Edward Cullen vs Jacob Black: Whom Should Bella Choose?

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic by 10 people | Log in to rate

Ranked #60 in Arts , #1,395 overall

HERE'S WHAT I THINK

Bella Swan should choose Edward Cullen! Being with Edward Cullen forever is what Bella Swan has wanted since she first fell in love with him. They are soul mates.

What do YOU think? Agree? Disagree? Pick a side and sound off, all in the spirit of friendly discussion, of course.

NOTE: Some of the comments on this page may contain spoilers about Twilight, New Moon, Eclipse, and Breaking Dawn. You've been warned.

WHAT ABOUT YOU? SPEAK UP! 

(no profanity, please) :-)

Okay, I know that Jacob Black is mostly human, warm-blooded, protective, and can offer Bella a human lifestyle. But what if he imprints on someone else in the future, and leaves Bella alone?

Edward Cullen, on the other hand, knows that Bella is his "brand of heroin." He will never leave her again. And Bella is so in love with him that she's willing to give up anything to be with him forever.

Should Bella choose Edward Cullen or Jacob Black?

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

I choose Edward!

cute says:

edward all the way

kirra says:

i would choose edward and jacob as they are both unquie in there own way.

IluvJacobB says:

Jacob's mine! Take Edward, you love him, don't you?

lidz1524 says:

10. Because he’ll hold your drink for you when you need to use your hands, and he’ll keep it cold, too. Not to mention he can be your personal ice-pack when you have a Bella moment.

9. He’s a vampire and they’ve been around for centuries whereas werewolves are just new inventions. (Quote courtesy of Rob Pattinson)

8. He won’t fall asleep and drool all over you.

7. Who needs a disco ball when you have Edward? Just take him outside and dance it up ’cause he sparkles!

6. He’s a gentleman and will offer you choices.

5. He won’t stink like a wet dog if you wash him.

4. Jacob may run a 108° temperature but Edward’s still hotter.

3. He’ll whisper sweet nothings in your ear in many different languages as well as quote Romeo & Juliet verbatim.

2. Because, in the end, he got the girl!

1. He is portrayed by Robert Pattinson….need we say more?

lidz1524 says:

Edward is kind, cool (lolz!) and AMAZING!!

phoebe says:

I L.O.V.E JACOB BUT ITS PRETTY CLEAR WHO BELLA WANTS N THATS EDWARD BUT IM STILL TEAM JACOB LOL HE STILLS WIN PART OF HER RENESMEE.....

ella says:

edward he would risk his live for her they should be forever

t.o.p bigbang says:

she love edward ♥♥♥

sassy23 says:

I think that Bella and Edward belong together. Watching them on screen is crazy the chemistry between them is intense.

team edward says:

bella should pick edward because even if he did leave her in new moon he was going to kill himself for her. and jacob also left her for a bit to. and she looks better together with edward:). and when jacob called bella a hipercrite...edward would NEVER say that to her because he truly loves her and if jacob loved her that much he would never say that to her.

cindy says:

Edward duh!!!!

Nancy x says:

WEll i think she should choose Edward cullen this is because ever since she first saw him she loved him so there no point in making jacob Black love her cause she don't love him.

flower says:

I CHOOSE EDWARD CULLEN.he is hot,he is a vampire witch are way better than werewolve(.stupid dogs!!! )vampires smell way better.and they really love each other.

brooke says:

defenetly edward i mean dont get me wrong jackobs pretty hot ........but edward,,,,,,damn,,,,,,,,realy sexy,,,,,,,got to get me one of him!!!!!!!!!!!!!

brandi says:

edward all the way i mean just look at him........ yummy.......all you people who hate (rob) edward are all crazy no matter what you say!!!!!!!!

Adrianna says:

Edward, cause i read all the books and Jacob imprints on Bella and Edwards daughter, Reneesme.SPIOLER!! Sorry.

nicole says:

bella should chose edward he is better looking and if she didnt it would spoil the books and movies

elizabeth says:

What I think is that Bella should stay with Edward Cullen!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

chick says:

EDWARD AND BELLA JUST MAKE A PERFECT COUPLE!!!!!!!!!! AND EDWARD IS TO DIE FOR!!!! HE CAN BITE ME ANYTIME!!!!!!!!!JACOB-BICEPS = YUKK!!!! THIMK ABOUT IT!!!!!

Bricet says:

Edward AND Bella are soul mates IT'S TOTALLY TRUE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

I choose Jacob!

kirra says:

i would choose edward and jacob as they are both unquie in there own way.

Alicia. says:

JACOB!!
For one, Edward wears foundation like there is noo
freaking tomorrow and I mean Taylor Lautner sacrificed and
excecised and worked so much to be in new moon. He still does
not get that much attention. I mean did anyone of you see the Tyra Banks
episode where a couple of their fans met them. The fans were all into Edward
even going as far as to reject the hug Taylor offered to one of them! He'll, even Tyra payed more attention to Robert
Jacob is the better man. Bella should be with Jacob.

Sarah says:

If it were me, I'd so pick Jacob. One, he's way cuter. Two, he's warm-blooded, not dangerous for her health, and Bella doesn't have to turn into a vampire. But Edward's good, too, because they both obviously love each other A LOT, Edward wouldn't try to kill himself (and/or get the Volturi to kill him), Bella wouldn't worry about Edward all the time, and there's no chance that he'll imprint someone else. But who knows whether or not Jake's actually lying and imprinted Bella? Either way, my vote goes to Jacob by THIS MUCH. *holding two fingers really close together*

Tom says:

Jacob + Bella = Love/Edward + Bella = Fantasy

haley says:

id chose jacob becouse hes very strong and brave

Jane says:

I think bella should always choose Jacob. duh! Jacob has a sense of humour.and can protect bella more.

Amy says:

werewolves dont have to imprint so Bella should choose Jacob

basv says:

η μπελλα πρεπει να επιλεξει τον jacob!!!!ειναι τρελοσ για αυτην και την αγαπάει πραγματικα. δεν θα την πληγωνε ποτε. ενω ο εντουαρτ την βαζει σε κινδυνο. εξαλλου πρεπει να λαβουμε υποψη οτι ο εντουαρτ ειναι νεκροσ ενω ο τζεικομπ οχι>>>>τζεικοπμ for ever!!!!!!!!

Wish Jacob's Girlfriend lol says:

If i was bella i would stay with HOT Jacob. But at the same time bella attitude and personality goes with Edward. JACOB deserves a girl with better and with a more fun personality. They should make like a two end versions of this story of how it would be if she stays with Jacob and obviously we're going to see the end with Edward.

KITTYKAT123 says:

I think Bella Swan should pick Jacob Black because he loves her and will never hurt her. She is stupid to pick Edward Cullen because 1. he lied to her 2. he left her 3. told her she wasn't good enough for him.And plus Jacob's body puts Edward's body to shame!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Taylor Lautner's girl frind says:

she should go with jacob cuz after all he does keep her comfortable in breaking dawn but jacob did betray her and put his tattoo mark on reneesme (her daughter with edward) but still they look great together

Mzconceitednez 23 says:

jacob because it would be an easier life if she chooses jacob and wont gget hurt like she did in twlight and new moon and plus it's all about team jacob

courtney says:

I believe she should end up with Jacob. Jacob has always been there for her and they are child hood friends. Jacob is cute too :) haha but still,Jacob would never leave her and honestly loves her,and in eclipse bella realizes she loves him too,so I think she should have ended up with Jacob.

zeeWULF says:

jacob has lika a bazillion abs lol, and that other guy edward put make up on, so bella should go out with me because i only 6 abs and i dont put make up on :D

clayton says:

i think she should date edward so she can get turned into a vampire then leave him and date jacob because if they have a baby (witch i hope they do) there baby will be half wolf and half vampire that would be wicked amagan what it could do

Emma Lautner says:

i think bella is better off with jacob cause edward just leaves her in forks with victoria on the loose if it wasn't for jacob bella would probably be dead right now i'm not saying edward is a bad guy he is really nice it's just what he did was really stupid and not the right choice at that time so go team JACOB!!

jacob lover haha says:

she should be with jacob he is so hot and romantic nice and funny i wish i could date him but he like salenna gomez P.S i have met him before we like talked then left but even though i acted like i did not like him i was screaming inside omg omg!!! he is so hot!!! SHE SHOULD BE LUCKY SHE EVEN KNOWS HIM HAHA!!!!!

hally says:

if she wants a REAL soulmate that can she can ALWAYS be with and someone who won't kill her, then WAKE UP BELLA and pick team JOCOB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

taylin says:

bella choose jacob because tink about who saved u wen that blod suckr did to u whn he left u al alon and who did u call ur best friend and u know i kind of pick both so just pick wo u truly love

Faye says:

Well I would love to see her with Jacob, they look so right together, but I've gotta feeling the bad guy will win this one.

 
view all 1,031 comments

Shop Twilight Stuff on Amazon 

You can't bring Edward or Jacob home for real, but you can get some stuff to remind you of them...
There was an error connecting to the Amazon web service. Please try again. Sorry, there are no results available from Amazon.

CAN'T DECIDE? READ WHAT OTHER PEOPLE ARE SAYING... 

Here are some of the latest blog posts on Twilight, Bella, and the boys. Do some research and then come back once you've decided which side you're on.
Maltese Puppies Ventura County » The Twilight Barbie Dolls - About ...
The Twilight Barbie Dolls - About The Bella And Edward Dolls. 03 Jan 2010. 3 Jan, 2010 Kids and Teens. Twilight Barbie dolls are getting to be rather popular with devotees of the Twilight novels by Stephenie Meyer and the legions of ...
Twilight Dolls – Collect Edward, Bella Or Jacob Dolls
One such item that ties in is the Twilight Barbie Dolls and action figures. They are bound to be a best selling toy, giving Twilight fans a chance to make their own romantic scenes with Bella and Edward. Or many people will prefer to ...
lion_lamb: Twilight - Bella - Do You Even Know I'm Here?
Twilight - Bella - Do You Even Know I'm Here? Medium: Book Fandom: The Twilight Saga Subject: Bella Swan Title: Do You Even Know I'm Here? Notes: Don't you ever wander what Bella's life was like before Forks, before Edward, ...
Barbie Twilight Bella Doll Preview « Toy Anxiety's Blog
With long brunette locks, an innocent expression, and her trademark outfit from the film (stylish jeans, sneaks, and a gray jacket), the Twilight Bella doll epitomizes her namesake. Add both dolls to your collection to reunite them for ...

CHECK OUT THESE TWILIGHT VIDEOS 

YouTube thumbnail
Twilight Official Movie Traile...

Runtime: 4:27 | 1529202 views | Comments

YouTube thumbnail
New Moon Movie Trailer - Offic...

Runtime: 1:49 | 25835748 views | Comments

YouTube thumbnail
Twilight teaser trailer OFFICI...

Runtime: 0:59 | 14048233 views | Comments

YouTube thumbnail
Twilight - Official Trailer [H...

Runtime: 2:24 | 2412382 views | Comments

YouTube thumbnail
Twilight 2 - Official Trailer ...

Runtime: 2:52 | 6438000 views | Comments

YouTube thumbnail
NEW OFFICIAL TWILIGHT MOVIE TR...

Runtime: 2:23 | 939479 views | Comments

YouTube thumbnail
Twilight : New Moon - Official...

Runtime: 1:49 | 8824632 views | Comments

YouTube thumbnail
Twilight OFFICIAL Movie Traile...

Runtime: 0:59 | 35563 views | Comments

YouTube thumbnail
New Moon Official Trailer #3 (...

Runtime: 2:28 | 10224255 views | Comments

automatically generated by YouTube"

THIRSTY FOR MORE TWILIGHT? 

Twilight, the movie: vampires, werewolves, romance, and magic
Fans of Stephenie Meyer's Twilight books are breathlessly awaiting the premiere of Twilight, the movie! Can't wait until December 12, 2008? Get your fix of Twilight tidbits right here, including photos, desktop wallpaper, videos, and news on Edward Cullen and Bella Swan.If you like what you find her
Robert Pattinson
Described by Twilight author Stephenie Meyer as one of the few people who can look both dangerous and beautiful, Robert Pattinson captured hearts of Harry Potter fans as the young wizard, Cedric Diggory. Now, Pattinson takes on the role of Edward Cullen, a romantic vampire. Learn more about Pattinso
Twilight online magazine
Articles, photos, videos, and more Twilight stuff. Created by fans - you can contribute!
Twilighters.Org | For the Obsessed Twilight Saga Fan - Breaking Dawn - Forums - Gallery - New Moon - Eclipse -Stephenie Meyer - Updates, News & more!
For obsessed Twilight fans.
TWILIGHT - The Official Movie Site - IN THEATERS 12.12.08
TWILIGHT is an action-packed, modern day love story between a vampire and a human starring Kristen Stewart as Bella Swan and Robert Pattinson as Edward Cullen.
Twilight Guy | A Guy Reads Twilight by Stephenie Meyer
The Twilight Series by Stephenie Meyer - read and blogged from a Guy's perspective
StephenieMeyer.com | Twilight Series | Midnight Sun
The Official Website of Stephenie Meyer. Midnight Sun: Edward's Version of Twilight
Bella Twilight Shop — Jewelry and Gifts for Twilighters
bella twilight shopBella Twilight Shop: Jewelry and Gifts for Twilighters
Welcome! My original Bella Bracelet® is bright sterling silver, embellished with your choice of a hand-carved stone wolf and a big, dazzling Swarovski® heart.

Before you go, any last words? 

No profanity, please. :-)

submit
  • Reply
    pjrock pjrock Dec 23, 2009 @ 12:22 pm
    bella and jacob should so go out but if jacob do not choose her he could always chooes one of us!!!
  • Reply
    pjrock pjrock Dec 23, 2009 @ 12:22 pm
    bella and jacob should so go out but if jacob do not choose her he could always chooes one of us!!!
  • Reply
    twilight twilight Oct 26, 2009 @ 9:00 am
    haha.. you should pick edward!!! haha.. even if edward leaves bella... it doesnt mean that edward doesnt love bella!! he just leave because he wants bella to be safe.. but he realized that he cannot leave without bella.... just read the book.. dont judge edward that fast... i dont like jacob.. jacob also leaves bella, when he became a werewolf..... umh.. both of them leave bella.. its a draw!! they both abandoned bella!!!!!!! go go go.. to all who doesnt want twilight,,you all sucks!! twilight is much beatiful than other vampire stories.. dont be jealous.. hahaha.,,
  • Reply
    brittaney brittaney Dec 15, 2009 @ 9:04 pm
    i have to totally agree with you i just got done watching new moon and what edward did was the right thing cause edward thought he wasn't pertecting bella but... he did wanna die cause he thought bella died and he only did that cause he loved her thats the only reason he left bella...............................
  • Reply
    donna donna Dec 30, 2009 @ 12:04 pm
    Edward and Bella it's just lust..
    Jacob and Bella it's true love.
  • Load More

by hmsweaver

Mom-Geek-Blogger. You can visit Bella Twilight Shop, Geek Mom Mashup, Sugar & Sweets and Club Twilight, to see more of what I do, or HeatherWeaver... (more)

Explore related pages

Create a Lens!