Harry Potter vs. Lord of the Rings

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic by 4 people | Log in to rate

Ranked #955 in Arts , #18,725 overall

Showdown Between Wizards, Elves, and Hobbits!

Harry Potter vs. Lord of the Rings - you knew this debate had to turn up sometime!

So which is it... Dumbledore or Gandalf? Harry or Frodo? Voldemort or Sauron? Horcruxes or Rings of Power? House elves or hobbits? Death Eaters or Uruk-hai?

In short, which fantasy world does it for you? Choose a side and join the fight.



But wait! Before you begin... be sure to choose your weapon.

Arm Yourselves, Harry Potter Fans... 

Harry Potter Wand
Harry Potter Wand


No wizard can properly duel without a wand. For that matter, a wizard can't do much at all without a wand, although Snape might beg to differ. And if you happen to be a non-magical muggle or squib, well, just poke your wand in your enemy's eye! That'll show 'em. (Kids, don't try this at home.)

Harry Potter Wand: $9.95

Enemy flailing after a poke in the eye: Priceless

Lord of the Rings Fans, Take Up Your Swords! 

Adult Aragorn Costume Sword - Lord of the Rings Costume Accessories

Adult Aragorn Costume Sword - Lord of the Rings Costume Accessories



Sure, you may not be able to do any magic with a sword, but look at it this way: A sword in the hands of a muggle always beats a muggle armed with a wand.

What if your opponent happens to be a wizard with a wand? Whether you're wielding a wand or a fine sword, I'm afraid you're hosed.

Either way, you'll look more menacing with a sword. All you need is a good pair of boots to die proudly.

Aragorn "replica" sword: $14.44

Look on your enemy's face: Priceless


Huge Selection! Flat Rate Shipping!

Grab Your Wand, Staff, or Sword and Join the Fight! 

Now that you've picked a side, duke it out here!

Harry Potter vs. Lord of the Rings

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

Harry Potter!

Number1Athlete says:

AHHHHH!!! i cant decide!!! im just going to pick harry potter because i read it before lord of the rings as a kid. They are both great though.

Pip says:

Definitely Harry Potter, I fell asleep during the first LOTR movie. I got through the books more easily but they never grabbed me. I suppose I liked the world of Harry Potter because its setting is set (more or less) in modern times.

fefe says:

Harry Potter, but I haven't really read all of the LOTR books.

Lord of the Rings!

jjj1 says:

I read TLOTR 30+ years ago now and it was my first GREAT book love. For that reason I have to choose it - but Harry Potter is pretty good in its own way.

anna says:

lord of the rings is verrrrrrrrrrrrrryyyyyyyyyyyyy goooooooooooooooooooood novel of all times

sauron says:

lord of the rings is the best book plus movie

bq says:

harry potter sucks lotr is great

Anthony says:

Definitely Lord of The Ring. Lord of The Ring is masterpiece books ever written. It even have their own language. And some of the elements in LOTR is being copied by Harry Potter.

LOTR Is one of the best book ever written.

ARAGORN says:

lord of the rings is the book we like the most because lotr is my 1st love

baqir says:

lord of the rings is the best book ever written. harry potter is a copy of lotr

Bomburon says:

This poll is pointless. There is no way to compare the two.
Harry potter: Commercially-driven book
Lord of the rings: Masterpiece that took the author his whole adult life to create.
Lord of the rings will still be remembered into the future, as it has already been proved.
Harry potter, on the other hand, will be gone

Sojourner1957 says:

Lord of the Rings drew me in from the first pages of the Hobbit. It is a world of beauty, power, poetry, incredible images. It is my favorite escape. While there is a great deal of violence, the violence has a point, a purpose. It is not senseless, random violence for the sake of violence. It is the reality of the world at war against evil, domination and darkness. A war to save all beings from slavery. How can you not love that?

Victoria_Neely says:

Potter is fun, but Lord of the Rings was my first love. Reading those books for the first time swept me away to a vibrant world filled with different cultures, languages, and subtle magic.

 
 
1 of 1 page
 

Lord of the Rings vs. Harry Potter 

What happens when the Fellowship of the Ring meet up with Harry Potter's gang? You get pranks, violence, and chaos, that's what!

Lotr vs. Harry Potter

a fight between characters from lord of the rings and harry potter.

powered by YouTube

Lord of the Rings DVD Series 

The Lord of the Rings - The Motion Picture Trilogy (Platinum Series Special Extended Edition)

Amazon Price: (as of 07/11/2009)Buy Now

Own the Lord of the Rings series... complete extended edition!

Vote for a Weapon! 

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Harry Potter on DVD 

Harry Potter Years 1-5 Limited Edition Gift Set (Sorcerers Stone/ Chamber of Secrets/ Prisoner of Azkaban/ Goblet of Fire/ Order of the Phoenix) [Blu-ray]

Amazon Price: $103.99 (as of 07/11/2009)Buy Now

Harry Potter on Blu-Ray, movies 1 through 5. Limited edition... probably because we'll have more movies added to the collection within the next few years.

Sauron vs. Voldemort 

sauron vs voldemort

a comparison of two dark lords, (though which the latter is lord of i have no idea) to see who has the best forms, servants weapons and causes of death, i admit its a little one sided but im a fan, not a diplomat THE NAME OF SAURONS SONG IS REQUIEM OF A DREAM

Runtime: 1:50
513346 views
10 Comments:

powered by YouTube

Did You Enjoy the Fight? 

Holster your wands and sheathe your swords! What else would you like to add to this debate?

riff999 wrote...

Nice lens. This will prove to be an interesting debate. I can't wait to see how things go.
~Jane

ReplyPosted April 03, 2008