Are mothers better parents than fathers?

Ranked #490 in Parenting & Kids, #15,963 overall

Are mothers better parents than fathers?

The word mother is synonymous to someone who feeds, cares, nurtures and protects. A mother will go to all ends to keep her young from harm's way.This is true for all animals where the maternal instinct is believed to be hard-wired to the brain. Mothers, with a higher level of the hormone, oxytocin, during pregnancy, exhibit a stronger bonding between mother and child. Children reach out more to their mothers than to their fathers. It may be because the mother spends more time with the child. Women naturally show emotion while men keep their feelings to themselves. Does this mean the mother have better parenting skills?

In many societies, mothers are destined to be the caregivers and fathers, the breadwinners and disciplinarians. However, in this day and age, the norm has changed due to social, cultural, and economic climate. Many households have both parents working; some have single moms or single dads; widowed husbands with children or widowed mothers with children; others are adoptive parents; single dads with daughters.

Do you think mothers are better parents than fathers?

Check out these controversial links on this topic

An evolutionary psychologist's opinion on why mothers are better parents than fathers Part I
Mommy's Baby, Daddy's Maybe
Part II
A woman's biological clock makes her a better parent?
Part III
Are mothers always good parents?

Read what others are saying

Motherhood Today: Tougher Challenges, Less Success - Pew Research Center
From managing busy schedules to dealing with outside influences, mothers have their hands full these days - and middle-aged women are their sharpest critics. At the same time, fully 70% of the public says it's harder to be a mother today than it was 20 or 30 years ago; somewhat fewer (60%) say the s
Single Fathers Compared to Single Mothers
Are single fathers just as good as parenting as mothers?
Be a Better Parent: 101 | ModernMom.com
What does it mean to be a better parent?
How to Be a Good Parent - wikiHow
Whether you are a father, mother or caregiver, there are bits of advice that can help when you are challenged in the growing up years.

A lecture every parent should watch.

Educational and entertaining


Unconditional Parenting


This is a 5-star rated video by Alfie Kohn with revolutionary ideas on parenting. It is challenging and funny because he hits all the points home. Everyone has to hear what Alfie has to say about unconditional parenting which will open your eyes to another option in parenting. All parents should watch this amazing video. Turn parenting into a fun and rewarding experience with happy chldren.

A Parent's lament

If I had my child to raise all over again,
I'd build self-esteem first, and the house later.
I'd finger-paint more, and point the finger less.
I would do less correcting and more connecting.
I'd take my eyes off my watch, and watch with my eyes.
I'd take more hikes and fly more kites.
I'd stop playing serious, and seriously play.
I would run through more fields and gaze at more stars.
I'd do more hugging and less tugging.
~Diane Loomans, from "If I Had My Child To Raise Over Again"

Dish it out here.

Let's hear it from you.

Are mothers better parents than fathers or vice versa?

Loading

FamilySolutions says:

Each parent has a different role in the family dynamics. If each parent stays within their role and fulfills it to the best of his ability, then I'd say it's a draw. The mother and the father will balance each other out.

AnimalHouse says:

For me, moms are the best.

Steve_Kaye says:

I think women are better mothers than men.

chrisssy says:

Both play an important part but it can go both ways. I think a lot of kids, especially girls would grow up with more morals and respect if they were in a single parent home with just the father, rather than just the mother. Not at all am I discriminating-if you're a single mum all power to you since I was, too

singledad713 says:

Fathers can be just as good at parenting as a mother can. Sometimes, even better then some moms.

www.donationsfordad.com

COUNTRYLUTHIER says:

That depends on the word better. I say it takes two and no one has all the strengths. parenting is not easy.

MOHAMMED ASHFAQ says:

YES

archangelptx says:

I've seen pieces of you know what parents from both sides of the gender spectrum--it really just depends on the individual and their parenting style (or lack there of).

Mujjen says:

I don't think so. Different doesn't mean better. Fathers can be excellent parents, and mothers can be really bad. It depends on the person, not the sex.

Flynn_the_Cat says:

This needs a yes or no! :D

Mine's a no. Even though there are differences between my parents, these are mostly because my father worked more while my mother stayed home more - these differences disappeared after (for example) my mother went away for a month and my dad took care of us, or when the situation was reversed. Their personalities are different, obviously, but they treated us the same, dependent on their situation/current 'role' in the family (it didn't matter which it was)

kiwinana71 says:

No fathers are as good as mothers, I have the proof in my own three sons as fathers, and what their children think of their father by love and dedication.

craigmitchell says:

Impossible to say really, without believing in gender constraints. My wife is an inspirational mother/grandmother, but I'd like to think that I'm an equally good father/grandfather.

fiona says:

mothers are better parents than fathers because without mothers no fathers!!!!!!!!!!!!

jordanmilesbasketballstuff says:

Well, I guessed it depends because my husband and I have our own way in taking care, guiding and helping our son.

godswill hyginus says:

i can touch everything

hlkljgk says:

they each play an important roll

Jack2205 says:

Sometimes fathers stay home with the children while the mother goes to work. The mother teaches the girls about female things, and the father teaches the boys about male things, so they're both needed.

Irenemaria says:

It is impossible to say generally.!! Both Fathers and Mothers can be lousy or loving.

 

Get some parenting tips from Amazon

Loading

I would love to hear from you.

  • samsipet May 23, 2012 @ 6:59 pm | delete
    Good question, and I think it all depends on each person.
  • ercramer36 Apr 9, 2012 @ 11:03 pm | delete
    Both are equally important. If mothers were the only important parent, the inner cities would be examples of peace and tranquility. Fathers are vital to the development of a child.
  • jordanmilesbasketballstuff Mar 28, 2012 @ 11:37 pm | delete
    It really depends on the family.. But I believe that both parents are doing their best..
  • Wedding_Mom Mar 15, 2012 @ 9:07 pm | delete
    Nice lens. This is a very interesting read, I think both parents play an important part.
  • singledad713 Feb 12, 2012 @ 2:43 am | delete
    As a single dad and victim of Domestic Violence, I have to say that men definitely have the potential to be just as good if not better than a woman at parenting.

    http://www.donationsfordad.com
  • Vallygems1 Jan 9, 2012 @ 1:51 pm | delete
    It very much depends on a lot of factors. Social, Cultural, Economic, etc. Some kids in some societies are brought up by neither
  • Spook Jun 15, 2011 @ 2:24 pm | delete
    A long time ago I used to think that this was hogswash, now however, in balance I think it is very true. Terrific lens for a debate.
  • hlkljgk May 9, 2011 @ 2:28 pm | delete
    there is this really interesting recent study out there about the family dynamic differences when the dad stays home and mom works vs the opposite.
  • Mujjen Dec 14, 2010 @ 1:47 am | delete
    Interesting discussion! Most important is that children feel loved by both parents, if they are around. Even if one spends more time at home than the other, both are necessary.
  • Irenemaria Oct 17, 2010 @ 9:11 am | delete
    What ever is the case. My strong believe is that the child needs both of them.
  • Load More

Oh, and don't forget to visit my other lenses.

Loading

by

bakerwoman

I am an avid baker, a knitting fiend, a watercolorist, and an art collector. I also love nature and wildlife. A day job keeps me busy which I blend with... more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!

Parenting tales 

Loading

Highly recommended- 5 stars 

How to Talk So Kids Will Listen & Listen So Kids Will Talk

Amazon Price: $9.42 (as of 06/03/2012)Buy Now

Enjoy your ;ife with your teens. 

Getting to Calm: Cool-Headed Strategies for Parenting Tweens + Teens

Amazon Price: $12.08 (as of 06/03/2012)Buy Now