Rechargeable Cordless Tools

Ranked #7,408 in Computers & Electronics, #144,517 overall

How to get maximum value out of your cordless rechargeable tools.

The purpose of this lense is to make a real and unbiased attempt to answer the following questions.

What cordless tool is the best value over 10 years?

How long should I expect my cordless tool batteries to last?

How do I maximize the life of my cordless tool batteries?

When my batteries fail (typically after 2-1/2 years) what is the cheapest way to replace them?

Is there a cordless rechargeable tool that is built to last 30 years? If so, what company makes it? What will it cost to operate for 30 years?

What tools are designed for planned obsolescence? In other words: What tools are a rip-off?

BACKGROUND:

I am a guy who builds things. I try to build things to last. That is one of the main reasons why I can't stand the idea of throw-away rechargeable tools.

How do you build something to last?

First: Make the non-wearing items out of strong and durable materials that can stand up to rough handling, water and solvent exposure.

Second: Make the wearable items 3 times the strength they need to be for a 10 year use cycle.

Third: Make the wearable items replaceable. Stock wearable items in a tool repair kit and/or provide and easy means to return tools for repair.

Last but not least: If it has a battery, standardize it and stock it cheaply.

Avoid The Planned Obsolescence Trap!!!

Stay away from Proprietary Batteries

Per Wikipedia: "Many portable consumer electronics contain proprietary, often lithium-based batteries. These batteries last only about 500 cycles before losing large amounts of their capacity. Production of these batteries is usually stopped at around the same time the product is discontinued, therefore rendering the product worthless once the batteries start to wear out. While battery packs can be rebuilt and fitted with new cells, this is either too costly or too time consuming for most consumers."

This is the path that Craftsman and Skil have chosen to take in order to boost sales and take advantage of their "loyal" consumers.

What a ripoff!
Source: Planned Obsolescence - Wikipedia
This is a Wikipedia article that further explains the planned obsolescence scheme. Buyer beware!

Craftsman and Skil Rechargeable Tools are a Rip-Off

Here's what happend to me. Don't let it happen to you.

These are my experiences with rechargeable cordless drills that inspired this lense.

First, I purchased a Skil Brand 14.4 volt cordless drill from Kmart for around $100. It came with 2 batteries, and a charger. I made sure that I always had a battery charged and on the drill and one on the charger, ready for action. It worked great for about 2-1/2 years. I use my cordless drills a lot. Then all of a sudden, the charger malfunctioned and fryed each of my 3 batteries. I couldn't easily find a charger. And when I did, it was too expensive - over $50 + 3 replacement batteries at $50 each = $200 to get my $100 Skil drill back in action. Wrong answer.

So, as a result, I decided not to make the same mistake again. I went to Sears and bought a 19.2 Volt Craftsman cordless drill for around $170. I have had great luck with Craftsman tools in the past and expected this drill to last for 10+ years. WRONG! The drill worked fine for about 2-1/2 years until one of the two batteries wouldn't hold a charge. I searched for a replacement battery and found out that it too was going to cost over $50. Knowing that 1 battery was bad, if I were going to buy 1 battery, I should buy two = $100+ to get my $170 Craftsman drill back in action. Wrong answer.

So, I did some research and found that Lithium-Ion batteries are supposed to last longer than the batteries of my previous two tools. Then, I searched for companies that appeared to have standard battery packs and chargers for Lithium-Ion batteries. As a result, I purchased a refurbished Makita with 2 Lithium-Ion batteries and a charger for $140. Details below.

My current assumption is that this tool will last longer than my previous two tools and that batteries will be cost-effective to replace when they do run out because of standardization. Time will tell.

I can't be the only one who has run into this kind of problem. Let me (and others) know what you think. What is the best route to go when buying a cordless rechargeable tool? Enter you comments below.

Cordless Tool Batteries

Question: What's the best way to replace dead batteries on a Craftsman 19.2 Volt Cordless Drill?

Answer: Throw away the Craftsman 19.2 Volt Cordless Drill and buy a brand that is built to last.

Supporting research is listed below.

These batteries lasted ~2.5 years.
Specs-
Model Number: 973.113400
Battery Number: 1301341
3/8" Drill/Driver
VSR 0-400/min, 0-1400/min

Craftsman 19.2 Volt Cordless Drill
Originally Purchased for ~$170.00
Came with 2 batteries and charger.
Everything works great except for the batteries.

See below:
2 New Batteries cost ~$120.00 + S&H
2 Rebuilt Batteries cost ~$100.00 + S&H
A new tool (equivalent Craftsman) cost ~$100.00 + S&H
I've found that this new Craftsman tool does not have batteries compatable with my old Craftsman tool.

Screw it, I've found a cordless Makita tool with lithium ion batteries and charger for $140. It's a factory refurb. Model BDF452HW and is compatible with makita 3.0ah lithium ion battery packs: battery pack model BL1830. I'll let you know how the new purchase went after I receive the new Makita tool.

UPDATE 11/14/2008: I have my new Makita tool. Purchased from CPO Makita... Link below. It works great. I will never buy another Craftsman Cordless Tool - They are made to be a throw-away. It is ridiculous to me to purchase a tool and have to throw it away when the battery goes bad. However, because Craftsman chooses not to standardize on a battery design, that is exactly what you have to do... Unless you choose to pay more for 2 new batteries than an new tool which would be silly.

Details:
Makita 18V Compact Lithium-Ion Cordless 1/2'' Driver Drill Kit Model BDF452HW
LXT Lithium-Ion
LXT Lithium-Ion battery and optimum charging system produces 280% total lifetime work with 2x more cycles
Makita built, 4-pole maximum torque motor delivers 450 in. lbs. of efficient torque in a compact size
More compact design at only 8" long and weighs only 3.5 lbs. for less operator fatigue
Batteries charge 4X faster in only 15 minutes
Ergonomic shape fits like a glove with even pressure and easy control
Makita Lithium-Ion provides longer run time, 5x lower self-discharge (for use any time) &16 firm holding contact terminals (for constant high power)
15-minute Rapid Optimum Charger and battery communicates throughout the charging process using the built-in chip in the battery and built-in CPU chip in the charger. The Charger also uses "Active 3 Control" for current control, thermal control & voltage control
15-minute Rapid Optimum Charger has a built-in fan to cool the battery to produce more lifetime work
Built-in LED light illuminates the work area
Accepts all Lithium-Ion slide-style batteries
3-year warranty on tool and 1-year warranty on battery
INCLUDES:
2 Compact Lithium-Ion batteries (194309-1)
15-minute Rapid Charger (DC18RA)
Tool case (824774-7)
Capacity Steel 1/2", Wood 1-1/2"
No Load RPM Low 0-450, High 0-1,500
Torque (in.-lbs.) 450
Watt Hours 27.0
Battery (Ah) 1.5 (Li Ion)
Accepts(Ah) 3.0 (Li Ion)
Length 8"
Net Weight (lbs. w/battery) 3.5
UPC Code 088381076784
%u2022 Shipping Weight: 11.00 lbs.
Primecell Rechargeable Battery Service
19.2 Volts Replace NiCds with capacity upgrade > 2100mAh: $51.00
19.2 Volts Replace NIMH - Upgrade to 3300mAh NIMH: $76.00
www.all-battery.com
19.2V Craftman Power Tool Batteries, NICD
Black Color CRAFTMAN 19.2V 1.5AH Power Tool Battery--SANYO NICD cells-TB3081B.15C
Regular Price: $95.99
Sale Price: $64.99
This Power Tool Battery meets or exceeds original manufacturer specifications for CRAFTSMAN Battery

Compatible Battery Models:
1323903

Replace the battery of the following Power tool Models: Craftsman 315.101540

Specifications:
Warranty: 12 Month
Chemistry: NICD
Volts (V): 19.2
Capacity (Ah): 1.5
Battery Cell: SANYO
Color: Black
New Craftsman Cordless Driver
Craftsman C3 19.2 volt DRILL/DRIVER
Sears item# 00911588000 Mfr. model# 11588
Comes with charger and 2 battery packs.
$99.99 + S&H
Craftsman Cordless Tool, Battery, and Charger Finder..
Craftsman Cordless Tool, Battery, and Charger Finder..
Makita BDF452HW-R Factory Reconditioned 18V Cordless LXT Lithium-Ion 1/2" Driver Drill Kit
This is where I bought my new (refurbished) Makita:

CPO Makita is your source for new Makita tools and accessories, and the world's largest selection of Certified Factory Reconditioned Makita power tools.

Rechargeable Tool Consumer Resources

Links to web sites that claim to provide rechargeable tool reviews and product information.
Cordlessdrillworld
Cordlessdrillworld provides current reviews and product information allowing you to choose the best cordless drill to suit your needs.
Makita Parts for Tool Repair
Makita tool parts - Tool Parts Direct offers a large selection of genuine Makita parts online for cordless, electric and pneumatic power tools.

Rechargeable Cordless Drill Voting

What is the best rechargeable cordless drill?

Makita BDF452HW 18V Cordless LXT Lithium-Ion 1/2" Driver Drill Kit

0 points

Discount >50% Makita LCT203W Free Shipping !

Discount 57% ..You Save > $190 ..for Buy Makita LCT203W more...0 points

Sears Coupon Codes

Exclusive Savings! EXTRA $20 off Toys & Games orders more...0 points

Makita Tools on eBay

Loading

Makita Tools on Amazon

Loading

Tips for Maximum Battery Life

Tips for Maximizing the Life of your Rechargeable Battery
Rechargeable Battery Recycling Corporation
Rechargeable Battery Tips

Recycle Your Old Batteries

.
Rechargeable Battery Recycling Corporation
Find the rechargeable battery and cell phone recycling location near you: ZIP/Postal Code RECYCLE NOW!
Type in your zip code and find
a recycling location near you. HOW IT ALL WORKS
PROGRAM OVERVIEW FAQs BATTERY SAFETY ABOUT THE SEAL RECHARGEABLE BATTERY TIPS RELATED LINK

Reader Feedback

Please enter your comments here.

  • mikejb1954 Aug 21, 2011 @ 5:36 pm | delete
    I have had the experience where I used cordless drill for 6 years,I wore out 3 sets of batteries and I also had to replace the charger
  • JNKish Nov 26, 2008 @ 8:22 pm | delete
    Skil 2566-02 120V 14.4-Volt Cordless Drill USA
    Review Listed on Cordless Drill World:
    I bought this drill because I bought it's predecessor about 4 years ago. ...I should have read the manual (who does that anyway? : ) as it tells you to charge the battery for 3 hours and then unplug the charger. Well, I'd leave it on for hours or even overnight, forgeting about it. So, that causes the battery to have a shorter life, and mine went bad. With this charger, when the battery goes bad, the charger overheats and dies. So, I look on-line to find a new battery and charger. Best price for the 2 was around $70. The new drill (which has the exact same battery and charger as the old one) can be found for between $56 - $60. So, now I have two working drills and one working charger/battery. I decided then to go ahead and get another battery so I could use the one drill for drilling pilot holes, and the other to drive in screws. My complaint is that if the Skil company had any kind of environmental consciousness they would provide replacement parts for less than a whole new product - which comes with a big box, a plastic case, and all kinds of throw-away packaging stuff - none of which I need and had to dispose of.
  • JNKish Nov 26, 2008 @ 8:19 pm | delete
    Skil 2566-02 120V 14.4-Volt Cordless Drill USA
    Review Listed on Cordless Drill World:
    I agree with the previous reviewer, as I had the same experience with this tool. The drill is quite adequate for most minor household jobs, that is if the battery charge will last more than a few minutes (mine do not)! I have other rechargables from DeWalt and Craftsman that don't have these battery problems. It looks as if Skil is trying to get away selling tools with inferior power supplies. With NiMhd and Litho systems so prevalent today Skils NiCds are so outdated.
  • JNKish Nov 26, 2008 @ 8:19 pm | delete
    Skil 2566-02 120V 14.4-Volt Cordless Drill USA
    Review Listed on Cordless Drill World:
    I this drill as a gift and used it a total of about 20 times, and the charger (and presumably the battery) died.

    After doing some research on the internet and learning that the old-style chargers were defective and would be destroyed when connected to a "bad battery," I contacted Skil's customer service department to request a replacement.

    I was told that the item was not defective, that it was not "a problem" that the chargers would die if connected to a bad battery, but that the newer chargers did not behave this way.

    The representative was argumentative, defensive, and rude, and finally hung up on me when I told her that I planned to share my experience with other consumers on the internet.

New RSS: Add Your Own Feed

Loading

New Flickr Photos

Loading

New YouTube vids

Loading

New Del.icio.us bookmarks

New Amazon Voting (Plexo)

Please add at least one item before saving.

Sources of Further Research

Rechargeable battery - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Rechargeable battery
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Refurb your old batteries?

Revive Nicad Batteries by Zapping with a Welder
Nicad batteries often die in such a way that they won't take a charge and have zero voltage. This usually means they're ...

by

JNKish

By nature, I am a worker- not a pedant. Every day I strive to improve. If you happen to find errors or omissions in my work they are not intentional. Please... more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!