Pit Bulls - Just Dogs

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic by 10 people | Log in to rate

Ranked #2,965 in Animals, #66,405 overall

Pit Bulls are Just Dogs

"Pit bull" is a term that's used to describe one of several breeds of dogs (pit bull is not a breed of dog in itself).

Although pit bulls have been involved in some highly-publicized incidents, knowledgeable dog aficionados and owners know that it's the owner and training (or lack of it) that make a dog 'good' or 'bad.' This sentiment can be summed up by the statement "punish the deed, not the breed."

Note

No matter which 'side' you're on, try to read the following material objectively. Thanks!

Pit Bull Origins 

Breeds that are Called Pit Bulls

The breeds commonly called pit bulls are the American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier and Staffordshire Bull Terrier.

"The ancestors of modern Pit Bulls come from the bulldogs and terriers of England. At one time, every county in England had its own breed of terrier. Many of these still exist; however, some have evolved into new ones. Such is the case for the English White and the Black and Tan terriers, whose descendants include the bull-and-terriers, the Fox Terrier, and the Manchester Terrier." (Wikipedia)

Media Hysteria and "Statistics" 

Inaccurate at Best

A pit bull's jaws don't lock. Think about it - do you see a big 'locking mechanism' sticking out next to their jaw? How would such a thing work? According to Dr. I. Brisbin, a senior researcher with the Savannah River Ecology Laboratory, University of South Carolina, Pit Bulls do not have a "locking jaw" mechanism: "The few studies which have been conducted of the structure of the skulls, mandibles and teeth of Pit Bulls show that, in proportion to their size, their jaw structure and thus its inferred functional morphology, is no different from that of any breed of dog. There is absolutely no evidence for the existence of any kind of 'locking mechanism' unique to the structure of the jaw and/or teeth of the American Pit Bull Terrier."

MOST statements I've ever seen in the media related to Pit Bulls has been erroneous and indicates a fundamental misunderstanding of statistics. A statement like '30% of reported dog bites are caused by pit bulls' is meaningless, because information is missing. To evaluate this statement, one would need to know the percentage of dogs pit bulls represent of the total, and be assured that the reporting of which breed did the biting is accurate. Suppose 35% of total dogs are pit bull-type breeds - then 30% of the bites is less than their share! Bites by smaller breeds often aren't reported. Many dog agencies don't keep statistics by breed, and the rare ones who do so usually have to rely on the victim's assessment of the type of dog (pit bulls are hard to identify - see 'find the pit bull' below).

Find the Pit Bull 

Bet you can't!

Is this a pit bull? Here's an interesting site that tests if you can identify the picture of a 'pit bull.' There are 20+ breeds that can be called one. Give it a try - you may be surprised and you'll certainly be educated.

Find the pit bull

The bottom line is, even if everyone agrees that 'pit bulls' should be legislated against, no one even agrees on what a pit bull is.

According to Wikipedia, "In the media the term [pit bull] is vague and may include other breeds with similar physical characteristics, such as the Perro de Presa Canario, Cane Corso, Dogo Argentino, Alano Espanol, Japanese Tosa, Dogue de Bordeaux, Cordoba Fighting Dog, Bull Terrier, Antebellum Bulldog, Alapaha Blue Blood Bulldog, American Bulldog, Boxer, Valley Bulldog, Olde English Bulldogge, Renascence Bulldogge, and Banter Bulldogge. These breeds are rarely listed by name in breed-specific legislation, but they are sometimes included when the term is defined broadly and based on physical appearance." (Wikipedia)

The Problem with Pit Bulls 

Something to Watch Out For

I didn't want one, but my son came home with a pit bull puppy one day (see the puppy pictures on this page). She was very cute, and soon became an essential and loved part of the family. Because of the media stigma associated with them, I researched it thoroughly.

Pit bulls (unless they're abused) are very good with people - loyal, trustworthy, gentle. According to some references, what they're not as good with are other animals. Pit bulls were originally bred to fight other dogs, kill vermin and assist with farming. Some say a pit bull should not be left alone with other dogs, cats, etc. We haven't had a problem, but that's what my research came up with.

Duel it Out - Are Pit Bulls Dangerous? 

What's your opinion?

So what do you think? Are pit bulls dangerous? Should they be banned? Are pit bulls subject to media hysteria? Let your opinion be known.

Are pit bulls dangerous and should they be banned?

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

Yes, they're dangerous and should be banned

No, pit bulls are like any other breed, the owner is responsible for their dog

norment says:

pit bulls are loving and caring companions

caitie says:

i became an unexpected pit owner while living at my exs house. his brother stayed with us and when he left he forgot to take his 4 legged shadow with him. i began to walk and feed him. he would come in at night and sleep under my feet as i rocked my new baby boy to sleep. when i went to bed he would patrole the hall .. going back and forth from my room to my sons. he put up with a lot of abuse from out cat without ever being aggressive back. hed just look at me like will u please take her claws out my face!!! now my son is a two yr old and the two are inseperable. hes a great addition to our family!!! ive always been a dog lover but never did i ever expect to favor one breed so much. Scooter is great and because of him i dont think i can ever go without a pit in my life : ) i hope to take in many pits in the future if i ever get the space.

Thomas Beckman says:

My wife and I have been involved with pits for years. We have bred, trained, and rescued many pits, and we loved them all. Unfortunately we have had to put down a few because of mishandling, neglect, or ill treatment by others. We do our best to correct what problems they have, and place them with appropriate dog owners. My aunt, who is in her 80s had a pit on the farm as a child, a great looking dog. My children, grandchildren have all owned pits, and hopefully my great grandchildren will have pits too.

jaykyza says:

no there not dangerouse only if u bring them up that way. im surounded by pittbulls evry day and there gentle as a mouse.

Britt says:

Pit Bulls should'nt be banned. They are very loyal and great guard dogs. I have a Pit Bull of my own, and she is amazing. Im waiting to get another one. She is great with my neice, also my cat. She is friendly. Pit Bulls only protect when nessesary. Mostly they bark and growl to warn you and to scare off the other person. Pretty much to let them know they cant mess with anything here. I used to be scared of this breed, but now, they are my FAVORITE and i wouldnt want it any other way!

 
view all 12 comments

Put bull references on Amazon 

Find out more about these dogs

Bandit: The Heart-Warming True Story of One Dog's Rescue from Death Row

Amazon Price: $10.17 (as of 12/20/2009) Buy Now

The Dogs Who Found Me: What I've Learned from Pets Who Were Left Behind

Amazon Price: $9.32 (as of 12/20/2009) Buy Now

Pit Bulls for Dummies

Amazon Price: $11.55 (as of 12/20/2009) Buy Now

Training Your Pit Bull (Training Your Dog Series)

Amazon Price: $10.39 (as of 12/20/2009) Buy Now

American Pit Bull Terrier Handbook (Barron's Pet Handbooks)

Amazon Price: $10.39 (as of 12/20/2009) Buy Now

Famous People Owning Pit Bulls 

Complements of Wikipedia

According to Wikipedia, these Famous People Own/owned Pit Bulls:
  • Theodore Roosevelt
  • Helen Keller
  • Mark Twain
  • Thomas Edison
  • Jessica Alba
  • Michael J. Fox
  • Alicia Silverstone
  • Jessica Biel owns three Pit Bulls
  • Adam Brody and Rachel Bilson have a Pit Bull named Penny Lane
  • Cesar Millan, otherwise known as The Dog Whisperer owns several Pit Bulls and uses them as model dogs with which to aid in rehabilitating misbehaved dogs in some circumstances.
  • TV cook Rachael Ray has one Pit Bull. Her Pit Bull's name is Isaboo and has appeared in cooking episodes and on her talk show. Rachel had another Pit Bull named Boo before she became famous.
  • Comedian Jon Stewart has two Pit Bulls, named Monkey and Shamsky
  • Author Andrew Vachss, a vocal opponent of Pit Bull fighting and breed-specific bans, has a Pit Bull named Honey.
  • American general George Patton owned a pit bull named Willy
  • Humphrey Bogart
  • Woodrow Wilson
  • Mary Tyler Moore

Pit bull-related pictures from Flickr 

Darling, aren't they

Caramel by drewgstephens

Caramel

Oh Tannendog! by NetDiva

Oh Tannendog!

Kujo by katesheets

Kujo

Bored. by katesheets

Bored.

Opposing Ends by BozDoz

Opposing Ends

automatically generated by Flickr

Reader Feedback 

submit

Useful links 

SquiDirectory
A Squidoo Directory featuring over 350 categories filled with an interesting variety of different subjects ranging from arts and literature, shopping, and eco friendly tips, to vehicles for sale, travel, and everything in between.
Dog breed info for pit bulls
Info on many dog breeds
Wikipedia
Wikipedia entry on pit bulls
Pit bull rescue central
Pit bull education and adoption
Pit bull lovers
Lots of pit bull info

by chucknp

Hello! I'm Chuck and I live in the Pacific Northwest. I own a pit bull and a dalmatian pit bull mix (whew). (more)

Explore related pages

Create a Lens!