Which Digital SLR Camera?

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic by 11 people | Log in to rate

Ranked #2,308 in Tech & Geek, #55,248 overall

How To Choose The Best Digital SLR Camera

There are so many good digital SLR cameras on the market now, with a wide range of prices and specifications, but which one should you buy and from which manufacturer? Why should you buy an SLR instead of a compact? What other features should you look for?

I have been using Nikon SLRs for over twenty years and I have a huge investment in Nikon lenses, so I chose Nikon again, but there are many good alternatives from Canon and others.

This article covers the things to consider when buying a digital camera, a full review of a good mid-range DSLR camera (Nikon D90 / D80) and the variations between the entry-level D40 / D50 / D60 cameras to the full professional cameras (D3, D3x, D700 etc.) in the range and a discussion about sensor sizes and technology. How many mega-pixels do you need? Do extra pixels actually improve the quality?

I have also written an article about classic SLR cameras

And an article about how to choose a compact camera

And a review of my favourite compact camera: Canon Powershot G10

Nikon D80/D90 Review 

There are a couple of new cameras in the Nikon line-up: The D90 is the replacement for the D80, but the D80 is still available and at a reduced price, it is still a great camera and better value than ever. The D700 has also been added between the D300 and the D3. I shall give a brief description each of these, but for many the mid-range D80 or D90 is the ideal choice. These are good either for the enthusiast or beginner.

I have been using Nikons for many years and the D80 or new D90 camera is quite light and compact compared to some earlier Nikon film cameras although not as small as the less expensive D40, D50 and D60 models. It fits nicely in the hand despite being small (I actually prefer cameras to be bigger than this, but I am probably quite old fashioned and in a minority) and all of the important functions are easily accessible even while looking through the view-finder. In fact the main functions are in exactly the same place they have always been on F series film cameras for the last few decades. The D80 is very well made when you consider the price and the lens-mount feels solid and robust when changing lenses. It also seems to be nicely sealed from the elements with rubber seals covering the important connectors etc.

My only complaint is that is doesn't allow me to use the aperture ring on my old lenses. It's not a big problem as the aperture is now set using a very useful finger-wheel which seems to have become the new standard for all SLRs. The old lenses work very well with the D80 body. I just need to remember to lock the aperture ring to minimum aperture setting. Also of course the sensor is smaller than a 35mm slide, so wide angle lenses are a bit less wide-angle than they would have been on a film camera and telephoto lenses a bit more telephoto, but that too appears to be the new standard except for very expensive professional cameras such as the Nikon D3 and now the new D700 "prosumer" model, which both have a full-frame sensor.

As for the photographic results, I certainly can't complain. The metering and focusing are excellent and colours appear very vibrant and images very sharp.

Overall this is a very good mid-priced DSLR sitting between the inexpensive new D60 and the more expensive "prosumer" D300, in terms of price, functionality and robustness. It is a widely available product and very popular. The built-in auto-focus motor allows it to be used with a very wide variety of lenses from Nikor/Nikon and several other manufacturers (The D40, D50 and D60 do not have an auto-focus motor and can only be used with the latest lenses with internal motors)

Difference between D90 and D80

The D90 has a new improved 12.5MP APS sized sensor, similar to the more expensive D300, giving slightly better resolution.

Summary: Good inexpensive alternative to the Nikon D300

The New Nikon D90 

The Nikon D90 is a fantastic mid-range DSLR camera:
Nikon D90 DX 12.3MP Digital SLR Camera with 18-105mm f/3.5-5.6G ED AF-S VR DX Nikkor Zoom Lens

Nikon D90 DX 12.3MP Digital SLR Camera with 18-105mm f/3.5-5.6G ED AF-S VR DX Nikkor Zoom Lens

Amazon Price: Too low to display (as of 12/09/2009) Buy Now

Magic Lantern DVD Guides: Nikon D90

Magic Lantern DVD Guides: Nikon D90

Amazon Price: (as of 12/09/2009) Buy Now

Nikon D90 Digital SLR Camera Body + Nikon 18-200mm VR II Lens + 16GB Memory Card + Nikon EN-EL3e Battery + Case + Cameta Bonus Accessory Kit

Nikon D90 Digital SLR Camera Body + Nikon 18-200mm VR II Lens + 16GB Memory Card + Nikon EN-EL3e Battery + Case + Cameta Bonus Accessory Kit

Amazon Price: $1,599.95 (as of 12/09/2009) Buy Now

Introduction to the Nikon D90 Volume 1 : Basic Controls

Introduction to the Nikon D90 Volume 1 : Basic Controls

Amazon Price: $12.99 (as of 12/09/2009) Buy Now

Compact Camera versus SLR 

What is an SLR?

An SLR is a "Single Lens Reflex" meaning that when composing the picture you are using the same lens to compose the photograph through an optical viewfinder as you will use to expose the photograph. In the past there were also twin-lens reflex cameras, which like many compacts use a different lens for the viewfinder although most digital compacts now use the main lens and photo-sensor, but the image is composed on the screen at the back of the camera. The complex shutter and mirror that allow the same lens to be used for both functions in the SLR make the camera bigger and heavier. For a detailed comparison between the Nikon D80 and a good Canon compact digital Please read this article

Why should you carry around a big digital SLR rather than a small compact camera?

I am not going to tell you that compact cameras are rubbish and you should always use an SLR, in fact many photographs are only captured because someone happened to have a compact in their pocket or handbag. In good lighting conditions the results from a compact can be extremely good, but an SLR gives far more creative control over the picture and in more difficult conditions will significantly outperform optically. I have written an article about how to choose a compact camera

If an SLR and a compact both have the same number of pixels they must both be the same quality?

The two main differences are that the controls are bigger on the SLR and usually much more accessible (i.e. not lots of fiddly menu functions, but discrete buttons and knobs and complete manual over-ride of the automatic functions) and the lenses and sensor are generally bigger in the SLR. You can also change lenses on the SLR rather than having just one general purpose lens. I have written more about different types of sensor below, but generally, the bigger the sensor the better. A small sensor with many pixels will be noisier than a larger sensor with the same number of pixels, which means dark areas in the photograph will be peppered with white dots or random electronic noise. Some compact cameras have tiny sensors, whereas most SLRs have an APS sized sensor (see below) which is a bit smaller than the old 35mm film size used in most film cameras although some expensive ones have the full-frame 35mm size. There are even some very expensive professional "medium format" cameras with enormous sensors.

Canon DSLRs 

Canon Digital Rebel XSi 12.2 MP Digital SLR Camera (Black Body Only)

Canon Digital Rebel XSi 12.2 MP Digital SLR Camera (Black Body Only)

Amazon Price: $499.88 (as of 12/10/2009) Buy Now

Canon EOS 50D 15.1MP Digital SLR Camera (Body Only)

Canon EOS 50D 15.1MP Digital SLR Camera (Body Only)

Amazon Price: Too low to display (as of 12/10/2009) Buy Now

Canon EOS Rebel T1i 15.1 MP CMOS Digital SLR Camera with 3-Inch LCD (Body Only)

Canon EOS Rebel T1i 15.1 MP CMOS Digital SLR Camera with 3-Inch LCD (Body Only)

Amazon Price: $619.95 (as of 12/10/2009) Buy Now

The Full Nikon DSLR Range 

All Nikon DSLR bodies are well made and robust, for the price, with excellent well thought out controls. There are a few extra features as you go up the range, and the cheaper ones have less buttons and simpler options. The image quality also increases as you more up the range, but even at the bottom end this is excellent. All modern lenses (i.e. less than a few decade old) will fit all of the bodies, although some autofocus lenses will only have manual focus on the cheaper models (see description below)

D40x, D50, D60 - good, small, inexpensive 10 MP DSLR cameras which are ideal for the beginner (there is also a 6MP D40) These do not have an internal motor and should be avoided if you have older autofocus Nikon lenses that you want to use (although they can still be used manually)

D5000 (new) - good, small, inexpensive 12 MP DSLR cameras which are ideal for the beginner. This, like the D60, does not have an internal motor and should be avoided if you have older autofocus Nikon lenses that you want to use (although they can still be used manually)

D80 - As reviewed above. An excellent mid-priced 10 MP, which will be replaced by the D90, but still offered great value for money.

D90 - 12 MP APS sized sensor

D200 - 10 MP APS sized sensor. Now replaced by the D300

D300 - 12 MP APS sized sensor. Excellent Prosumer camera, but not as good as the new more expensive D700

D700 - A cut-down version of the D3, with a fantastic, extremely sensitive full-frame 12 MP sensor. I want this one, but it is expensive.

D3 - Huge, expensive professional machine. Very fast. Excellent, but with many features only needed by the professional sports photographer, but only 12 MP (unlike the equivalent Canon that has 24MP)

D3x - Updated D3 Now with 24MP The best DSLR in the world at the moment?

This is my old Nikon F4

Not Impressed...

Film vs. Digital Cameras 

There has been a long debate about which is better film or digital. This debate is getting more and more one-sided as the progress of digital cameras continues. The ultimate resolution may still be from slide-film, although some digital cameras now have more than 20 MP and even that claim looks difficult to justify. I still have several film cameras and of course a huge archive of film and slides going back decades. I think I may finally retire the old camera, but I shall continue scanning my old slides and negatives until I have them all in digital form.

I have written a separate article about classic film cameras, here

A typical scanned slide on a 4000 dpi scanner is 140 MB or 70 MP, arguably a higher resolution than any full-frame digital SLR, but there is also grain on the film, which gives an effective resolution equivalent to rather less than 70MP, depending on the film used. Film can be scanned at higher resolution than 4000dpi, but with diminishing improvement in quality. Scanned film also has the disadvantage that there is an extra stage, during which imperfections may be introduced, between taking the photo and getting the digital image.

I have written a separate article about scanners, here

Whether scanning negatives and/or slides, or using a digital SLR or compact camera you need photo-editing software to improve the results: crop them to get better composition, adjust colours and brightness or just to remove read-eye. There are many great software programs, such as Adobe Photoshop, but you can also download a good free tool called GIMP (This is more complicated, so I have written a separate article about that - see below)

Free Photo-Editing Software (GIMP)

Digital Film Scanners (eBay) 

Loading Fetching new data from eBay now... please stand by
eBay

Different Sensor Sizes 

Compacts

Compacts have various sizes of sensor and when choosing it is worth checking the specification, but most importantly read reviews of the camera because the quality will vary a lot for small cameras. The size is just one thing to consider.

To confuse things further, compact camera sensor sizes are often measured differently to DSLRs. Some sensors are wide-screen and some have an aspect ratio of 4:3. The size is often denoted as a fraction of an inch e.g. 1/3" but may even appear as something like 1/3.6" or 1/1.8" (the crop factor is the relative size compared to 35mm film i.e. a sensor with a crop factor of 2.0 is half the linear size or a quarter of the area)

1/3.6" = 4.0 x 3.0mm = area 12.0mm2 (crop factor 8.7)
1/2.5" = 5.8 x 4.3mm = area 24.7mm2 (crop factor 6.0)
4/3" = 17.3 x 13.0mm = area 225mm2 (crop factor 2.0)

As I said before always read a review of the performance in addition to the size specification.

DSLRs

SLRs have a few different sensor sizes, including Full-frame, APS and Four-Thirds, most are APS, but even these come with variations:

APS-C:

Nikon "DX" format have a crop factor of 1.5
(Nikon, Pentax, Konica, Minolta, Sony and Fuji DSLRs)

Canon entry level cameras have a crop factor of 1.6
Sigma have a crop factor of 1.7

APS-H:

Canon professional DSLRs. These are virtually full-frame and have a crop factor of 1.3

Four Thirds

e.g. Olympus have a crop factor of 2.0

Full Frame
24mm x 36mm i.e. crop factor 1.0

Nikon D3 and D700

The bigger the sensor the easier it is to get low noise and high sensitivity, but the cost and size of the camera will also increase. There are a new range of smaller, lighter, much cheaper lenses from various manufacturers that will only work well with APS and smaller sensors. Always check reviews and don't just go for the biggest sensor.

Photo Galleries 

featured lens Photo Gallery: African Safari Photographs

After many years of world travel, in search of wild animals and beautiful scenery, I have published some of my African Safari photographs here: From Namiba, Botswana, Zimbabwe and Zambia in Southern Africa, these photographs are available as postcar...

featured lens Photo Gallery: South America, Mexico, Cuba

Photo Gallery of South America Countries: Cuba, Mexico, Latin America, Peru These photographs are from my related South American and Latin American travel articles listed below and are available for sale in the form of postcards, mouse-pads, greetin...

featured lens European Photo Gallery

A collection of travel and wildlife photography from all over Europe. Europe has a very diverse variety of architecture and scenery and a long and fascinating history. Here is a selection of some of my photographs from my travel, in the form of pro...

featured lens Photo Gallery: USA and Canada

Photographs from North America: National Parks in USA and Canada, wildlife and nature published by Zazzle on various products from postcard, greeting cards and mouse-pads to T-Shirts and Aprons. These photos are taken from my various North American...

featured lens Photo Gallery: Asia (China, Australia, Borneo, Komodo, India...)

Here is a selection of products featuring photographs from Asia: mainly wildlife photographs from India, the rain forests of Borneo, Malaysia, Australia, Malaysia and China available on postcards, greeting cards, T-Shirts, mugs, mouse-pads etc. from...

Canon Alternatives 

Canon also make an excellent selection of DSLR cameras, including some very high resolution full-frame cameras.

Loading Fetching new data from eBay now... please stand by
eBay

Camera Sensor Technology (CMOS or CCD) 

Which is better CMOS or CCD? First of all, what is the difference and what does it mean?

As I said before always check the reviews before buying, because to say one is better than another is a huge generalisation.

I am a silicon chip design consultant, so I have designed chips similar to these.

CCD

A CCD is a charge-coupled device. Photons (i.e. light "particles") fall onto a matrix of light-sensitive material on the surface of the sensor after being focused by the camera lens and a charge builds up, according to the number of photons hitting each pixel (there are coloured filters to differentiate between red, green and blue light frequencies) When the picture has been taken, the charge from each pixel is then swept off to some computer circuitry where its magnitude is measured, converted to a number and it is processed and stored in the camera memory.

CMOS

CMOS is Complimentary Metal Oxide Semiconductor (or Silicon) i.e. it is a standard silicon chip. There are two main types of silicon chip: CMOS which is small and low-powered and Bipolar which expensive, fast, much larger and uses lots of power and is used for very high-end digital and analogue circuits (my speciality). CMOS is what powers your computer CPU, memory, CD player etc. It has the unfortunate feature of being light sensitive, which is why chips are usually sealed in small black plastic cases, but it also means we can make cheap sensors on a normal chip production line with all of the computer circuitry built into the same chip. The matrix of pixels is similar to the CCD, except there is electronic circuitry between the pixels in the matrix, causing some additional electronic noise. The production is cheaper, so money can be spent elsewhere.

So which is better? That really depends on the individual camera. Always read reviews, but most SLRs, whether CMOS or CCD will have very good, low-noise sensors and generally the bigger the better.

Photography Websites 

featured lens Wildlife and Nature Photography

Wildlife Photography from all over the world: I have been travelling the world taking photographs of animals and nature for many years, so here are some of my photographs and some of my experiences, travel tips, recommendations and advice. I have w...

featured lens Photography, Cameras and Photo Galleries

Here is a selection of Photography articles and Galleries: Travel and Wildlife photography from all over the world, camera reviews, photography tips and techniques, how to choose the best camera for you, digital techniques and software, computer equi...

featured lens Worldwide Travel Photography

This article is about travel-photography all over the world including Brazil, China, Peru, USA, Canada, UK, Morocco, Mexico, Egypt, India, Thailand. I have published several travel photography articles, which I have listed below with some of the ph...

Film Photography, Scanning and Editing Articles 

featured lens Classic Cameras and 35mm Slide Photography

Digital photography is now so good, why would anyone still use film? Surprising a few people still do. The days of 35mm film photography may be numbered, but there are still some reasons to persevere with the old technology, even if you are just goi...

featured lens Wildlife & Travel Photo Gallery

After many years of traveling the world and taking photos, mostly of wildlife and nature and I have published some of them in a Zazzle Gallery. Here is a selection of some of these photographs and links to the associated Zazzle productions; cards and...

featured lens GIMP FREE Photo Editing Software

GIMP is a free photo-editing tool similar to Adobe Photoshop, which can be used for anything from simple red-eye reduction, cropping and image size or file format changing to full professional photo retouching. GIMP was originally written for Linux,...

featured lens How to Scan Photographs, Negatives and Slides

Do you still use a film camera, or do you have lots of 35mm negatives, slides or photographs from years ago that you want to get onto your computer? This article is about my experiences with digital film/slide scanners, a couple of scanner reviews,...

My Home Page 

featured lens Lensography Retire Young and Travel The World...

I am a semi-professional travel photographer (i.e. I once sold a few photos) and semi-retired consultant physicist (i.e. unemployed boffin) but with a keen interest in finance (i.e. how to get rich quick) I live in Richmond-upon-Thames in West Lond...

Vote For Your Favourite DSLR Camera 

1

Vote Up
Vote Down
Canon EOS 50D 15.1MP Digital SLR Camera (Body Only)

Canon EOS 50D 15.1MP Digital SLR Camera (Body Only)

Canons new EOS 50D bridges the gap between the nov more...0 points

3

Vote Up
Vote Down
Nikon D700 12.1MP Digital SLR Camera (Body Only)

Nikon D700 12.1MP Digital SLR Camera (Body Only)

<b>This Nikon D700 12-Megapixel Digital SLR more...0 points

5

Vote Up
Vote Down
Nikon D5000 12.3 MP DX Digital SLR Camera with 2.7-inch Vari-angle LCD (Body Only)

Nikon D5000 12.3 MP DX Digital SLR Camera with 2.7-inch Vari-angle LCD (Body Only)

A remarkable blend of simplicity and highly advanc more...0 points

Please Leave Some Feedback 

submit
Show All

About Me 

Lensmaster AndyPo has been a member since July 7 2008, has rated 1,953 lenses, favorited 1,876, and has created 204 lenses from scratch. This member's top-ranked page is "GIMP FREE Photo Editing Software". See all my lenses

My Bio

Hi, I am Andy. I live in the U.K. but have worked and travelled all over the world. I am a semi-professional wildlife and travel photographer (i.e. I sold a couple of photos once), semi-retired consultant physicist (i.e. unemployed boffin) with a keen interest in finance (i.e. get rich quick..ly):

My Home Page, More About Me!, My Blog and My other publications

My Newest Lenses:
Apple Mac Computers, Software etc.
Volterra in Italy
Etosha National Park
Turtle Island, Borneo
Chianti Road, Tuscany, Italy
Chobe National Park, Africa
Danum Valley, Jungles in Malaysia


Lens Of The Day (Twice) and a purple star: "Rain Forests of Borneo" - 20th AND 30th November 2008



Please also check out my Zazzle Gallery



And a few other publications:

Safari in Botswana
Understanding ETFs (Exchange Traded Funds)
Rio de Janeiro: A Travel Diary
Waterfalls in Brazil and Argentina
Bangkok, Thailand (during a military coup)
Tiger Safari in India
Marrakech, Morocco
Vacation in Cuba
African Safari: Namibia
Classic Car Review: Ferrari 308 GTS
Car Review: Jaguar XJ12, Daimler Double Six
Car Review: Jaguar XKR
Investing in National Savings Premium Bonds
How to Reduce Risk of Your Investment Portfolio
Investing in Corporate Bonds

Check out these great lenses...

lens image
Wildlife & Travel Photo Gallery
After many years of traveling the world and taking photos, mostly of wildlife and nature and I have published some of them in a Zazzle Gallery. Here is a selection of some of these photographs and links to the associated Zazzle productions; cards and... view lens
lens image
Safari and Wildlife Viewing
Here is a selection of articles and reviews of safari holidays and wildlife viewing vacations in various parts of the world: Africa (Namibia and Botswana), Borneo, Canada, USA and Asia... Lots of photographs, travel tips, advice and recommendations,... view lens
lens image
Make Money From Home
There are many ways to make money from home and there is a lot of money out there on the internet to be had, but there are also a lot of people chasing the money. This article is about my research: The methods I have tried and the results I have achi... view lens
lens image
European Travel Highlights
A quick photographic tour of Europe to some of my favourite bits and links to a few more of my more detailed european travel articles, including: Tuscany in Italy Loire Valley and Brittany, France Gibraltar, U.K. (Near Spain) Richmond, London, Engla... view lens
lens image
Great Investment and Money Making Ideas
Have you ever been stuck for investment ideas? What should I invest in at the moment? Which stocks are good value? Which markets or investment vehicles should you invest in?This article attempts to cut through some of the jargon and provide some safe... view lens

by AndyPo

Hi, I am Andy. I live in the U.K. but have worked and travelled all over the world. I am a semi-professional wildlife and travel photographer (i.e. I... (more)

Explore related pages

How to Scan Photographs, Negatives and Slides
Do you still use a film camera, or do you have lots of 35mm negatives, slides or...
Best Digital Compact Camera: Canon Powershot G10, G11
The Canon Powershot G10 is a top of the range compact digital camera from one of...
How To Photograph Fireworks With A Digital Camera
We've all seen those crispy clear professional photographs of beautiful firework...
Best Digital Compact Camera: Canon Powershot G10, G11
The Canon Powershot G10 is a top of the range compact digital camera from one of...
Nikon D40x
The Nikon D40X camera is an entry level Digital LSR camera, designed to introduc...
Lensography Retire Young and Travel The World...
I am a semi-professional travel photographer (i.e. I once sold a few photos) and...

Related Topics

AndyPo Recommends...

Create a Lens!