Is the Secret really a Secret? What is it and should I Care?
Time For Your Opinion
After every chapter I've written on I'll plunk in a your say space. The only posts that will be editing out are those that are hateful and use foul language.... Lens is rated 'G' folks so as long as your opinion is 'G' rated, whether you agree or disagree with what I've written, it stays. Anyone can post their opinion of my opinion of the Secret.....
-
Reply
- Linda Woods Linda Woods Nov 30, 2008 @ 11:35 am
- The secret is that we are vibrational beings. www.Abraham-Hicks.com has been teaching this stuff for over 20 years. We are Source Energy in a physical body. We attract into our lives according to our vibration. The best videos out there show us radiating out a frequency or resonance that the Universe responds to. In the movie 'The Secret', we see the girl on the beach, yearning for a partner. She sees what she wants: the genuine love and appreciation being shared between a couple. She aligns with that feeling. She gets into the feeling of what it would be like. She holds that thought. She follows her instincts. She follows her guidance and spontaneity and accepts the invitation to play volleyball. She meets someone special. When we get clear about what we want, and align with it, it comes to us. Maybe not in the way we think it will, but Spirit always responds if we are aligned with the "feeling" of what we want. Our emotions are the key to where we are in our manifesting.
-
Reply
- boiscanot boiscanot Jun 20, 2008 @ 10:19 am
- This, your lens, is what I have heard of before.
I do not know enough to judge either way, but I have heard that this 'new news' is really VERY VERY OLD!! ;0)
It never hurts to keep things in perspective ...
-
Reply
- MissThee MissThee Mar 20, 2008 @ 10:09 pm
- The secret has changed myself, my perception how to life in this kind of world...
You can said this isn't a SECRET...
But you COULD said; this is a BRILLIANT book, and somehow changed people's live.
That's the important thing to know, Rhonda has write something brilliant in her book, doesn't matter how genius the marketing are... The only matter is; what's inside the book...
Sometimes a great marketing strategy ends with terrible book's inside...
Well, that's only just a thought from a 22 years old girl...
-
Reply
- ZoeyJordan ZoeyJordan Mar 14, 2008 @ 8:17 am
- I really enjoyed this. Thanks for having such a fresh voice on the subject!
-
Reply
- davesaunders davesaunders Mar 4, 2008 @ 2:25 pm
- Of course "the Secret" is not a secret. It's been stated several times that it was chosen because of the good marketing it represents.
Also, if you research the origins of the word "secret" you will find that its meaning isn't what people commonly take it for these days. Being a secret doesn't mean no one knows about it or that the information is withheld.
- Load More
The Secret : The Forward
The book starts out with a Personalized account of how Rhonda Bryne became introduced to the secret, via a 100 year old book, and why she wrote the book. Ms. Bryne does not yet mention the book she read. She continues to mention she researched the secret without mentioning the name of the secret, I'm sure it wasn't always called the secret. She has turned books like Dr. Vincent Peele's book the Power of Positive Thinking, into a mystical and secretive marketing sensation.Motivational speakers have been touting the visualize what you want and you will get it message for years. The Bible, the best selling book of all time, preaches this message throughout it pages, the most famous passage -- "Ask and Ye Shall Receive." (Matthew 22:21). No secret revealed so far.
Rhonda Bryne gives accounts of people using the secret to overcome illness and to gain good marks and money. As one business motivational speaker says, "you are what you think about most of the time." What this means is if you think about something lots, you are passionate about it and act on it. By thinking about getting good grades you start to study and wow guess what you get good grades. By changing your thinking from self pity and fixating on illness to health and feeling good, you start to take steps to that end. You will automatically start to eat better because you are choosing to. You are thinking about being one way, you really want to be that way, and you start to act that way.
No secret so far.......
The Secret and More for the Secret
The Secret : Chapter One, The Secret Revealed
So far, the Secret is not your average book, it takes the whole mystic feel of the movie into its pages. Wording is exactly the same. The whole chapter is a collection of quotes by people who proffess to benefit from the secret.First Page and I am astounded by the claims Ms. Bryne and her contributors are making. She names a number of famous people who knew the law, then lists all the religions and ancient civilizations that wrote about the law and how its always been there. It has always been there for whoever wanted to know about the secret: the law of attraction.
"The Law began at the beginning of time. It has always been and will always be." p.5
According to the book, the Law of Attraction determines the complete order of the universe and everything you experience. You are the one who calls the Law into action through your thoughts.
"In 1912 Charles Haanel described the law of attraction as the greatest and most infallible law upon which the entire system of creation depends." p. 5
The claim Ms. Bryne is making is that the law of attraction is Creation and only acts upon the thoughts of man.
Ms. Bryne then turns your attention toward how those who are wealthy are so because they think they are. This has been touted by those who have researched why millionaires are millionaires, the first of which was Napoleon Hill in his book, 'Think and Grow Rich.' These people are not wealthy because they just sit around and think, I'm wealthy, and voila they are wealthy. The main thought these people have is based on wealth and the lifestyle it provides them. They then ACT upon these thoughts and earn the money to gain the lifestyle they visualize as being acceptible to them. This is one of many characteristics attributed to those of wealth.
The chapter then jumps... to be continued in Chapter one part 2.
"If you see it in your mind, you're going to hold it in your hand.
--Bob Proctor--"
Chapter One of The Secret by Rhonda Bryne Part 2
The the chapter jumps to how if you are miserable it is because you have negative thoughts and attract that which you don't want. This isn't a secret either. If you focus on that which is bad in your life you won't see the good stuff or you will minimalize the good stuff. It's how you choose to view your life, not really a matter of attracting anything to it.Then while you are distracted thinking about these two concepts they come back to the Law of Attraction being Creation. Sorry to be all over the place, but the chapter itself is and I wanted to make a point by staying with the thought process Ms. Bryne is leading the reader with. Because right after looking at how the universe removes negative from sentence structure the next paragraph says:
"The law of attraction is the law of creation. Quantum physicists tell us that the entire Universe emerged from thought! You create your life through your thoughts and the law of attraction, and everty single person does the same. It doesn't just work if you know about it. It has always been working in your life and every other person's life throughout history. When you become aware of this great law, then you become aware of how incredibly powerful you are, to be able to THINK your life into existence." p.15
The next paragraph tells you that you are always thinking, whether you know it or not you are always thinking.
WHAT... Not only is Rhonda Bryne all over the place with no coherant structure. She is slipping huge philosophical statements into the middle to hide the huge claims these statements are making. What they are saying is that the Law of Attraction always was and always will be, created the universe and all of creation. That the Law of Attraction only works on our thought and that we created our own exhistance and the universe. In essense Rhonda Bryne and those contributing to The Secret are saying, there is no 'GOD' in the traditional sense because we are God.
To remove the impact of the statements and to try and mitigate the shock she keeps the reader going back and forth between what the reader wants from the book and the statement the writer is making about God.
The thought process of Rhonda Bryne is hard to follow as it is incomplete and all over the place. One second she is talking about creation the next how we are like television transmitters, then all of sudden about how the wealthy think and how thinking negatively brings negative then back to creation and then to meditation and then to positive thinking. My head now hurts just trying to comprehend what I was reading.
So what is YOUR opinion?
-
Reply
- Angl Dvyn Angl Dvyn Jan 2, 2009 @ 2:01 pm
- The secret is retailing words from wholesale distributors. I have read so many books and articles online about the power of thoughts, positive thinking and law of attraction. Human are always looking for answers outside themselves so obviously something as common as whats written in the secret becomes a sensation. Its like a high. Because after reading positive literature people tend to feel powerful and optimistic but when what they desire doesn't manifest then they slump into an abyss of despondency. Its not about manifesting more things. In truth we arre almost perfect the way we are. There are a few thing we can change but almost everythng else is unecessary. Most of the thing we are trying to manifest are materialistic in nature. What about living a simply life and creating happiness from within. Lets accepting our divine created bodies, share with each other and let go of what cannot be change and change what we can. stop all the wanting; cause wants can't ever be satified.
-
Reply
- thrivingmom thrivingmom Jul 18, 2008 @ 12:54 pm
- I'm a huge fan of "The Secret" and am familiar with the quantum physics behind it's principals. I don't really agree with the statement below about believing in the law of attraction takes God out of the whole idea of creation. I think the law of attraction supports the idea of God. He created the universe and our world by thinking it into existence and then gave us free will to allow us to create our own existence. If you pray to God for guidance on the whole idea and ask him to show you scriptures to support it and then open your Bible, you will be truly amazed at what He will reveal to you. We truly create our own lives and make of them what we choose.
Who Created the Universe?
"The law of attraction is the law of creation. Quantum Physicists tell us that the entire Universe emerged from thought! You create your life through your thoughts...how incredibly powerful you are, to be able to think your life into existence."p.15
They have taken the essense that is God out of Creation and have replaced it with the self. To be God or like God, this was the original temptation in the Garden of Eden. Man did NOT Create the universe, God did.
Rhonda Bryne's The Secret and it's Reviews
- The Official Secret Website
- Start off with linking to the official site and then go from there.....
- Newsweek Book Review
- An excerpt from the book: 'The Secret and Your Body.'
- A Christian review of the book
- A Book Review from a Christian Perspective and what the secret lacks.
- Another Christian Perspective
- A Review of The Secret by Rhonda Byrne by Don Whitney, Professor of Biblical Spirituality at SBTS and director of the Center for Biblical Spirituality.
Takes a while to get to it but this review really blasts the book for stealing Biblical truths and being a Gnostic book. - A Comprehensive Pro Secret Review
- A review from the pro Secret Camp.
The Secret by Rhonda Bryne on heck of a Marketing Piece
I must say this book is one heck of a marketing piece. I don't understand how Oprah attached herself to it. I get that she'd be for the positive thinking and overcoming the negatives in life, but all this other new age metaphysical stuff isn't how I perceived Oprah to be. If it wasn't for Oprah, this book would be considered a new age book and not a best seller. I'll continue with Chapter two another day, until then your comments would be appreciated please provide them.So the secret is that we are gods and we created the universe and our exhistence with law of attraction thrown in for good measure. I'll have to continue to find out.....
Other Law of Attraction Books
Blogs - What others are saying about THE SECRET by Rhonda Bryne
"Attract the good instead of the bad"
The Secret: Chapter Two, The Secret Made Simple
Chapter two of The Secret, starts out with stating that you have complete control over everything that happens to you even the really bad stuff like 9/11. Although I agree that evil in the world is a result of consequences of choices humanity, as a whole, has made. I don't think that everyone in the twin towers had persistant thoughts of being in the wrong place at the wrong time. Since the end of WW II the American Media and Politicians are constantly stirring up the fears of Americans about the outside evils, ie Cold War, Terrorism. In all that time the only attack on American soil was 9/11. There were lots of bunkers built to survive a nucular attack, but they have never been used for that purpose, thank God. The Secret is touting if you build it, it will happen.... I hope their wrong.Then it jumps to knowing how you feel and you need to feel good all the time in order for good things to happen all the time. So if someone dies we have to think happy thoughts so no one else dies? Chances are that's not what Rhonda Bryne meant but she doesn't explain what she mean either leaving it up to constant interpretation by the reader.
The whole chapter has a very self oriented attitude where you need to be in constant awareness of your 'self'. Life is all about you, your thoughts, your feelings, your wants and through these you create the world around you.
The Basis of All Sin
Someone once told me that the basis of all sin is Selfishness. We sin when we only think of ourselves and not other people. Consider why someone steals, rapes, or murders, they do so for their own selfishness at the expense of others. Think about it....
Blogs about the Law of Attraction
- Law of Attraction Handbook: Revealing the Secrets to Manifest Your ...
- Product DescriptionThis book is designed be a simple, practical and easy how-to guide for working wi...
- Let Loose! The Law of Attraction In Action, Episode X
- Product DescriptionYou are as free as you allow yourself to be by virtue of the thoughts you think....
- Law Of Attraction – Miracle Manifesting – High Conversions!
- Highly Acclaimed* The Miracle Mind Manifesting Program Is The Definitive Guide On The Law Of Attract...
- Using the Law of Attraction for Weight Loss | Human Rights Law
- The Secret, it is called. It lay practically dormant since its inception, long before the Knights of...
"You are the Michelangelo of your own life. The David You are sculpting is you.
--Dr.Joe Vitale"
Life is made up of Choices and Consequences
Every day you make choices and those choices have consequences. Some consequences are bad, others are good, still others are amazing. Take responsibility for all the choices you've made so far and where they have landed you in life. Now make the choice to start over and to make better choices in the future.Making excuses for yourself and passing blame off to others doesn't get you anywhere, maybe a middle management position. Leaders and those whom the Secret look to as examples of the Secret have taken control of their lives. By being a positive influence and making concious positive choices they have made themselves what they are, successful.
The Secret isn't a Secret, it has been touted by motivational speakers, writers, religions, trainers, entrepreneurs, business tycoons and more. It is knowing what you want, having a clear understanding of exactly what you want, coming up with a plan and making the concious choice to act in a manner as to achieve it. Nothing metaphysical about it, just attitude, clear goals and good old hard work.
Yes, Another Your Opinion....
For you to rebutt or comment on what I've written about so far or maybe you just had a brain burp that you want to share.
More on The Secret
- Bill Muehlenberg's thoughts on the secret
- A good and witty and review on the secret and this quote from the review sums up what to expect from it. No attack on the ideology of the book, just a good review.
Quote:
"The message is simple: you and I are God, are energy, are the universe, are perfection, are spirit, etc. As such, "you can have, be, or do anything you want". That's it. Want a brand new car? Visualise it and receive it. Think and feel that you already have it."
Let the Law of Attraction help you on the Path to Healthy Livingor Anything you want to Achieve
by Joan Jones
Would you like to improve your health and boost your immune system? Would you like to lose weight or overcome an illness? Would you like to be the kind of person who loves exercise and meditation? Would you like more abundance and joy in your life?
The fact is, you get what you think about, whether you want it or not. Take a moment to examine what you think about all day.
Most people have a running dialogue in their head that never stops. Studies have shown that the average person has over 60,000 different thoughts in one day. What most people don't realize is the power of thought to create our lives and our future.
How to use the Law of Attraction - Create the life you want, one moment at a time
The biggest secret to creating the life you want is not really about making lists of goals to focus on or doing affirmations. The simplest way to create the life you want in the future is to focus on the present moment and feel happiness, joy, love, peace, whatever you want your life to be in the future. Whatever you want in your future, you MUST create it now because these emotions are projected into the future, creating more of what you feel at this moment.
When I say stay in the present, it doesn't mean don't think about the future or plan for the future. It's fine to plan for the future as long as you attend first to your emotions in the present. Whatever your worries, you need to try to drum up calm and joy as emotions for this present moment. The calm and joy you feel in the present moment projects into your future and brings you things to feel more happiness and joy about. But those feelings have to start in the present moment. It's the only one you really have.
It isn't the thoughts (like planning or thinking of paying bills or visualizing the perfect job) that are important, it's the feelings and emotions. In this moment, think of the emotions that are most beneficial to the present AND the future. What do you want to be creating more of in the future? Fear, Worry, Anxiety, Resentments? I would think joy and calm and peace would be more beneficial to your present AND your future so this is what you need to feel RIGHT NOW. If you create it now you are also creating it for the future.
Even if you're worrying about paying the rent, for instance, you can still
control your feelings and emotions in the present moment. You always have control of your thoughts and feelings, you always have a choice.
Whatever your worries, open to the Universe to show you a way - perhaps a way you hadn't thought of. If we ask the Universe to help us and then we proceed to hold on to the problem emotionally, figuring out how WE can solve it, then the Universe figures "OK, you're intent on solving this yourself so I don't need to do it for you."
You can take the practical steps to create the income you need or the life you want but also tell the Universe "I'm giving this over to you so if you send me
another way, let me see it. If there's another way to do this, I'm open to
that."
Maybe while feeling peace and calm and joy, you can throw in "I know the
Universe is there for me, providing help and support. I have nothing to fear
because I am not alone."
Quantum Physics Supports the Law of Attraction
Quantum physics has proven that thoughts have energy and the vibration of our thoughts can influence the future and our reality. If you think a thought, you emit a certain vibration and by the law of attraction, you receive experiences back into your life that match your vibration.
The Law of Attraction is based on the concept that like attracts like. If you get out of bed in the morning and stub your toe, you could begin thinking "this is going to be a terrible day! I have so many stressful things going on today, I'll probably be late for work, my boss will yell at me and my kids will fight when I get home! Today is sure to be a rotten day."
By the Law of Attraction you have set into motion attracting people, situations and negative energy that is going to bring that day to your reality. Negative thought attracts more negative thought.
Use the Law of Attraction to Create your Day
For the Rest of the Law of Attraction Article and other Law of Attraction Resources
Does the Law of Attration Work or Is it Just a bunch of Malarky?
Is the Law of Attraction a Real Law that Works?
Fetching blurbs now... please stand byYes
Breman says:
The law of attraction works all the time. For me it is a matter of understanding all the small details to make it work and manifest my desires.
Posted March 18, 2009
thrivingmom says:
"I think, therefore I am" comes to mind. Of course the law of attraction is at work all around us. We all believe in it, we just didn't know what it was called. We all know people who put off good vibes and we enjoy being around them or people who put off bad vibes and just seem to suck the joy out of your day. Throughout time we've had sayings that remind people that negativity attracts more negativity: lay down with dogs you wake up with flees or the infamous one bad apple spoils the whole bunch. It doesn't matter whether or not you believe in the law of attraction because it believes in you.
Posted July 18, 2008
No
"Everything thats coming into your life you are attracting into your life. -- Bob Proctor"
New YouTube vids
What Others are Saying about the Secret by Rhonda Byrne
- Biblical Evidence for Catholicism: The Secret: Christian Critiques ...
- The Secret: Christian Critiques of Rhonda Byrne's New Age Book (and Now a Movie, Too) · Best-sellin...
- The Secret Riches Visualization Tool, from Rhonda Byrne | Secret ...
- attraction money help law of attraction thinking keys to apply law of attraction key to using law of...
- The Masters of the Secret - Your Rapidshare Downloads Aggregator ...
- Rhonda Byrne | ISBN: N/a | MP3 | 131 Mb. ?These are books (pdf) and audio books (mp3) by the spiri...
- Step Away from the Bottle or Poker Table: The Best Self Help Books ...
- The Secret by Rhonda Byrne This best selling 2006 self-help book about spirituality and success was...
Other Squidoo Lenses about the Secret
- The Secret by Rhonda Byrne
- The Secret by Rhonda Byrne is breaking all sales records - and rightly so! This book will change the lifes of many people for the better - opening doors that people have shut in front of themselves, removing walls that had blocked the view to a brighter future. The Secret is the basis for excellent
- Christian Response To "The Secret" The Movie
- Great lens, lots of information, not just a bunch of links and You tube videos. Worth the click.
I've debated long and hard about posting this lense as I know the content is very controversial. However, the heretical statements made by "The Secret" teachers cannot go unchallanged. It is often said of opponents of "The Secret" and other Metaphysical teachings - The Secret - The Law of Attraction and Christianity
- I just finished a forum thread called The Law of Attraction and Christianity on Bible.org. Although the topic is the Law of Attraction, much of the discussion was centered around The Secret DVD and book. It was fascinating reading the discussion from an outsider's viewpoint. By outsider, I mean that
Response to the Secret by the other side
"You become what you think about most, you also attract what you think about most. --John Assaraf"
Chapter 5 - The Secret to Money
Well, until I get to this chapter......May I suggest you read:
Rich Dad Poor Dad
The Wealthy Barber
The Richest Man in Babylon
There are lots of good sound financial planning books out there that have good practical advice....
We'll see if the Secret is one of Them.
Better Books to Spend your Hard Earned Dollar On
And you'll get the same message.
The Valuable Lesson of the Secret by Rhonda Bryne
The lesson that everyone can benefit from is to think positive. Focus on that which is good and find the silver lining in that which is bad. By doing so you will be happier and see more good in your life.Will you always get a perfect parking spot? Will only cheques come in the mail? It is all in how you view it and what you make of it. Open your eyes and mind to the possibilities and see what happens? All you have to loose is a negative attitude.
"Thoughts become Things!
-- Mike Dooley--"
10 Things to Get You on the Road to Positive Thinking
The secret is all about positive thinking and reaping the rewards of visualization. So how can you start to enhance your life using these two important lessons from the Secret book?1. Make a list of all your blessings
2. Remember that even your worst day is 1000 times better than 95% of the world's populations best day.
3. Always remember that things work themselves out
4. Find the positive in every negative - it's there you just have to find it, then focus on it.
5. Stop complaining
6. Stop listening to other people complain**
7. Thank God every day for all the great things that happened
8. Stop focusing on what you WANT and focus on what you HAVE
9. Stop trying to keep up with the Jones'
10. Have positive role models and positive celebrities to emulate.
**By stop listening to others complain, I mean those that find constant stress, negativity, and shortcomings about everyday life and don't really want help to change it. Still be there for those around you who really need your help and be there to listen to their hardships.
Why the recycle symbol? Because what goes around comes around, start with positive attitude and it will pass on to others until it reaches you again.
New YouTube vids
You speak on the Evils of the Secret
Only one rule, Keep it rated 'G'
Is the Secret the work of the Devil?
Fetching blurbs now... please stand byNo
Yes
spirituality says:
It promotes insensitivity and greed - so yes, in a sense, it's the work of the devil.
Posted March 24, 2008
For Woman who Work from Home or are Considering it.
Law of Attraction, lets put it into practice.
Fetching RSS feed... please stand byThe Daily Onion
Seriously, the best way to be positive is to find funny things and realize hey, it could always be worse.
- [video] VH1 Reality Show Bus Crashes In California Causing Major Slut Spill
- Clean-up crews are hard at work after a VH1 bus carrying reality show contestants overturned, spilli...
- Most People Exposed To Secondhand Smoke
- According to the World Health Organization, over 94 percent people around the globe are unprotected...
- In Focus: Blues Musician To U.N.: 'Yemen Done Me Wrong'
- UNITED NATIONS—Legendary Delta bluesman Willie "Skipbone" Johnson is calling for U.N. sanction...
- Department Of Interior Employee Caught Embezzling 50,000 Wolves
- BILLINGS, MT—In what is being called the largest wildlife embezzlement scheme in more than 40...
- Cat Refuses To Die
- SOMERVILLE, MA—"He's a sweet old guy, and he's been through a lot," said Brian Pressman, 33, w...
by Carennedy
I am a mom of two wonderful children who together make Carennedy. Carennedy is also the name of my Company, Carennedy Solutions that was developed to...
(more)
by 2 people |









