Genetically Modified Foods: The Debate

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic by 4 people | Log in to rate

Ranked #520 in Green, #54,798 overall

What is Genetically Modified Food?

Genetically modified food, a type of GMO (genetically modified organisms), is produced from changing the genetic characteristics of an organism, such as a seed. This can be done through inserting a new DNA into the organism, adding, removing or rearrangement the order of the gene, with the purpose of changing some of the characteristics of the food.

Other Facts 

The When and Why of Genetic Modification

When did GMO become available?
The food was actually available in the early 1990s.

Why did people make GMO?
Scientists aim to product a superior "species" of food, e.g. bigger, sweeter fruits, wheat that is tolerant of herbicides or insects, or tomato that is more resistant to rotting. Many of them have a noble aim: to produce more food to solve the world's hunger problem, or to improve the efficiency of agricultural land to save the environment. However, there are concerns related to potential harm of genetically engineered food to human, the environment and the world. We will explore this big debate below.

Is Genetically Modified Foods Common? 

You bet!

In 2005, about 222 million acres (900,000 KM2, or double the size of California) are used for GM food cultivation, of which 55% are from US. In terms of harvest, around 60% of the world's GM food comes from US, 20% from Argentina, 5% from Canada, and the rest mostly from the 3 biggest emerging countries: Brazil, China and India.

In terms of crops, the most common genetically engineered food in the US is soybeans (89%), cotton (83%), maize (66%). Most of them are modified to become more herbicide tolerant.

Do People Care about GM Foods? 

It depends. According to a poll done in 2005, only a small proportion of Americans have knowledge on GM foods. Among them, they oppose animal cloning and support active product regulation, but in general remain supportive of the technology. The fact that GM food isn't required to be labeled, and absence of organized anti-GM-food campaign also contribute to the relatively lack of concern among Americans in this matter.

On the other hand, Britons (and Europeans) have much stronger views, with more than half of the Britons against GM food being available to the market. It may be a result of a controversial study in 1999 suggested that a few strains of GM potatoes might be toxic to laboratory rats, as well as wide-spread food concern since the Mad Chow Disease scare.

Interestingly, if we assume that the developing countries don't care, we are wrong!

  • In 2002, Zambia, a country suffering from acute famine, refuses to accept GM maize from the UN World Food Program. It was until the famine got so bad three years later that the government changed its mind and started importing GM food again.

  • Hugo Chavez imposes a ban on GM seeds throughout Venezuela in 2004.

  • The Hungarian government also disallowed import and planting of GM maize seeds in 2005.
  • What is the Future of GM Foods? 

    As creative as you want! Animals can be made to mature faster, fruits made to yield faster and bigger, and plants made to yield more of the chemicals useful to humans (e.g. for making vaccines and special raw materials). Sky is your limit!

    Given such a potential, it is not surprisingly that some people are marvelled by this invention while others are very worried about its impact to our planet.

    The Big Debate: Should We Love or Hate GM Food? 

    On solving food hunger
  • Lovers: More food can be made efficiently. In particular, crops can be made to grow in harsh agricultural condition, e.g. in some parts of Africa.

  • Haters: There are enough food for everyone to eat, but currently food is not distributed to the right place. So problem is not quantity, but logistics, distribution and politics.


  • On solving malnutrition
  • Lovers: Food can be modified to contain more vitamins and minerals. For example, a new strain of vitamin-A rich rice is being developed, hopefully to alleviate blindness which has been affecting 500,000 persons on an annual basis.

  • Haters: Food can be consciously made good, but unconsciously made toxic at the same time. There are valid concerns of unforeseen consequences.


  • On food safety
  • Haters: There is not enough scientific research to study the potential harm of GM food.

  • Lovers: There are already more than 100 government research. None of them have conclusive evidence of harm from GM food.


  • On politics and balance of power
  • Haters: Since the GM technology is owned by a few biotechnology firms, there is a worry that these firms have too much power in controlling the world food market. Also, the millions of farmers' livelihood will be controlled by these few firms.

  • Lovers: The reduction of herbicides used and increased efficiency of GM food actually make farming more profitable for individual farmers. Also, a few genetically engineering licenses are given to farmers in poorer regions allowing to save seeds for next year's planting.


  • On the environment
  • Lovers: Crops are made to be herbicide-tolerant. Therefore, less herbicides are used which is only positive for the environment.

  • Haters: It is true, but now that herbicides are so successful in killing the weeds, the animals that live off from crop weeds will be wiped out.


  • It happens in nature anyway
  • Lovers: Cross breeding is a natural process of producing new breeds with different genetic characteristics. Sounds the same for genetic engineering, so what's the big deal?

  • Haters: Cross breeding is a process that goes through thousands of years and is well tested in the environment. However, genetic engineering done in a lab in large quantities is too quick and too large-scale for our vulnerable eco-system.


  • The debate continues.

    While the GM food issue remains controversial, it is the most important that we find out the facts, then give our support or opposing accordingly. I hope you have learned a little bit about genetic modified foods today and please do take a poll below and tell the world what you think!

    Our readers' view 

    Loading poll. Please Wait...

    Featured Shop: Simply Organic 

    Not so sure about GM food? Let's support organic food and farming where GMO is prohibited. Simply Organic promotes a fresh, natural and healthy way of eating and living, as well as harmony with nature and the environment.

    No to Growth Hormones: Cows Women's Light T-Shirt

    Everyday we have been fed with produce from animals stuffed with growth hormones. Say no to this practice and support organic farming!

    Price: 20.99 Buy Now

    You are what you eat Light T-Shirt

    You are what you eat: go Organic -- a good reminder on the importance of healthy eating, drinking and living.

    Price: 19.99 Buy Now

    Go Organic Tote Bag

    This Scrabble-inspired design reminds us that healthy living is an educational process, and your health will just get better and better with practice!

    Price: 18.99 Buy Now

    Asian cultures have emphasized harmony with nature, environment, and spiritual balance for centuries. Now spread the Zen philosophies with us! Makes perfect outfit for yoga and meditation

    Price: 0.00 Buy Now

    I make Organic Fertilizers Infant Bodysuit

    Make everyone laugh out loud with this T-shirt, and promote organic farming in a whole new way! This collection also makes excellent baby and pet gifts.

    Price: 14.99 Buy Now

    Powered by CafePress

    Lastly, if it is only a Yes or No Answer... 

    If you are now the President of your country and have to vote for a Yes or No on GM food in a UN convention, what would you do?

    My Vote and My Reason

    Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

    YES

    calvin says:

    I would say there should be GM food. it is unhealthy but you should get the chice if you want to eat it or ot. there should be a label on it. it is more faster & easyier. farmers have less work to do. if we can have it , then why not ?

    B. J. says:

    I would have a tough time trying to decide, as many people have grown used to eating genetically modified food without realizing it. Take the seedless watermelon for example. When I walk into a grocery store and see a seedless watermelon, I don't think "Hmm, a seedless watermelon? How on Earth could that be possible, as watermelons need seeds to reproduce? Let me see, what could it be? Oh, I know! Genetically modified food!" But instead I thought: "Cool! They hav watermelons without seeds now! That means I won't have to pick them oout any more!"
    I think you understans what I mean.

    NO

    Bob says:

    What happened to freshly naturally grown foods? The next thing you know we will be growing tomatos in test tubes. Just stick to the original!

     
     
    1 of 1 page
     

    Links from the Pro-GM Camp 

    New Scientist Special GMO Report
    My favorite site in the Pro camp. Generally supportive of GM technology and makes best effort to lay out the facts. Also reports on the anti-GM news to give a complete picture.
    Genetic Maize
    A more light-hearted blog written by PhD student Anastasia, whose research includes improving bioavailable iron in maize through genetic engineering.
    GMO Food For Thought
    A weekly blog that reports the latest news and innovation of the agricultural biotech industry. Somewhat technical, but lots of information.
    GMO Africa
    Similar to GMO Food For Thought. It actually discusses issues beyond Africa and has a nice blog.

    Books from the Pro-GM Camp 

    Tomorrow's Table: Organic Farming, Genetics, and the Future of Food

    Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

    Amazon Price: $23.96 (as of 07/06/2009) Buy Now

    Links from the Anti-GM Camp 

    Greenpeace on GMO
    My favorite site in the Against camp. While some people may frown on Greenpeace's usual "activist" approach, in this website they present the arguments rationally, with lots of useful information e.g. food labelling legislation on GM products in different countries.
    GM Watch
    A site with lots of anecdotes against the usage of GMO / GM foods.
    Seeds of Deception
    Website that promotes the book of the same title.
    A rather intense site. Also check out its sister site, responsibletechnology.org.

    Books from the Anti-GM Camp 

    The Food Revolution: How Your Diet Can Help Save Your Life and Our World

    Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

    Amazon Price: $12.21 (as of 07/06/2009) Buy Now

    Seeds of Deception: Exposing Industry and Government Lies About the Safety of the Genetically Engineered Foods You're Eating

    Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

    Amazon Price: $12.21 (as of 07/06/2009) Buy Now

    Genetically Engineered Food: Changing the Nature of Nature

    Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

    Amazon Price: $12.71 (as of 07/06/2009) Buy Now

    Related Lens 

    What Do You Think? 

    Whether it's your views, comments, ideas, constructive criticisms or improvements about this lens, you are most welcome to drop us a note. Thank you!

    ChineseKitesforKids wrote...

    I think you have yourself a good debate going here. Very creative topic with engaging content. Thank you for sharing! Come check out our lens Daycare School Nutrition

    ReplyPosted June 03, 2009