVITY VS. ACADEMIC CONTENT 

WE MUST HAVE BOTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ken Robinson, England's creativity guru, is famous for promoting more creativity in schools. Problem is, he makes it an either/or situation. He talks as if we have to vanquish traditional academic activity:

"All over the world, formal education systematically suppresses creative thinking and flexibility. National strategies to raise standards in education are making matters worse...In the interests of raising traditional academic standards, schools are now encased in standardized testing regimes that shrivel the creativity of teachers and students alike."

Robinson basically proposes junking most of what we call schooling and instituting a creativity curriculum. I believe this is bunk. The problem now is that the children have empty heads. First, put a lot more in their heads. Second, perhaps a few times a week, do have a class where students are told, "Here there are NO rules. We think about each question as if nobody has EVER thought about it before."

Then you have the best of both worlds.

In Robinson's talk, there is a terrible blurring about what might be good for formally educated adults (let's say computer geeks at Microsoft who might actually profit from spending a week in the country sniffing flowers ) and young teenagers who don't know any math, history, science, etc.

The scary aspect here is that educrats will use Robinson's sermons on creativity to destroy what academic rigor we still have.

FOR MORE ON THIS TOPIC, PLEASE SEE "#23: THE CREATIVITY QUESTION" ON IMPROVE-EDUCATION.ORG
--------------------------------------------

LATE NEWS: A think tank called the National Center on Education and the Economy released a report in December, 06 calling for a restructuring of American education in order to make all students more creative. Hmmm, is this helpful or more bull? The director of this organization said: "One thing we know about creativity is that it typically occurs when people who have mastered two or more quite different fields use the framework of one to think afresh about the other." Sounds good to me. The key word is MASTERED. If our schools require that anybody master anything, we'll be making progress. Two or more fields?! That would be wonderful, indeed. And yes, my experience (big generalist that I am) is that the more you know about anything, the more likely you'll find a new slant somewhere else.

Education Revolution -- Book Shelf II 

SUPPORT THESE BOOKS

NEA: Trojan Horse in American Education

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 05/22/2008)
List Price: $19.95
Used Price: $4.93

The Whole Language/Obe Fraud: The Shocking Story of How America Is Being Dumbed Down by Its Own Education System

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 05/22/2008)
List Price: $19.95
Used Price: $6.99

The Victims of Dick and Jane

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $22.00 (as of 05/22/2008)
List Price: $22.00
Used Price: $11.00

Usually ships in 24 hours

Cheating Our Kids: How Politics and Greed Ruin Education

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $16.47 (as of 05/22/2008)
List Price: $24.95
Used Price: $0.40

Usually ships in 24 hours

PRESS RELEASE from Center for Education Reform 

The whole story in a few words

American Students Failing to Meet Global Standards

Washington, D.C.-- American students continue to lag behind students internationally, a trend that is threatening our nation's global standing. Despite spending more than $11,000 per student annually on education, the United States ranks towards the bottom in international testing and is forced to dedicate $16.6 billion each year to remedial education for high school graduates who still lack the skills needed to go on to college or join the work force.

"The American Education Diet: Can U.S. Students Survive on Junk Food?", released today as an action paper by the Center for Education Reform (CER), reveals the shocking state of American education and calls for the necessary reforms to put America back on the path to academic prominence.

It's really sad.... 

Sites for Cheaters

On my main site (Improve-Education.org), GoogleAds was always sticking in essay sites that let kids cheat their way through college. I do not approve! Finally, I realized I had to type in the names of all the sites I did NOT want. So many! The list below is simply copied from my Google control panel:
---------------------------------
007termpapers.com
a-termpapers.info
absolutepapers.com
academicblueprint.com
codemanagers.com
customessay.com
customessaywriting.com
customizedessay.com
customresearchpapers.us
customwriting.com
directessays.com
essay.ca
essayedge.com
essayfinder.com
essayspace.com
essayuniversity.com
essayuniversity.org
exampleessays.com
faster-results.com
qualitytermpapers.net
samedayresearch.com
schoolessays.com
vault.com
vault.com/college
----------------------------------
(Note: actual list is over 50 by Dec.) It's amazing when you realize that many of these things are large businesses with crowded websites. One funny aspect is that quite a few sites brag that their papers are not plagiarism. But isn't the kid handing in somebody else's work a plagiarist??!
Safe to say a lot of cheating is going on, and many college students must not be able to write their own papers.
Maybe it all starts with Mom and Dad doing the homework for their children. Seems to me that is cheating, and it sets a bad pattern. If I were a Principal, it would be considered cheating if ANYBODY but the student does the work.
---

Bruce Deitrick Price's Ed Blog 

My Blog on Edublogs.org
15 short pieces, all good reads, about ways to make our schools better

Art and Literary Sites 

My sites. Not directly tied to education.
ArtNorfolk.com--just redesigned
Site displays 3 styles--digital painting, extreme drawing, and Small Universes. Site is prettier than ever.
Price.myexpose.com--second art site
Site shows 55 digital paintings. And some extreme drawings on page 4.
Lit4u.com--my literary site
Site has a nice scattering of poems, essays, novel pitches, even movie pitches. There's a big chunk of "In the Shadow of the White House," a thriller set in 1996. I'm especially proud of an epic satiric poem on this site: Theoryland. (Poem satirizes academic pretenders so it is related to education.)
Universal Homepage for Internet Novices
I created this page for teachers, then realized its main usefulness is for people getting their first computer. Children and senior citizens, for example. This site is basically a long page with 50 great portals and a dozen features that update daily. A beginner could spend time here every day and in a few weeks be a pro.

MORE RESOURCES 

Education Alternatives
Just to prove how original my lens name is, I Googled "education revolution." Whoa! Turns out there's a huge site by that name, devoted to different ways of doing things educationally. Here's how they say it:

"For many years AERO has been helping people who want to start new educational alternatives from many different approaches, including democratic schools, homeschool resource centers, public and private alternatives, charter schools and more. Our ultimate goal is to encourage a system of educational approaches which is learner-centered and empowers students, teachers and parents."

About to try something new? You better check this site.
X

Hi, I'm brucedeitrickprice

brucedeitrickprice

Join my fan club

Novelist, artist, poet and education activist. That last interest led to creating Improve-Education.org and now this site.

Both sites start from the same premise: our schools should be better.

Improve-Education.org
is 31 essays on language, culture, and education. It's formal and
intellectual...This site will be more of a clearing house or bulletin board. This one will be about revolution.

--------------------

I'll list my art and lit sites at the end. They are my real bio.

Bruce Deitrick Price 



My main art site ArtNorfolk.com has been redesigned. Now shows 3 styles of art.

More pages by me...

See all my pages