Is ADD Over-Diagnosed?

Ranked #3,866 in Parenting & Kids, #126,277 overall

If So, What Does This Mean For Those Who Really Have The Condition?

Attention Deficit Disorder can be a tough problem for those who truly have it. Not being able to focus, and then becoming aware of this inability is both frustrating and demoralizing. That being said, there has been an exponential increase in the number of children diagnosed in the last year. According to the Drug Enforcement Administration:

"The number of preschool children being treated with medication for ADHD tripled between 1990 and 1995."

"The number of children ages 15 to 19 taking medication for ADHD has increased by 311 percent over 15 years."

"The use of medication to treat children between the ages of 5 and 14 also increased by approximately 170 percent."

Is an increase of this magnitude plausible? According to the American Pediatric Association such an increase in cases would be classified as an epidemic. However, because of the uncertain nature of the diagnostic procedure, it is hard to be certain of who actually has the disease.This fact, coupled with the wide abuse of ADD medication as "study drugs", has deprived ADD of the respect it deserves as a serious medical problem.

Is Add Real?

yup.

ADD is sometimes cast aside as a 'fake' disease most likely because, at times, we all suffer from moments of inattention and impulsiveness. However, for a person with ADD these symptoms are both persistent and chronic and often impede their general day-to-day functionality. Unfortunately, there is no simple medical litmus test when rendering a diagnosis, despite scientific proof that brain activity in a child with ADD is different from that of a child without the disease.

It is never good to be labeled. Those with ADD, like those suffering from other illnesses, should know that they are never defined by their disease.

Abuse of ADD Medication

Reports:

10 percent of high school students and 30 percent of college students use ADD medication to get through tough periods throghout the school year (Illegally)

Wired Magazine - "one fourth of our readers use ADD medication illegally"

The Reality:

A growing population of professionals and students are using ADD pills to gain an intellectual advantage.

The Danger:

Stimulants like Adderall, Ritalin, and Concerta are extremely addictive. They work by stimulating the nervous system and essentially low doses of "speed". These drugs also have a plethora of side effects.

Side Affects:

anorexia, headaches, insomnia, dry mouth, abdominal pain, heartburn, fever, urinary tract infection, asthenia, increased heart rate, increase in blood pressure, nausea

Also, 50 cases of sudden death have been associated with the use of these drugs.

Conclusion:

Some individuals really need this medication - scientists are getting more and more detailed proof every day - but it is dangerous if abused.

Is ADD Over-Diagnosed?

What does this mean for our children?

Is ADD Over-Diagnosed?

Loading

Yes, ADD is Over-Diagnosed!

Ali Janae says:

Everyone has ADD-like symptoms, but sometimes I feel it can be used for lazy parenting, teaching, or impatience of an adult. Many kids are hyper in elementary school, but not showing up consistently. it also means the people with actual ADD are being over seen, and seen as a fake disease, even when it actually happens. People need to see the whole picture to ADD, because sometimes, kids just have bad parents and bad role models.

Carrol Todds says:

My sister-in-law is a former high school teacher who now operates a daycare out of her home. She has a 4 year old boy in her daycare who is very hyper. She has recommended to his mom that he be tested for ADD. I think she NEVER should have made such a suggestion ( gotta love teachers! "problem? MEDS! NOW! solved....") I have spend a lot of time at her home with her daycare kids and I do not in the slightest believe that this boy has ADD. He comes from a home with little structure, his mother has very poor time management, he has a younger sibling who is very ill and requires a lot of his parents' attention, and he eats a lot of sugary foods. I think its pretty obvious what could be causing the problems here. The fact that he can consentrate perfectly during craft time, puzzle time, and during circle time are clear indications that he does not have ADD. And yet my sister-in-law argues with me when I try to tell her this. He is so hyper! Read the symptoms, he has all of the symptoms! Yes , OK, he can have times where he is displaying ADD type symptoms....but not ALL the time. She also disslikes this child and has been debating replacing him with a different kid for almost a year now. I think that she is using ADD as an excuse to hide the fact that she is unwilling to give him the attention he deserves while in her care. The sad thing is that this child will probably go to be tested, and be found to have it, and given meds. I wish that I could talk to his mom and tell her that I strongly disagree with my sis in law's opinion about him, but I dont think there is a way to do this without enraging my sister in law.

Venom says:

Yes.....My husband's Ex-girlfriend, who he has a daughter with, claims that their daughter has ADHD. However, when she is with us on the weekends all she ever did was stare at walls, watch TV, read, and color. She never showed any signs of being Hyper. Her doctor and teacher agreed with "mommy" and now she is on meds Mon-Fri.

My son, on the other hand, bounces of walls, yells, won't sit still, and is extremely hyper. He is only 3 yrs old. I have decided to try to get him into a preschool that deals with behavior and disabilities to see if he settles down any being in a atmosphere with other kids. He doesn't really have any kids his age to play with at home and I think that is why he acts the way he does. Of course, his Pediatrician won't diagnose him with ADHD. Or atlease yet. Says he won't diagnose him because insurance wouldn't pay for meds anyway because of his age.

No! Of course some mistakes are made, but you can't be perfect!

Hunter says:

I was diagnosed with ADHD in the third grade, and began taking Ritalin in the fourth. I'm now 24, and I am a full time programmer. The medication helped me to get where I am, and when I don't take it, it's very obvious I still have ADHD. I can't focus at all on my work, and usually get very little if anything done. When I do take it, I'm very productive and often times work faster and harder than our other programmers. If the medication can help others like it helped me, it should be one of the first options available.

 
view all 13 comments

Read Up...

Loading

Like This Lens?

your rating is appreciated.

If you would like to rate this lens, then you can do so here (Squidoo members only)

This module only appears with actual data when viewed on a live lens. The favorite and lensroll options will appear on a live lens if the viewer is a member of Squidoo and logged in.

Add this to your lens »

Does my child have ADD?

Some criteria that are used to figure it out.

If your child exhibits several of these symptoms, he/she may have ADD, according to current diagnostic standards.

It easy to see that these diagnostic ideas can easily produce improper diagnosis, as many children exhibit these traits, sometimes they are just apart of growing up.
  • Child makes careless mistakes.
  • Child has difficulty focusing on homework or other tasks.
  • Child rarely completes one task before moving on to the next.
  • Even when spoken to directly, child seems to not be paying attention.
  • Child continues to be disorganized even after instruction from parents.
  • Child frequently loses things.
  • Child avoids activities that include prolonged concentration or mental effort.
  • Child frequently forgets to do things, even when constantly reminded.
  • Child is thrown off task even by the smallest distractions.

FDA WARNING

The FDA Black Box Warning:

High abuse/diversion potential: Amphetamines have a high potential for abuse. Particular attention should be paid to the possibility of subjects obtaining amphetamines for non-therapeutic use or distribution to others, and the drugs should be prescribed or dispensed sparingly.

Drug dependence: Administration of amphetmaines for prolonged periods of time may lead to drug dependence and must be avoided.

Serious Adverse Events: Misuse of amphetamines may cause sudden death and serious cardiovascular adverse events

Feedback?

Let me know what you think.

  • Prescriptiondrugrehab Feb 24, 2012 @ 5:01 pm | delete
    Great hub about this topic. As you mentioned, there are no valid proofs that these drugs help kids to do better in life or happier.
  • ADD Treatments Jul 2, 2010 @ 4:02 am | delete
    For successful recovery diagnosis of ADD and ADHD is very much required. Many times parents are unable to identify the needs of ADD children that make kids stressed and depressed. Therapeutic boarding schools, wilderness camps are appropriate for ADHD teens. Wide ranges of treatment programs and guidelines are prescribed by counselors for teenagers help.
  • ShirlW May 21, 2010 @ 2:14 pm | delete
    Excellent lens and an excellent point of view. My best to you and your son.
  • Ramkitten Dec 7, 2009 @ 7:40 pm | delete
    This is a tough subject, and you've handled it very well. Like I said above, I don't at all think ADD isn't a legitimate diagnosis ... for some. But I can't help but believe that it is often mis-diagnosed. Way too often I hear people say, "I think I have ADD," whether a doctor has given the diagnosis or not.
  • eftemofreedom Sep 8, 2009 @ 11:47 pm | delete
    this is nice thank you for sharing this topic with us medication for ADD or ADHD aren't the answer to all the problems it's only imposes a small time effect for cure. the only big solution is the quality time with parents and a lot of hard patience will do. well if you had a time please visit the eft page and the eft training I hope this will help you a lot also.
  • Load More

Liked This Debate?

Here are a few other pages...

Loading

by

NotePromote

Hi! I'm John. I'm an English Literature Student. My top-ranked lens, as of now, is: are we the cause or the solution? Have a blessed day! more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!