Top Five Movies with a Quadriplegic Hero

Ranked #5,359 in Entertainment, #66,199 overall

Unable to find ten movies with heroes who are quadriplegic, this list will be a bit shorter than the others. Perhaps more will get made or I will discover more and be able to expand this list. I hope you'll let me know in the comments if you know of any I am missing!

Other Count Downs

Loading

NUMBER FIVE

Guzzarish

I'm reluctant to include this one at all because I am disgusted with movies whose message is that people with quadriplegia are just waiting to die.

This is a Hindi movie about a man who has been a quad for fourteen years and suddenly, for no apparent reason, decides he wants assisted suicide and petitions the court to allow it. He is a good example of someone who does not have adequate support. Though he has a good wheelchair that he is able to maneuver himself, for some unknown reason, whenever they leave the house he is put into a dinky manual chair that is no good for him. His friends are distraught and upset that he wants to die. No matter how many people tell him they value his life, he won't listen. I don't know why. He runs a very successful radio program that has touched many lives.

The movie is visually beautiful, though, and the actor is a very handsome man.
Review at DisabilityMovies.com
"While it is impossible to deny that many people with disabilities-particularly the newly disabled-are indeed suicidal, "right to die" movies such as Guzaarish are problematic because movies are the primary vehicle for the able-bodied to learn about the lives of the disabled. Suicidal tendencies among the disabled are seen as a perfectly rational, and even noble, response to their condition; a movie such as this only reinforces such perceptions. Depression is thus left untreated and available services unapplied for. Studies show that once disabled people are offered adequate services, pain relief, and adaptive equipment to maximize their independence, they become much less likely to be suicidal."

The Trailer

powered by Youtube

Get it at Amazon

Loading

NUMBER FOUR

MonkeyShines

This movie follows a common trope in using disability in a story, it is a horror movie and the reason the main character is paralyzed is basically just to up the fear and the tension.

Allan is given a helper monkey shortly after he breaks his neck by being hit by a bus. The monkey is donated by his friend, who happened to be running experiments on it, including injecting it with human DNA. The friend thought his experiments weren't working, but it quickly becomes clear that the monkey has some human feelings for Allan and sets about killing anyone who is close to him in jealous rages.

The very last scene of the movie is despicable in my opinion, but it isn't part of the main plot. It's not all that scary, partly because its a slightly older movie and partly because it borders on ridiculous in many places.

However, there is a love interest and a love-making scene that I thought was well done.

[image from www.movieline.com]

The Trailer

powered by Youtube

Get it at Amazon

Predictably, the book is significantly better than the movie
Loading

NUMBER THREE

Rear Window (remake)

I wish I had liked this one more. Christopher Reeve remade the Hitchcock classic after his accident, which I thought was a wonderful idea. In the original, the main character has a broken leg and is stuck indoors spying on his neighbors. Reeve reworked this premise to fit his own quadriplegia.

However, the movie got bogged down in a lot of explanations about quadriplegia. It felt more like an educational after-school special than a movie. While that does have its uses, the entertainment value of this movie took a nosedive.

On the other hand it is probably the only movie with a realistic portrayal of high-level quadriplegia and I appreciated the romance plot.

[image from www.chrisreevehomepage.com]

The Trailer

powered by Youtube

Get it at Amazon

Loading

NUMBER TWO

The Bone Collector

Unfortunately, this movie also seems to use quadriplegia as a way to make the main character more vulnerable. Rather than being as independent as he could be, Lincoln spends much of the movie in bed. It is still a well-made movie, though, with some great moments. Lincoln does have a love interest, which I appreciated.

The book is far better than the movie (as is often the case). Not only does Lincoln handle himself better in the showdown with the bad guy, the mystery itself is much stronger and more interesting.

The Trailer

powered by Youtube

Get it at Amazon

Loading

NUMBER ONE

The Waterdance

This is a quiet movie about a spinal cord injury rehabilitation center and its various inhabitants. The main character, Joel (played by Eric Stoltz), has broken his neck while hiking and he is going through the process of learning about his new body. Helen Hunt plays the woman he has been sleeping with, who is married to someone else. Their relationship experiences realistic strain and many of the most interesting scenes of the movie are between the two of them.

There are many good moments: touching, funny, and emotional.

The movie was written and directed by a man who has a spinal cord injury and rumor is that it is loosely based on his experience.

[image from http://www.thefancarpet.com]

The Trailer

powered by Youtube

Get it at Amazon

Loading

Movies I haven't watched

Mostly I haven't watched these movies because the plots involve people who want to die for no reason other than that they are quadriplegic. I find it extremely ableist to assume that someone in this situation would want to die.

By most studies, what is found is that people enjoy living. People have a drive to live, no matter the circumstances. However, that assumes proper support and care. Rather than encouraging people who sustain spinal cord injuries to die, we should be doing more to support their lives.

These movies are invariably written and acted by people without experience of quadriplegia and I think the assumptions that get made are dangerous to the civil rights fight that people who have disabilities are currently a part of.
Loading

A Great Documentary

My lists have been mostly focused on fiction, but this is a movie featuring quadriplegia that is very worth watching.

This documentary follows a couple of quad rugby teams preparing for the Paralympics. Quad rugby is a fierce and sometimes violent sport that can only be played by people who have some level of quadriplegia.
Loading

Which am I missing?

  • amex Mar 25, 2012 @ 2:55 am | delete
    awsome list

by

RuthMadison

There isn't enough fiction out there with characters who have disabilities. Ruth Madison aims to fix that.

After years of combing through the dusty...
more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!

 

Blue Moon

Amazon Price: (as of 06/04/2012)Buy Now

Is it ever too late for love?

 

True Tales: Encounters with Disabled Men

Amazon Price: (as of 06/04/2012)Buy Now

 

Breath(e)

Amazon Price: (as of 06/04/2012)Buy Now

Elizabeth and her mother disagree about love and relationships. Will Elizabeth be able to stay true to herself?