Paper or Plastic? a debate run by Loyalis

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic (by 9 people)   Your rating: 1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic

Paper or Plastic... Fish or Trees ... is it Life or Death?

 

Paper or Plastic?

Paper or Plastic.... this is a tough one. One causes deforestation and the other one litters the ocean and kills fish if you are an environmentalist. You can carry many more bags at once with plastic than with paper but paper bags are much 'roomier' and your bread stays well.. bread-shaped.

Well, What's the Verdict? 

Is Paper or Plastic Better?

Paper or Plastic?

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

Paper, All the Way!

MiaD says:

sundaydriver says 'neither'..i would say - both - under the condition of (re)using them wisely, aware and counscious of the consequences...our daily life proves we need them both for different functions/characteristics, some of them cannot be substituted from one with the other (see al least shynab 56's comment)..

bbclarke97 says:

In order to be good to our environment I say Paper even though
plastic is more convenient. We all need to make small sacrifices.

LoneCyclist says:

Paper,plant trees and use only biodegradable plastic,

VARADHARAJAN says:

i prefer paper bags.i don't want the world to get polluted by plastic

sundaydriver says:

NEITHER:
I bring reusable canvas bags to the store. The market that I frequent in my neighborhood (Trader Joes) gives you a raffle ticket for brining in your own bags. at the end of the month, one lucky winner gets a gift certificate. I never win, but who cares!

opalship says:

Paper made from hemp or other non tree sources like recycling.

poohgahk says:

paper - it is reusable

photographybyterriharper says:

I try to use 'green' products and recycle as much as possible.

Jamie123 says:

destroy rain forests!!

hethir says:

Cloth!

Paper - It can be made from recycled paper and other materials.

ricky-macleod says:

you see plenty of signs in super markets about special offers but never about saving the planet there should be a bloody great sign offering life time bags to cut down on the use of plastic. yes we have bio degradable bags but they take many years to rot they are a pollutant .

batman71 says:

as long as its recycled paper.

ZooRajah10 says:

It's better for the enviroment and can be recycled much easier than plastic, so the deforestation to me is just an excuse by the big grocery markets to keep you asking for plastic. It cost considerbly less to make a plastic bag, moneywise, than paper. And we all know that every Supermarket is all about the bottom line and how much they can line their pockets with. They don't really care about the environment, the neighborhood, or their own employees.

domdom says:

well i would choose niether i would use a reusable grocery bag!

Cindybt says:

I use cloth bags anyways. :)

bingskee says:

Well, of course, unnatural procedures in acquiring resources to make paper will cause deforestation but it can be avoided. Information dissemination is very important. If people are just aware that if one felled tree must be replaced the soonest then there will be no problem. I think of paper, all the way!

Greekgeek says:

Paper, though I like BeCanDo's comment. But recycled paper bags are more common right now. Of course, personally, I always try to carry cotton string bags with me... they fit in my pocket, and work great!

acaper says:

Paper will break down fairly quickly. Paper bags can be msde from recycled paper products. Plastic is made from petroleum and oil hit $110.

groovyoldlady says:

Paper. I like paper. BUT, I also like handles -and plastic bags really have that going, so I choose....CLOTH!

Donna_Fallon says:

Better for the environment and recycling.
Hiya
I adored your 5 stars Lens!,Check my lens out - how to loose belly fat.
Visit My Lens:)
Donna

If you enjoy reading my lens, please join my fan club

Plastic Rocks!

CuteCountryClipart says:

Plastic...not to save the trees, because I'm not a tree hugger and I'm not green. Plastic is easier.

Tipi says:

I mostly use plastic and recycle at home for many things. I think a cloth bag looks smart and I should use them more.

wolf-mama says:

I know I'm a bad girl using plastic. Shame on me :)

Joodie says:

Easier to carry to my apartment.

shynab56 says:

I prefer plastic bags. I was one time embarrass when when my paper bag spilled out it contents. Wash-out as they say. I did not turn my back and leave immediately. As to the hazards that the plastic bags may have on our environment, the people will care about them. Let us keep recycling to minimize the problem. Plastic bags are handy while paper bags are risky!

MexicoLarry says:

In Mexico they don't even offer paper, but that's not much of an endorsement! But really, plastic bags are much more useful to reuse for all sorts of things afterwards.

2inlaws says:

I do reuse them at home!

ShakerMaker says:

Plastic! Easier to carry and easy
to use to keep the litter box tidy.

BarbD says:

I actually prefer re-usable canvas totes. However, with the new materials, many plastic bags are made with biodegradable and/or recycled materials. Plus, plastic bags are in fact MORE reusable. Think about it, you need to throw your wet, stinky gym clothes in something, are you going to use plastic or paper?

Just remember to save them to re-use and/or recycle them!

BeCanDo says:

Paper is traditionally a more sustainable and degradable option, however some new plastics, called bioplastics are both biodegradable and come from renewable resources.

As long as we are talking bioplastics they are the better option. Being more lightweight and compact the transport costs are reduced. As other debaters have mentioned the issue is to re-use as well.

BostonRob says:

Heck, where I live they just say ' open your arms and catch '

Abbotts says:

I say plastic. Our local I G A sells heavy plastic bags to use over and over.They donate a certain amount back to our school. That is neat. The problem is not so much plastic as no one ever thinks of the amount of times you can use a heavy plastic bag. Most just throw it away . That is what creates clutter. Love this SQUIDOO

Mac33 says:

Paper is better for the environment, but plastic bags are more useful because they get reused to clean up after my dog.

girlyred says:

I like plastic better but, it's important to remember to recycle.

ComingSoon says:

Plastic, but only if we talk about Biodegradable that it will decompose in the natural environment.
Want to know more? Wikipedia is the answer:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biodegradable_plastic

GypsyPirate says:

I can take my plastic bags back and have them recycled again so they don't go to the ocean. Mostly, I do use my reusable tote bag, which I think does look cool.

 
1 of 2 pages
 

Forget the Fish, Save the Trees! 

Plastic is way better than Paper

Help Champion the Cause for Plastic Bags. Add some supporting evidence in and vote the best of the best positions on plastic bags to the top.

Reusable Bags - Paper Bags Are Better Than Plastic, Right?

Helping advance the adoption of reusable shopping more...0 points

Paper or plastic %u2014 what%u2019s the greener choice? - Nightly News with Brian Williams - MSNBC.com

Would you like paper or plastic? It's the question more...0 points

O Noes! Plastic Bags are Greener than Paper | EcoGeek | Bags, Plastic, Paper, Written, Bag

Whole Foods, which, for those of you who don't hav more...0 points

Paper Or Plastic Debated on Camera 

Paper or Plastic Recycling videos

Paper or Plastic? Trailer

About excelling in life at whatever you do, Paper or Plastic? is a character-driven documentary feature that follows eight contestants and their dedicated supporters from around the U.S. as they get ready for the National Grocery Bagging competition in Las Vegas. Speed, accuracy and heart will determine who is best qualified to ask you, "Paper or plastic?"

Runtime: 2:12 | 2981 views | 15 Comments

 

powered by YouTube

Paper is way Better, I don't eat Fish anyway.. 

Paper Bags are Better than Plastic bags

Think those folks and their plastic bags have got it all wrong? Share your news story or blog post proving that paper bags are wayyy better than plastic.

Reusable Bags - Paper, Plastic, or Something Better?

Plastic bags are hard on the environment--litterin more...0 points

Do some Research with books made from paper 

Don't see a lot of plastic books around do ya?

More Recycle Warriors Join the Battle for Paper or Plastic 

Paper or plastic? Choose wisely
As a new and recent victim of credit card fraud, I wanted to make a quick post and encourage everyone to try and use paper money instead of credit cards or, in my case especially, debit cards. My bank called me just the other day to ...
Paper or Plastic screenings
Paper or Plastic is showing at the at the Austin and Heartland Film Festivals starting next week. Austin Film Festival Sunday, October 19th at 12:15pm at the Alamo Drafthouse Thursday, October 23rd at 9pm at Bob Bullock Spirit Theater ...
almost famous
I want to live this life.

OK, So What's the Final Decision Here? 

Loading poll. Please Wait...