It should have been Duckie!

Ranked #9,223 in Entertainment, #103,821 overall

Would you have picked Duckie or Blane? For me it's a no-brainer!

Did you ever see the John Hughes movie Pretty in Pink? If so, how did you find the ending? Did it feel like there was something amiss? I always thought that Andie (Molly Ringwald) should've chosen Duckie (Jon Cryer) in the end, after all he was there for her all the time -- especially when Blane (Andrew McCarthy), the guy she ended up choosing, did not stand up for her in front of his rich, snobby friend Steff and the rest of the billionaire boys & girls club. What was that all about?

Well, the truth is what we saw was not the original ending. Prince Charming should've been Duckie like we knew in our hearts all along.

I actually liked Pretty in Pink the first time I saw it in the 80s, even though I felt bad for Duckie at the end of the movie. Learning the truth a couple of decades later stirred up that feeling again. Read on and I'll show you why I, and a lot of other movie fans, think Duckie deserved a chance.

Blane or Duckie -- who's it gonna be? 

Who did you want Andie to end up with, Duckie or Blaine?

Cast your votes here.

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Would you have picked Duckie or Blaine?

Your thoughts are most welcome.

If you were Andie, would you have chosen Duckie or Blane?

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

I'm with Duckie all the way!

Ana says:

Duckie is amazing! he loves her and he is really unique. blaine isnt good enough for her! plus duckies hot.

ThatsYourPeople says:

Duckie was the man. I spent the entire movie wondering what she saw in Blaine then completely lost respect for her when she picked him.

Gina says:

Duckie! I mean Blaine was too much of a pussy to stick up for Andie to his best friend. And he never introduced her as a girlfriend or anything like that. Not to mention, he took her to some party she didn't want to go to begin with.

Alice says:

yesssssss im 12 years old...and i tottaly love this movie i saw this movie like afteryesterday.... and i see every day two n a half men just to see the old duckie...jajaja.... I love duckieee... <3

kimaje says:

Duckie!

gracezmom says:

people don't know that it wasn't filmed as writer wanted so it was remade as Somekind of wonderful where the Andy(Eric Stoltz) ended up with Ducky(Mary Stewart Masterson). That was suppose to be the really story line of Pretty in pink. Pretty in Pink is a Bastard child of the original screen play!!!

Maria says:

Duckie!!!

DuckieFan says:

Duckie!

milk says:

no flippin way would i choose blane he is uglier than vin diesel!

tiffany says:

duckie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! he stuck by andie all the way and never did anything to hurt her, and never doubted that he liked her unlike blane........ so i choose duckie.! he is the best!!!!!!!!! i love duckie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Stuff says:

Duckie is uber awesome!

anonymous says:

duckie ! blane is cute and all but duckie was always there for andie, how could she be so blind and ungrateful ?! And anyways, who can say no to that cutie pie face of duckie's ? :3

alice says:

duckieeeee <3<3<3

Lisa says:

The Duckman of Course

Mint says:

Duckie! No doubt about it.

Angela says:

Duckie

Jewelsofawe says:

Duckie for sure!

arncyn says:

Every girl needs a Duckie Dale in her life - someone reliable, cool (well, in an alterna-hip kind of way) and romantic.

Andie got it right. Team Blane forever!

kia says:

duckie is way sexier than blaine i think blaine is ugly and ducki is way funnier and fun !

davia says:

BLANE,i like duckie but he's her best friend but sometimes u just don't love them like that no matter how much they r in love with u (i've been through it)
blane is hot and romantic and he does care for andie u saw from the star he had a crush on her he even said he will always love her plus he treated her with respect and made her smile

Jen says:

Blane! I fell in love with him too!

 

Duckie vs. Blane: The short of it

Pretty in Pink's plot in 2 minutes and 12 seconds.

If you haven't seen Pretty in Pink and have no idea what I'm talking about, check out this short, and may I add, very funny, video explaining why Duckie should've been IT.
powered by Youtube

Better yet, just go watch the movie first

And then tell me what you think later.

The Pretty in Pink (Everything's Duckie Edition) DVD has a featurette called "The Lost Dance" which describes the original ending wherein Duckie ends up getting the girl. It was also revealed that test audiences said they would have preferred to see Blane win Andie's heart. Additionally, Molly Ringwald was sick during the filming of the ending and John Hughes wasn't satisfied with the editing. He was also concerned that audiences would take the original ending as a message that poor people and rich people don't belong together.

Well, despite the ending mishap, I actually did like the movie in its entirety. It's a John Hughes classic that's reflective of teenage life back in the 80s and should definitely be part of any generation X-er's collection.

Pretty in Pink (Everything's Duckie Edition)

Amazon Price: $5.29 (as of 02/13/2012)Buy Now

From Amazon: The era of Molly Ringwald's profitable collaboration with writer-producer-director John Hughes was at its peak with this 1986 film. Ringwald plays a high school girl on the budget side of the tracks, living with her warm and loving father (Harry Dean Stanton) and usually accompanied by her insecure best friend (Jon Cryer). When a wealthy but well-meaning boy (Andrew McCarthy) asks her out, her perspective is overturned and Cryer's character is threatened.

The famous "Try A Little Tenderness" Duckie performance

His fantastic Otis Redding impression.

powered by Youtube

Jon Cryer speaks on Duckie's behalf

Juicy information from an insider, two decades later.

Duckman T-Shirt shirt
Duckman T-Shirt

Diablo Cody talked to Jon Cryer (Duckie) in 2008 about Pretty in Pink and he reveals in the three-part interview that Molly Ringwald (Andie) was very close to producer John Hughes and she had convinced him to make her character end up with Blane (Andrew McCarthy) because she had a crush on the actor. He also reveals in the video I've attached below that Robert Downey Jr. was initially cast for the part of Duckie and that if it had been Robert instead of Jon who played the role, Molly would have agreed for her character to end up with Duckie. Uh-huh.

Molly pretty much confirms that she had a crush on Robert Downey in the DVD featurette "All About Molly".

Part 1 / Part 2 (watch it below) / Part 3

powered by Youtube

People are still talking about Duckie and Blaine

Blogs that mention the great Duckie and Blane debate.

In 2012, these restaurants are opening soon in a Twin Cities neighborhood near you
(The first was Blaine, different franchisee). In addition to 51 types of customizable sandwiches, there are also salads, chips, cookies and thick shakes. Wi-Fi, loyalty cards, a kids' menu and a free birthday sandwich are also part of the mix.

Calling Team Duckie

More t-shirts to support our cause.

Team Duckie shirtI would've picked Duckie! shirtAndie & Duckie shirt

And if there's anything perfect about the movie at all, it's the soundtrack:

Pretty In Pink: Original Motion Picture Soundtrack

Amazon Price: $4.44 (as of 02/13/2012)Buy Now

Few filmmakers managed to capture the awkward coming-of-age catastrophes of '80s teens the way John Hughes did, just as few soundtracks encapsulate the sound of an era better than this one does. It's not the best 1986 had to offer, but it's a cohesive whole, transporting the listener to that other time, imagined or otherwise. There's enough variety to ensure that it doesn't become wallpaper, and very little filler. "Left of Center" by Suzanne Vega, with Joe Jackson on piano, is tremendous and transcends generations. Psychedelic Furs frontman Richard Butler has long been bemused about Hughes not taking Molly Ringwald's character's name from the title song, which inspired the film, but everyone was paying too much attention to what Ducky was wearing to notice anyway. --Scott Wilson

His name is Blane? That's a major appliance, that's not a name!  

Is there anything else you'd like to add?

Let me know.

Your thoughts are most welcome!

submit

Send some love (or stars, if you please)

Your opinion matters to me.

If you would like to rate this lens, please do so here.

This module only appears with actual data when viewed on a live lens. The favorite and lensroll options will appear on a live lens if the viewer is a member of Squidoo and logged in.

Add this to your lens »

This page is called a Squidoo lens.
If you're passionate about something -- anything! --,
you can make a lens about it and even earn money on the side.
Isn't that awesome?
Click on the button below to get started!

Loading

If you leave,

don't leave now.

Check out these other lenses I made on 80s pop culture.
Loading

by

arncyn

I design retro graphic tees & funky wedding invitations and blog about asian pop culture in my free time. I'm also the designated Squid Angel for Weddings:... more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!

Take the John Hughes movie quiz! 

See how well you know your 80s teen films

Loading

Pretty In Pink: Original Motion Picture Soundtrack  

Relive high school and the 80s

Pretty In Pink: Original Motion Picture Soundtrack

Amazon Price: $4.44 (as of 02/13/2012)Buy Now

Few filmmakers managed to capture the awkward coming-of-age catastrophes of '80s teens the way John Hughes did, just as few soundtracks encapsulate the sound of an era better than this one does. It's not the best 1986 had to offer, but it's a cohesive whole, transporting the listener to that other time, imagined or otherwise.

Pretty in Pink (1986) 

Pretty in Pink

Amazon Price: $4.90 (as of 02/13/2012)Buy Now

This John Hughes movie will forever be a classic. It's a must-have for any DVD collection!