Holy Cow: An Indian Adventure
A Book Discussion run by spirituality

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic (by 2 people)   Your rating: 1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic

On a trip to India

Great book if you want to go to India yourself - especially if you're interested in India as the home of spirituality.

India in pictures 

2007-11-0770 by Argenberg

2007-11-0770

2007-11-0769 by Argenberg

2007-11-0769

2007-11-0721 by Argenberg

2007-11-0721

2007-11-0728 by Argenberg

2007-11-0728

2007-11-0745 by Argenberg

2007-11-0745

2007-11-0735 by Argenberg

2007-11-0735

2007-11-0748 by Argenberg

2007-11-0748

2007-11-0775 by Argenberg

2007-11-0775

2007-11-0782 by Argenberg

2007-11-0782

2007-11-0715 by Argenberg

2007-11-0715

Powered by Flickr

The storyline 

The book starts with Sarah just before her plane leaves and she can get out of India (which she's hated). A begger tells her she'll be back: following love.

The next scene, ten years later, is Sarah coming back to India because her new Husband, Jonathan, has a job here as a journalist. She has given up her own high profile job as a journalist to be able to follow him there.

We follow Sarah as she gets close to death, dives into the main religions India has to offer, tries to learn Hindi, makes friends, follows Indian fashion and watches Bollywood movies.

Sarah leaves India pregnant and sad to leave India for her native Australia. Even though she knows how much easier things will be there.

WHO WAS YOUR FAVORITE CHARACTER? 

Loading poll. Please Wait...

India 

India is a country like other countries: it has bad people and good people. It has poverty (lots of it) and wealth (lots of that too). It has technological innovation and people living in hunter gatherer type groups.

India is the largest democracy in the world. It's also the home of yoga, Buddhism and Hinduism. These religious/spiritual traditions have moved west in the last century.

Some of the people who describe India just ignore one or another aspect of it. It's all divine yogi's, or all poverty, all technology or all Dalai Lama type Buddhists.

Holy Cow: An Indian Adventure actually gives a decently balanced picture, even though it can be seen as too superficial. Well - there isn't a book out there that can do India justice, there's just too much of it. But this book does do a good job of introducing India to Westerners in a way that does it justice enough, I feel.

What was your favorite spiritual teacher or tradition in this novel? 

Sarah finds the most famous spiritual teachers and spiritual traditions in India and gives each a try. Which inspired you most?

#1

Vote Up
Vote Down

Ganga - the sacred river

Sarah is both repulsed and fascinated by this sacr more...1 point

#2

Vote Up
Vote Down

Astrologer Rakesh

Who prophesies the year Sarah and Jonathan have co more...1 point

#3

Vote Up
Vote Down

S.N. Goenka

The Vipassana teacher who is only present on video more...1 point

#4

Vote Up
Vote Down

Dalai Lama

Tibetan Buddhism made easy. Main message: find hap more...1 point

#5

Vote Up
Vote Down

Mata Amritanandamayi

The hugging Amma. Her unjudgmental love for everyb more...1 point

#6

Vote Up
Vote Down

Sufi Love in Pakistan

The center of spirituality for Sarah is Love for a more...1 point

#7

Vote Up
Vote Down

Satya Sai Baba

The guru who supports various charities, has great more...0 points

#8

Vote Up
Vote Down

the Sikhs

The religion of perseverance, protection of the we more...0 points

#9

Vote Up
Vote Down

Islam in India

Devotion to God instead of doubt in everything.0 points

#10

Vote Up
Vote Down

Hinduism

Religion of tolerance.0 points

#11

Vote Up
Vote Down

Judaism

Food as spiritual service and living life with pas more...0 points

#12

Vote Up
Vote Down

Parsi's followers of Zarathustra

Purity.0 points

#13

Vote Up
Vote Down

Kryon, space guru

Sarah goes new age in India0 points

#14

Vote Up
Vote Down

Christianity

The Indian variety.0 points

Holy Cow: An Indian Adventure 

by Sarah Macdonald

Holy Cow: An Indian Adventure

Holy Cow: An Indian Adventure

by Sarah Macdonald

Amazon Price: $11.20 (as of 05/17/2008)

I loved this book and read it out in three nights of reading. I've studied India in college and went there myself some time ago - yet I could not find many mistakes. Given the size and variety of the country - that's quite an achievement.

This book really is great for those who are thinking of going to India to grow spiritually - it will get you out of your romantic haze. It's also great for those who've been there - a feast of recognition. And if you aren't spiritually inclined - this may just change your mind.

Zoroastrianism / Parsis 

This is the only religion where the descriptions went off a bit. I was taught, in my ancient religion class, that Zoroaster lived around 1000 BC. Certainly not 600 B.C. Also - the Parsis are in trouble and deal with their dwindling numbers in a variety of ways. Sarah is most sympathetic to the people who marry outside the tribe. But their choice makes it even harder for the rest to keep going.

WHAT WAS THE MOST MEMORABLE MOMENT IN THE BOOK? 

Please add your own favorite scene/moment from the book.

#1

Vote Up
Vote Down

When Sarah lost all her hair

She almost dies of double pneumonia.1 point

#2

Vote Up
Vote Down

When Sarah went to Afghanistan with Jonathan

1 point

#3

Vote Up
Vote Down

When the Twin Towers get hit

Sarah and Jonathan face the horrors religion can b more...1 point

#4

Vote Up
Vote Down

When Sarah got cursed by an Indian begger

0 points

#5

Vote Up
Vote Down

When Sarah got a quick hug from Amma

0 points

#6

Vote Up
Vote Down

When Jonathan and Sarah went to see Sai Baba

0 points

What did you think about this description of India? 

Write a review, add a comment, or debate someone who disagrees with you.

Was this book good, or too superficial, or something else? Tell me.

Was this book good, or too superficial, or something else?

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

Inspiring read, good book, well written.

Mac33 says:

My wife loved it. A couple friends of ours who have visited India really enjoyed reading it also.

Posted April 25, 2008

spirituality says:

I loved it. Gave me some ideas of what to do and where to go when I go back to India in a few years.

Posted April 16, 2008

Too superficial, read something else to get to know India and its relgions.

 
 
1 of 1 page
 

More books about India 

City of Djinns: A Year in Delhi

City of Djinns: A Year in Delhi

by William Dalrymple

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $11.20 (as of 05/17/2008)

Tales of a Female Nomad: Living at Large in the World

Tales of a Female Nomad: Living at Large in the World

by Rita Golden Gelman

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $10.17 (as of 05/17/2008)

Travelers' Tales India: True Stories (Travelers' Tales Guides)

Travelers' Tales India: True Stories (Travelers' Tales Guides)

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $13.57 (as of 05/17/2008)

India (Country Guide)

India (Country Guide)

by Sarina Singh, Joe Bindloss, Rafael Wlodarski, Amy Karafin, Paul Harding, Lindsay Brown, Mark Elliott, Simon Richmond, Virginia Jealous, Tom Spurling

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $19.49 (as of 05/17/2008)

India - Culture Smart!: a quick guide to customs and etiquette (Culture Smart!)

India - Culture Smart!: a quick guide to customs and etiquette (Culture Smart!)

by Nicki Grihault

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $9.95 (as of 05/17/2008)

Got inspired to got to India yourself? 

Here's how.

Travel to New Delhi from...






Travelers

Children or Seniors?
Adults (18-64):

     

   

powered by Orbitz

Reader Feedback 

indiamarks

I've never read this book...but now I'm intrigued and will definitely check it out! Thanks!

Posted May 05, 2008

More on India and Spirituality 

Lenses related to this book.
featured lens The 14th Dalai Lama: Tenzin Gyatso

Nobel Peace Prize Winner, popularizer of Buddhism and head of the Tibetan Government in Exile. The Dalai Lama's life is a unique convergence of religion, politics and an admirable stand on peace in the face of aggression. This lens focuses on his lif...

featured lens What is an Ashram?

An ashram is a place of spiritual retreat. Usually there are permanent residents as well as visitors who come for retreats.

featured lens Spiritual Lenses - Katinka Hesselink Net - Religion and Spirituality resources

A lensography of my best spirituality lenses as well as a summary of my website. I feature information from various religious traditions like Buddhism, Sufism, Fourth Way and Theosophy. I also pay attention to various spiritual teachers, whether the...

featured lens Spiritual Teachers - my favorites and yours

These are some of the teachers - past and present - who will keep reminding us that there IS more to life. There is more to US... Spiritual teachers are the salt that gives flavor to our otherwise somewhat dry western culture. With all the focus on...

featured lens Everything India!

indiamarks brings India to everyone with simple, crisp and relevent content and guides to everything India. Find quality information and great articles about everything India - from business, sports, bollywood to travel, food, shopping, videos and mu...

More on the spiritual traditions Sarah was investigating 

Did you like the taste Sarah gave you of Indian Religion? Here is more about Buddhism, Sufism, Alternative ways of looking at Christianity and Jiddu Krishnamurti.

Was This Lens Helpful?

So many ways to show your appreciation! Rank this lens with the little stars at the top. Check out the advertiser's, if you are interested in their products. Stumble it. Digg it. Add it to your lens roll. Leave a comment. Favorite it.

Thank you!

SquidLit

What's your favorite book? Start a free discussion page about it. You could even earn a royalty for charity