What Makes a Rock Concert Special?
Making this list was not easy! There are a few concerts that just barely missed being in my Top 10, partly because I didn't want to be too repetitive with the bands and acts I listed (I could easily do a Top 10 list just of Police concerts at this point, given how many I attended on the reunion tour. ::cough::) I'm sure I'll probably kick myself later for forgetting a few completely as well. But perhaps I'll just have to create a second list at a later date...
(Note: All concert photos on this page were taken by me, unless otherwise indicated. Click on each the image to see a full gallery of photos from the show, when available.)
What Makes a Concert Memorable to You?
Before going on with my experiences and preferences, I'd like to know what you enjoy the most about the concert-going experience and what you think makes some events more memorable than others.
10. Roger Waters - August 20, 1999
Baltimore Arena, Baltimore
This concert was the second one I attended on Roger Waters' "In The Flesh" tour, but it was much more memorable to me than the first. The first time had been at the E-Center in Camden New Jersey, a terrible venue where I'd been all the way at the back surrounded by people who'd never heard any of Roger's solo work - they only wanted to hear Pink Floyd classics like "Money." (Someone also stole the t-shirt I'd bought right off the back of my chair!) When some friends of mine from the Pink Floyd mailing list "Echoes" scored a great block of tickets on the floor for the Baltimore date, I jumped at the opportunity to see the show again with them. I was so glad I did because our seats were 9th row, dead center on the floor, a perfect vantage point to enjoy Roger's performance.
I loved finally getting to hear some of the songs from one of my favorite albums, "Amused to Death," performed live and Roger's band was very good - maybe not Pink Floyd, no, but good enough to recreate the older songs well and give them some fresh life, too. The crowd around us were more dedicated fans who appreciated Roger's solo work as much as the Pink Floyd tracks. Also memorable was the fact that my mother wanted to go to the concert at the last minute, but all I was able to purchase for her was a bad seat in the back of the arena. At the show's intermission, my friends banded together to help me "smuggle" her down onto the floor with us. We had discovered Floyd and Roger's music together, so it was great to be able to enjoy the concert with my mom, and in the company of some of my best "fannish friends" at the time.
"In The Flesh" Concert DVD
Roger Waters - In the Flesh (Live)
Amazon Price: $7.39 (as of 02/23/2012)![]()
This DVD is a great concert video, fully capturing Roger's 1999-2000 "In The Flesh" tour. I highly recommend it to any fan of Roger's work who may have missed the chance to see this show in person.
9. Taylor Hawkins - May 4, 2010
Sonar, Baltimore
I love good drumming - and really good drummers! Taylor Hawkins of the Foo Fighters is one of my favorite drummers, and I especially enjoy his solo work with his band Taylor Hawkins & The Coattail Riders (in fact sometimes I think I like their music even better than the Foos'...!) Getting the chance to see Taylor perform in small, grungy clubs when he tours with the Coattail Riders is just an awesome experience for a drum geek like me, and of the three times to date I've seen him the most memorable was at the Sonar in Baltimore, Maryland. The sound wasn't the best in there - in fact the room was incredibly loud! - but I couldn't beat the vantage point, being dead center and close enough to practically touch Taylor's bass drum as he was playing.
It didn't hurt to be there with a wonderful fellow fan and friend to enjoy the experience - and who made sure I had the chance to finally meet Taylor after the show and get a photograph with him. Sweet!
Want to read my full concert review of Taylor Hawkins, May 4 2010? Click here.
Taylor Hawkins: "Red Light Fever"
Red Light Fever
Amazon Price: $5.00 (as of 02/23/2012)![]()
Taylor's second solo album with The Coattail Riders is great fun, especially for any fan of 70s and 80s rock music. While paying tribute to his favorite musicians, Taylor even gets some of them to contribute to the proceedings, including Roger Taylor and Brian May of Queen. Read my full album review if you need further convincing that this album is worth checking out.
8. Van Halen - October 1, 2007
Wachovia Center, Philadelphia
Confession time: although I grew up as a child of the 80s, I never was big on Van Halen when I was younger. The music, the macho bravado - it just wasn't my thing even as hugely popular as they were at the time. Yet VH is one of my fiance David's all-time favorite bands, so when they announced they would be touring again in 2007, we bought a pair of tickets and I figured I'd have fun because David would be having fun. I didn't expect to be so thrilled by the Van Halen concert experience myself!
When I was younger I did not realize what an incredible guitar player Eddie Van Halen was. Hearing him perform live certainly opened my ears to his amazing, unique talent, and the way he can get sounds from his guitar I've never heard anyone else ever make. And David Lee Roth, of course, is perhaps the ultimate showman. Cheesy and over-the-top, he embraces his outrageousness like I've never seen any other performer do. Even when he forgot the words to "Ice Cream Man" after a long and convoluted intro, he turned it into a joke that had the whole arena cheering and applauding. Van Halen's music is just plain, fun music and the kind of hard rock simply meant to be enjoyed at full ear-splitting volume in an arena. Now every time "Panama" or "Atomic Punk" comes on the radio, I have to crank it up!
7. Fish - June 21, 2008
Theater of the Living Arts, Philadelphia

It's 1991 and I'm a freshman in college with a crush on a boy who was completely wrong for me, save we shared the same taste in music. i> he told me. He made me a copy of "Misplaced Childhood" and I soon after bought a copy of "Clutching at Straws" which would become my supreme "theme album" for all of college - and then some.
Oddly enough, I became more interested in lead singer/songwriter Fish's solo work than that college crush ever was, and followed Fish's career for years but never got to see him perform live until 2008. The concert was at one of my favorite intimate venues, the Theater of the Living Arts in Philadelphia. I was able to briefly meet Fish at a fan meet & greet before the show - awesome! - and at least thank him for the music that meant so much to me all these years. I had no idea that the show to follow would in fact be a special "Clutching at Straws" night featuring nearly the entire album performed live. I'd be lying to say I didn't get extremely emotional at finally hearing him perform these songs which meant so much to me, and looking around at the audience many others were obviously having the same emotional reaction as well. Fish is a great showman and tells great stories to go with the music. I'd not miss him again if he ever comes back to tour in the United States.
Marillion's "Clutching at Straws"
Clutching at Straws
Amazon Price: $4.94 (as of 02/23/2012)![]()
No doubt about it, this album has a place on my "Desert Island Discs" list. Fans of progressive and "concept"-driven rock music definitely need to have this album in their collection. Gorgeous music and great lyrics.
6. Foo Fighters - October 6, 2007
The Borgata, Atlantic City
The Foo Fighters are perhaps my favorite live band, hands down. There's a joy and energy to their live performances like no other, especially when you get the chance to see them in a smaller venue as compared to an arena or concert hall. I've seen them twice at the Borgata in Atlantic City and will always go there to see them tear up the stage. Dave Grohl is another master of audience participation, joking with fans, inviting young kids up onto the stage so they can see better, and just having as much fun as everyone else in the audience is having. This show was memorable for me because I'd gotten there early enough to secure a space right up at the edge of the stage - at least, up to the edge of the pit, which was mostly empty except for crew and one little old lady in a wheelchair. I don't know if she was a relative of one of the band members or an Atlantic City high roller seeking some entertainment thrills, but she was rocking out with the rest of us, proving that the Foos can entertain everyone, young and old. A Different Side of the Foos Live...
Foo Fighters: Skin and Bones
Amazon Price: $11.36 (as of 02/23/2012)![]()
Although this specific Foos tour didn't make my Top 10 list of concerts, it's a great concert video to get a taste for their "softer side." Featuring acoustic arrangements of many of their hits as well as selections from the "In Your Honor" double-cd, it's definitely a must have for any Foo fan.
5. Warren Zevon - February 14, 1996
Theater of the Living Arts, Philadelphia
Velentine's Day may not seem like the kind of a night to go to a concert solo. Yet in a way, that's what made this Warren Zevon performance so special to me. I had just had a bad split with my long-distance, on-again-off-again boyfriend and was feeling particularly low. When Warren opened his Valentine's Day set with "Splendid Isolation," I knew I was in the right place that night.
Warren's music had long been a favorite of mine, and his voice and witty, cutting lyrics always touched a special place in my musical soul. Warren also was a master at communicating with his audience in a small venue like the TLA. I was near the stage, and it was only the second time I'd seen Warren live but this was a much more intimate venue than the first. He ribbed us, wondering what we all doing there on Valentine's Day listening to his morose music. He cut down hecklers and kept us captivated, playing nothing more than guitar, harmonica and piano. I would see Warren two more times at the TLA before cancer stole him from us; each performance was always one to treasure and proof that a true artist needs nothing more than his voice and his instrument to communicate with his audience. I still miss Warren and his music so badly today.
Warren Zevon Live: "Learning to Flinch"
Learning to Flinch
Amazon Price: $0.97 (as of 02/23/2012)![]()
This live music cd does a great job of capturing Warren's performance around the time that I saw him in 1996. Lots of great classic songs such as "Roland the Headless Thompson Gunner" and "Excitable Boy," along with more recent (at the time) numbers such as the fabulous "Piano Fighter."
4. The Musical Box performs "The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway"
Keswick Theater, Glenside (can't remember the date)
There are tribute bands, and then there is "The Musical Box." This band from Montreal takes the art of tribute band musicianship and staging to a level unlike any other group I've ever seen. They recreate specific Genesis tours to the letter, including all of Peter Gabriel's on-stage monologues, elaborate costumes, lighting and slide-show effects. And of course, the music. The Musical Box sound so good, some have even commented that they sound better than Genesis ever did themselves when performing live in the 1970s!
Singer Denis Gagné's ability to nearly "channel" Peter Gabriel is almost eerie, and was never more evident than when the band re-staged the classic Genesis album/tour "The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway." The Musical Box received tremendous support from Genesis themselves for this project, including giving them copies of the original 1,200 slides for the back-screen projections. They were also given access to the original album master tapes and did a fabulous job of recreating the music and entire experience of the show.
I've seen The Musical Box perform at least a half-dozen times through the years, recreating every early Genesis tour from "Foxtrot" to "Trick of the Tail," but none was as mind-blowing an experience as their "Lamb" show. I can't wait to see it again when they bright the production back on the road in 2011/2012.
The Musical Box - "Back in NYC"
3. The Police - February 12, 2007
Whisky A Go-Go, Los Angeles
Getting to attend this press conference/"rehearsal" concert was an absolute dream come true, and no small accomplishment. Although I had been a lifelong fan of The Police, I'd never had the chance to see them live in concert during the 1980s which was something I'd always regretted. Rumors were flying like crazy by the end of 2006 that a reunion tour was in the air, and when it was announced that the band would be opening the Grammy Awards on February 11, 2007 with a "press conference" to follow the next day, us fans all knew that could only mean one thing: TOUR TIME!
Always an instigator, I started making a lot of noise on various fan forums when it was announced that members of Sting's official fan club would be eligible for 20 invitations to the press conference, but none were being offered to fans on Stewart and Andy's websites/forums. Well, all of a sudden 4 tickets became available to people on Stewart's site - and I was one of the lucky four to win one! I had only a few days to make travel arrangements from the East Coast, but ended up sharing a hotel room with a friend and fellow fan and met up with numerous others there, some whom I would end up seeing and getting to know much better over the next two years...
The rehearsal/performance the next morning was brief, but magical. We stood in line for hours to get in right at the foot of the stage, and I couldn't believe I was, at long last, hearing my favorite band perform live! Yes, the performance was rough, but the energy was intense, the room full of fellow fans (some great, popular musicians in their own right) celebrating the return of The Police. I'll never forget the magic of that morning performance and the adventures that followed through the length of the entire tour.
2. The Police, August 7 2008
Madison Square Garden, New York City
The final show of The Police's Reunion Tour was something special, more so for the celebration and the people I was with than the concert itself. After several months of aggravation as the band kept adding more shows to the end of the tour - frustrating people who had bought tickets to earlier dates believing those to be the actual last shows, many fans were fed up. They were also upset because, as the concert was being offered "for charity", ticket prices were double what they had been for all other dates.
But then something special happened - Stewart Copeland offered up 100 free tickets to his fans via his website. 80 of the tickets were in a prime side location to the stage, the other 20 were in the front "pit" at the stage. These pit tickets had been selling for over $1,000 each on ebay, if you could even obtain one as most were going to friends and family of the band and other "VIPs." I was one of the lucky ones to get a free pit ticket from Stewart so I could be there right at the front, with some of my best friends from around the world, to say goodbye to our favorite band. The experience was truly magical, especially with the interaction we had with Stewart and getting the chance to, at long last, pass along the Flag of Copelandia and see it displayed triumphantly behind his kit for the encores. I'd been there for the very beginning of the tour, and was there to say goodbye at the very end.
Read the PoliceWiki entry for more information about this concert performance.
The Police 8/7/2008 - Final Farewell Video
The Police are "Certifiable"!
The Police: Certifiable - Live In Buenos Aires (2-DVD 2-CD Set)
Amazon Price: $7.90 (as of 02/23/2012)![]()
This 2-CD, 2-DVD boxed set is a great memento from The Police's Reunion Tour. The live show was recorded in Buenos Ares and the set also features a cool behind-the-scenes documentary about the band and the tour.
1. Roger Waters - November 11, 2010
Wachovia Center, Philadelphia
When Roger Waters announced he would be taking "The Wall" back out on the road for the album's 30th anniversary, I was thrilled. I had not been one of the fortunate few to see "The Wall" performed back in the early 1980s but had long heard about this amazing live show. I originally planned to go to two shows on the tour - and ended up going four times because I was so blown away by the production.
"Spectacle" doesn't even begin to describe what this concert was like. I've never seen a concert presentation that so masterfully combined every element of what makes a live music presentation special. The sound quality was pristine, even in a venue, the Wachovia Center, which is notoriously dreadful for rock concerts. Roger and his band were in top musical form, recreating the magic of the original album while driving some songs, such as "Run Like Hell," harder than ever. Roger was incredibly dynamic and wonderful at engaging with the audience, even with the humongous Wall towering over him and dwarfing the performers.
And of course, the visual presentation of "The Wall" was unlike anything I'd ever seen. Large animated puppets, airplanes crashing into the stage, smoke and explosions, 3-dimensional video effects projected onto the Wall being built before the audience's eyes and finally being brought down in a tumbling crash at the end. It was such a phenomenal show I had to go to as many performances as possible just to try to take in all the different aspects of it all. November 11, 2010 was the last performance I saw and in some ways I had the best vantage point: slightly elevated side stage, so I could appreciate the visual effects as well as get a view of the stage mechanics. I was also right next to where Roger appears from behind the Wall during "Nobody Home," which was really special to get to experience so close-up.
Read my review of Roger Waters' "The Wall Live" three nights in Philadelphia: November 8, 9 and 11, 2010.
Roger Waters Performs "Nobody Home" - November 11, 2010
Pink Floyd's "The Wall"
The Wall
Amazon Price: $18.99 (as of 02/23/2012)![]()
Is "The Wall" the greatest Pink Floyd album of all time? That may be a topic of considerable debate among fans, but there's no denying the power of the music and this album to many. The grandeur of "The Wall" doesn't need an immense stage show to appreciate, and it is certainly unlike any other rock album I've ever heard.
What Was Your Most Memorable Concert Experience?
Tell me about the concerts you've been to and enjoyed the most, and what made them so special to you. I'd love to hear about them!
-
Reply
-
AnthonyAltorenna
Jul 27, 2011 @ 8:04 pm | delete
- I've seen a lot of bands, from the Allman Brothers to the Who. For my money, Bruce & the E Street Band consistently put on the best live show.
Take a bow, Big Man. You will be missed.
-
-
Reply
-
sockii
Jul 27, 2011 @ 8:07 pm | delete
- I was lucky to see Bruce/the E Street Band a few years ago when they were closing down the Spectrum in Philly. Actually I think it was the last time they played Philly before we lost Clarence - just such a huge loss to music, he was absolutely one of the best.
-
-
Reply
-
LabKitty
Jul 9, 2011 @ 5:33 pm | delete
- Wasn't there, but this is an amazing moment:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N8ByjoK3VVc
-
-
Reply
-
poddys
Mar 30, 2011 @ 4:26 am | delete
- Thanks for the link to my article and I am really pleased that it helped to inspire a great lens. The Music Box would be a great concert for me. I first heard Genesis back in 1972 when someone loaned me a copy of their latest album, Foxtrot. From then I have been a great fan, but only saw them once, 1st July 1987 at Wembley Stadium.
I have seen Yes twice, in the 70's, they used to put on a great concert back in the day.
I saw Pink Floyd once, but the venue was a small outdoor one in Auckland, and half the audience had to try to find somewhere to squat on a steep slope in the trees. You couldn't see half the stage, plus my ex didn't like them, so the mood was killed.
Other notable concerts include Steve Miller Band, Juan Luis Guerra, Camel, Rick Wakeman. Haven't been to any lately, but I would love to see the stage production of War Of The Worlds, and also Kitaro.
-
-
Reply
-
sockii
Mar 30, 2011 @ 7:23 am | delete
- The Musical Box are great - I'm looking forward to their return tour this winter for sure. I only saw Genesis perform once, a few years ago. It was definitely a good show but I would have loved to have seen them back in the Gabriel days. I saw Yes once as well and agree - great show! I've long been a fan of progressive rock from the 70s and their musicianship generally makes for a quality live performance.
Pity about the Floyd show - I saw them a few times on the Momentary Lapse and Division Bell tours. Gilmour is a wonderful guitarist but I missed the "edge" of Waters with him no longer being in the band.
-
by sockii
I'm a self-proclaimed Jane of All Trades who has written for numerous sites on-line including the Yahoo!Contributor Network, Demand Studios and Suite101.... more »
- 114 featured lenses
- Winner of 35 trophies!
- Top lens » Weight Watchers Points Plus: The Problem of 29
Explore related pages
- The Police Tour 2007-2008: My Wild Adventures Following The Band The Police Tour 2007-2008: My Wild Adventures Following The Band
- Stewart Copeland - The Rhythmatist of The Police Stewart Copeland - The Rhythmatist of The Police
- The Ultimate Pink Floyd Fan Survey The Ultimate Pink Floyd Fan Survey
- The Ultimate Police Fan Survey The Ultimate Police Fan Survey
- Who Is the Best Drummer in Rock Music? Who Is the Best Drummer in Rock Music?
- Foo Fighters Drummer Taylor Hawkins: A Tribute Foo Fighters Drummer Taylor Hawkins: A Tribute






