Missouri Medical Association has a hissy fit when midwives are allowed to practice
Missouri Medical Association (MSMA): The Bullies on the Block
by Yvonne Lapp Cryns
The recent passage of the Missouri Bill 818 that made it lawful for Certified Professional Midwives to practice also gave Missouri women the right to legally give birth home with these trained professionals. Admittedly, only a small number of the state's women will pick a midwife. Yet, the Missouri Medical Association is launching a time-consuming and costly lawsuit to challenge the constitutionality of this law.
Why? It is not due to the superiority of birth outcomes by physicians. We know this from repeated valid studies and statistics that conclude midwives and home births are at least as safe as those conducted in the hospitals with physicians.
It is not due to the state of the art technology in the hospital, such as Electronic Fetal Monitoring, EFM. EFM has never been proved to save the life of a single baby in all the years of use. EFM has, however, been clearly linked to a dramatic increase in cesarean sections and other needless intrusive interventions.
It is not due to MSMA's success in improving outcomes for Missouri's African-American women, who deliver their babies prematurely at three times the rate of the state's white women.
The decision to sue is not based on unanimous MSMA physician support. Many Missouri physicians are clearly pleased to welcome the addition of CPMs.
Perhaps, the true reason for this squandering of their members' dues is because those holding MSMA office can't help themselves. They are accustomed to being the bullies on the block. If only they could muster this kind of financial and professional enthusiasm to address the appalling infant mortality of Missouri, the lives of someone beside themselves might be enriched.
Resources for facts cited above:
http://msma.org/cgi-bin/cgiwrap/msmaorg/start.cgi/dev05/setup.html
MO birth stats; http://bmj.bmjjournals.com/cgi/content/full/330/7505/1416?ehom
In Search of Evidence Supporting Electronic Fetal Monitoring, AJN, American Journal of Nursing: Volume 107 (6) June 2007, p 22.
http://www.emaxhealth.com/84/9507.html
http://www.unitedhealthfoundation.org/shr2005/components/infantmortality.html
Senator John Loudon
He got the Missouri Bill through
Senator John Loudon
The Republican Missouri State Senator talks to http://PubDef.net about his controversial Midwives legislation.
Runtime: 4:25
2386 views
10 Comments:
Compleat Mother magazine
Missouri Medical Association suing state over new midwifery law
June 19, 2007
Grassroots Network Message 706014Missouri Medical Association suing state over new midwifery law
june 19, 2007
Dear Friends,
Missouri midwifery advocates have been working long and hard for many years to achieve legal status for direct entry midwives; Missouri is one of the few states where the practice of midwifery is specifically a felony. After opposition filibustered a good licensing bill this spring, successfully keeping it from a vote, the courageous sponsor inserted a single sentence into a related bill (on health insurance) that made CPMs legal but not regulated. This bill passed, in part because almost no one was aware of the inserted sentence.
Missouri Friends of Midwives has just issued a press release responding to the state medical association's announcement that they are going to court in an attempt to get the midwifery sentence ruled unconstitutional! Read the press release below or at www.friendsofmomidwives.org /www.friendsofmomidwives.org/>
The midwifery provision used the word "tocological," a little known synonym for "obstetrical and midwifery", so it went under the radar. Needless to say, the opposition was furious. The critical sentence in HB818 reads: "Notwithstanding any law to the contrary, any person who holds current ministerial or tocological certification by an organization accredited by the National Organization for Competency Assurance (NOCA) may provide services as defined in 42 U.S.C. 1396 f-6(b) (4) (E) (ii) (I)." This means that midwives certified by certifying bodies accredited by NOCA, which includes the North American Registry of Midwives, can practice legally in MO.
Of course the state medical association opposed the licensing bill (and helped stop it), and is furious about the passage of HB818 with the "stealth" midwifery provision, and now they are going to court to get the midwifery sentence ruled unconstitutional. You can read their announcement featured on their home page at www.msma.org /www.msma.org/> . Not unexpectedly, it includes gross misstatements (to be polite) about the actual meaning of the critical sentence.
To be continued%u2026. And kudos to all those active advocates and midwives in Missouri!!
Sincerely,
Susan Hodges, "gatekeeper"
Home Sweet Homebirth
A Video about Midwives and Homebirth in America

Click
HERE
to help save the midwives in the USA.
Buy a $6 one-year digital subscription to Compleat Mother.
Home Sweet Homebirth
A Video about Midwives and Homebirth in America
MIDWIVES: YOUR BEST BET
by Yvonne Lapp Cryns
MIDWIVES: YOUR BEST BETHistory
In 1900 half of all Americans were born into the hands of a midwife, at home. Early studies comparing the birth outcomes of physicians versus midwives showed that midwives had fewer maternal and infant loses than the doctors. The United States had a very high percentage of maternal deaths compared to other countries.
Reports done by the White House Conference on Child Health and Protection, the national Committee on the Costs of Medical Care, and the New York Academy of Medicine in the 1930's all concluded that midwives were safer than physicians. These reports chastised doctors for their frequency of interventions which led to problems. Many physicians, in response to the findings of the reports, placed the blame on the midwives claiming that midwives were "ignorant", "dirty", untrained and a threat to the safety of childbearing women. Medical journals and popular magazines contained many articles bashing midwives and blaming them for the nations appalling maternal mortality and infant mortality rates.
Many physicians and public health advocates spoke up for the midwives and their excellent statistics, but the prestige of the anti-midwife physicians and the strong push to move births into the hospitals far over-shadowed their voices. This barrage of anti-midwife articles and propaganda continues today despite the lack of any studies or statistics to prove claims that physicians guarantee the safest outcomes or healthier babies or mothers.
MSMA Announces Preparations to Take New Midwifery Law to Court - Part 1
aka Doctors throw a hissy fit
Press Release - June 16, 2007FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
MSMA Announces Preparations to Take New Midwifery Law to Court
Contact:Mary Ueland
Email: LegislativeChair@MissouriMidwivesAssociation.org
Cell Phone: 417-543-4258
Fax: 314-721-1149
Homebirth families around the state are appalled at the Missouri State Medical Association's plans to try to overturn the new law legalizing Certified Professional Midwives.
Homebirth families have all been celebrating a victory since Governor Blunt signed HB 818 several weeks ago. The bill legalized Certified Professional Midwives and ended 48 years of the practice of midwifery being a felony in Missouri.
Despite broad bi-partisan support in the Missouri legislature for the legalization of midwives and the passage of HB818, MSMA's tyrannical insistence on the felony status of midwifery in Missouri has now turned its efforts to the court system. The announcement of the planned law suit against the state of Missouri has claimed the top banner on the MSMA website.
Those lobbying for the midwifery bill say that they were always willing to sit down and work out a midwifery law agreeable to all parties if the medical associations would have agreed to withdraw their intense opposition. However, they only intensified the opposition as time went on. The midwifery supporters say that the goal of the medical associations seemed to be making sure that no midwives would be available for mothers who choose to give birth at home in Missouri.
"The Missouri State Medical Association has never had any need to work with us, because they intended to maintain a complete monopoly on birth," explained Dr. Keith Nisbett, Ph.D., a professor and homebirth father who has tried to change Missouri's midwife law for nearly twenty years.
"The Missouri State Medical Association does not speak for me as a physician, nor do they speak for many of my physician colleagues who respect midwives and want to see them join us at the table as experts in healthy pregnancy and birth," said Dr. Elizabeth Allemann, MD, a physician from Columbia. "The MSMA has spent twenty years of time and energy fighting the legalization of midwifery in Missouri. You would think the sky is falling and terrible things are going to happen to doctors! That's the farthest thing from the truth. Midwives are well trained professionals and work well together with doctors."
MSMA Announces Preparations to Take New Midwifery Law to Court - Part 2
Missouri Medical Association wants its cake and eat it too!
The midwifery supporters say that they are encouraged that other medical groups such as the Missouri Hospital Association are refusing to join the MSMA in the lawsuit. "It shows that the Missouri Hospital Association knows that there are more important things to focus on, like increasing access to healthcare for all of Missouri's citizens," commented Dr. Allemann. "For that, I applaud them.""There are so many other healthcare issues that need attention in Missouri. Why does the medical association spend so much time trying to criminalize my midwife and limit my access to the birthing service of my choice?" questioned Samanda Rossi, St. Louis Friends of Missouri Midwives area coordinator.
Missouri women who choose home birth are more qualified to determine who should assist them than the MSMA. It is both demeaning and an insult to the intelligence of women to suggest that they would choose anyone other than a qualified professional to deliver their children.
Midwifery is about access to healthcare. Some women do not have the choice whether or not to use a physician. The MSMA, if successful, is actually endangering the lives of women and their babies by denying access to trained professional midwives to attend homebirths. Every pregnant woman deserves to have a professional attend her birth who has been trained to recognize fetal distress, resuscitate a baby, and stop a hemorrhage.
Mary Ueland, legislative chair for the Missouri Midwives Association, contends that MSMA is giving false information to its members and the public. "Anyone can look up the definition of tocology and see that bricklayers and professional golfers are obviously not certified in tocology. Because the truth will not cause concern among physicians or the public, MSMA is telling them lies about what the new law does. We had hoped that we could at least have a candid discussion of the facts with obstetricians."
The law says that those certified in tocology under the National Organization for Competency Assurance can provide prenatal, birth, and postpartum care. The two tocological certification processes certified by NOCA are the Certified Professional Midwives and the Certified Nurse Midwives.
New Text / Write module
Midwife
If hospitals are so awesome, why do many people turn to a midwife?
Ina May's Guide to Childbirth
Amazon Price: $11.56 (as of 07/19/2008)
Monique and the Mango Rains: Two Years with a Midwife in Mali
Amazon Price: $12.21 (as of 07/19/2008)
A Midwife's Tale: The Life of Martha Ballard, Based on Her Diary, 1785-1812
Amazon Price: $10.85 (as of 07/19/2008)
The Midwife's Apprentice
Amazon Price: $5.99 (as of 07/19/2008)
Baby Catcher: Chronicles of a Modern Midwife
Amazon Price: $10.20 (as of 07/19/2008)
Midwives
- DHB responsible for maternity problems: midwives
- By JOHN MASLIN The New Zealand College of Midwives says problems with maternity services at Wanganui...
- 'Four midwives for 26 women'
- A report into English maternity units says that some still do not have enough midwives or beds to co...
- Jennifer Block: A turf war over the maternity market
- As a healthy woman with a normal pregnancy, she saw midwives. And one of their first questions to he...
- Midwives come under spotlight after deaths
- The competency of midwives has come under the spotlight in recent weeks after Health Minister David...
Important natural parenting links
My Squidoo lenses are here
- natural birth
- The Compleat Mother Magazine has been a strong voice for midwifery since the magazine started in 1986.
- All About Breastfeeding
- http://www.squidoo.com/gobreastfeeding/
- Childbirth Videos
- The amazing thing to me is that most mothers never SAW a childbirth!
- Video Taping your childbirth
- Childbirth video
- All About Pregnancy
- Pregnancy
- all about circumcision
- Circumcision
- Breastfeeding videos
- Breastfeeding videos
- All About Midwives
- Midwifery
New Text / Write module
New RSS: Add Your Own Feed
Fetching RSS feed... please stand byTalk about women's rights in childbirth
Like this lens? Want to share your feedback, or just give a thumbs up? Be the first to submit a blurb!





