Kirk Vs Picard

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic by 3 people | Log in to rate

Ranked #3,312 in Entertainment, #89,468 overall

HERE'S WHAT I THINK

Kirk Vs Picard

It's a debate as old as time itself... who was the better captain, James T. Kirk or Jean Luc Picard? Kirk was a dashing fellow who flew by the seat of his pants and often took off those pants to romance some space aliens. Picard was much more thoughtful, respected his crew more and intelligently led the USS Enterprise out of the most dangerous of situations. It's like nerd vs jock except, well, they are both nerds.

MAKE IT SO! 

KhaaaannnnnnnnnnN!

Let the world know who captain's your ship.

Kirk Vs Picard

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

Kirk all the way, dude!

Rain says:

first of all both captains are awesome in their own way. but kirk has this big ego for being stupid and reckless which isn't actually true. for example he plays chess (and beat a vulcan!), one of his old starfleet friends said he was a "stack of book on legs, aka he was a total nerd, plus he beat the maur karyoshi (i know i spelled that wrong) simulation! also it's stated that the enterprise comes before women (even those w/ green skin). it was stated multiple times! (although he does later sacrifice the enterprise for spock-but spocks awesome!)i'm not saying he's not totally bad @ss-he is! but he also has a head on his shoulders and he doesn't let relationships get in the way of being captain.

Calagara says:

Kirk has it all. Picard would have to absorb Ryker and Worf just to get in the ring . . .

Dead Red Shirt #2720 says:

Kirk all the way! Who else are you going to trust in a fight with the bad guys but a guy who snorts Romulan Ale before doing battle with the next half-human sex-pot in a mini skirt? (um... she'd be wearing the mini-skirt, although you'd never know with Kirk after a few drinks...)

Victoria_Neely says:

Kirk got all the hot alien babes.

Jimmie says:

I'm a rarity -- a girl trekkie! I love sci fi.

Kirk is awesome -- a real man's man. Picard is great too but you chose the best word for him -- aloof. When it comes down to Kirk vs. Picard, I have to go with my childhood hero --Captain Kirk. Besides, I like hair. Kirk's got Picard in this area.

Picard is my choice, good fellow.

Slade says:

picard wore a red shirt....didn't die

Mel says:

Jean-Luc Picard all the way. He respects authority, yet does not blindly follow orders and is a very intellectual man. Certainly a positive role model for young men.

fefe says:

Picard. Tea. Earl Gray. Hot.

Monteath says:

It's gotta' be Picard. He has an awesome military manuever named after him, and he has a James Bond like class, but is willing to take on the klingons in hand to hand. Picard rocks.

steve ross says:

1. Spock.
2. Picard.
3. Hippie McCoy w/ medallion.
4. Kirk.

famousmortimer says:

I'm gonna start off brief and reserve the right to change my mind. TNG got me into Star Trek and Picard was my intellectual hero. But now that I'm older I really appreciate all the aliens that Kirk has punched in the face and/or sexed up. It's a hard decision, but for now I'm going with my first love.

 

Also check out my blog about HMB 

A blog about HMB? YES!

www.famousmortimer.wordpress.com

I grab and link up the best arguments on HMB and blog my blogger all about them. If you have something you would like featured on there contact me for consideration.

P.S. Anything I make on HMB gets automatically featured. It's really awesome to be me.

Hahahaaha 

hohohoho

Yes, I made the url kirkvsspock. Did I do it on purpose? No, I didn't. But I can't figure out how to edit it, so it is now on display for everyone to see how big of an idiot I am.

/bow

by famousmortimer

A magic beam of light that does nothing to fill up the room. (more)

Explore related pages

Related Topics

Create a Lens!