CRISIS IN SCHOOL MANAGEMENT: Making Schools Work for Everybody
In our big cities 50% of our students do not graduate from high school, and in the nation as whole 30% on average do not graduate. And these numbers have remained the same or have gotten worse for years, even after all attempts at school reforms, including No Child Left Behind. Imagine trying to run a business with those rates of failure.
Actually, we've had well over a century of failed school reforms, yet we keep trying to reform our schools, hoping to finally make them effective. Why do most attempts at reforming our schools fail? They fail because the school management system is structured in the out dated style of 19th-century manufacturing -- a bureaucratic management that imposes its will on the school culture - often by pressure from the political culture - without collaborating with everyone. That's a surefire way to fail and it's a way that does not create an effective learning environment. Schools cannot be reformed; they must be TRANSFORMED into organizations that are democratically managed.
There is compelling evidence that democratically run organizations are highly effective. In this lens and in greater detail in my book, CRISIS IN SCHOOL MANAGEMENT, (free e-book), you will find this compelling evidence, and you will find how to build a positive environment in which everyone matters, through a management system of collaboration -- a system that some schools are now using and a system that many successful business organizations have long been using. Below, and in my book, you will also find resources especially for management practices that help build schools that work for everyone. And in the section below called TRIM TAB ACTIVITIES, you will find simple actions that anyone can take to help initiate a turn towards this transformation.
My Bloggings
Reactions to news and to other's ideas about schools
Fetching RSS feed... please stand byBooks for Helping to Build a Collaborative Organization
Here are some other vital resources for helping build a democratically collaborative organization:
TRIM TAB ACTIVITIES FOR TRANSFORMING A SCHOOL
MAKING SCHOOLS WORK FOR EVERYBODY
R. Buckminster Fuller once said he wanted to be a trim tab: the little rudder that turns the big rudder that turns the ship. He further added that "The child is really the trim tab of the future."In this module you'll find some trim tabs ways for helping to transform our schools.Schools can't be reformed; they need to be transformed - - turned into places that work for everyone. They need to turn away from the outdated bureaucratic, command and control management model of the industrial era, and instead turning to the successful model of democratic collaboration practiced by many businesses and schools.
In transformed schools, everyone is mutually RESPECTED, APPRECIATED, RECOGNIZED, and RESPONSIBLE. This is especially accomplished through three management practices explained in my book. There you will also find compelling evidence of successful organizations where these practices are being used.
TRIM TAB ACTIONS
Transforming our schools may seem like a tall order, but if we remember the trim tab concept, then all that is needed is for someone to do a simple trim tab action. Here are simple trim tab actions anyone can take to begin to turn around the large ship of education.
AS A PARENT:
1. Get other parents, teachers and students to join in collecting, writing, and publishing (hard copy and web site) the school's history and the school's best practices. Gather information from alumnae, long time residents of the area, newspaper archives, politicians, business people. Explain the history behind the school's name (or number). Tell about any famous people who went to the school, and if possible, get them to make a visit to the school. Have a school history recognition day.
2. Start a study group to read/discuss books related to building an organization in which everyone matters. Some are listed above in this lens and others are in my book. Invite anyone to attend: school people, students, parents, politicians, business people, community leaders. Encourage everyone to put into practice in all aspects of their personal lives as well as in school such practices as appreciative inquiry, servant leadership, transparency, recognition, respect, and responsibility.
AS A STUDENT:
1. Initiate a newsletter of the school's history, best practices and strengths. 2. Practice being appreciative of teachers' best practices.
(Board members and administrators, see my book CRISIS IN SCHOOL MANAGEMENT at www.jamesevers.com.)
TRIM TAB IDEAS FOR ADMINISTRATORS, TEACHERS, BOARD MEMBERS
from CRISIS IN SCHOOL MANAGMENT
Administrator1. Bring together stakeholders to collect statements about what's good about the school or district, what's working well, and what are its best practices, and its history. (See APPRECIATIVE INQUIRY SUMMIT)
2. Become a Servant Leader to all stakeholders and ask all stakeholders to regularly evaluate your strengths as a servant to their needs.
3. Make all finances transparent.
School Board Member
1. Encourage chief administrator to initiate activities above.
2. Ask all board members and the administrators to read The Great Game of Business and/or A Stake in the Action.
3. Read CRISIS IN SCHOOL MANAGEMENT (free download at http://jamesevers.com)
Teacher
1. Begin practicing the art of supporting students' strengths before making suggestions for improvement.
2. Be a servant leader to students, parents, fellow teachers, and administrators
3. Get a group of colleagues together to share best practices. (A good model of these practices can be found in Writing IQ Program, a free download for teachers at http?? http//www.jamesevers.com.)
4. Have students collect stories of the school's history from any source: parents, alumnae, senior citizens, retired teachers, and retired administrators.
Key Resources:
CRISIS IN SCHOOL MANAGEMENT (http://www.jamesevers.com)
SERVANT LEADERSHIP (amazon.com)
APPRECIATIVE INQUIRY SUMMIT (amazon.com)
GREAT GAME OF BUSINESS (amazon.com)
A STAKE IN THE ACTION (amazon.com)
DEVELOPING THE WRITING IQ PROGRAM (http://www.jamesevers.com)
What's a Democratic Organization?
The fonder of WorldBlu explains democratic organzations
Traci Fenton, WorldBlu CEO, on organizational democracy
Traci Fenton, Founder + CEO of WorldBlu Inc., talks about what organizational democracy is and isn't.
Runtime: 4:28
3411 views
3 Comments:
OTHER TRANSFORMING IDEAS
Other thoughts for helping transform our schools
COMPUTERS FOR THE POORIn the early days of PCs, I had suggested to several CEOs of corporations that giving a PC to each poor child would be a good way to help them improve their reading and writing. The cost then was too prohibitive. However, under the inspiration and guidance of Nicholas Negroponte at MIT a $100,highly effective laptop has been developed for poor kids and poor nations. It's called the X-O Laptop. Negroponte then organized One Laptop Per Child an organization helping to distribute the computer and the vision. Go to their web site at http:www.laptop.org
GLOSSARY
Terms used in Crisis in School Management: Making Schools Work for Everyone
To help you start an understanding of some of the practices used in organizations that work well for everyone, here is a glossary of these practices. I write in detail about these in my book Crisis in School Management (free download at jamesevers.com).SERVANT LEADERSHIP (SL)
A worldwide practice, SL was initiated in the 1960s by Robert Greenleaf. It is both a philosophy and a practice calling for leaders to be resourceful servants and role models to those whom they serve (lead). And it is a call for all other members and stakeholders to do the same for those whom they serve. A key concept is that the leader is servant first but considers her/himself to be first among equals, not a boss over others.
(See www.greenleaf.org)
APPRECIATIVE INQUIRY (AI)
Initiated in the 1980s by David Cooperrider, and practiced world wide, AI is a positive change or renewal process that focuses on the strengths and best practices in an organization, a systematic discovery of what gives "life" to an organization when it is most effective. (See appreciativeinquiry.case.edu/)
OPEN BOOK MANAGEMENT/TRANSPARANCY
Open book management, initiated by Jack Stack in the late 1980s, and practiced world wide, is a management process that gives all employees the key financial numbers of an organization as well as a stake (ownership) in the outcome. It makes all employees stewards of the well being of the organization and of each other. (See www.ggob.com)
ORGANIZATIONS WHERE EVERYONE MATTERS
Collaboration Abounds
In his book, The Predictable Failure of School Reforms, Seymour B. Sarason, Yale Psychology Professor Emeritus, says that we will never get school reforms right until we get the power relationships right in our schools both of administrators toward teachers and other administrators and teachers toward students. You can't have power games going on and still expect to create an environment in which everyone matters.Here are names of some of the hundreds of organizations in which everyone does matter:
SOME ORGANIZATIONS THAT PRACTICE OPEN BOOK/TRANSPARENCY
Springfield Remanufacturing, Harley-Davidson, VeriFone, Outback Steakhouse, Herman Miller, Home Depot, Science Applications International Corporation, AES Corporation, Whole Food Market, Kingston Technology, and Service-Master. It also includes oil companies, hair salons, internet companies, a roller coaster manufacturer, fast-food chains, law firms, landscaping companies, furniture retailers, mining operations, municipal governments, non-profit organizations, and schools such as alternative and charter schools.
SOME ORGANIZATIONS THAT PRACTICE SERVANT LEADERSHIP
ServiceMaster, Toro Co., Synovus Austin Medical, Parkland Hospital, Ascension Health, hundreds more nationally and internationally, and many colleges, and universities.
SOME ORGANIZATIONS THAT PRACTICE APPRECIATIVE INQUIRY
Roadway Express, Hunter Douglas, Blue Shield, EPA, U.S. Navy, City of Berkeley, City of Denver, Cleveland Clinic, hundreds more around the world, and hundreds of schools in England, Scotland, Germany, Australia, Canada, and the U.S.
DEMOCRATICALLY MANAGED CORPORATIONS
Here's a baker's dozen podcasts from WorldBlu's CONFERENCE ON ORGANIZATIONAL DEMOCRACY(http://www.worldblu.com/forum/podcasts.php)
1:DAN PINK, AUTHOR, "A WHOLE NEW MIND", tells why business people need to think like designers and what design has to do with organizational democracy.
2: ANN PRICE, CEO MOTEK, a democratic company in Beverly Hills, California, talks about how her employees democratically run the business.
3: GRAHAM PARKER, GENERAL DIRECTOR, ORPHEUS CHAMBER ORCHESTRA, talks about the world's only conductorless orchestra, the most democratic orchestra in the world.
4: FREDO ARIAS-KING, CEO, T&R CHEMICAL, tells how his boundless energy, worldwide network and strategic thinking combine to work for lasting democracy around the world.
5: BASHAR AL-NAHER, REPRESENTATIVE OF THE PRIME MINISTER OF IRAQ, representative outside of Iraq of the current Iraqi Prime Minister, Dr. Ibrahim Al-Jafaari, talks about bridging the gap and harmonize the relationship between the Muslim world and the West.
6: ALEXANDER KJERULF, CEO, HAPPY AT WORK PROJECT, explains why happiness belongs in the workplace, and why it's a major success factor for organizational success.
7: RALF BEUKER, FOUNDER, DESIGN THINKING INSTITUTE, a leading expert on design, management, and business and the founder of the Design Thinking Institute, talks about design.
8: ANDREI CHERNEY, AUTHOR, "THE NEXT DEAL"
At age 21, he became the youngest speechwriter in the White House in American history. Here Andrei offers his historical insights on the evolution of workplace management and what it means to business today.
9: STEPHEN SHAPIRO, AUTHOR, "GOAL-FREE LIVING", "24/7 Innovation" and "Goal-Free Living," explains that a "compass instead of a map" in life allows for the adaptability needed into today's work, personal, and global environment.
10: ROOSEVELT FINLAYSON, CEO, FESTIVAL IN THE WORKPLACE INSTITUTE, talks about The Festival in the Workplace
PODCAST 11: US NAVAL ACADEMY MIDSHIPMEN, US NAVAL ACADEMY, say that not only corporations who can benefit from the principles of organizational democracy, but the military can too.
12: DAVID WEINBERGER, CO-AUTHOR, THE CLUETRAIN MANIFESTO,
speaks on the potential impact of using freedom, rather than fear, to govern the workplace.
13: RITA BAILEY, FORMER DIRECTOR, SOUTHWEST AIRLINES UNIVERSITY, former director of Southwest Airlines University, talks about how she helped build Southwest Airlines into a model democratic company.
New Guestbook
Stefani-girl wrote...
Great lens! 5 stars. You are highlighting a very important cause. Best wishes, Stefani.
Coral_Milburn_Curtis wrote...
Excellent resource for parents and teachers. 5 stars and straight into my lensroll. It is about time that education authorities realised that flogging old failing methods will only get you failing results. A new dawn is required. in education. Full marks to you, from a fellow school principal. Coral
A School and a Workpalce Where Everybody Matters
Democracy in The School and Workplace
Interview with Ricardo Semler
Interview with Ricardo Semler, Chairman of Brazilian Company Semco, a democratic workplace. Aired on Australian ABC television 7:30 Report March 2007 Check out this video for a tour of SEMCO: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gG3HPX0D2mU&feature=related
Runtime: 10:25
21946 views
10 Comments:
CHARLIE LEADBEATER ON COLLABORATION AND CREATIVITY
Charlie Leadbeater at Nesta Uploading Innovation
Charlie's 3 minute opener
Runtime: 4:14
2582 views
0 Comments:
What's Your Favorite Resource for Transforming Our Schools?
This module is for you and other readers to share titles of important resources for transforming our schools
AN EXCITING VOLUNTEER PROGRAM FOR CITY KIDS
Professional Writers Create a Drop-In Center That's Very Popular
Dave Eggers: 2008 TED Prize wish: Once Upon a School
http://www.ted.com Accepting his 2008 TED Prize, author Dave Eggers asks the TED community to personally, creatively engage with local public schools. With spellbinding eagerness, he talks about how his 826 Valencia tutoring center inspired others around the world to open their own volunteer-driven, wildly creative writing labs. But you don't need to go that far, he reminds us -- it's as simple as asking a teacher "How can I help?" He asks that we share our own volunteering stories at his new website, Once Upon a School.
Runtime: 24:30
17518 views
10 Comments:
CHILDREN'S LITERATURE TEACHING POSITIVE VALUES AND TOLERANCE
Jeff Fifield, Curriculum Facilitator at Colegio Maya American International School of Guatemal, sent the following request to members of the Positive Change Core (Appreciative Inquiry):"Every year at our elementary school during the month of February we promote a reading incentive month where our students begin with a school-wide read of one book that set's the tone/theme for the month. Last year's example was "The Three Questions" by Jon Muth (the story is based on Tolstoy's book of the same title) which was chosen so as to promote 'finding almost a Zen inner-peace through doing good deeds' amongst our young students. The illustrations are beautiful and complimentary.
This year, I am wondering if there might be a picture book that might lend itself to providing an 'Appreciative Inquiry' lens that might be suitable for your young readers. Any suggestions?"
Jeff has received several responses that I'm posting here for those of you interested in letting children experience through a reading context such thinking as Appreciative Inquiry, mindfulness, tolerance, etc.
"The WrongStone" by Russell Deal
www.innovativeresources.org/display_details.aspx?productcode=6050
This picture book I think is wonderfully appreciative, and which I use extensively (with adults as well as with children!) It's published in Australia by Innovative Resources. The story is a wonderful way to start the conversations about accepting people who are different and appreciating the unuique contribution everyone can make - as well as appreciating oneself!
"The Man Who Loved Boxes" by Stephen Michael King
www.aussiereviews.com/article1814.html
Sadly this is not available through Amazon and a quick search hasn't produced a purchasing source on the web. But I assume some other sources would have it - it was published in 1996.
"The Wonderful Life of a Fly Who Couldn't Fly" by Bo Lozoff
tinyurl.com/27zyn2
"The Red Tree" by Shaun Tan
tinyurl.com/2gk474
"The Spy Glass" by Richard Evans
It's about seeing the possibilities and then making it so. Although it uses the word "faith" I don't think it needs to be taken in a religious sense. If there would be sensitivity about that in your context, thought, you might substitute another word that would convey the same meaning.
"Imagine a Day" by Sarah L. Thomson with paintings by Rob Gonsalves
http://www.amazon.com/Imagine-Day-Byron-Preiss-Book/dp/0689852193
This book encourages the reader to look at the world through the lens of possibility.
"Imagine a Night" by Sarah L. Thomson with paintings by Rob Gonsalves
www.amazon.com/Imagine-Night-Rob-Gonsalves/dp/0689852185
"The Pumpkin Patch" by Margaret McNamara and Mike Gordon
http://www.amazon.com/Pumpkin-Patch-Ready-Read-Level/dp/0689858744
"The Wrong Stone" by Russell Deal
The story is a wonderful way to start the conversations about accepting people who are different and appreciating the unique contribution everyone can make - as well as appreciating oneself! (may not be available - Aussie)
"The Red Tree" by Shaun Tan
www.amazon.com/Red-Tree-Shaun-Tan/dp/0968876838
The Empty Pot by Demi
www.amazon.com/Empty-Pot-Owlet-Book/dp/0805049002
A Chinese boy with an green thumb wins the emperor's competition; PW praised the "extraordinarily delicate Oriental landscapes." Ages 4-7.
IS YOUR SCHOOL DESTROYING YOUR CHILD'S CREATIVITY?
Sir Ken Robinson: Do schools kill creativity?
http://www.ted.com Sir Ken Robinson makes an entertaining and profoundly moving case for creating an education system that nurtures (rather than undermines) creativity. TEDTalks is a daily video podcast of the best talks and performances from the TED Conference, where the world's leading thinkers and doers are invited to give the talk of their lives in 18 minutes -- including speakers such as Jill Bolte Taylor, Sir Ken Robinson, Hans Rosling, Al Gore and Arthur Benjamin. TED stands for Technology, Entertainment, and Design, and TEDTalks cover these topics as well as science, business, politics and the arts. Watch the Top 10 TEDTalks on TED.com, at http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/top10
Runtime: 20:03
722120 views
10 Comments:
Additional Resources on Making Schools Work for Everyone
Here are more resources for making schools or any organization work well for all of its stake holders.
Teen Voices from the Holy Land: Who Am I to You? by Mahmoud Watad
Read the words (voices) of Palestinian and Israeli more...0 points
The Future of Management by Gary Hamel, Bill Breen
What fuels long-term business success? Not operati more...0 points
The Leader in Me: How Schools and Parents Around the World Are Inspiring Greatness, One Child At a Time by Stephen R. Covey
The world has entered an era of the most profound more...0 points
Links for Making Schools and All Organizations Work for Everyone
http://www.squidoo.com/preventbullying/
Turn here for help with bullying.3 points
http://www.squidoo.com/confidentchildren
What do you want for your child? The answer invari more...3 points
www.squidoo.com/dyslexiology
Should you let dyslexia be a barrier to your succe more...3 points
Raising Boys
What is it with boys?
Boys are different - have more...3 points
Positive Deviance Initiative
Similar to Appreciaitve Inquiry1 point
Robert K. Greenleaf Center for Servant-Leadership
Home site of Servant Leadership1 point
WorldBlu | Designing Democratic Organizations
WorldBlu, Inc., is a leadership and business desig more...1 point
lumiar.org
A democratically run school, factory, and foundati more...1 point
http://www.netform.com/html/netmanage.pdf (managing networks)
How to manange network structured organizations1 point
http://www.essentialschools.org/pub/ces_docs/about/about.htm
Home site of Essential Schools1 point
www.chaordic.org
All about chaordic management1 point
Celebrate Schools with LifeTrek Coaching
Great articles about transformed schools1 point
http://www.squidoo.com/pollyklaas/hq
The Child Safety Program and Kit1 point
http://www.squidoo.com/Confessions-Of-An-Internet-Researcher/
Lots of help for the internet researcher1 point
http://www.emergingfutures.net/>
Enabling people and organizations to fulfill their more...1 point
Question Resources
Resources for effective questioning1 point
Leaders for the Long Haul
How Roadway Express found value in Appreciative In more...1 point
http://www.gervasebushe.ca/AI_pos.pdf
Appreciaitve Inquiry is not about the Positive1 point
http://www.temple.edu/education/newdeel/about.html
A group of scholars promoting democratic ethical e more...1 point
Vision and Purpose at K20 Center
A program of the University of Oklahoma Vice Provo more...1 point
www.montessorihighschool.org.au/News/Q_A/How will this high school%2
Find why Findland Schools do well0 points
New York Times Video
The trap of lottery money for schools0 points
Andre Agassi Charitable Foundation
The site of the Andre Agassi Charitable Foundation more...0 points
Tiger Woods Foundation
0 points
LINK UPDATES
New Links Posted When Discoverd
- Blog of Paul Orfalea, Founder of Kinkos
- Orfalea founded Kinkos and ran it democratically. He writes about this in his blog and in a forthcoming book by Dean Katkowski
LIKEMINDED LINKS
- Change.org
- Change.org is the leading site for social change, providing daily news and information about important social issues and empowering people to take action.






































