The Best-Ever Homemade Chicken Pot Pie Recipe
Ranked #102 in Food & Cooking, #1,900 overall
Homemade Chicken Pot Pie Is Comfort Food At Its Best
I have been making this suppertime pie as a special occasion treat for twenty years and I can assure you that the recipe is neither easy nor quick. As a matter of fact, I am ordinarily pastry challenged but the final result of this recipe convinces me to persevere. If you are looking for a recipe that results in the most amazing chicken pot pie you've ever eaten, then you should definitely try this one. If pastry is 'easy as pie' for you, then this recipe will not be a challenge.
The best-ever homemade chicken pot pie recipe is from one of my all-time favorite cookbooks from a series of books produced by Time-Life in their American Country series. It is called Country Cooking: Recipes for Traditional Country Fare. It features many of my favorite comfort food recipes and is still readily available through Amazon at a very affordable price. You can order a copy for your collection by clicking right here. They call this recipe chicken pot pie in a cheese crust.
Now, won't you settle in to read this page and join me for a slice of chicken pot pie?
Contents at a Glance
- Chicken Pot Pie In A Cheese Crust Recipe
- Country Cooking: Recipes for Traditional...
- Country Pot Pie Recipes From Celebrity C...
- Shortcuts For Making Homemade Chicken Po...
- Chicken Pot Pie Is In The News
- Amazon's Bestselling Pie Bird
- Perhaps A Vintage Pie Bird
- A Chicken Pot Pie Apron
- Nordic Ware Naturals Pie Pan with Lid
Chicken Pot Pie In A Cheese Crust Recipe
Serves 6 to 8 people.
1.5 cups flour
1/4 cup grated Parmesan cheese
2 tbsps parsley
1/2 tsp salt
1/4 tsp pepper
1 stick (4 ounces) chilled butter cut into bits
3 to 4 tbsps ice water
FILLING
2 cups chicken broth (I use homemade but you can use canned)
1/4 pound small white onions (I use cut up regular-sized white onions)
2 cups peeled and diced yam or sweet potato
3/4 to 1 tsp crumbled sage
1/4 tsp pepper
2 medium-sized carrots cut into 1/4-inch thick rounds
2 cups broccoli florets
1/2 cup diced celery
1/4 cup flour
4 tbsps butter at room temperature
3 cups cooked chicken cut into bite sized pieces
1 beaten egg
INSTRUCTIONS:
-
Pastry:
In a large bowl combine the flour, Parmesan, parsley, salt and pepper. Cut in the butter until it looks like coarse meal; perhaps smaller than peas. Add the 3 tablespoons of water and work it in, adding up to another tablespoon of water until you form a dough that you can gather in a ball. Divide it in half, press it into a disc shape, wrap in plastic and refrigerate for 30 minutes. -
Filling:
In a large pot, bring the chicken broth to a boil and add the onions, yam, sage and pepper. Cook until the yam is just starting to get tender, about 5 minutes, then add the carrots, broccoli and celery and cook for another 5 minutes.
In a small bowl, with your fingers, blend the flour with the butter. Increase the heat under the pot to high and pinch off pieces of the flour butter mix, dropping them into the pan and stirring to mix them in. Cook until the sauce has thickened a little bit, about 3 minutes and then remove from the heat and stir in the chicken. - Preheat oven to 425 degrees.
-
Roll half of the dough into a 12-inch circle which will fit into your 9-inch pie pan. Add the filling and then roll the other half of the dough into a 9-inch circle to place on top. Trim the overhang to about 1/2 an inch all the way around and then fold this extra pastry over the top crust, crimping to seal. Cut steam vents or use a pie bird
to vent the pie. Brush the pie with the beaten egg.
- Bake the pie for 15 minutes and then lower the temperature to 325 degrees and bake a further 10 to 15 minutes until it is golden.
Country Cooking: Recipes for Traditional Country Fare Cookbook
From Time Life's American Country Series comes a collection of comfort-food style recipes.

Country Cooking: Recipes for Traditional Country Fare from Amazon.
Country Pot Pie Recipes From Celebrity Chefs
- Chicken Pot Pie Recipe From Ina Garten, The Barefoot Contessa, On The Food Network
- Food Network invites you to try this Chicken Pot Pie recipe from Ina Garten.
- Chicken Pot Pie In A Mug Recipe From Rachael Ray On The Food Network
- Food Network invites you to try this Chicken Mug Pie recipe from Rachael Ray. From the show called 30 Minute Meals, episode: A Taste of Home.
- Chicken Pot Pie Throwdown With Casserole Queens & Bobby Flay
- Bobby Flay challenges the Casserole Queens of Austin, Texas, to a Chicken Pot Pie throwdown. The Food Network chef won on the originally aired show in March 2009, but as Crystal Cook and Sandy Pollock says, "Everyone agreed we should have won."
- Lighter Chicken Pot Pie Recipe From Martha Stewart
- Martha Stewart shares a lighter chicken pot pie recipe.
- Perfect Chicken Pot Pie From Martha Stewart
- Martha Stewart shares the perfect chicken pot pie recipe.
- Chicken Pot Pie Recipe From Tyler Florence and the Food Network
- Food Network invites you to try this Chicken Pot Pie recipe from Tyler Florence.
Shortcuts For Making Homemade Chicken Pot Pie
Bake a roast chicken one day and save 3 cups of cooked chicken for this recipe.
With the carcass of the roast chicken, make chicken broth the same night as you roasted it.
Both the chicken and the broth can be frozen so that you can make the pie at a future date.
Use canned broth or substitue if you are trying to speed up the process but beware of sodium.
The entire pie can be made ahead and cooked from frozen when required.
You Can Use A Glass, Ceramic, Metal or Cast Iron Pie Pan
All of the pie plates that follow are top-rated bestsellers on Amazon so you can purchase the type of plate that you prefer and know you are getting a great product.
Pyrex Grip-Rite 9 1/2 Inch Pie Plate, Clear
Amazon Price: $4.90 (as of 02/15/2012)![]()
Amazon customer reviews of this pyrex pie dish include comments like S.C. Sander's that she really likes the grips on this pie dish, Cristiano Fontes' that this dish lives up to the reputation of Pyrex and K. Knorr's that these dishes are not fancy but that that is rather irrelevant when you serve a HOMEMADE pie in one!
Chicken Pot Pie Is In The News
- Chicken pot pie recipe
- Wet the leaves with water and place them on the pie tops, then quickly paint the pies with beaten egg. Bake in the oven for 20 minutes until piping hot, puffed up and golden. Serve immediately. Chicken pot pie - pie recipes Diana Henry.
- Pie Sisters
- In the savory category, tomato-cheese pie with basil channels a very rich pizza; chicken potpie packed with veggies tastes faintly of nutmeg; and chili pie topped with shredded cheddar is wonderfully homey. Alli says they use the same pie crust for ...
- LOOKING FOR
- I would love to have that recipe or something similar," says Dawn. Adele is looking for recipes for slippery-noodle style Pennsylvania Dutch Chicken Pot Pie. Bob Ravier of Center Valley is looking for a recipe for Steamed Apple Dumplings.
Amazon's Bestselling Pie Bird
Is this brand-new cute little white bird.
R & M White Pie Bird
Amazon Price: $4.75 (as of 02/15/2012)![]()
"I admit to being a foodie, and Elton Brown (host of Good Eats) said I HAD to have one of these, so... I could have purchased a much less expensive version, but let's face it, four and twenty may be an awkard number, but one cute little pie bird was a must have. I will not bake fruit pie again without this treasure. It really does vent the pie and prevent the juices from spilling out and burning in my oven. Pie bird - yes...I think it's too cute." Ann Warner "Grannie Annie"
Perhaps A Vintage Pie Bird
Is more to your liking. These ones are available right now on eBay.
A Chicken Pot Pie Apron
Available in three colors for adults and for children.

Chicken Pot Pie by apollo335
Many more apron designs at zazzle
Nordic Ware Naturals Pie Pan with Lid
This is Amazon's number top selling pie plate although I expect that the sales are due more to the lid than the pie plate itself! However, there is no arguing with the practicality of this piece!
Nordic Ware Naturals Hi-Dome Pie Pan with Lid, 10 Inch
Amazon Price: $13.55 (as of 02/15/2012)![]()
"OK, I will be to the point. This is a really good pie plate. It is a solid, heavy plate that will not burn your crust. It has a slotted cover so you can pull your pie right from the oven, let it cool just a bit, and then slap the top on it and take it to your friend's house for dinner without steaming the crust soggy. Or to a church potluck. Or whatever. When you have a good tool, with convenience built in, grab it. You will leave this plate to your kids. It would also make a great shower gift for not a heck of a lot of money." ~~ By Wordsmith
OXO Steel Pie Server
Another top quality OXO product.
This pie lifter features a brushed stainless-steel handle, flexible rubber fins for comfort, serrated edges for easy of cutting, a strong and flexible head. Dishwasher safe.
"The great part about this Oxo pie server is that it is strong and has serration on both sides of the blade. We are both right-handed in our house, but I still like that it is symmetrical. The blade is actually pretty sharp, but it probably has more to do with that it is really strong. This is not a bendable item, and I have no problem whatsoever cutting through whatever foods I am presented with." ~~ Ms. M. Nicholson
Click here to order your
Oxo Steel Pie Server
from Amazon.
$9.99
More Great Kitchen Tools
Including more OXO tools, the best salad spinner and some great kitchen timers.
I Use A Basic Wooden Rolling Pin
Danesco 2-3/4 by 10-Inch Beechwood Rolling Pin
Amazon Price: $22.00 (as of 02/15/2012)![]()
List Price:
I use a simple wooden rolling pin with a cylinder which turns. This one is made of Danish hardwood and cleans with warm soap and water.
The Best-Ever Country-Seed Bread Recipe
A wonderful, homemade bread perfect with chicken pot pie!
The Best-Ever Garden Salad Recipe
A crunchy green salad sets off this chicken pot pie perfectly.
Pot Pies By Beatrice A. Ojakangas
"For a hot, hearty meal after a cold day spent frolicking in the snow, what could be better than an easy, delicious pot pie? Beatrice Ojakangas dishes up forty varied recipes for pot pies, sure to please everyone's palate, from Finnish Country Vegetable Pie to Chicken Pot Pie with Roasted Peppers, Herbed Leek and Chèvre Tart, Seafood Gumbo Pie, Venison Pot Pie, and Pizza Pot Pie.
Beatrice Ojakangas is the author of more than twenty cookbooks, including The Great Scandinavian Baking Book (1999), Scandinavian Feasts (2001), The Great Holiday Baking Book (2001), and Quick Breads (2003)-all available in paperback from the University of Minnesota Press. Her articles have been published in Bon Appétit, Cooking Light, Cuisine, and Redbook, and she has appeared on television's Baking with Julia Child and Martha Stewart's Living. She lives in Duluth, Minnesota." ~~ Amazon
Click here to buy
Pot Pies for your cookbook collection
from Amazon.
"Hearing the words
chicken pot pie
make me feel like I'm in a haze of comfort
and if the words do that,
imagine what the food does!"
~~ Nigella Lawson
A Chicken Pot Pie T-Shirt
This shirt made me smile! Somebody clever dreamed it up.

Click here to order this Chicken Pot Pie t-shirt by apollo335
Shop the t-shirts section of zazzle
Have you ever had a homemade chicken pot pie?
My Complete Collection Of Best-Ever Recipes
A delicious, homemade Hawaiian punch.
The Best-Ever Lemon Cupcake Recipe
Martha Stewart and I share a unique journey to a yummy lemon cupcake.
The Best-Ever Sloppy Joes Recipe
A huge hit in our household, you will love these sloppy joes.
The Best-Ever Creamy Scalloped Potatoes
These creamy scalloped potatoes are definitely comfort food!
The Best-Ever Glazed Baked Ham
Delicious and EASY, is this baked ham recipe!
The Best-Ever Carrot Cake Recipe
The best carrot cake you will ever eat.
The Best-Ever Banana Bread
So easy to throw together and so delicious!
The Best-Ever Chicken Pot Pie
Homemade is the way to go if you want the tastiest chicken pot pie ever.
The Best-Ever M&M Cookies
So yummy you won't be able to stop at just one or two%u2026
The Best-Ever Hawaiian Potato Salad
Another family favorite, you will love this unique potato salad recipe.
The Best-Ever Corn Chowder Recipe
More comfort food, this one an amazing corn chowder.
Are you ready for a piece of chicken pot pie?
-
Reply
-
cffutah
Jan 18, 2012 @ 10:08 am | delete
- We just made this from scratch on Sunday, had company over and it was awesome to eat!
-
-
Reply
-
WriterJanis
Jan 8, 2012 @ 2:37 pm | delete
- This sounds really good.
-
-
Reply
-
GrammaLinda
Jan 8, 2012 @ 11:45 am | delete
- Sounds delicious. Chicken pot pie is one of my favorite dishes. I really like that you have instructions to make broth from the carcass. This is a process so many people ignore, but makes your food taste so much better.
-
-
Reply
-
Graceonline
Dec 30, 2011 @ 7:51 pm | delete
- You know, I've been making pies for years, but never made a chicken pot pie. I think I'll use some of my frozen turkey stock (from the Thanksgiving turkey) and make one up very soon. I love the idea of adding grated Parmesan to the crust. That has to make it extra delicious!
-
-
Reply
-
SereneSea
Dec 13, 2011 @ 7:02 am | delete
- Yummy and delicious recipe, nicely done - great for a get-together and family.
-
- Load More
Do you have some fantastic recipes in YOUR collection? You can create pages or lenses on Squidoo, too!
YES YOU CAN! Anyone can create pages or lenses on Squidoo!
by Treasures-By-Brenda
We do not eat chicken pot pie very often but when we do, we really do enjoy it! I hope you'll love my recipe, too!
- 518 featured lenses
- Top lens » Simple Affordable Little Girls Easter Dresses For Spring & Summer
- This lens »
Won purple star

Explore related pages
- My Best-Ever Recipes Collection My Best-Ever Recipes Collection
- The Best-Ever Creamy Scalloped Potatoes Recipe The Best-Ever Creamy Scalloped Potatoes Recipe
- The Best-Ever Glazed Baked Ham Recipe The Best-Ever Glazed Baked Ham Recipe
- The Best-Ever Lemon Cupcakes Recipe Adventure Story The Best-Ever Lemon Cupcakes Recipe Adventure Story
- The Best-Ever Banana Bread Recipe The Best-Ever Banana Bread Recipe
- The Best-Ever Maple Cupcakes, A Maple Syrup Recipe The Best-Ever Maple Cupcakes, A Maple Syrup Recipe


