The Film Versus Digital Debate

Ranked #4,438 in Computers & Electronics, #89,842 overall

Film or Digital Cameras?

Film Vs Digital

Two different but similar ways to record your memories or your trips away but which one is better?

There could be many reasons for using either film cameras or digital cameras but there has to be one that is better than the other, doesn't there?

Now's your chance to tell me!

Professional Photographers use...

...all types of cameras.

Chris J Ball, is a professional Fine Arts photographer. He found

...that many models do not even know that film still exists.
...that many professional photographers do not even know how to use film.
...that many photographers both amateur and professional will give the entire shoot of images away without working on them or sorting out the wheat from the chaff.

An Introductory Photography workshop

by: Freeman Patterson, Andre Gallant

Photography for the Joy of It: An Introductory Workshop for Film and Digital Photography

Amazon Price: $99.91 (as of 02/14/2012)Buy Now
List Price: $22.00

Patterson and his teaching partner, Andre Gallant, take a look at the basics in photography, providing clear instruction for beginning color or black-and-white photographers on choosing equipment, selecting the correct exposure, understanding depth of field and much more.

Film Cameras

High quality, professional cameras

Loading

Film or Digital?

Which do you think is better?

Do you use one over the other? Do you use both methods? What do you like about digital? About film? What does your budget allow? Do you find using film expensive? Restrictive? Do you find you get better quality images if you use digital?


Film or Digital?

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

Film for sure; digital is for amateurs!

Nathan says:

Digital is obviously a whole lot better quality, but with film you have to know what you're doing and you get a much more...almost emotional image with film in black and white

photostephen says:

Black and white film is better than converted digital in my opinion, because there is an advantage in the use of development for long tonal range especially on medium format, but you need a scanner that will give the full image detail from such a large negative, the end result will be sharper than traditional printing and if pigment ink is used in the ink jet printer, the archival permanence will be as good or even better than the traditional print.

Anna says:

I used to like digital better, but then when i analyzed the quality i was disappointed by the results. I use both methods. There's not much i like about digital. I like the quality of film, i like the grain, and the colour, or contrast with black and white. I like the way it makes photo's look so real.

nikons210 says:

Digital are more easy to use, but for the perfect image quality, use film, I use about two cameras, the Nikon S210 and the Old Classic kodak camera.

Tim G says:

There are pros and cons with both. I like the fact that I can actually see what I just shot to determine if I want to keep it or not, but (to me) I find the image quality of slides to be much cleaner and more detailed. When i shoot for the agencies I am contracted with, they mostly want slides scanned onto discs, but will accept digital of various file size and qualities. I personally love shooting slides better. I use my digital like a Polaroid before taking the actual shot like I did years ago. BUT, I DO keep my digital images stored as RAW + JPEG Fine or Normal. I never know when I will want to send digital to an agency in lieu of slides. Another thought for purists, anyone can manipulate a photo to create a desired effect. When i shoot a film or slide image I try to capture what I see. I realize that if the image is not as "dynamic" as I'd like it to be I can always play with it later in the lab, but I really do try to get it just as I saw it. With digital, there's the underlying "understood" fact that you or anyone can alter an image to whatever suits your taste. That's fine i suppose, but then what does it say about me (or anyone) as a photographer? Is my message to bring to others the beauty (or otherwise) of what I am trying to convey, or is it to show the creative side of myself? perhaps being a photographer means more than just taking quality, insightful photos. Perhaps it also includes an artistic expression of ones' self to relay a feeling or other affect on the viewer. I believe it is both, then both digital and film have their place in the photographic world.

Digital wins hands down! Film is out of date.

manchester says:

Digital all the way!

cstronner says:

I prefer film as I have always found the quality better, but with ease of editing, financial restraints on buying and processing film, I now use digital. For me personally I will choose the digital option, but think film is better :-)

GrammaLinda says:

I tend to forget to develop film, so digital is the way for me to go!

TWOnline2 says:

there is no debate here. it just depends upon what you are comfortable with and which process/tool fits your project.

Brent Morando says:

The truth is, Film was done when the tests showed that the Canon d30 out-resolved out resolved film, showed higher dynamic range, better noise performance, and overall better IQ back in 2000. It's incredible that this debate still continues. Digital has proven to be less expensive, easier, and overall just better looking.
Unless you're using a 20,000 dollar scanner, a film slr will in no aspect beat a dslr. And for 20,000 you could Digital Leaf, and destroy both.
Sorry film, you were fun, but you're done.

 
view all 23 comments

Saint Marys Lake

Film photography

Why just stick to Digital or Film?

Use as many formats as you can

For ease of use, Digital cameras come top. As long as you have the camera, the card to write your images to and batteries, you're ready to go. Just point and click. Okay, so there's slightly more skill to it than that.

My point is, is that digital photography is ideal for those who do not wish to embark on a career as a professional photographer. In order to extract the images from the card you need your own computer and a memory card reader. No need to worry about sending your film off for processing and no one else has to see your images.

Digital cameras now are packed with so many features and they're relatively cheap, so they're easily accessible for the majority of us.

Film cameras are a different thing altogether.

Initial pricing for film cameras are exceptionally high and are usually only within reach for those of us who take our photography seriously. They also cost money to process them either by sending them away or by doing it yourself. With digital cameras now becoming so popular the need for film developers etc. are dwindling so it's even harder to find a shop or retailer than caters for this market. However, they are there if you know where to look and most, if not all, professional photographers would.

In terms of picture quality, they are two different mediums. No image will be exactly alike on whatever camera you take them on. Quality will also depend on any additional processes you may add i.e. scanning, quality of film developers, time and software.

Some photographers will shoot the same image on both types of cameras in order to get the maximum potential for the image.

So, really it all comes down to personal preferences and resources as to which camera you decide to use. There really is no good way of comparing the two types of photography together.

But, don't let that stop you from debating your views :)

Why I choose Digital over Film

My reasons

As a Squidoo Lensmaster, images are very important to me for improving the look of my lenses. Many of my images are displayed on my lenses using my account on Flickr.

As an amateur photographer, I believe Digital is far easier and cheaper than using a Film camera. For ease of use and speed, Digital wins hands down.

Why?

Digital Cameras are cheaper than Film: The initial cost of the camera is considerably cheaper than a Film camera. I can pick up a very good Digital Camera for under ยฃ100, although I would be happy to pay up to ยฃ150.

There are also no processing costs. I won't have to send my film away to be processed (though I wouldn't have to do that anyway, as I have a professional photographer on hand! ;)) All I need is a memory card (of which I have loads!), a computer and a memory card reader to transfer to my computer. I would also require editing software but these can be found on the Internet for free.

Digital Cameras are fast: Not just in the actual taking of the photograph but the processing of images to the computer. You take the images today and you can have them ready for editing the very same day maybe less than one hour after you have taken them.

Digital Cameras are Easy: For amateur photographers they are easy to use and process. Most, now, have software included to improve your images as you take them e.g. face recognition. Just point and click. All you need to worry about is composition.

Combat Camera Shake

Camera tips

1} Practice holding the camera steady by bracing yourself, keeping your weight balanced and your elbows tucked into your side. Breathe out as you squeeze the shutter.

2} If you're working without a tripod, use a shutter speed of 1/60 sec or faster, according to which lens you are using. For example, using a zoom lens (55-200mm) pick the longest focal length and then translate it into a corresponding fast shutter speed.

3} Rest the camera on something. Use walls, sturdy trees, for example, as a natural tripod. Avoid touching the camera during the exposure by using a cable release or self-timer.

Digital? Film? Both? Neither?

Time to Vote!

Photobucket

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Samsung S760

Samsung S760 Red 7.0 Megapixel Digital Camera

Amazon Price: $49.00 (as of 02/14/2012)Buy Now
List Price:
Used Price: $49.00

This is the camera I went for in the end, although I chose the colour, black. This camera was currently priced at just under 50 pounds in Jacobs. I'm very pleased so far with the results of the images and it's very easy and light to use. It's small, too, which is good for fitting into your coat pocket ready for use.

Digital Cameras

Compact, reasonably priced

Loading

Photography & Squidoo

Resources

Webmaster Resources:
SquiDirectory Squidoo Directory - A categorized Squidoo directory featuring selected pages by expert Squidoo authors, featuring a variety of interesting subjects. From art to shopping, music, people, sports, religion, how's and more.

Photobucket

submit

by

Christopher-John-Ball

Christopher John Ball BA (Hon's) MA is a widely exhibited and published, award winning, London based, fine arts photographer, playwright, writer and l... more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!

The Digital Photography Book 

The Digital Photography Book

Amazon Price: $13.53 (as of 02/14/2012)Buy Now