Never Too Many Christmas Cookies

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic by 25 people | Log in to rate

Ranked #294 in Food, #4,031 overall

Welcome

Merry Christmas. Come on in and have a cookie. You can never have too many Christmas cookies around the house during the holiday season. So no matter if you are a beginner baker or a seasoned seasonal human cookie factory come take break from the flour and the dough and lets talk cookies.

Christmas Day has is coming soon. The kitchen is covered in flour and cookie sheets. Tis the season of flour in your hair and chocolate on your nose. Keep those ovens warm.Have a safe and Happy New Year.

The Basics of Baking 

Getting Started

If you've never baked in your life, don't stress, cookies are easy.

What kind of cookies do you want to make?

The most easiest cookies to make are drop cookies. You follow your recipe, preheat your oven, get your batter ready, prepare your cookie sheet, and drop lumps of batter on cookie sheet, put in oven, set timer, it rings and they are done, take cookies off sheet place on rack or wax paper to cool. Try not to burn fingers on cookies while sampling. Ta da you've made cookies.

The next cookies you can choose are molded cookies. These are often balled or shaped by hand in some way. Often these recipes need to be refridgerated between mixing and putting them on the baking sheet. Most of my favorite cookies need to be refridgerated, rolled in balls, rolled in sugar, then placed on the cookie sheet to bake.

Then there are rolled cookies. These cookies are rolled out with a rolling pin and cut into shapes, either with a knife or cookie cutter. Often this dough also needs to refridgerated before using.

There are a couple of other methods for making cookies but frankly I'm not a fan of them so lets stick with these three for now. :)

Cookie Books on Amazon 

Mrs. Fields Cookie Book: 100 Recipes from the Kitchen of Mrs. Fields

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $12.95

Betty Crocker's Cooky Book

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $16.47 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $24.95

Usually ships in 24 hours

Betty Crocker Cookie Book

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $15.61 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $22.95

Usually ships in 24 hours

New Baking Book: More than 600 Recipes, Tips, and How-to Techniques (Better Homes & Gardens)

Great book. Try the recipe for 'Big Soft Ginger Cookies'. They are so good. I gave this recipe a 10 in my recipe rating system.

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $19.95

Cookie Recipes 

Cookies at AllRecipes
A great site with tons of recipes. I like this site because of the printing option it gives you when printing out the recipes. You can enlarge the type and print it for different size recipe cards. It makes filing your printed recipes so easy.
Christmas-Cookies
500 searchable cookie recipes.
Grandma Clara's Favorite Christmas Cookies
A small collection of cookie recipes.
Holiday Cookie Recipes & Tips
Cookies with a southern flare.
Baking Christmas Cookies
Recipes and baking tips
Cookie Recipes
This site features a nice photo interface for their recipes.
Vegan Cookie Recipes
Here are a three vegan cookie recipes.
Fat-free Cookies Recipes
Here are some recipes for people concerned about their fat intake. Many of these recipes are noted as vegan as well.

My First Cook Book 

I still have the first cookbook I ever got. I was in 4th grade and the book fair came to my school and there was this cookbook. It was a whole 95 cents and had 12 recipes one for each month. I still use my first cookbook as it has the best snicker doodle recipe ever in it. I keep planning to scan the pages so I don't ruin the book as the pages have many spills and musta been printed on the cheapest of paper as they have yellowed and are brittle tho it hasn't been that many years since its purchase.

So all you parents out there go get your little future bakers a cookbook to call their own, they'll thank you heaps for it later. :)

Baking with Kids books on Amazon 

Christmas Cookies!: A Cookbook with Cookie Cutters

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $12.99

The Kids' Holiday Baking Book: 150 Favorite Dessert Recipes from Around the World

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $16.95

Gifts in a Jar: For Kids

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $9.00 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $9.00

Usually ships in 24 hours

Following a Recipe 

I've always said that a recipe is merely a suggestion. I use them as a place to start. I often depart from a recipe and the finished cookie may in no way reseamble the cookie in the recipe.

So while you look over recipes and make your cookies, learn from them, get to know what ingredient will do what then after you have learned a bit about your ingredients you can play by adding more of this or less of that. Soon you can start making recipes of your own.

Ingredients Explained 

Cookies 101: Tips
A good place to start to learn about what ingredients are, what they do to your recipe etc.

Successful Cookies 

Helpful Hints

  • Read First Read the recipe all the way thru first before starting
  • Ingredients Make sure you have all the ingredients you need before starting to mix your recipe
  • Preheat your oven Before you start to combine your ingredient turn your oven on and start it preheating so it will be all ready when you finish mixing your recipe together(*note: if dough needs to be refridgerated before molding or rolling do not preheat oven until you are ready to begin putting cookies on baking sheet.)
  • Flattening If your recipe calls for you to flatten your dropped or molded cookie a sugar coated juice or tumbler glass bottom is usually perfect.
  • Air Pans I love Air Bake pan. They cook your cookies evenly so your cookies do not get too brown and crisp on the edges.
  • Parchment Paper This was the best thing someone ever advised me to use for cookies. A sheet of baking parchment paper between the dough and the pan saves on cleanup time, makes the cookies release so much easier, and makes for a prettier cookie. One sheet of parchment paper can be used many times. Once you give using parchment a try you will never go back to baking without it.
  • Storing I like to store my cookies in a tight sealing plastic container. Rubbermaid or tupperware containers are perfect. They can be used in the freezer too.
  • Freezing Most cookies can be frozen. Plastic containers such as mentioned in the hint above are perfect to freeze your cookies in. Cookies with delicate decorations might not freeze nicely and the decorations crumble from being stacked.

Make It Fun 

Baking can be boring, I admit it, it is very repetitive. Rolling 120 little balls of dough in sugar over and over can become a drag. So make it fun. Turn your music on and do a little dancing, sing along badly. Have a baking buddy come over and join you.

If you find rolling all those little dough balls in sugar just too monotonous a feat to even think about consider making cut out cookies. Cutting out and decorating shaped cookies can entertain children for hours. It can be very creative.

Cake Mix Cookies 

Did you know you can make cookies from store bought cake mixes. They can be a real time saver when you need cookies fast.
Cake Mix Cookies
Turn any cake mix into a cookie mix.
Vegan Cake Mix Cookie Recipe
Turn any cake mix into a vegan cookie mix, no eggs needed.
Easy Cake Mix Cookies
Four Cookie recipes using a cake mix base

Cake Mix Cookie Books on Amazon 

Cake Mix Cookies: More Than 175 Delectable Cookie Recipes That Begin With a Box of Cake Mix

I own this one. Lots of easy to make cookies in this book. I am planning on trying the peanut butter cookie recipe that is made from a yellow cake mix.

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $11.53 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $16.95

Temporarily out of stock. Order now and we'll deliver when available. We'll e-mail you with an estimated delivery date as soon as we have more information. Your credit card will not be charged until we ship the item.

About Chocolate Chip Cookies 

America's Most Popular Cookie

The History of Chocolate Chip Cookies
The story about how Ruth Wakefield invented Chocolate Chip Cookies.
Giant Chocolate Chip Cookie
A giant chocolate chip cookie baked in a pizza pan.
Secrets of Really Good Chocolate Chip Cookies
Hints and suggestions for successful chocolate chip cookies.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Stuff on Amazon 

A Baker's Field Guide to Chocolate Chip Cookies

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $15.34 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $17.95

Usually ships in 24 hours

Hershey Special Dark Chips 12oz - 6 Unit Pack

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $23.94 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price:

Usually ships in 1-2 business days

About Gingerbread 

Christmas Gingerbread
The History Of Gingerbread
Christmas Gingerbread (Lebkuchen) and Christmas Cheer
Something for you science lovers, why gingerbread makes the spirit brighter.
Christmas Customs Gingerbread House Recipe Holiday Cooking
Recipe and directions to build a Gingerbread house.
Christmas Gingerbread Recipes
Traditional gingerbread recipes and others for you gingerbread lovers.

Gingerbread Stuff on Amazon 

Gingerbread Houses

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $10.04 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $13.95

Usually ships in 24 hours

R & M Gingerbread Cookie Cutter Set - 6 pcs

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $8.75 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price:

Usually ships in 1-2 business days

Decorating Your Christmas Cookies 

Christmas Cookie Decorating 101
A short article on different methods and kinds of items to decorate your Christmas cookies with.
Decorating Cookies Takes a Certain Touch (Okay, Craziness)
A long article from the Washington Post on decorating cookies for Christmas
Holiday Cookie Decorating
Decorating ideas.

Storing And Freezing Your Cookies 

Saving & Storing Your Christmas Cookies
A short article on the best way to save, store and freeze your Christmas cookies.
Create a Holiday Gift Container
Make a cookie storage or gift canister out of a FolgersĀ® AromaSeal%u2122 canister. FolgersĀ® shows how to reuse their coffee container into a christmasy place to store your goodies. The direction contains templates to print out on your printer to create a unique gift for friends and family.

Wrapping the Cookies to Give 

When I was a kid I watched my mom make cookie and give them away in almost anything. One year they would be given away in a santa head cookie jar, the next a metal tin with a Christmas image on it. It was alway different.

Personally I like tins or covered platters. These can be gotten cheaply after Christmas and kept for the next year. They travel well for family and friends going home after the holidays and stack well so you can fit alot of cookies in a small area. I usually add a bow and a tag with the recipients name on it. Inside the cookies will be wrapped in color saran wrap(I like red) to keep them fresh.

Gift Giving Containers on Amazon 

Pfaltzgraff Snow Bear 6-Piece Enamel on Steel Bowl Set, Small

Separate or all together these pretty containers filled with homemade goodness will make a cheerful holiday gift.

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $11.00

Tupperware Holiday Snack Canister

A great holiday container for your homebaked goodies.

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $13.99

Rubbermaid HPFG4013RDCHILI Durable Square 4.2-Cup Food Storage Container

Add a bow, a tag, and of course your cookies for the perfect homemade gift.

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $3.29

Rubbermaid HPFG4020RDCHILI Durable Rectangle 5.1-Cup Food Storage Container

Add a bow, a tag, and of course your cookies for the perfect homemade gift.

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price:

Rubbermaid FG7G1200DENIM Collapsibles 6-Cup Food Storage Container

These are very cool. These collapse flat when empty for better cabinet storage. They would make a nice addition to your gift of cookies.

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $10.39 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price:

Usually ships in 24 hours

Cookies as Gifts 

Cookies as a gift usually is a big hit. Who might like a gift of a plate of cookies for Christmas?
  • The Office- Bring a big covered platter of cookies to the office as a gift to all. Leave in the breakroom with a Christmas card signed with your name.
  • The Mailman- We always leave a plate of cookie in the mailbox for our postal carrier. Address the gift to your mailman so they know it is meant for them. Make sure your offering is sealed so as to keep the ants and other critters from stealing your mail person's treat.
  • The Babysitter- A take home plate for the babysitter always seems to go over well. Tho do still gift your babysitter with a bit of $ for the holidays too. That holiday cash seems to make her more available on short notice all year long. Cookies just make her smile.
  • Party Host or Hostess- Going to a party? Bring a container of cookies for your host. Don't pressure the host to put them out on their well planned spread. You might even hint it is a treat just for them for after everyone has gone home. Maybe a fun card included about relaxing and cleaning up.
  • Extended Family- If your family is anything like mine it is just too darn big to get everyone a gift. A card seems too small an effort but a gift just isn't in the budget. Cookies come to the rescue. I assemble family cookie plates for all our extended family and close family friends. They are really enjoyed by those with not enough time to bake their own. I always make sure there is at least one of every kind of cookie for every family member of the recipient family. So the bigger the family of the extended family member the bigger the plate they get.
  • Neighbors- We always give a plate to all our neighbors we know. Some have kids, some are elderly, some we only know in passing but come Christmas time they all get cookies. Some exchange gifts of other food stuff with us others just thank you and slip inside their door and later tell you which were there favorites(so you can add more of those next year :) The nice thing about cookie gifts is that no one ever dislikes your gift and no one feels badly about not getting you a gift afterall it is just cookies.

Cookies in a Jar Gifts 

Another way to give the gift of cookies are Cookies in a Jar Recipes. Basically you the gift giver prepare the dry ingredients and pack them up in a pretty jar. Print out the recipe and instructions on a notecard and give the jar as a DIY gift. The nice thing about this gift is that the recipient can make the cookies whenever they want so if they get an avalance of holiday treats at Christmas your gift of cookies in a jar can be enjoyed later when treats are not so overwhelming.
Cookies in a Jar
Very good directions for preparing your mix in a jar and some recipes.
Cookie Mix in a Jar
This site has 40 cookie in a jar recipes. Have fun.
Gifts In a Jar
Twelve recipes perfect to gift in a jar.
Cookie In A Jar Recipes
Twelve more recipes to give as gifts.
Cookie Mixes in a Jar
Seven recipes to gift to friends and family.

Cookies in a Jar Recipe Books on Amazon 

The Mason Jar Cookie Cookbook

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $9.32 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $12.95

Usually ships in 24 hours

Gifts in a Jar: Cookies (Gifts in a Jar, 1)

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $9.00 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $9.00

Usually ships in 24 hours

Favorite Cookie? 

What's Yours?

Loading poll. Please Wait...

2006 Cookie Poll Winner 

The cookie with the most votes for 2007(for the second Christmas in a row) was....drumroll please...Snickerdoodles....Congrats to the fantabulous Snickerdoodle. What a talented cookie it is too, spicey and cinnimony and that subtle taste of cream of tarter...it couldn't of happened to a nicer cookie.

Continue voting as a new winner for 2008 will be announced next year. Thanks for all who participated in the voting.

More Cookie Books on Amazon 

Christmas Cookies Are for Giving: Recipes, Stories and Tips for Making Heartwarming Gifts

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $11.53 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $16.95

Usually ships in 24 hours

1001 Cookie Recipes: The Ultimate A-To-Z Collection of Bars, Drops, Crescents, Snaps, Squares, Biscuits, and Everything That Crumbles

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $19.95

Cookies & Biscotti (Williams-Sonoma Kitchen Library)

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $14.95

Joy of Cooking Christmas Cookies

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $18.95

The 2006 Christmas Cookie Baking Season 

A list of cookies that I have baked this Christmas Season(so far)
  • Peanut Butter and Jelly Thumbprint Jammers - Tasted Just like PB & J sandwich, the kids are sure to like them
  • Big Soft Ginger Cookies - Recipe found in the BH&G baking Book, very good cookie, the taste of a ginger snap but but soft and cakey.
  • M&M Cookies - This is a family favorite it is made every year. The Nestle tollhouse cookie recipe is used but with M&Ms instead of chips.
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter M&M Cookies - Got some peanut butter M&Ms on clearance after Halloween, adapted a chewy chocolate cookie recipe to use with them. They were a bit too rich for me but my mom loved them.
  • Chocolate Coconut Cake Mix Cookies - I kinda just threw this one together. I hoped they would come out tasting closer to a mounds bar but the tasted more like brownies with coconut. Still good but not quite what I had intended. They had a great texture.
  • Kissable Cookies - My mom really wanted to try making cookies with these Hersey Kissable candies. We made a double chocolate brownie cookie recipe found in a Hersey chocolate baking book she had and added the Kissables to it. It was very chocolaty. Too much for me but perfect for mom.
  • Big Fat Oatmeal-Raisin Cookies - Found this recipe in the book 'Cake Mix Cookies' by Camilla V. Saulsbury. I made the cookies smaller than the recipe called for so ended up with about double the 2 dozen the book said it should make. The cookies were soft, cakey and spicey.
  • Coconut Macaroons - These are yummy. The recipe came from the same book as the previous cookie. The cookies were cakey and chewy and moist. Perfect.
  • Chocolate Mint Chippers - This was another thrown together recipe. It had a swiss chocolate cake mix starting point. I added some peppermint extract, then a bit of left over mint chips and some white chocolate/milk chocolate swirled chipped. They came out quite well, not as cakey as I thought they would but still semisoft.
  • Strawberry Bananarama Softies - Also from the 'Cake Mixe Cookies' book. These are darn tasty. The recipe is actually just for bananarama cookies but I used a strawberry cake mix instead of the yellow cake mix the recipe called for. A nice melt in your mouth soft texture too. I sprinkled with red decorating sugar to make them festive.

Christmas Cookie Exchanges 

I've been to a few Christmas Cookie Exchanges. They are a great way to get a large variety of cookies without baking many, many different batches.

The way the ones I've gone to have worked is that you bring one dozen cookies per party guest plus one extra dozen, so if there are 12 other party guests besides you, you'd bring 13 dozen cookies of one type of cookie to the exchange. Each exchange guest gets one of your dozen to take home, you get one of each of their dozen. The extra dozen is for sharing and snacking while at the exchange party.

So basically you take 13 dozen of one kind of cookie and bring home 12 dozen of 12 kinds of cookies. Its fun and practical.
Christmas Cookie Exchange
Heres how this person arranges her exchanges.
Cookie Exchange Party
A slightly different approach to a cookie exchange. This is more like the ones i've attended.

No Time to Bake? 

Purchasing Cookies to Give or Have on Hand.

Lots of people just don't have the time to bake dozens and dozens of cookies. Luckily there are those that will not only do that for you but will send your handpicked treats to you or your friends. My sister is not such a good baker of cookies so she orders hers for friends and family. Here are some places to shop for some yummy goodies to give and get.


David's Cookies (Fairfield Gourmet Foods Corporation)



Cheryl & Co.



Mrs. Fields Gifts, Inc

Cat Cookies 

It wouldn't be Christmas without the cat trying to climb the tree at least once per holiday season. So keep your furball in the holiday spirit with these tastey treats.
Homemade Cat Treat Recipes
Sardine cookies for your cat. Yum?
Holy Mackerel Cat Treats
Another cat treat recipe, this one using mackeral. MMMMMeow.
Kitty Kookies
Tuna flavored kitty cookies. Use a Christmas cookie cutter to make these purrfect present for your feline.

Dog Cookies 

Pamper your pooch for keeping the season merry with some homemade snacks. Fill his little stocking with some goodies made just for him.
Christmas Cookies for your Doggie
Make some homemade christmas yummies for Fido. Dogs like Chrismas cookies too.
Good Dog Cookies
Another dog cookie recipe to please your pooch.
Microwave Dog Cookies Gift in a Jar
A cookie gift to give to your friends' doggie dears.

Pet Treat Cookbooks on Amazon 

Cats and Pups love homemade goodies. Here are a couple of books to keep purr boxes purring and dog tails wagging.

The Ultimate Dog Treat Cookbook: Homemade Goodies for Man's Best Friend

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $10.19 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $14.99

Usually ships in 24 hours

The Ultimate Cat Treat Cookbook: Homemade Goodies for Finicky Felines

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $10.19 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $14.99

Usually ships in 24 hours

Cookie Ornaments 

How to Make Gingerbread Christmas Ornaments
Directions for making non-edible gingerbread cookie ornaments.

Baking and Cookie Forums 

Got a question? Confused about something your cookbook says? Looking for a recipe your Grandmother used to make? Find the appropriate forum discussion and ask away.
Baking 911
A great resource. This forum has a great collection of knowing poster. Go visit, lots to learn here. Forums on many baking topics.

Christmas Cookies Stories 

The Christmas Cookie Case
A Children's story about Mother Goose's missing Christmas Cookies.
The Baker's Dozen: A Saint Nicholas Tale
Tale told by Aaron Shepard about the gift of generosity.

What an Odd Cookie... 

Strange cookie stories from around the net

Dashboard Baking
New Hampshire woman bakes cookies on dashboard of her Toyota
Cat Poop Cookies
Not very festive but very strange.

Suggestions and Feedback 

I welcome your feedback. Would you like something added? Know a good link or book? Did I manage to misspell something? Did you find a dead link? Let me know, afterall this Kiln Goddess isn't all knowing ;-)

submit

Baking Stuff on Amazon 

Kaiser Bakeware ExtraordinAire 16-by-14-Inch Nonstick Cookie Sheet

I only use air pans when baking. They bake your cookies evenly, no more brown edges and not quite cooked centers.

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $27.99 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $28.00

Usually ships in 1-2 business days

Silpat 11-5/8-by-16-1/2-Inch Nonstick Silicone Baking Mat

I want one of these, seems like it would make rolling out dough easier.

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: $18.99 (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $24.99

Usually ships in 24 hours

Baker's Secret 10-by-16-Inch Nonstick Cooling Rack, Set of 2

I don't use racks but my mother swears by them. Mom can't be wrong, can she?

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $7.99

Rubbermaid HPFG4025RDCHILI Durable Rectangle 2.4-Gallon Food Storage Container

Great for storing and freezing your Christmas baking.

Avg. Customer Rating: Amazon Rating

Amazon Price: (as of 12/17/2009) Buy Now
List Price: $12.99

by KilnGoddess

The Kiln Goddess is an artist/potter but come Christmas time her kitchen oven is full of cookies and other goodies. From Novenber thru December she ba... (more)
Create a Lens!