HERE'S WHAT I THINK
What do YOU think? Agree? Disagree? Pick a side and sound off, all in the spirit of friendly discussion, of course.
NOTE: Some of the comments on this page may contain spoilers about Twilight, New Moon, Eclipse, and Breaking Dawn. You've been warned.
WHAT ABOUT YOU? SPEAK UP!
(no profanity, please) :-)
Okay, I know that Jacob Black is mostly human, warm-blooded, protective, and can offer Bella a human lifestyle. But what if he imprints on someone else in the future, and leaves Bella alone?
Edward Cullen, on the other hand, knows that Bella is his "brand of heroin." He will never leave her again. And Bella is so in love with him that she's willing to give up anything to be with him forever.
Should Bella choose Edward Cullen or Jacob Black?
Fetching blurbs now... please stand byI choose Edward!
Kelsey says:
Bella and Edward just clicked instantly and fell in love so romanticly!! the chemistry between the two just drawn me into the movie, so i believe they should stay together!
Posted November 25, 2009
mocha girl says:
I think Edward and Bella should be together because Edward was a pure gentleman and loves Bella..he never had loved someone as much as he loved her.
Posted November 25, 2009
LeeLeeCullen says:
Edward and Bella love each other no matter what and Jacob can't take it so hes a big baby. I would most deffo rather have ice thn fire cu ice is cool and leaves you frozen ;) Fire burns you, and I don't like hot things like when my feet have been under the covers too long...oh and, Dave, SCREW YOU! Twilight is the best saga of books/films since Harry Potter! All young girls wish that they could be in the fantasy story and they dream endlessly about what they would do if they were in Bella's place. Don't crush thier dreams by saying that its pointless. I know obsession can be a bad thing sometimes but please, let us have our fun and once were done you can go off into your mad world of ' Punch Face' (lol got it frm New Moon) but while your in fightso land we'll be the ones waiting paitently for you to return.
Think about that.
Posted November 25, 2009
LeeLeeCullen says:
She should choose Edward of course! Edward rocks and Jacob is a DOG! This is my impression of him- Awoooof! lol
Posted November 25, 2009
billie says:
i love them both but more to edward. jacob never really imprinted on bella, he only loved her. i choose edward because he really loved bella and would do anything for her. only flaw he had was being too overprotective, while jacob was always persistent on having bella when he knew she was taken. personally i find it repulsive how he imprinted on her daughter, after a (passionate i must say) kiss they shared. edwards her drug (unhealthy) jacob is her sun (healthy) but edward and bella really are soulmates and were meant to be.
Posted November 25, 2009
olivia says:
edward
Posted November 24, 2009
Rachel Lautner says:
Bella can have her freakin ugly Edward as long as I get Jacob.
..... (\_/)
(... {, "-;
.)).. /';.\
((_()'_\\,,
Posted November 24, 2009
Ashley says:
Jacob is pretty amazing, but he doesn't think of Bella in the same way as Edward. He doesn't want anything out of life unless it involves her, and she would die for him. They are meant to be together.
Posted November 23, 2009
vampireedward says:
Jacob is a dog; Edward is a vampire. Do I really need to explain more? Plus Edward is way hotter, cooler, and more mature. He's a man while Jacob is a boy. But Bella is an idiot (or slut I should say). She flirts with Jacob obviously and in the third movie she realizes she loves him too. What a slut!
Posted November 23, 2009
Kayla says:
I chose him cause he had to leave her but did'nt waant to. I mean he wanted to kill himself cause he thoght bella was dead so when he died he could be with bella again. I mean Jacob is so tottally hot!! but edward is the one for her.
:D
Posted November 23, 2009
Belle says:
Stay with edward leave Jacob for me!!!!!
Posted November 23, 2009
fany says:
edward all the wayyyyy
Posted November 22, 2009
fany says:
i chosse edward da day they met it was official haha totally edwarddddd team EDWARD yesssss !!!!!!!!!!
Posted November 22, 2009
robert says:
edward all the way
Posted November 22, 2009
Alex says:
You guys are right, Bella and Edward are in love, so they should be together!
Posted November 22, 2009
Amelia says:
Edward because she doesn't deserve Jacob. Send that sexy, native-american, werewolf to ME!
Posted November 21, 2009
Jordan(: says:
i say edward because he's more loveable and he's been there for her and even though he left here in new moon he was doing what he thought was best to not hurt her and even though it did she always ha jaob that she could rely on and edward knew there would be conseqeunces on leaving bella but h e got her back so haha its EDWARD.
Posted November 21, 2009
tinbffltan says:
Jacob is cute but edward is soo cute everything about him is cute its stupid to have these polls when edward and bella r together jacob is used to make a problem happen in the story duh
Posted November 21, 2009
....... says:
so edward i h8 jacob
Posted November 21, 2009
#1 twilighter says:
iT'S HARD TO CHOOSE THEY'RE BOTH TOTTALY AWESOME. I SAY EDWARD
Posted November 20, 2009
I choose Jacob!
Leanna says:
JACOB BLACK ALL THE WAY!! Jacob would be able 2 do all the simple things a human can do and all things he can do with the fact of him being a werewolf. Jacob wouldnt have 2 torture himself, because all he wants is her!BOOOOOO EDWARD!! Jacob warm comforting, kind, sweet, gentle, loving man.
Posted November 26, 2009
lina says:
i say Bella and Jacob are more made for each other.
Posted November 26, 2009
Jackie says:
Jacob. He is soo much better for Bella.
Posted November 26, 2009
ibn says:
jacob saved her life when his own partenr was about to kill her.
Posted November 26, 2009
rocker says:
jacob black
Posted November 26, 2009
Hannah says:
I think Bella should choose Jacob i mean really what is up with his Hair seriously and he needs to get a tan too!
Posted November 25, 2009
Jacob says:
i say bella swan should choose JACOB BLACK.
Posted November 25, 2009
KRYSTA says:
THEY BEEN FRIENDS SINCE THEY WERE KIDS
Posted November 24, 2009
NEJack says:
go back to what her dad told her... "sometimes you need to learn to love whats good for you" she needs to get over her little high school crush and move on... edward is a jack***
Posted November 24, 2009
Rachel Lautner says:
Jake can kick edward's gay, sparkly butt any day !
Posted November 24, 2009
aimee says:
bella should so be with Jacob .I meen face it....their the perfect couple end Bella doesnt have to turn into a vampire after giving birth to her and Jacobs child so that she wont die!!!!!
Posted November 24, 2009
Sonia says:
Jacob. Clearly. He encourages her to have her own life, she is okay with hanging out with other people when she's with him. Edward is too possessive. He IS her life... she has nothing else going on when she's with him. Ever heard of healthy balances between love and life Bella? Apparently not.
Posted November 23, 2009
iLoveAbby<33 says:
I vote for Jacob because he is hott-blooded-human than edwards who wants to turn her into a vampire fuckin need to drink blood and try to control tht . Pluz Jacob was there for Bella and edward left.
Posted November 23, 2009
EMILY says:
JACOB BLACK! HE IS SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO HOT HOT HOT HOT HOT HOT HOT HOT GO WAREWOLFS DONT CHOOSE EDWART HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Posted November 23, 2009
ilovejacob=] says:
jacob really loves her and she can still be human who wants to be a bloodsucker and you go for edward than thats you but i goo for jacob and he wuld never leave her like you people sayy
Posted November 23, 2009
Becca says:
jacob is a more trustworhty friend and edward left her and he hurt bella jacob said that he would neve do tha to her.Bella has known him longer and they are about the same age not one 18 and one17 years old plus hes cute!
Posted November 23, 2009
shaniyah says:
i think Jacob because he's cute, nice, And have knew Bella ever since they we're little and made mud pies toqether lol. And Edward left Bella before on a promise there's no tellinq if he would aqian. Because before he made a promise and broke it so i wouldn't trust him .And he was all the way in paris,France while Jacob protected Bella than came back to forks and expect's thinqs to be all qoody qood. I think BElla's dumb i would have just sent his sister to tell him that i was alive of called him DUH. That's why i chose Sexy jacob Black.
Posted November 21, 2009
natalie says:
Jacob
Posted November 21, 2009
:TEAM JACOB: says:
1:i think she should of gone with jacob because when edward left her and he left her in the woods alone.When Jacob is around her he protects and loves her more.e2:why did she go with edward to jacob to edward like its to her 'i dont care i got both of them if ones leaved her i got him". Like comeon.3:jacob saved out of the water from her drowning.4:and poor jacob he loves her so much and she chooses the vampire. so GO TAM JACOB,
Posted November 21, 2009
kaitlin says:
Jacob because jacob is SUPER hot and he like is in love with Bella and would do like anything for her,and he was there for her when Edward wasn't
Posted November 20, 2009
Shop Twilight Stuff on Amazon
CAN'T DECIDE? READ WHAT OTHER PEOPLE ARE SAYING...
- Twilight's Bella Is "The Sexual Aggressor" - Books - io9
- Over at Strange Horizons, author Karen Healey has an amazing essay about body transformations in young adult fiction. She looks at adolescent physical changes in several novels, including the Twilight series. Vamp-loving hero Bella, ...
- Twilight Lexicon » Bella's Bracelet and Ring On Sale
- Infinite Jewelry, the company that manufactured the Bella's Engagement ring and Bella's Bracelet that used to be carried by Twilight Teez, now has that merchandise up on their own, newly launched website. According to their site, ...
- ohnotheydidnt: Twilight's Bella Is "The Sexual Aggressor"
- Twilight's Bella Is "The Sexual Aggressor" Image and video hosting by TinyPic. Over at Strange Horizons, author Karen Healey has an amazing essay about body transformations in young adult fiction. She looks at adolescent physical ...
- Candy on the Cape: Is Bella Swan of "Twilight" a Good Role Model ...
- Is Bella Swan of "Twilight" a Good Role Model? I'm Not So Sure. I read all four of the "Twilight" books last winter and while they weren't great literature, I had a good time reading them. I did however always have my concerns about the ...
THIRSTY FOR MORE TWILIGHT?
Visit Club Twilight to meet more Twilight fans!- Twilight, the movie: vampires, werewolves, romance, and magic
- Fans of Stephenie Meyer's Twilight books are breathlessly awaiting the premiere of Twilight, the movie! Can't wait until December 12, 2008? Get your fix of Twilight tidbits right here, including photos, desktop wallpaper, videos, and news on Edward Cullen and Bella Swan.If you like what you find her
- Robert Pattinson
- Described by Twilight author Stephenie Meyer as one of the few people who can look both dangerous and beautiful, Robert Pattinson captured hearts of Harry Potter fans as the young wizard, Cedric Diggory. Now, Pattinson takes on the role of Edward Cullen, a romantic vampire. Learn more about Pattinso
- Twilight online magazine
- Articles, photos, videos, and more Twilight stuff. Created by fans - you can contribute!
- Twilighters.Org | For the Obsessed Twilight Saga Fan - Breaking Dawn - Forums - Gallery - New Moon - Eclipse -Stephenie Meyer - Updates, News & more!
- For obsessed Twilight fans.
- TWILIGHT - The Official Movie Site - IN THEATERS 12.12.08
- TWILIGHT is an action-packed, modern day love story between a vampire and a human starring Kristen Stewart as Bella Swan and Robert Pattinson as Edward Cullen.
- Twilight Guy | A Guy Reads Twilight by Stephenie Meyer
- The Twilight Series by Stephenie Meyer - read and blogged from a Guy's perspective
- StephenieMeyer.com | Twilight Series | Midnight Sun
- The Official Website of Stephenie Meyer. Midnight Sun: Edward's Version of Twilight
- Bella Twilight Shop — Jewelry and Gifts for Twilighters
Bella Twilight Shop: Jewelry and Gifts for Twilighters
Welcome! My original Bella Bracelet® is bright sterling silver, embellished with your choice of a hand-carved stone wolf and a big, dazzling Swarovski® heart.
ARE YOU ON TEAM EDWARD?
Add your favorite Edward and Bella links here!
Bella and Edward seem perfect together. Neither one of them can stand it when the other is gone. If you have a favorite Bella & Edward photo, site, or link, add it here!
everglow | www.edwardandbella.net - Edward Cullen and Bella Swan fansite :: TWILIGHT NEW MOON ECLIPSE BREAKING DAWN
Everglow @ www.edwardandbella.net: Your first and more...1 point
50 Ways to Annoy Jacob Black
The ultimate Twilight fan lens!1 point
http://www.stepheniemeyer.com/pdf/midnightsun_chapter1.pdf
Read a rough draft of Stephenie Meyer's "Midn more...0 points
Twilight Barbies
Twilight Barbies - Bring Twilight Barbie Dolls Bel more...0 points
OR TEAM JACOB?
Add your favorite Jacob and Bella links here!
So you like the hot-blooded passion between Jacob and Bella? Share your favorite photos and links featuring Jacob and Bella here.
Like Juliet & Paris {Bella & Jacob Fanlisting}
Welcome to the approved fanlisting for the relatio more...2 points
Edward Cullen is an abusive, controlling boyfriend!
While reading Twilight, New Moon and now Eclipse, more...0 points
http://www.twilightbarbies.info/bella-twilight-bella
Bella Swan Barbie %u2013 the Bella Barbie vampire more...0 points
Before you go, any last words?
No profanity, please. :-)
-
Reply
- twilight twilight Oct 26, 2009 @ 9:00 am
- haha.. you should pick edward!!! haha.. even if edward leaves bella... it doesnt mean that edward doesnt love bella!! he just leave because he wants bella to be safe.. but he realized that he cannot leave without bella.... just read the book.. dont judge edward that fast... i dont like jacob.. jacob also leaves bella, when he became a werewolf..... umh.. both of them leave bella.. its a draw!! they both abandoned bella!!!!!!! go go go.. to all who doesnt want twilight,,you all sucks!! twilight is much beatiful than other vampire stories.. dont be jealous.. hahaha.,,
-
Reply
- twilight "0b$€$$€d" twilight "0b$€$$€d" Oct 26, 2009 @ 8:58 am
- haha.. you should pick edward!!! haha.. even if edward leaves bella... it doesnt mean that edward doesnt love bella!! he just leave because he wants bella to be safe.. but he realized that he cannot leave without bella.... just read the book.. dont judge edward that fast... i dont like jacob.. jacob also leaves bella, when he became a werewolf..... umh.. both of them leave bella.. its a draw!! they both abandoned bella!!!!!!! go go go.. to all who doesnt want twilight,,you all sucks!! twilight is much beatiful than other vampire stories.. dont be jealous.. hahaha.,,
-
Reply
- JacobRocks85 JacobRocks85 Sep 27, 2009 @ 6:23 pm
- JACOB JACOB JACOB JACOB!!!!! Edward Cullen is a pathetis excuse of a man lol!
-
Reply
- Jess Jess Aug 30, 2009 @ 2:47 am
- JACOB....the kiss in eclipse makes me shiver and its so sad that she starts crying cause she sees the life that she would have with him. What and idiot Jacob is the one!!
-
Reply
- twilighter twilighter Aug 26, 2009 @ 4:54 pm | in reply to EDWARD NEEDS TO DIE!!!!
- you hav some serious problems lik really? you re just a hater i dont understand y u read the books if you hate everyone in it. Plus Edward just wants whats best for her he is nt controlling in the end he lets them hang out. Now i love Jacob too ok i agree with you but seriously. Hav you seen the trailer he looks freaky with those huge arms and long hair. Plus jacob is so selfish hes hurting her and making her feel guilty all the time purposely lik seriously whats his problem. He seriously need to get alife. In the beging i felt bad for him but he needs to grow up realize what he cant hav and stop tryin to make others miserable. Kristen Stewart is a little bad but so wat. I would hav liked another person to play her but she plays bella just fine. Theres no difference? exactly thats what makes a role so believable. Yea when she dropped her award that was funny if u're just gonna be ruining everyone else's fun stop goin on these websites & talkin bad
- Load More
by hmsweaver
Explore related pages
Bella Swan - Twilight Heroine- Bella Swan is the heroine of the Twilight series by Stephenie Meyer. "About thre...
Edward Cullen - Twilight Hero, Bella Swan's Obsession- Edward Cullen is the hero in Stephenie Meyer's Twilight Saga "Before you, Bella...
T-shirt Designs: From Twilight to Gilmore Girls and more!- Looking for great t-shirt designs? Find great designs here, at The Funk House, f...
Robert Pattinson- Described by Twilight author Stephenie Meyer as one of the few people who can lo...
Twilight, the movie: vampires, werewolves, romance, and magic- Fans of Stephenie Meyer's Twilight books made a blockbuster of Twilight, the mov...
Bella Swan's Bracelet from The Twilight Saga- There are many other versions of Bella's Bracelet available, but I like this one...
