Michael Phelps vs Usain Bolt

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic by 6 people | Log in to rate

Ranked #1,812 in Sports, #48,117 overall

Who was the King of Beijing?

Michael Phelps vs Usain Bolt

Michael Phelps swam 5 individual races and 3 relays in Beijing. He won 8 golds and set 7 world records and 1 Olympic record. Usain Bolt ran 2 individual races and 1 relay in Beijing. He won 3 golds and set 3 world records.

Together, Michael Phelps and Usain Bolt were the two most amazing stories from the two most watched sports in Beijing. And while most people will look at the number of medals that Phelps won and conclude that his Olympics was more impressive, they'd be wrong. Usain Bolt had the most impressive Olympics in Beijing.

First Off: How biased are you? 

Let's just call this out now...

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Facts about Phelps' and Bolt's amazing performances 

  • No athlete had ever won 8 gold medals in a single Olympics. The previous record was 7, by Mark Spitz in 1976. However, there was no 50m freestyle in 1976, and Mark Spitz believes if there were he would have won that event, too.

    No male sprinter had won all 3 short sprint events at the Olympics Games since Carl Lewis in 1984. But Carl didn't set world records in all of his races.



  • Michael Phelps held 6 of the 8 world records in the races he was competing in at the start of the Olympics (including as a member of two relays).

    Usain Bolt held only the 100m world record. The 200m world record was widely (very very widely) held to be untouchable.



  • The average age of the world records in Michael Phelps' events was about 2 years.

    Usain Bolt took down a 12 year-old record (200m) and a 16 year-old record (4 x 100m).



  • Advances in technology, primarily with regard to drag-reducing swimsuits and wave-reducing swimming pools have helped swimmers achieve faster times in Beijing.

    There have been no (legal) advances in recent sprinting technology--Usain Bolt broke 3 world records with nothing more than talent and execution.



  • Michael Phelps had to swim in a total of 17 races over 9 days. He often had to compete in more than one race per day, when you include his prelims and finals.

    Usain Bolt ran in a total of 7 races over one week.



Usain Bolt raises the bar...Can Michael Phelps compete with this? 

Usain Bolt and Asafa Powell have a dance-off...Usain wins again!

curated content from YouTube

THE DEBATE RAGES! 

How many swimming golds is one track gold worth?

Do you want to read more about Phelps' and Bolt's epic performances? See below for more details about their fantastic Olympics!

Who was King of Beijing: Usain Bolt or Michael Phelps?

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

Usain Bolt, definitely

Chef BD says:

usain bolt

ayesha says:

we just have to admit to greatness when we see it. I was amazed at the way in which he ran the 100m. the fact that he had a whole lot left in him.....he totally looked like he was jogging (in world record time) all i could say is WOW. I must say too that another thing he has over Phelps is a awesome, loveable and contagious personality top off with a winning pose. BOLT TO THE WORLD

NYRoots says:

Usain Bolt. Usain Bolt had the most brilliant performance, and Michael Phelps had the lifetime achievement award. Look at Bolt's margin of victory. For those that say, he had no competition...it's the Olympics. The showcased events in the Olympics are the track and field events. There's a full field. If the argument is that 1 or 2 people (Tyson Gay, Asafa Powell) didn't run their races, which would've challenged Bolt...that's more testament to his greatness if there are only 1 or 2 people in the world that can challenge him. (Though last week, shattering the WR in 100m and 200m, he proved that it's just not that close with anyone in the world right now.)

Finally, I think the point about technological advances are important...swimming records are shattered more easily these days. Track records are not.

NIkel says:

Usain Bolt he was just more impressive in breaking the records as none of his win were controversial all by a wide margin...and swimming records go each race so i dont make much of them..but Michael Phelps is also incredible

Alex says:

If bolt had more sprint choices (like micheal phelps with freestyle backstroke butterfly and breastroke) he would get 8 golds easy

Yo says:

Phelps overwhelmed his competition.
Bolt had no competition.
And that my friends is the difference.

ThanosJB says:

Hands Down Usain Bolt. Just look at how he destroyed his competition. Far Ahead. Just imagine a guy running 11 metres/second.

George says:

Usain bolt..is the best of the game..trained only for 2 months and already killed it.!! USIAN BOLT IS THE MAN

francisco says:

Hard to say, Bolt is a big natural talent in a sport open to everyone, yet competing in events where cheating is pretty much the norm. Swimminng is a highly technical sport pretty much restricted to the first world with a very much smaller participation.
From February 13 to August 14 2008 62 swimming world records were broken. In the same time frame Usain Bolt was the only track athlete to break a world record. Bolt is actually one of only three male track athletes to be holding a current world record set this millenium.
Swimming is much more open to clean sweeps. Remember only a short while ago when Ian Thorpe was 'definately' the greatest swimmer of all time?
To hail Phelps really really great he has to win the 100, 200 & 400 in the same meet, preferably all with world records ;) and definately without LZR suit in a 3m deep pool. Although physically tough, the butterfly & I.M. events are not core to swimming (Like the walks or decathlon in track)

In summary all Phelps and Bolt have to do next is to win their respective 100, 200, 400m triple. Phelps is a supreme athlete and Bolt is a 'natural'. My pick is Bolt despite Phelp's astonishing program in Beijing.

Kittery says:

It's a bit apples to oranges, but Bolt comes out the winner for reasons beyond specific performances and records. This guy couples his surreal performances to the right attitude, saying that head to head competition is the thing. Besides, Bolt has more charisma and Olympic spirit in his right pinkie toe (see barefoot victory laps, celebratory parties in Beijing) than Phelps could hope to find within his 17 pairs of $500 budgie smugglers.
[Full disclosure, I'm a recovering sprint swimmer turned endurance runner, basically the opposite of both Phelps and Bolt]

Michael Phelps, without a doubt

Phil says:

i do cross counrty swim and track and hands down phelps takes it. usain bolt's biggest competition was injured at the olympics. if tyson gay was at the top of his game, bolt wouldve never won so easily. in fact, its possible that he may have even been beaten. to me the fact that phelps had to go through so many different events and finals with guys who specialize in just those specific events, and come out on topp, thats amazing. Bolt specializes in sprints. toss him in the 800 and see how well he does. phelps wins easily

pdazzle says:

I've done both, though I am more a track guy. However, I have to say what Phelps did was more impressive. What Bolt did will be matched/surpassed in 10-15 years; what Phelps did may not be for 30-50 years.

Melanie says:

Duhh Phelps!!!! I dont even see y this is a debate. He made history. Plus this is USA, duhh were gonna rep him!

Ryan says:

Michael Phelps obviously, I can't believe people are debating this. Phelps's swimming involved many more skill sets (he swims all four strokes) and the mental toughness involved with 17 races over a short span of time belittles Bolt's three short races. He individually beat the best in the world in 5 separate events. Give Phelps three races and you're going to see him demolish records even more so than he did-- and even more so than Bolt did. I'm way biased towards track, but for the life of me, I can not believe anyone could ponder this...

swimfan says:

Michael Phelps... hands down. Yes, Usain Bolt ran unbelievable races and set world records but anyone can run. Put Michael Phelps on a track and he could finish the races that Bolt ran. Not as fast and probably not as gracefully but he could complete it. I would like to see Bolt try to swim a 400 IM (x2) and finish.. along with a 200 fly (x3) and a 200 free (x4), 100 fly (x3), 200 IM (x3), 100 Free...

Simon says:

Phelps, HANDS DOWN!!!

Peins says:

Buraian, u need to go back to elementry school. 7 does not equal 8. 30 years ago Mark Spitz won 7 gold medals, MP just won 8. Usain could not have won his relay without the help of his teammates on his relay similarly.

Phelps feat in the swimming world has changed the sport forever, what he did and the FEROCITY in which he raced each of his 8 finals is unparalleled.

justin says:

Phelps for sure

charlesgrimes says:

Michael is the best! Thanks for this great lens and for stopping by my lens at www.squidoo.com/swimolympic. I also have a new lens at
www.squidoo.com/michael-phelps-olympic-swimmer

BOBBY says:

ENOUGH this isn't even a debate it is no time to leave michael out of the picture after some rookie usain bolt brings some new running ability to the games. I'll admit Bolt has some skills but michael phelps is a veteran to the games and he is a class act. He knows how to handle himself much better than bolt who is already showboating before even finishes the race. phelps has to do a diferent stroke every race when bolt just runs differnt distances each race. not only that but michael phelps has done something NO ONE has EVER done before bolt has done something someone has done already just setting records while doing it and phelps set many records to.THE DISCUSION IS OVER MICHAEL PHELPS IS CLEARLY THE BETTER MAN AND ATHLETE.

 
view all 27 comments

Usain Bolt - 3 Races, 3 Golds, 3 World Records

An Incomparable Performance: The Case for Usain Bolt 

"I never knew how fast I was going. One aim was just to win and do what I have to do." --Usain Bolt after his 100m world record gold medal performance in Beijing

Usain Bolt entered the Beijing Olympics as one of the favorites in the 100m and 200m. The reigning world record holder in the 100m (9.72 at the time) and runner of the fastest 200m of the year (19.67 at the time) was expected to medal in Beijing. But...

At the time--people are probably forgetting this right now--Asafa Powell and Tyson Gay were considered to be nearly equal candidates to take the gold in these races. On top of that, Usain Bolt was a mere 21 years old, and didn't have any championship race experience. How would he handle the pressure?

Bolt gave the world its first glance in the 100m, when he dominated his prelims with ease and came out dancing for the final. With a decent--but far from great--start, he was equal with everyone after 40 meters and by 80 meters he had such a commanding lead that he put it in cruise control, pounded his chest, and still crossed the line in 9.69, a new world record. There is significant debate over just how fast Bolt could have run had he not eased up at the finish.



Four days later, after cruising through three more sets of prelims, Bolt came out for the 200 meters. The build-up to this race was a different story. There was no longer any doubt as to who should win the race. Now people expected a record.

But the only record to be taken was Michael Johnson's 19.32 run 1996 Olympic Final. That race was not only a 12-year old world record. It was the fastest race ever run by .28 seconds. Nobody had ever come close. But would the fans expect anything less?

When Bolt came out for the 200m final, he looked as relaxed as ever. He rubbed his head and pointed to the crowd when he was announced, and simply oozed confidence. It was clear then that he would win. The question was whether he would run through the tape.

At the gun, Bolt took off from lane 4 and halfway through the turn, had passed people in every lane. (He arguably caused two athletes to step out of their lanes and get disqualified by being so far ahead of them so quickly.) He had a massive lead by the half-way mark and never let up. He pressed to the line and clocked a new world record 19.30, making him the first man to set two sprint world record at the same Olympics.



The two-time gold medalist and two time world record-holder wasn't done, though. His team was still the favorite to win the gold in the 4x100m. He didn't run in the prelims, but Jamaica qualified easily for the final. With the US dropping the baton, Jamaica's likelihood of winning the gold went way up. But they wanted more than a gold. They wanted history.

Nesta Carter led off and handed to Michael Frater. Frater handed the baton to Bolt in the lead, and Bolt ran a smoking turn (clocked unofficially at 8.9 seconds!), to hand off to Asafa Powell who powered home to a Jamaican victory in 37.10, far surpassing the 16-year old world record of 37.40 set by the Americans in 1992. Bolt was now three for three for three: 3 Races, 3 Golds, 3 World Records.




Learn More about Usain Bolt

Wikipedia: Usain Bolt

Discovering Bolt: Who is Usain, and should we be surprised?

Quick Poll: What's most impressive about Usain Bolt's performance in Beijing? 

What stood out the most to you?

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Michael Phelps - 8 Races, 8 Golds, 7 World + 1 Olympic Records

Spitz + 1: Michael Phelps sets a new standard for excellence 

"I want to test my maximum and see how much I can do. And I want to change the world of swimming." --Michael Phelps

Michael Phelps entered the Olympics with the highest expectations of any athlete outside of Liu Xiang (the Chinese hurdler who won gold in Athens). He was entered in 8 races over 9 days, favored to win all 8, and had the potential to break the world record in most if not all of them. He did just that.

His 1st race was arguably his toughest: the 400m individual medley. All four strokes, 100m each, non-stop. It just so happens that this is also Phelps' most dominant event. He swam a brilliant race, winning by almost 2.5 seconds in a world record time 4:03.84.

Phelps' 2nd race was certainly the most dramatic, and will likely be his most remembered. The 4 x 100 freestyle saw the US facing a strong French team that included the 100m freestyle world record holder, Alain Bernard, who predicted the French would "crush" the Americans.

Phelps led off with a 47.51 second first leg, touching in second place. Garrett Weber-Gale and Cullen Jones slipped to half a second behind the French by the final leg. At that point, Jason Lezak swam the fastest leg ever (46.06) to come from behind on Bernard and seal the victory for the US in a world record, 3:08.24.



Phelps' 3rd race was the 200m freestyle. He went out hard and had the lead by the first 50m. No other competitor swam any portion of the race as fast as Phelps swam, and Phelps won the race by nearly 2 seconds in 1:42.96.

His 4th race was the 200m butterfly. Phelps touched the wall after 50m in 2nd, but moved into the lead after a solid second leg. 2nd place finisher Laszlo Cseh made an effort to catch up with the fastest 3rd leg of the race, but Phelps was too strong and kicked in to finish in a world record 1:52.03.

Phelps' 5th final came one hour after his 200m butterfly victory. It was the 4 x 200m freestyle. Phelps led with a blistering first leg, coming in a solid 2 seconds ahead of the next closest competitor in 1:43.31. Ryan Lochte then extended the lead, and Ricky Berens maintained it. Peter Vanderkaay finished off the race and brought the US home with a 6:58.56 world record victory.

Phelps' 6th race was the 200m medley. With a day off (well, no finals at least) Phelps was a little more rested than for his previous races. He took control early and was out-paced on only one leg, the backstroke (but by only one competitor). He swam consistently faster than his competition and won by 2 seconds in a world record 1:54.23.

Phelps' 7th race created the most intrigue. It was the 100m butterfly, and he made it to the turn far from the lead. He then flew down the lane and caught up to the leader, Milorad Cavic, and touched the wall .01 seconds ahead of him in an Olympic record 50.58. There was some controversy, and the race was protested, but the protest was thrown out. This was the only race in which Phelps did not get a world record.



In his 8th and final race, Phelps competed in the 4 x 100m medley. The team--Aaron Piersol, Brendan Hansen, Phelps, and Jason Lezak--got out to a commanding lead and went on to break the world record in a time of 3:29.34.

Quick Poll: What was most impressive about Michael Phelps' performance in Beijing? 

What stood out to you most?

Loading poll. Please Wait...

The blogosphere speaks! What others are saying... 

Wallace Spearmon to attend Bolt's superparty; Michael Phelps ...
Wallace Spearmon to attend Bolt's superparty; Michael Phelps agrees to support. Publish on Nov 24th, 2009 and filed under External news. 4 views. Email This Post · Print This Post. Triple Olympic and World Championships gold medallist, ...
Who would win in a fight... Usain Bolt vs Michael Phelps | Hail ...
Usain Bolt and Michael Phelps have a lot in common. They are both amazing athletes, they both won lots of gold medals and they both appreciate the reefer. Everyone saw the Michael Phelps bong pic that came out and some of you heard ...
How does the Olympic athletes react on Michael Jackson? « choke
Maybe you've forget or missed the Olympics last year, maybe you've forget Michael Phelps or Usain Bolt winning the gold medal or the overrated gymnastics competition last year (Nastia Liukin, Shawn Johnson, Alicia Sacramone, He Kexin, ...
Wallace Spearmon to attend Usain Bolt 9.58 Super Party | Jahkno
usain-bolt-super-party. While Sanya Richards and Michael Phelps have indicated they will not be able to attend due to previous commitments, they have agreed to support the event. Phelps will in fact sending personal memorabilia for ...

Your feedback: What do you think? 

Love the lens? Hate the topic? Missing something? What's your gut reaction?

submit
  • Reply
    Superfly Superfly Sep 15, 2009 @ 10:06 pm
    Bolt hands down, cause raw speed is what impresses me. To be honest I think there are too man medals available in swimming and its a bit of a joke. Sure, a guy who could win gold medals in the 100m backwards run and 200m one legged hop and even the 400m skip would be impressive given its extrememly difficult to be the best at anything in the world (all respectable styles such as the breast, back and butterfly strokes). But lets be serious. What impresses most people are things that push the limit. The fastest car to run a 1/4 mile, the fastest skier to finish a run, or even the guy who can eat the most hot dogs in a minute. I mean as impressive as it may be I'm less wowed with the car with the fastes 1/4 mile time in reverse, or the quickest ski run while doing the snow plow or the most hot dogs eaten while twirling around in circles.
  • Reply
    Dave Dave Sep 8, 2008 @ 3:13 am
    In athletics there are 14 events which test running speed when you include the hurdles, stepplechase, etc... Plus a whole heap of field events which have obvious cross over advantages to fast runners like long jump, triple jump, etc. In swimming there are 17 events.

    Of the 17 available Phelps won 8 (47%) whereas Bolt won 3 out of 14 (21%). Phelps was the best in the world across 4 different swimming styles and from events which took 50 secs up to 4 minutes. Bolt was the best in events which took 9 to 19 seconds in only one style. For Bolt to achieve the equivalent of what Phelps did he'd have to do something like expanding his range to at least the 400 metre distance and add the hurdles. Then he'd have to win the 100, 200, 400, 110 hurdles, 400 hurdles and the 4X100 and 4X400 and set world records in all but 1.

    The fact that Phelps made a feat like that look easy is a testamony to the greatness of his achievement.

Other great lenses by buraian 

Check 'em out and tell me what you think!

I have an extensive number of track and field lenses at my lensography, too!

Optimal Training 

Develop the mindset of a champion

You can also read my feature articles at The Runner's Tribe!

Loading Fetching RSS feed... please stand by

by buraian

Hey.  I'm buraian.  I used to be a competitive distance runner.  Now, I still run, but mostly blog about running.  Check out my le...

(more)

Explore related pages

Create a Lens!