Question: How to get edited videos onto youtube from a mobile cell phone?

dannystaple by dannystaple
Last updated: 09/06/2011

How would you get films from a nokia phone onto youtube?

I have a conundrum, and I am sure I am not the first person to face it. I own a Nokia n73 phone, which is in the n-series, which includes the n95 that produces similar video streams. This applies to many other phones too.

How do I get those phones through a video editor, where I can manipulate them, and eventually onto Youtube?
I am looking for answers from people - on Squidoo, Youtube and Twitter.
Read on for info - but this is chance to have your say, and promote your solution. I will even show you a place you can write it, and earn commission on it if you have not got a place!

Current Best Solution - Youtube itself

Youtube has moved on in leaps and bounds since I originally wrote this lens. Youtube now can take 3gp/amr files as uploads directly. A user can upload a bunch of clips without sharing them, and then use youtube's own video editor to create the video.

You can then also add music to the video from Youtube's vast licenses music library. Sure, this may not compete with the top expensive video editors in features, but for most users, wanting to do what I did, it is definitely good enough.

It also makes the above diagram simpler - you can then link phone with the computer and then to youtube, or with more recent phones - Android phones for example, you can put the video directly on youtube, and just use a computer to do the editing.

Android based phones allow direct uploading

Using Android phones with some of the latest software, and Videos can be directly uploaded to Youtube. By uploading and keeping them private, they can the be edited into a sequence that is published. This is by far the easiest way to achieve this. The lens was originally about Nokia phones, but these days a new Android phone is far cheaper than video software, and will save plenty of the frustration. It is also worth mentioning that support for Nokia phones in general is likely to have a very limited lifespan now.
Loading

The Basic Idea

So simply put, this is the workflow I want to facilitate:


  • Copy videos from my phone to my computer.

  • Edit those files into a short film.

  • Output the film to youtube.



In the above diagram, each arrow is one of these steps. Conversion/transcode steps are implied, but I know they may be necessary.

I am looking for the cheapest and least hassle solution. I am trying to avoid adware/malware, and clearly free is the cheapest but if a small fee gets me something much better (with enough of a trial to verify that really is the case) then I would go for that too.

Companies wishing to showcase their video editing packages are welcome here.

If you have a solution, but need a web page to write about it - then Make a page here, free - better still you will even get commission for it.

The Phone - Nokia n73

The phone I own at the time of writing this is a Nokia n73. It is fairly common, and similar to much of the Nokia n series, as well as other smartphones of its class.
It has 2 cameras, both capable of video. One is geared towards video conferencing, and the other has a rather nice autofocus lens and 3.2 Mp ccd. It is ok for photos, if a little slow, and the video is not too bad - not particularly high resolution or high frame rate, but at the time of writing, it accounts for the closest to a camcorder I have ever owned and the best video capture device I have owned.

I already have a bunch of footage recorded on this, so although I am likely to invest in a proper camcorder, that footage needs this treatment. Plus others are probably in the same situation.

The phone by default creates video files which are 3gp videos with AMR audio. Both are described below. I transfer them to my PC via a link cable in either storage media mode or pc link mode.

About the Nokia n73
About 3gp video
About AMR audio

An alternative solution

If you have not already taken the video (but I have) one alternative, which is to use a Digital Video Camera designed for the purpose. Mobile phones cameras and video taking is more designed for picture and multimedia messaging than creating edited videos.

There are a number of great and inexpensive options, including camera designed entirely for getting video's onto youtube. Also they often come with reasonable video editing software bundled.
Loading

Nokia smartphones

Loading

My computer resources

As I have stated, I have not yet made outlay for a camcorder. I am looking for a solution that will run on what I have.

The computer I own is a 2Ghz Dual Core machine, 2gb RAM and with shuffling about, 400Gb of disk space I could use (150 here, 250 there).



Velocity Micro Performance PCs


It is running either Windows Vista (Ultimate Edition) or Ubuntu Linux. Solutions that require a mac will be mentioned here, but will not be featured unless buying a Mac and its software is actually a cheaper/simpler move than other solutions. The ideal solution will involve just downloading software and possibly paying a small fee.

What kind of computer do you use for video editing?

Some people consider Apple machines as the only platform that can do video editing well. Some others use other platforms - Windows, Linux or even lesser known things like BSD.

So, do you think Mac is the only way for video, or do you use something else?

Is Mac the only real platform for Video Editing?

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

No, Windows/Linux or some other OS will do!

Laura says:

My bb is a mac and I'll still go with any *nix will do esp. at this level (no idea if the overhead in windows makes it a good idea but I'm pretty sure some pros try somehow and I'm certain amateurs use it) - or maybe even the latest Amiga ;) .

dannystaple says:

I am asking the questions, but I think that most OS's can do this. Mac platforms did have a head start but I don't think it counts for that much any more.

Yes, other stuff wont cut it. Steve Jobs is a legend.

mymusic1234 says:

I personally prefer Mac although I do have a windows machine. The Mac just is more stable.

mymusic1234 says:

I personally prefer the Mac for video and audio editing although I do have a windows machine. To me the Mac just seems more stable.

 

Try to keep it clearly costable

Solutions with "price on request" will not make the top of list or be featured. I prefer (as do most people) prices that are clearly stated.

For things that are free - free is great, but finding hidden costs, like having to buy an additional license to actually save the project or something, will also be considered very negatively. If those costs are stated upfront, so that those downloading it know what will happen, it is fine. If it is in the small print, or not mentioned, that will IMHO count negatively toward it.

Love This Lens?

If you would like to rate this lens, then you can do so here (Squidoo members only)

This module only appears with actual data when viewed on a live lens. The favorite and lensroll options will appear on a live lens if the viewer is a member of Squidoo and logged in.

Add this to your lens »

Share your solutions here

If you have a simple link, submit it to the link list above, if you want to write a page of info, use the link above to create the page then submit it.
If you have a one liner, or comments about this page - improvements, group suggestions and so on, then add them here. I would love to hear what you have to say on the subject. Simple HTML (a, b and p) is allowed.

submit

About Danny Staple

Loading

This HOT APPS page written by

dannystaple

I have a number of articles now and think it is the right time to make videos to accompany them. However, I am not an expert on everything - so I am asking... more »

A guide to the hottest mobile apps around. Both iOS and Android. Curated by the Dolphin Browser team.

Connect with HOT APPS

This author recommends...