Military Women in Combat

Ranked #155 in Culture & Society, #3,905 overall

There have been women in combat since the human race began...

When warring tribes fought over food or men during our first beginnings, those women were undoubtedly in combat. As the centuries went on, women warriors were not considered so unusual, among others there was Joan of Arc, and Bodecia who fought as warriors. There were women in the Civil War who donned men's clothing and fought alongside their buddies, only to be found out once they were slain in battle. This is by way of explaining that women in combat are nothing new, but have been in existence since ancient times. Only in modern, "enlightened" times have we thought of women as weak and ineffectual. They are neither, as many a commanding officer could tell you. They are as fierce in battle as any man.

Countries who currently allow women to serve in combat include Israel, France, Germany, New Zealand, Canada, Denmark, Finland, Norway, Serbia, Sweden and Switzerland. The United Kingdom allows women to serve in an Artillery capacity, but they are excluded from a dedicated infantry division.

A recent Pentagon commission on diversity has recommended that American women be allowed to serve in combat. Maybe if they took a trip to Afghanistan right now and checked under a few helmets, they'd find many females right in the thick of things. When a combat unit leaves United States soil for the the war zone, they do not pull all the women out of line and leave them here at home to tend to their knitting. They are shipped out with their unit, and are trained to fight the same as their male counterparts.

http://i167.photobucket.com/albums/u157/jibrael_2007/PERS_Zalkovsky_Iraq_lg.jpg

When Janey Comes Marching Home: Portraits of Women Combat Veterans

I served in the military during the Vietnam War.

But never in combat.

When I was in the Women's Army Corps from 1968 to 1972 during the Vietnam War era, we did not have to qualify on a rifle, run an obstacle course or learn how to wriggle across the ground on our belly with a gun in hand. I served four years during a time when anyone in military uniform, male or female, was not popular. In fact as a Recruiter, I knew many of my colleagues who had been shot at in rural communities. The bullet holes in the Army staff car proved it, and in a certain sense, we were in combat. There were few women in the front lines in Vietnam, mostly nurses or doctors. A few others were "in country" but further from the front lines, not in combat areas.

Since that time two of my daughters have served in the Army. Both trained on the M16 Army Rifle, (both qualified as 'Expert') and my youngest daughter has since joined her state's National Guard. She has trained in combat and her unit was supposed to ship out to Iraq at one time. That did not happen, but her unit then patrolled New Orleans after Katrina, got shot at a few times, but saved lives, both human and animal. Her unit is now in Afghanistan, and I pray for her every day. Yes, I worry, but I salute her for her courage and her patriotism. She contacts me frequently online and has even managed to phone me a couple times to let me know she's okay and I'm very proud of her. Still, I will not rest easy until she is safely home again.

UPDATE TO MY DAUGHTER'S STATUS: As of the end of March, she is home safe and sound. She did have to defend herself and her unit a few times. There were losses in her unit which she still grieves about. She will need time to adjust to our world again, and to stop carrying the guilt of survival. Thanks to all of you for your good wishes for her. I'm very proud of her.
Loading
As a United States Women's Army Corps Recruiter

Me in my United States Women's Army Corps Uniform about 1969 

Video from the New York Times

Straight from those women who serve...

powered by Youtube

DVDs on Military Women in Combat

Loading

Books on the subject of military women in combat..........

....written by those who've been there!

Loading

Women Soldiers in the American Civil War

Loading

More on Women Warriors

Loading

This lens has been blessed by SquidAngels ohcaroline, Dawn_Mathisen_aka_Candle_Dawn, Spook, ItsAngel, LisaAuch,Jewelsofawe, KimGiancaterino, LisaKleinWeber, hotbrain, Tipi,TravelingRae, JoshK47, traveller27, LNAngel, Bdkz and boutiqueshops. Thank you so much!

Women in Combat: Pro or Con?

Give your opinion of military women in combat... Vote Yes, No, or No Opinion..

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Women in Combat? What's your opinion?

Do you think women should serve in combat?

Loading

Tell why you think military women should go into combat.

poddys says:

The only problems I see are the mixture of the sexes in a combat platoon, as well as emotions, in particular at that time of the month, but if a woman believes she is capable of going into combat, why stop her.

Kirrily says:

I think that women should be aloud to fight in combat. Women in combat is nothing new, as women dressed up as men during the civil war to fight, and then there is Joan of Arc who successfully led hundreds of men into battle. There is also Bodecia, who had a fantastic victory over the Romans.

jayceehaynes says:

Women serve in combat everyday and do the job...Let them do it.

hippiechicjewelz says:

I think it is up to the woman, it is her choice.

Supersweetcutebunny says:

I favor the concept for women should go into combat; albeit women may not have the same survival instincts as men. And yet I believe that they should be able to choose to participate if they so desire because even they can contribute in combat no matter of gender. I recently have read two articles from Upfront magazines discussing this issue and I suggest you should read them yourselves on the matter if you do so please.

Tell why you think military women should NOT go into combat.

3 Combat Tours says:

Women should only be allowed in combat if they can abide by all of the same standards as men. Every aspect of the military mandates lower standards for women than for men. If women are going deploy and fight in a combat military occupational specialty, then they need to also be held to the exact same standards as the men. As long as women receive lower standards in training, they will not be fit for duty

Michey says:

I think woman can be in military, but not in combat... there are a lot of other positions they can apply for within the military.

mowug1776 says:

Women take the psychological side of warfare too far. Also they are somewhat of a distraction to the men whether they mean to be or not. I have seen reports of women being on front lines for instance Molly pitcher in the Revolutionary war when her husband's battery fell silent she stepped up and kept firing the cannon until the end of the battle. Also I forget which war but another woman tended the wounds of the men on the front lines we got to the point that the men actually liked being around her because wherever she was not one shell hit near. I find though that if women are put in a position where they must fight or die they rarely pull out of the mindset that they allow themselves to get into in order to survive. I have seen many men who cannot handle warfare I have also observed that women cannot handle it as easily as men can (that not being much). I believe that this is because men are able to in effect turn off their emotions. Although women can it is more difficult for them to do so, this makes them better suited for caring for children. I am not saying however that women should not at least go through basic combat training making them a danger to those around them when the fighting comes onto the base. Although I am saying that men and women are fundamentally different both psychologically and physically and that should draw upon each other's strengths rather than expect both to do with the other is better suited to.

BuddyBink says:

They are a distraction. They have different requirements when it comes to things like sanitation. They can serve very well but not in combat arms. I always found them lacking during my tenure in the military.

BarbRad says:

I don't think women should be forced into combat situations. I agree they weren't built for it emotionally or physically. If a woman wants to do it and the Army doesn't have a problem with it, I wouldn't forbid it, but I'm afraid once it's not against the rules women who don't want to be in combat may be forced to be. This will be especially bad if the draft is re instituted. I think mothers, especially, shouldn't be in combat zones, especially if their children are young. I think children need to have their mothers around during those years. It's one thing to be a working mom. It's another to be working on the other side of the world where you can't be home for the kids at night.

 
view all 39 comments

I like to know what countries my visitors are from....

If you learned something new, please leave a comment and...

...if you liked it, don't forget to give it a thumbs up!

  • OhMe May 8, 2012 @ 9:52 pm | delete
    Hi, just dropped back by to let you know that this lens is featured on my latest lens about the book, Kimberly's Flight.
  • grannysage May 4, 2012 @ 1:42 am | delete
    Never underestimate the power of a woman. If a woman decides to serve her country, then she is just as capable of being in combat as a man. That being said, I'm glad none of my children have chosen that path.
  • poddys May 2, 2012 @ 4:24 pm | delete
    It's so wonderful that you and your daughters have served your country in the military. Excellent discussion point, and nicely done. Blessed.
  • happynutritionist Apr 30, 2012 @ 11:40 am | delete
    Back again to visit and bless...I hope you are doing well!
  • jayceehaynes Apr 27, 2012 @ 1:08 pm | delete
    pray for peace, prepare for war....nice lens :)
  • Load More

If you like this lens about Military Women in Combat....

....please share it here.

Add this to your lens »

Bookmark and Share

Follow Me on Pinterest

Thanks for your support for our troops, and thank you for visiting this page.

About Me

Loading

by

nancycarol

Hi, I'm Nancy Hardin, retired from the newspaper industry and now a freelance writer. I love reading true crime stories and the technology that helps... more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!

Military stories you might like. 

Loading